Cont: Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part V

on the bivalent boosters

I agree that this needs further thought and study. In addition to the important distinction between infections and hospitalizations, their study does not discriminate between symptomatic versus asymptomatic infections. For these reasons, I am disinclined to change my present stance, which is to continue getting boosted on a regular basis.
Eric Topol wrote, "All of the data confirm that bivalent boosters work, and they work especially well in the people who need it the most—seniors."
 
both threads needed

I think that its appearance on Fox and social media could be discussed here (Fox did not report the story accurately), and the phenomenon can be discussed in the science thread.
 
Last edited:
Charlie Kirk Branded 'Human Garbage' Over Damar Hamlin Remarks

Outgoing Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-IL) bashed conservative activist Charlie Kirk for his comments seemingly fueling anti-vaccine conspiracy theories after football star Damar Hamlin suffered a cardiac arrest during the first quarter of a match against the Cincinnati Bengals on Monday night.

Hamlin received on-field medical attention for more than half an hour before being taken to a local hospital, where he's now in a critical condition.

According to a statement by the Buffalo Bills, his heartbeat was restored on the field.

In a tweet, Kirk claimed that the collapse of the 24-year-old Buffalo Bills player fits in a series of recent incidents involving "athletes dropping suddenly," something he said has become an "all too familiar sight right now."
 

Oh good lord....

In a tweet, Kirk claimed that the collapse of the 24-year-old Buffalo Bills player fits in a series of recent incidents involving "athletes dropping suddenly," something he said has become an "all too familiar sight right now."

So familiar that I can't remember seeing it for awhile, even though football historically has medical crises on the field, something they have made strives to improve upon. I have no doubt that in earlier years the standard of care available on-site probably wouldn't have been able to save him. The health risks associated with PEDs in sports are probably a hundredfold more than anything else.

These people are getting really desperate. Luckily for them, the people lapping this crap up are stupider than they are.
 
Last edited:
Oh good lord....



So familiar that I can't remember seeing it for awhile, even though football historically has medical crises on the field, something they have made strives to improve upon. I have no doubt that in earlier years the standard of care available on-site probably wouldn't have been able to save him. The health risks associated with PEDs in sports are probably a hundredfold more than anything else.

These people are getting really desperate. Luckily for them, the people lapping this crap up are stupider than they are.

Twitter was awash in COVID vaccine theories last night, and today. Stupid people are loud.
 
"Ontario judge dismisses 'puzzling' $1M libel action by anti-vaxx nurses"

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/anti-vaxx-nurse-libel-suit-ontario-1.6698686

Further fuel for my long-standing contention that nurse training in a number of countries (I usually stick to talking about the UK as that is the one I know most about, but cases like this...) is short on teaching critical thinking, basic statistics, how to read scientific papers and understand the basics of scientific method. Makes me even gladder I'd reasonably equipped myself prior to starting nurse training...
 
On the Thursday 29 December Jesse Watters program, a guest host (Katie Pavlich) was slamming boosters. In a segment (starting around 3:30) a study using workers at the Cleveland Clinic is claimed to involve more than 51,011 subjects. The segment referenced Yale workers claiming that vaccine was only 30% effective at preventing infection. Her most interesting claim is that each booster increase the risk of getting Covid-19 by 300%. This was put on screen:

"Among 51011 working-aged Cleveland Clinic employees, the bivalent COVID-19 vaccine booster was 30% effective in preventing infection..."

With respect to the question 30% effectiveness, I would counter by asking what the same study showed about hospitalizations and deaths, but see below. I am a little bit less sure what is going on with the 300% claim, but this link to a CBS News story from last June might be a good place to start. I did not see 300% in the preprint discussed below, but I would like to know the origin of this number.

Getting back to the quote above, I found a preprint (not yet peer-reviewed) where this quote appeared here. These authors wrote, "There were too few severe illnesses for the study to be able to determine if the vaccine decreased severity of illness. Our study of healthcare personnel included no children and few elderly subjects, and the majority would not have been immunocompromised." They also wrote, "The bivalent COVID-19 vaccine given to working-aged adults afforded modest protection overall against COVID-19, while the virus strains dominant in the community were those represented in the vaccine."
EDT
See this link starting near 3:35 for Katie Pavlich's comments.

To poke at likely CT related to that Cleveland Clinic thing - A Tea Party friend of mine accidentally sent me what's probably one of the most recent ADE narrative arguments from the guy who inspired the Tea Party. I seem to have lost the link, but no great loss there, I think. Basically, the guy zoomed in with a claim that Ig4 levels apparently rising after some number of shots is proof positive that ADE actually is happening, on the premise that Ig4 creates tolerance for being infected. To add to that a little, to listen to the friend, vaccines haven't saved anyone, they're just creating breeding grounds for worse.
 
The usual suspects

At CNN Jonathan Reiner wrote, "But while [Damar] Hamlin’s near-death experience traumatized his family, teammates, the NFL and millions of people who witnessed his struggle live on television, for others it has become just another crass opportunity to promote vaccine disinformation."

He reported, "Former New York Times columnist and prolific vaccine opponent Alex Berenson wrote on Substack the next day, “When I saw the video of what had happened, my immediate reaction - beyond fear for Hamlin’s life - was, I suspect, the same as most of yours. Had Damar Hamlin suffered cardiac arrest? Were the mRNA vaccines ultimately responsible, perhaps by causing myocarditis that left him vulnerable.”"

He continued, "During the same show, Carlson insinuated that athletes have been dying because of the Covid-19 vaccine, “Since the vax campaign began, there have been more than 1,500 total cardiac arrests in those leagues and two-thirds of those were fatal,” he claimed.

Those statistics about deaths in athletes, promoted by Carlson, was taken from an letter published in a Scandinavian journal, whose only attribution was “GoodSciencing.com,” (which is about as credible as it sounds)."
 
Last edited:
letter and a blog entry

AP News indicated that a letter to a journal gave the citation to the a blog entry at goodsciencing.com, "The blog’s list is a compilation of news reports about recent deaths and medical emergencies, and it includes cases not reported to be spurred by cardiac arrest: Some deaths, for example, were reportedly from cancer.

The list also includes incidents from around the world and among people of all ages — including some in their 70s and 80s — not just athletes in “European sports leagues,” as Carlson claimed." One of the coauthors of the letter is Dr. Peter McCullough, whom I have previously discussed.
 
^ That was covered last week by the "More Or Less" programme on Radio 4 (available on BBC Sounds in certain places).

McCullough was essentially just making things up and included some folk who were known not to have been vaccinated at the time of an incident (Christian Eriksen being one of those). More attached to the idea of being a "brave, maverick doctor" than actually being a good doctor and looking at facts and evidence and truth...
 
I haven't followed Drs Kory and Marik for a while but just ran acoss this:

https://flccc.substack.com/p/reducing-cardiac-risk-after-covid

There are two peak windows when deaths that may be linked to vaccination seem to occur. “They happen either within a few days, which we think is acute heart inflammation causing myocarditis and then a fatal arrhythmia,” says Dr. Kory. “And then there are those that die around five months later.”

Appears they are part of the "Died Suddenly" set. Sheesh. From being early advocates of steroids in the inflamitory phase of severe covid, which was legit, to the useless but largely harmless IVM, and finally to full blown anti-vax craziness.

What a long strange trip it's been.
 
Seen on Twitter: videos of anti-vaxxers "shaking uncontrollably after having the covid vaccine".

Yeah, right, the acting is as bad as the ideology.

One example:
https://twitter.com/healthbyjames/status/1616142878723407894?s=61&t=DOfnuZNtuxAiXsuEZ724Hg

Honestly, I'm of the opinion that expectations held firmly enough can cause... unusual reactions to all kind of things, so I wouldn't automatically discount such categorically, myself. That the cause then would be people working themselves into some kind of psychological frenzy rather than as an actual side effect of the vaccines is another matter, of course. With that said, motivated/attention-seeking acting is fairly certainly a safer bet for a trend like that.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I'm of the opinion that expectations held firmly enough can cause... unusual reactions to all kind of things, so I wouldn't automatically discount such categorically, myself. That the cause then would be people working themselves into some kind of psychological frenzy rather than as an actual side effect of the vaccines is another matter, of course. With that said, motivated/attention-seeking acting is fairly certainly a safer bet for a trend like that.


Also, I couldn't help but notice that in the video of her testimony, the only time she shook very much was when she mentioned she was shaking. Her other gestures and movements were not only quite subdued, but often were perfectly normal.

Also, paralysis followed by seizures is rather unheard of, unlike conditions such as Todd's Paralysis, which occurs after a seizure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom