Cut Defense spending to cut the deficit?

The War Resisters League think that war in ANY circumstance is wrong. Good thing they were not in power in the 1930's.
I admit that I have a low intellectual opinion of absolute pacifists.
And, like most hard core ideologues, they are willing to lie and distort to promote their views.

I disagree. I think many hard-core ideologues - the preponderance in fact - truly believe what they're saying. In the same manner as 9/11 CTers, their mind has filtered their worldview to the point where their "facts" are in fact true, in their distorted world only perhaps.

The two things I think that make absolute pacifists most glaringly incorrect are their near religious faith in the underlying goodness of mankind and a belief that the degree of international cooperation required to enact a pacifist world is actually achievable.

This of course takes us back to age old philosophical debates about the fundamental nature of man. Hobbes and Locke and all that.

Anyway, if an absolute pacifist truly believes those two things there will certainly be a rather large rift between them and most other people - one so large that people on the other side may slip and explain the difference through a conscious will to deceive. Most of the time, it has more to do with incompatible worldviews.
 
Praktik, I agree. I think much of the military budget is a form of welfare to corporations, as well as a job stimulus.
 
I don't agree that not having permanent, military presence in other countries is Isolationist. I don't think we need to have bases in other countries. If we have one or two bases in each region, instead of the many, many bases we have now, we can save money and still be able to help allies that need it.
Yes, let's put all our assets in one or 2 places... what could possibly go wrong?
 
yes. if we put all of our battleships in one or two places, we might get attacked by the vast Japanese airforce.

Tora...Tora...Tora!!!!!!

or maybe...the Wehrmacht will attack!!!

Blut und Eisen!!!!!
 
I've wondered about this and one thing that comes to mind is just how much structural adjustment would it take for the US to seriously cut its military expenditures?
It would probably collapse the entire economy and probably would remove a significant amount of funding that would prevent us from getting screwed over on another oil issue.
Seems to me there's an entire - oh what should I call it - MIC underneath that spending which would be very painful to actually reduce significantly, so realistically speaking in this economic downturn how can make-work jobs from graft be taken away and other seemingly obvious places to cut be cut?
Seems to me that there is an entire-oh what should I call it- paranoid conspiracy minded people that thinks that the army only spends on weapons of war. The more I think of it the science side of the army probably rivals the MIC.
yes. if we put all of our battleships in one or two places, we might get attacked by the vast Japanese airforce.

Tora...Tora...Tora!!!!!!

or maybe...the Wehrmacht will attack!!!

Blut und Eisen!!!!!
Or you know a nuclear bomb. Darth Robot is right.
 
Last edited:
Seems to me that there is an entire-oh what should I call it- paranoid conspiracy minded people that thinks that the army only spends on weapons of war. The more I think of it the science side of the army probably rivals the MIC.

Oh - don't those people just make your blood boil??

;)
 
It would probably collapse the entire economy and probably would remove a significant amount of funding that would prevent us from getting screwed over on another oil issue.

Seems to me that there is an entire-oh what should I call it- paranoid conspiracy minded people that thinks that the army only spends on weapons of war. The more I think of it the science side of the army probably rivals the MIC.

Or you know a nuclear bomb. Darth Robot is right.

Oh - don't those people just make your blood boil??

;)
Considering that nearly all of the R&D going on today is associated with either NASA or the Military (No instant gratification for industry to do it), Technological advance would crater pretty quickly. I know for a fact that technology-dependent industries (Computer programming is not, IMO, "technology" per se) have/are not bringing on any bodies in the R&D areas for the last year, and in fact are generally the last to recover from Washington's manipulations...
 
I don't agree that not having permanent, military presence in other countries is Isolationist.
A fair statement. During the 90's, there was a huge push for "CONUS based forward deployable" force, the US Army, that relied a lot less on troops based in foreign countries. That vision was in part implemented.
I don't think we need to have bases in other countries.
Then you want a larger navy. Works for me. ;)
If we have one or two bases in each region, instead of the many, many bases we have now, we can save money and still be able to help allies that need it.
That's a very Rumsfeldian position to take, Ken. ;) In fact, what you just wrote is about 80% match to a draft white paper that crossed my desk for comment mid 2001 ... which outlined far deeper cuts in overseas bases, and fewer in the US ... which at the time included a complete pull out from Korea.

As far as I know, that initiative died 12 September 2001, but Rummy did get to pull some folks out of Korea that a lot of people wanted to stay there.

DR
 
Just because Rummy was an evil, warmonger doesn't mean that he never had good ideas. :-)
 
Hm. An evil warmonger wanted to (severely?) reduce his overseas capabilities.
Something doesn't sound right :)

McHrozni

Really? You think consolidating resources to centralized locations is reducing capability?
 
Considering that nearly all of the R&D going on today is associated with either NASA or the Military (No instant gratification for industry to do it), Technological advance would crater pretty quickly. I know for a fact that technology-dependent industries (Computer programming is not, IMO, "technology" per se) have/are not bringing on any bodies in the R&D areas for the last year, and in fact are generally the last to recover from Washington's manipulations...

Private research is a bit more than twice Federal reasearch funding. http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/91xx/doc9135/FigureA-1.gif

You may not consider computer programming to be "technology", but your shiny computer would be a very expensive paperweight without it. In fact, it is amazing how much of what people rely on every day simply would not function without software, whether it is "software" that isn't burned to a EEPROM, or if it is "firmware"...which is basically just software burned to an EEPROM. That's almost like saying steel and concrete aren't "technologies". Hell, something as simple as the horse collar transformed Europe and was largely responsible for the rise of a middle class and the emancipation of serfs.
 
Just because Rummy was an evil, warmonger doesn't mean that he never had good ideas. :-)
He had a great many ideas, some of them good. With those ideas came a lot of damnably frustrating corporate America BS that had bloody eff all to do with the military.

One of the ideas he had before 9-11 had a lot to do with, are you ready for this? parky's dream: cutting the size of the armed forces.

He was keen to reduce manpower, and based on another staffing paper, reducing the number of carrier battle groups from 12 to 8. I have often criticized Rummy as a silver bulletist, and I have had little reason to change that opinion. He was, however, a huge proponent of Special Forces, and increased manning and funding for that arm of the DoD. It was IMO one of his better long term visions.

However, that larger manpower reduction theory he held onto, even when he was embarked in the second war.

I won't derail, but therein lay a root problem of the decisions taken that still have us in Iraq, and that let the civil war fester for three years before someone woke up to reality.
parky said:
Hitler funded the Autobahn and the V2 rocket, 2 concepts adopted by the USA.
Why do the R & D yourself, if you can borrow or steal it from someone else? :p By the way, Hitler didn't do that, German scientists did, but I suppose you can say he funded it.

DR
 
Last edited:

Probably because forces of all types have a limited operating range and need bases in the reasonable vicinity of combat operations to refuel, rearm, repair and rest at a minimum. The size of bases is less important, since it's a lot easier and a lot quicker to enlarge bases than it is to build them from scratch. It is also a lot easier to move forces around than it is to move supplies, since they don't have locomotive capabilities.

McHrozni
 
Even though we have the technology that gives us great range on our vehicles and weapons and that capability to build temporary bases very quickly?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom