Correct speed of building collapse

By the way, I'm an engineer. I'm a software engineer. I know other people who are engineers. They drive trains. Oh, and there's an engineer that will be picking up my garbage this morning. He's a sanitation engineer. I had a roommate in college who was an engineer. He's an electrical engineer.

Guess what? My train driving, garbage collecting, and microchip soldering buddies (and my own computer hacker skillz included) are NOT qualified to do calculations on this topic even though we have the word "engineer" in our titles. Maybe I missed something - you said you are an electrical engineer. Are you also a structural or mechanical engineer? If not, why mislead people by just saying that you're an "engineer"?

Perhaps a real structural engineer can go through your calculations and help us know whether you have some side talent or something. If you do, that's great, but just try not to mislead people with your ambiguous "I'm an engineer" statements. M'kay? I apologize in advance if I missed where you've stated that your "engineer" skillz match the subject matter in question.


GregoryUlrich gets a lot closer than most people do. He still egregiously overestimates somethings in favor of collapse prevention. However, I think this is generally based on his lack of knowledge of the subject and perhaps mine and others inability to explain what is going on clearly.

And yes, I'm a practicing structural engineer if you will.
 
Physicist, but no offence taken ;). The formulas are good enough simplifications, and as I said earlier, if I take out the structural resistance, the floating floor results look right. The issues are, as Gregory says, mainly with the assumptions, and that's where the structural engineers are the experts; failure modes of steel columns aren't exactly mainstream applied physics.

Dave

They're not really mainstream structural engineering either. We generally try to prevent steel columns from ever getting close to failing. In most seismic systems, we verify that the column is the last element that will fail. As column failure generally means the building begins to accelerate vertically down. Most people frown on that for some reason.

The actual analysis of why and when and how fast column fails is a level of math that I can read and understand (and use from time to time), but I can't explain it very well to other people who aren't already familiar with some very advanced topics of structural engineering. Second-order analysis and stability design just aren't subjects that are easy to pick up from scratch.
 
I know the buildings didn't collapse at free fall.

My problem is, what would the correct speed be?

The 13.48 and 12.07 second times found by (Dr. Greening). I know he also says these are the minimum. I'm also aware of the large chunk of the center columns left standing after the initial collapse.

Anyways though, back to my original question, what should the times be? 13.48 seconds? 20 seconds? 30 seconds? Is there no scientific way to accurately calculate this?
You could take each floor; just the floors. They fail at 29,000,000 pounds. So you get;;;
Velocity second/ seconds 101
impact new floor total floor
0.00 0.000 0.00 99
8.52 7.86 0.869 0.87 98
11.60 10.77 0.397 1.27 97
13.73 12.81 0.314 1.58 96
15.39 14.43 0.272 1.85 95
16.76 15.77 0.245 2.10 94
17.92 16.93 0.226 2.32 93
18.95 17.95 0.212 2.53 92
19.87 18.88 0.201 2.74 91
20.71 19.73 0.192 2.93 90
21.49 20.51 0.184 3.11 89
22.21 21.24 0.177 3.29 88
22.89 21.94 0.171 3.46 87
23.53 22.59 0.166 3.63 86
24.14 23.22 0.162 3.79 85
24.73 23.81 0.157 3.94 84
25.29 24.39 0.154 4.10 83
25.83 24.94 0.150 4.25 82
26.36 25.48 0.147 4.40 81
26.87 26.00 0.144 4.54 80
27.36 26.51 0.141 4.68 79
27.84 27.00 0.138 4.82 78
28.31 27.48 0.136 4.95 77
28.77 27.95 0.134 5.09 76
29.22 28.40 0.131 5.22 75
29.65 28.85 0.129 5.35 74
30.09 29.29 0.127 5.48 73
30.51 29.73 0.125 5.60 72
30.92 30.15 0.124 5.72 71
31.33 30.57 0.122 5.85 70
31.73 30.98 0.120 5.97 69
32.13 31.38 0.119 6.09 68
32.52 31.78 0.117 6.20 67
32.90 32.17 0.116 6.32 66
33.28 32.55 0.114 6.43 65
33.65 32.93 0.113 6.55 64
34.02 33.31 0.112 6.66 63
34.38 33.68 0.110 6.77 62
34.74 34.05 0.109 6.88 61
35.10 34.41 0.108 6.98 60
35.45 34.77 0.107 7.09 59
35.79 35.12 0.106 7.20 58
36.14 35.47 0.105 7.30 57
36.48 35.81 0.104 7.41 56
36.81 36.16 0.103 7.51 55
37.15 36.50 0.102 7.61 54
37.48 36.83 0.101 7.71 53
37.80 37.16 0.100 7.81 52
38.13 37.49 0.099 7.91 51
38.45 37.82 0.098 8.01 50
38.76 38.14 0.097 8.11 49
39.08 38.46 0.097 8.20 48
39.39 38.78 0.096 8.30 47
39.70 39.09 0.095 8.39 46
40.01 39.40 0.094 8.49 45
40.31 39.71 0.094 8.58 44
40.61 40.02 0.093 8.67 43
40.91 40.32 0.092 8.77 42
41.21 40.62 0.091 8.86 41
41.51 40.92 0.091 8.95 40
41.80 41.22 0.090 9.04 39
42.09 41.51 0.089 9.13 38
42.38 41.81 0.089 9.22 37
42.67 42.10 0.088 9.31 36
42.95 42.39 0.088 9.39 35
43.23 42.67 0.087 9.48 34
43.51 42.96 0.086 9.57 33
43.79 43.24 0.086 9.65 32
44.07 43.52 0.085 9.74 31
44.35 43.80 0.085 9.82 30
44.62 44.08 0.084 9.91 29
44.89 44.35 0.084 9.99 28
45.16 44.62 0.083 10.07 27
45.43 44.90 0.083 10.16 26
45.70 45.17 0.082 10.24 25
45.96 45.43 0.082 10.32 24
46.23 45.70 0.081 10.40 23
46.49 45.97 0.081 10.48 22
46.75 46.23 0.080 10.56 21
47.01 46.49 0.080 10.64 20
47.27 46.75 0.079 10.72 19
47.52 47.01 0.079 10.80 18
47.78 47.27 0.078 10.88 17
48.03 47.52 0.078 10.96 16
48.28 47.78 0.078 11.03 15
48.53 48.03 0.077 11.11 14
48.78 48.28 0.077 11.19 13
49.03 48.54 0.076 11.27 12
49.28 48.78 0.076 11.34 11
49.52 49.03 0.076 11.42 10
49.77 49.28 0.075 11.49 9
50.01 49.53 0.075 11.57 8
50.25 49.77 0.075 11.64 7
50.49 50.01 0.074 11.72 6
50.73 50.25 0.074 11.79 5
50.97 50.50 0.073 11.86 4
51.21 50.74 0.073 11.94 3
51.45 50.97 0.073 12.01 2
51.68 51.21 0.072 12.08 1

Impact velocity, velocity after impact, time to hit, and total time

Final velocity at the bottom is close to 51.2 m/s, I think I need one more floor to make this work, but it would only add .071 second to the time.

Simple model. It is based on floor failure, with just the weight of floors. Very close to times calculated by others.

The first column the speed of impact, followed by the speed after impact. No, the floors do not stop, they fail and the new mass is going at a velocity based on the momentum. Momentum is equal after impact with a new mass and velocity to the falling mass and old velocity. But you can do some of this yourself, or get help from a physics teacher.

This spread sheet ignores the initial impact speed. Thus, there is at least 1GJ of energy, like a 500 pound bomb of energy, I have ignored. I need no impact to start the collapse. Just the weight of 11 floors on the lower floor, and the floor fails! The buildings falls. Of course you need some of that energy to do the nasty destructive chaotic junk, but a big reason the WTC does not stop falling is too much weight on the floors when the tops fails. A floor can hold 29,000,000 pounds before its support fail and the floor falls onto the floor below; then the rest of the energy, the excess energy is used to give you the things you see on 9/11. Shell being ejected, three story shell sections falling off, being peeled off; core being fatally damaged as the floors fail. To get a better feel for this look at the building design.
124474626583dcee82.jpg

That is all that support the floor and ties the core to the shell. The WTC is a system of three elements. Core, shell and floors.
12447453ddef493eb8.jpg

WTC was build as a system. If you put the load of 11 floors on that floor it will fail. If you drop 6 floors of junk of the floor from 3.7 meters the floor will fail. After that, you no longer have a system, you have a falling building. The mass falling does not stop at each floor, that is junk science.

http://www.glenbrook.k12.il.us/gbssci/phys/Class/newtlaws/newtltoc.html
 
Last edited:
Beachnut,

You know the top section is a part of the building itself and therefore has the same construction. Did you already figure out how to place the load of 11 floors on the next floor ? The challenge is of course to avoid that the core columns touch each other because they can handle the load of much more floors.
 
Last edited:
Beachnut,

You know the top section is a part of the building itself and therefore has the same construction. Did you already figure out how to place the load of 11 floors on the next floor ? The challenge is of course to avoid that the core columns touch each other because they can handle the load of much more floors.
Oops, the fire and impact damage lead to the top falling 3.7 meters onto the lower floor. Oops, some of the core along with over 11 floors of mass made the lower floor fail. Since there were not BLAST sounds, or BLAST effects, the building fell just like steel does! To start the failure of the entire building you only need to over load one floor. As you see on 9/11 the upper section falls; as I say over and over, if any of the core falls with the upper floors on to the lower section, that is extra weight, I only need the upper floors to fall down. The core weight would only add to the failure. BTW, if the top sections falls, it is very bad, it is over 1 GJ of energy! That is like a 500 pound bomb, I only need the weight, any movement is extra force, the building will fail anyway, but there is extra energy to do the things you see on 9/11. No bombs.

The core can stand as long as it wants, I do not need the core to make the floors fail! The floors fail because there is too much weight on them. You can calculate the weight a floor can hold by evaluating each connection. It makes your core useless after a mass makes a floor fail, the core can not stop the mass of many floors failing. But alas, the core was damaged by the aircraft impact, and the fire destroyed ( a big giant fire, acres of fire) the strength of the steel and the building fell. I was hoping your core would not add to the weight of the overall mass, but oops, some fell on my floor and over loaded the floor which can only hold 29,000,000 pounds (do not ask Greg, his floor hold less! but my floor model acts just like 9/11 video. oops, I cheated and studied the WTC. the floor is one of the keys). As seen on 9/11, the core did stand, badly damaged and lacking much help for lateral support it fell too. No bombs, because we had people in the building, who would have been killed by blasts, that is why in real cd they get people back 2500 feet sometimes. Blast effects can reach out and get you! BOOM. No real sounds of RDX, or cutter charges; please never bring up thermite, that was made up by Jones 4 years after 9/11.

Unless you have some evidence of thermite, or bombs; please, what the heck are you saying? Fire does not weaken steel? What?

I understood the falling WTC on 9/11. You and I can get first hand information from Robertson; he was the chief structural engineer on the WTC. In the past few years I was sad to find so many humans are so stupid about 9/11 and basic science. So people need to work on their science. I even took the time to confirm the physics of the falling WTC, the energy of impacts, etc. What a waste, when you could do the same and drop the biased dumb act of 9/11 truth.

E man, you know the top section fell on the lower section! Say what you have, do not act like a truther.

good morning
 
Last edited:
I believe posters NewtonsBit and RWGuinn are structural engineers. They have already done some review of this work, as has R.Mackey, our resident expert on pretty much everything.

Thanks for the vote of confidence, but manage your expectations, please! I need checking on just like everyone else, particularly out of my fields. I also am not a structural engineer. I've had a couple of years of solid mechanics and FEA, but that hardly makes me infallible...

Dave has already pointed out a number of issues with my assumptions but he thinks the formulas are correct (as far as I can tell). I am by no means clinging to my assumptions. This is a work in progress and we are discussing many of the issues. You can watch and see how it develops.

I'm pretty sure Newton's bit is a structural engineer if he's not studying to be one. Mackey, 3bodyproblem, and realcddeal know this stuff pretty well and I think rguinn is a structural engineer, but he's usually so grumpy that I don't bother discussing it with him.

I haven't looked at the revised calculations in detail, not yet. I did comment in the Request For Comments thread -- before it turned into Romper Room -- that some of the assumptions appear unrealistic, e.g. the "spring constant" of lower floors seems high, partly because the buckling action and splices will make transmission of stress waves inefficient beyond three floors. However, to the level of precision one expects from this kind of model, the results seem reasonable and the inferences useful, if not actually correct.

Getting a good calculation of something so complicated to within +/- 20% is respectable. It's just that last 3% or so (provided it isn't a fluke) that takes extreme detail and effort.
 
Ok. It is obvious a truther isn't going to answer my question so i'll open it to anyone here. What is the "wrong" collapse speed and why is it wrong? An answer to this should be given before anyone wastes any more time on this foolishness.
 
Ok. It is obvious a truther isn't going to answer my question so i'll open it to anyone here. What is the "wrong" collapse speed and why is it wrong? An answer to this should be given before anyone wastes any more time on this foolishness.

One of the truther holy grails is a proof that the collapse of the Twin Towers and WTC7 could not have progressed at the speed it did without the use of explosives set off in a precisely timed sequence to destroy the support columns just in advance of the downward propagation of the collapse zone. This has its genesis in the early truther meme that the collapse of the towers was at, or faster than, freefall speed. (Many truthers now claim that no such suggestion was ever seriously made, though a Google search I did a couple of weeks ago came up with three truther articles written in 2007 which claimed the Twin Towers fell faster than freefall.) Since the freefall speed meme has been so thoroughly debunked, many in and around the truth movement have tried to show through calculations that the collapse, although significantly slower than freefall, was nevertheless too fast to be accounted for by a physical model. It's an extremely difficult target to shoot at, though, because the collapse is essentially too complex to be modelled accurately, and the simplifications used are therefore always open to challenge. On the other hand, it makes for some fascinating engineering discussions, and it's quite an informative testbed for learning about building collapses, so the more physics/engineering inclined among us find it a worthwhile subject to discuss.

Does that make things any clearer?

Dave
 
One of the truther holy grails is a proof that the collapse of the Twin Towers and WTC7 could not have progressed at the speed it did without the use of explosives set off in a precisely timed sequence to destroy the support columns just in advance of the downward propagation of the collapse zone. This has its genesis in the early truther meme that the collapse of the towers was at, or faster than, freefall speed. (Many truthers now claim that no such suggestion was ever seriously made, though a Google search I did a couple of weeks ago came up with three truther articles written in 2007 which claimed the Twin Towers fell faster than freefall.) Since the freefall speed meme has been so thoroughly debunked, many in and around the truth movement have tried to show through calculations that the collapse, although significantly slower than freefall, was nevertheless too fast to be accounted for by a physical model. It's an extremely difficult target to shoot at, though, because the collapse is essentially too complex to be modelled accurately, and the simplifications used are therefore always open to challenge. On the other hand, it makes for some fascinating engineering discussions, and it's quite an informative testbed for learning about building collapses, so the more physics/engineering inclined among us find it a worthwhile subject to discuss.

Does that make things any clearer?

Dave
it clarifies it but I still don't see how ANYONE can claim the collapse speed was wrong without explaining (with calculations) why it was wrong and WHAT it should have been. Anything other than those
two items is totally superfluous and is essentially pissing in the wind. To put it in the vein of impotence (which is where the 9/11 woo belong)...without these two items they are shooting blanks :)
 
it clarifies it but I still don't see how ANYONE can claim the collapse speed was wrong without explaining (with calculations) why it was wrong and WHAT it should have been. Anything other than those two items is totally superfluous and is essentially pissing in the wind.

Oh, absolutely. The whole collapse speed argument is a classic example of the unevaluated inequality fallacy, in which two quantities are asserted to be unequal despite the fact that one or both of them is completely unknown. Mathematically it's a non-argument: it boils down to "A is unknown but is clearly not equal to B", which is absurd. Or, in simpler language, "I don't know what it ought to look like, but it oughtn't to look like that!"

Dave
 
Ok. It is obvious a truther isn't going to answer my question so i'll open it to anyone here. What is the "wrong" collapse speed and why is it wrong? An answer to this should be given before anyone wastes any more time on this foolishness.
Just add it to the long list of anomalies that supposedly mean something to them. Any reasonable person can understand that calculating a chaotic event like that to the last split second is impossible.

Any reasonable person can also step back one level and ask themselves that IF the collapse time seems anomalous, then what is the plausible cause for this discrepancy.

But we all know that we are not dealing with reasonable people. There is some problem with the truther process of reasoning that prevents the logical progression of big picture thinking. Focus on minutia is important. This is related to a form of some specific psychological affliction that escapes me at the moment.
 
Just add it to the long list of anomalies that supposedly mean something to them. Any reasonable person can understand that calculating a chaotic event like that to the last split second is impossible.

Any reasonable person can also step back one level and ask themselves that IF the collapse time seems anomalous, then what is the plausible cause for this discrepancy.

But we all know that we are not dealing with reasonable people. There is some problem with the truther process of reasoning that prevents the logical progression of big picture thinking. Focus on minutia is important. This is related to a form of some specific psychological affliction that escapes me at the moment.
Hate to bring religion into it but the 9/11 woo are doing the exact things the religious do with their 300+ list of messianic prophecies. When examined closely, most are not even messianic nor do they pertain to their dead hero just as most of the woo reported anomalies aren't anomalies. Guess 9/11 is really a new religious cult :)
 
Oh, absolutely. The whole collapse speed argument is a classic example of the unevaluated inequality fallacy, in which two quantities are asserted to be unequal despite the fact that one or both of them is completely unknown. Mathematically it's a non-argument: it boils down to "A is unknown but is clearly not equal to B", which is absurd. Or, in simpler language, "I don't know what it ought to look like, but it oughtn't to look like that!"

Dave

Couldn't this truther stance also be categorized as an "argument from personal incredulity?"

I see these types of arguments all the time. One friend of mine would say things like "There's just no way we could have gone to the moon with the technology we had back then." To which I would reply with something like, "Well, what exactly was the technology they had back then and what was needed in order to do the job?" Silence. He didn't know, but he was absolutely certain what they had wasn't sufficient. It's some of the strangest behavior I've seen.
 
May be I have missed a posting - anyway: Did all of you think about the fact, that the time of the collapse is not a linear, but a quadratic function of the acceleration of the upper block?

If we assume, that the free - fall time is 8 seconds, then, with a collapse - time 0f less than 12 seconds 50% of the potential energy of the tower is already available for destruction. make it 17 seconds and more than 75% are available for destruction.
 
Yup, been covered. See Appendix B of my whitepaper.

Also, for clarity, nearly 100% is available for destruction -- the fraction discussed is the amount dissipated during collapse. The rest is liberated at impact with the ground and will further bend, break, or crumble materials.
 
What does the 9/11 commission report say?

It is part of the debunker Gospel no?

No it is not. I reached my conclusions based on what I saw and my knowledge of physics. If you continue to make these blanket statements i might be forced to take it personally.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom