Correct speed of building collapse

I trust you a little more than you trust me, but sorry no. If you have my SSN you can set up an account. I don't know why they don't give the degree. It's easier to tell if I know anything by reading my papers. I have never used my degree professionally, as I started in software at CSC immediately after graduating. I do have a patent in digital rights management (DRM). If you care to read that, you'll see I'm no bonehead.

... and if the topic of discussion was DRM, then I would personally be impressed.
 
Correction: Greg's a bonehead, but an intelligent one.

Seriously Greg you let that one float over the plate, I had to knock it out of the park. :D

Personal attack! Personal attack!

To quote my avatar:

I know you are but what am I?
 
As far as falltimes go, my thinking regarding adding the elastic strain energies back is as follows:

Newtons Bit and others have been modeling the structure as a mass with spring. If you imagine the spring breaking, both sections of the spring will unload. Early in the collapse, my hunch is that the springs will have time to unload before the next impact. Whether the sudden unloading or the associated vibration has a significant damaging effect on the structure is an interesting question. We could probably work out a simple formula based on the fall time between impacts. Actually getting into the occilation with damping and matching the phase to impact time seems like overkill, but I'm open for suggestions. A tough question is how realistic we can get without advanced computer simulations. Just the floor by floor simplification is probably giving the largest error anyway.


Just a few comments (and not off-topic after all, as it's directly relevant to your collapse time model):

Elastic strain is potential energy. An elastically strained column will do work on whatever members applied the stress to it, once the structure is no longer capable of maintaining that stress. (Consider a catapult, or a bow and arrow.) For a column, the stress results from the crush front above it, working against the lower structure below it. Most of the stress is released when the structure below it starts failing. If, as is likely, it is not capable of exerting sufficient force to lift the crushing mass, then the work will be done on the members below, assisting in their crushing and acceleration.

But as you pointed out, analyzing specific forces on individual members is inappropriate at the level of simulation we're talking about in your collapse speed calculation. Ultimately, your calculated collapse speed is constrained by energy balance considerations. The kinetic energy cannot exceed the potential energy change, at any point in the collapse; this constrains the velocity of the falling mass. That's ultimately why the conversion of energy into heat via inelastic strain slows the collapse. But elastic strain energy is not "lost" in any analogous way. The elastic strain energy is released at the crush front as the spring(s) shorten(s). So, elastic strain does not slow the collapse as much as you've calculated, if at all.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
I went here https://www.ubconnect.org/olc/pub/BUF/register/register.cgi?FNC=Detail__Aresults_html___BUF___508423 is that you?

You mind filling in your Social Security Number then reposting?
Why is no bachelor of science in electrical engineering degree
given? Don't be so defensive I just want to trust you. And Correct, holding a BA in music is irrelevant.


Proxywar, I hope you weren't serious in requesting Gregory provide, on a public board, his SSN or a link to a logged-in personal account. I understand your desire for evidence to support a claim (though count me among those who regard Gregory's educational claims as completely plausible by the evidence already available). But, come on now. That's just being rude, not to mention unrealistic.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Elastic strain is potential energy. An elastically strained column will do work on whatever members applied the stress to it, once the structure is no longer capable of maintaining that stress. (Consider a catapult, or a bow and arrow.) For a column, the stress results from the crush front above it, working against the lower structure below it. Most of the stress is released when the structure below it starts failing. If, as is likely, it is not capable of exerting sufficient force to lift the crushing mass, then the work will be done on the members below, assisting in their crushing and acceleration.

Actually, having thought about this in more detail, I can quite easily visualise a mechanism by which the elastic strain is released into plastic deformation. Gregory, your comment that "If you imagine the spring breaking, both sections of the spring will unload" seems rather an over-simplification, because it suggests that the spring fractures immediately as soon as it reaches its yield point. This is unrealistic for the behaviour of structural steel columns, and would lead effectively to negligible plastic strain energy. In fact, what is expected is that, when the column reaches its ultimate yield point, it then deforms plastically, and its strength decreases. By a simple application of Hooke's law we can therefore see that any elastically strained parts of the structure will then unload by accelerating the plastic deformation process. The force exerted by the upper, falling block will therefore be exerted over a shorter distance before fracture failure occurs. The ultimate result of this is that the plastic deformation energy supplied by the kinetic energy of the upper block will be reduced by an amount equal to the elastic deformation energy.

Note, of course, that this is particularly relevant to a one-dimensional simulation, because in this approximation the elastic strain energy has nowhere else to go. In my opinion, therefore - and I'm happy to defer to the structural engineers if I'm wrong - the elastic deformation energy has to be assumed to contribute to the plastic deformation. This will not only affect the collapse time calculation, but will also have major implications on the overload calculation for the collapse initiation; if there is enough energy to overcome, not the sum of, but to a first approximation the greater of, the elastic and the plastic deformation energy, then collapse will propagate past the first floor-to-floor impact.

Any comments from those better versed in structural engineering?

Dave
 
Proxywar, I hope you weren't serious in requesting Gregory provide, on a public board, his SSN or a link to a logged-in personal account. I understand your desire for evidence to support a claim (though count me among those who regard Gregory's educational claims as completely plausible by the evidence already available). But, come on now. That's just being rude, not to mention unrealistic.

Respectfully,
Myriad


I said he could fill it in himself then repost it.
That way I don't see his SSN.
The SSN just verfies it's him.
He can PM me.
Why are you surppressing my methods?
 
Last edited:
I said he could fill it in himself then repost it.
That way I don't see his SSN.
The SSN just verfies it's him.
He can PM me.
Why are you surppressing my methods?

No, I won't send you my SSN. If I fill in the SSN, you will be logged in and can register me or play with my account. Not going to happen. Your method is: challenging the credentials instead of the argument. Why not focus on the argument instead?
 
OK, my spreadsheet is here.

Meh. I hate proofreading other people's spreadsheets. However...

You've assumed a linear increase in speed for each stage of the fall, which isn't quite right but not too far off. I set the energy loss to zero and got just over 12 seconds for collapse, which looks about right for a floating floor model with losses. Your collapse time is very much more sensitive to collapse energy because of the increase in energy by storey, but that's what would be expected because that's how the columns were actually constructed. Overall this looks reasonable, although I may have missed something somewhere - I haven't dissected it fully.

What does make a huge difference to the predicted collapse time, as I commented in another thread, is the actual failure mechanism, specifically the number of buckles per storey. Changing from three buckles per storey to one per three storeys - which, based on the column lengths in the debris, appears closer to what actually happened - makes a difference of about a second for every ten floors in the early stages of the collapse; for example, if you assume the first twenty storeys failed one at a time and that the collapse progressed by three-storey collapses from then onwards, the collapse time comes down to about 15.3 seconds. While I take your point about not over-refining a very simple model, this is relevant to the 1-D approach, so I think it's a valid line of discussion.

What I think this shows is that the collapse time is maybe more dependent than I initially thought on the detailed collapse mechanism.

Dave
 
Meh. I hate proofreading other people's spreadsheets. However...

You've assumed a linear increase in speed for each stage of the fall, which isn't quite right but not too far off. I set the energy loss to zero and got just over 12 seconds for collapse, which looks about right for a floating floor model with losses. Your collapse time is very much more sensitive to collapse energy because of the increase in energy by storey, but that's what would be expected because that's how the columns were actually constructed. Overall this looks reasonable, although I may have missed something somewhere - I haven't dissected it fully.

What does make a huge difference to the predicted collapse time, as I commented in another thread, is the actual failure mechanism, specifically the number of buckles per storey. Changing from three buckles per storey to one per three storeys - which, based on the column lengths in the debris, appears closer to what actually happened - makes a difference of about a second for every ten floors in the early stages of the collapse; for example, if you assume the first twenty storeys failed one at a time and that the collapse progressed by three-storey collapses from then onwards, the collapse time comes down to about 15.3 seconds. While I take your point about not over-refining a very simple model, this is relevant to the 1-D approach, so I think it's a valid line of discussion.

What I think this shows is that the collapse time is maybe more dependent than I initially thought on the detailed collapse mechanism.

Dave

I sympathize.;)

Remember that calculation is hard top which favors a shorter duration. I made a comment regarding the number of stories involved in a buckle on the failure mode thread. I think it should be one every three stories but there are some other energy issues.
 
Remember that calculation is hard top which favors a shorter duration. I made a comment regarding the number of stories involved in a buckle on the failure mode thread. I think it should be one every three stories but there are some other energy issues.

Soft top collapse adds about a second. Clearly there's a lot more uncertainty than that associated with the failure mode. If it's one buckle every three storeys all the way down plus a second for the final collapse of the top block, that gives a predicted collapse time of about 14.5 seconds, comfortably within the observational error.

Dave
 
No, I won't send you my SSN. If I fill in the SSN, you will be logged in and can register me or play with my account. Not going to happen. Your method is: challenging the credentials instead of the argument. Why not focus on the argument instead?

By the way, I'm an engineer. I'm a software engineer. I know other people who are engineers. They drive trains. Oh, and there's an engineer that will be picking up my garbage this morning. He's a sanitation engineer. I had a roommate in college who was an engineer. He's an electrical engineer.

Guess what? My train driving, garbage collecting, and microchip soldering buddies (and my own computer hacker skillz included) are NOT qualified to do calculations on this topic even though we have the word "engineer" in our titles. Maybe I missed something - you said you are an electrical engineer. Are you also a structural or mechanical engineer? If not, why mislead people by just saying that you're an "engineer"?

Perhaps a real structural engineer can go through your calculations and help us know whether you have some side talent or something. If you do, that's great, but just try not to mislead people with your ambiguous "I'm an engineer" statements. M'kay? I apologize in advance if I missed where you've stated that your "engineer" skillz match the subject matter in question.
 
Can some kind hearted truther please tell me what is the incorrect speed and why it is the incorrect speed. You'll get extra credit for showing all work :)
 
By the way, I'm an engineer. I'm a software engineer. I know other people who are engineers. They drive trains. Oh, and there's an engineer that will be picking up my garbage this morning. He's a sanitation engineer. I had a roommate in college who was an engineer. He's an electrical engineer.

Guess what? My train driving, garbage collecting, and microchip soldering buddies (and my own computer hacker skillz included) are NOT qualified to do calculations on this topic even though we have the word "engineer" in our titles. Maybe I missed something - you said you are an electrical engineer. Are you also a structural or mechanical engineer? If not, why mislead people by just saying that you're an "engineer"?

Perhaps a real structural engineer can go through your calculations and help us know whether you have some side talent or something. If you do, that's great, but just try not to mislead people with your ambiguous "I'm an engineer" statements. M'kay? I apologize in advance if I missed where you've stated that your "engineer" skillz match the subject matter in question.

You can apologize because out of the blue someone was suggesting that I get an "engineering degree". If I was trying to mislead people, I'd just lie and say I have a PhD in structural mechanics. I have already stated a number of times in this thread that I'm an electrical engineer. I state that at the beginning of my papers and alot of people here already know that.

If you don't think an electrical engineer can handle the discussions we are having here, or Bazant's models for that matter, then either you didn't take mechanics (required for my degree) or you failed it. If there is something I don't understand, I ask about it. There are a number of structural engineers here who will either explain nicely or call me an idiot and maybe give me a hint. The best way to tell if I know anything is by reading my papers.
 
Last edited:
You can apologize because out of the blue someone was suggesting that I get an "engineering degree". If I was trying to mislead people, I'd just lie and say I have a PhD in structural mechanics. I have already stated a number of times in this thread that I'm an electrical engineer. I state that at the beginning of my papers and alot of people here already know that.

If you don't think an electrical engineer can handle the discussions we are having here, or Bazant's models for that matter, then either you didn't take mechanics (required for my degree) or you failed it. If there is something I don't understand, I ask about it. There are a number of structural engineers here who will either explain nicely or call me an idiot and maybe give me a hint. The best way to tell if I know anything is by reading my papers.

Fair enough. Ok - which one here is a structural engineer who can check the calculations?
 
Fair enough. Ok - which one here is a structural engineer who can check the calculations?

Dave Rogers is the only who has said he looked at the calc. I'm not sure if he is an engineer. If you read further back on the thread you can see what he says and how we got into the discussion. I didn't start this thread, and I haven't said that I have solved the collapse theoretically. Dave has already pointed out a number of issues with my assumptions but he thinks the formulas are correct (as far as I can tell). I am by no means clinging to my assumptions. This is a work in progress and we are discussing many of the issues. You can watch and see how it develops.

I'm pretty sure Newton's bit is a structural engineer if he's not studying to be one. Mackey, 3bodyproblem, and realcddeal know this stuff pretty well and I think rguinn is a structural engineer, but he's usually so grumpy that I don't bother discussing it with him.
 
Dave Rogers is the only who has said he looked at the calc. I'm not sure if he is an engineer. If you read further back on the thread you can see what he says and how we got into the discussion. I didn't start this thread, and I haven't said that I have solved the collapse theoretically. Dave has already pointed out a number of issues with my assumptions but he thinks the formulas are correct (as far as I can tell).

Physicist, but no offence taken ;). The formulas are good enough simplifications, and as I said earlier, if I take out the structural resistance, the floating floor results look right. The issues are, as Gregory says, mainly with the assumptions, and that's where the structural engineers are the experts; failure modes of steel columns aren't exactly mainstream applied physics.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom