Cont: Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part V

Threats against Dr. Fauci and his family

"The abuse toward his family is more perturbing, he [Dr. Anthony Fauci] said. He noted that at least two people are in jail in the United States for “credible” attempts on his life." WaPo. There is also a BBC interview here.

Which thread is the best place for this story is arguable, but I decided to put it here. Based partially on the BBC prelude, I would opine that if it were not for conspiracy theories and other misinformation, such threats would not be taking place.
 
DeSantis's pandering

In October Science Editor-in-Chief H. Holden Thorpe quoted Scripps' Eric Topol: "'Ladapo’s dissemination of flawed data that purports a risk of cardiac death among men age 18 to 39 after mRNA vaccines was baseless, reckless, and irresponsible,” said cardiologist Eric Topol. “The risk of myocarditis in this demographic is real and notable, but all studies with close follow-up have indicated it is typically mild and fully resolves in nearly all affected." IIRC I commented upthread on this subject a few months ago.

Governor DeSantis is forming an "integrity" committee and trying to convene a grand jury regarding the vaccines because he does not trust the CDC. Dr. Ladapo is part of this effort (Guardian). See also this link. DeSantis is putting wood on a fire that he should be stamping out.
 
Last edited:
In October Science Editor-in-Chief H. Holden Thorpe quoted Scripps' Eric Topol: "'Ladapo’s dissemination of flawed data that purports a risk of cardiac death among men age 18 to 39 after mRNA vaccines was baseless, reckless, and irresponsible,” said cardiologist Eric Topol. “The risk of myocarditis in this demographic is real and notable, but all studies with close follow-up have indicated it is typically mild and fully resolves in nearly all affected." IIRC I commented upthread on this subject a few months ago.

Governor DeSantis is forming an "integrity" committee and trying to convene a grand jury regarding the vaccines because he does not trust the CDC. Dr. Ladapo is part of this effort (Guardian). See also this link. DeSantis is putting wood on a fire that he should be stamping out.
Came to the thread to post about DeathSantis. He know if he runs for Pres his handling of Covid will be an issue, so he wants to put on a Soviet-style show trial to deflect it.
 
More on DeSantis

"An analysis released Tuesday by the Commonwealth Fund and the Yale School of Public Health estimated Covid-19 vaccines prevented more than 3.2 million deaths and 18.5 million hospitalizations in the United States and saved more than $1.15 trillion in medical costs." CNN. This story also covers DeSantis' two actions, both of which will support conspiracy theorizing in Florida and elsewhere.
 
"The abuse toward his family is more perturbing, he [Dr. Anthony Fauci] said. He noted that at least two people are in jail in the United States for “credible” attempts on his life." WaPo. There is also a BBC interview here.

Which thread is the best place for this story is arguable, but I decided to put it here. Based partially on the BBC prelude, I would opine that if it were not for conspiracy theories and other misinformation, such threats would not be taking place.

Disinformationists are delusional, dangerous ********. We are well-rid of a few of them in this venue.
 
"An analysis released Tuesday by the Commonwealth Fund and the Yale School of Public Health estimated Covid-19 vaccines prevented more than 3.2 million deaths and 18.5 million hospitalizations in the United States and saved more than $1.15 trillion in medical costs." CNN. This story also covers DeSantis' two actions, both of which will support conspiracy theorizing in Florida and elsewhere.

I'm skeptical. For one thing that would be 4.3 million USA deaths and would corresspond to an IFR of 1.3% and requires everyone in the USA was infected. Further, Paxlovid (not a vaccine) came out in late 2021 and was 89% effective for people that weren't vaccinated. I can believe another 1 to 1.5M but not 3.2M more.
 
Last edited:
the effects of a wave on the health care system

I'm skeptical. For one thing that would be 4.3 million USA deaths and would corresspond to an IFR of 1.3% and requires everyone in the USA was infected. Further, Paxlovid (not a vaccine) came out in late 2021 and was 89% effective for people that weren't vaccinated. I can believe another 1 to 1.5M but not 3.2M more.
Obviously I take what you say very seriously. Have they or you considered that without the vaccines, a viral wave could overwhelm the health care system and cause excess deaths by an indirect mechanism (all beds in intensive care being taken up as more people need various treatments). I can imagine that this would be difficult to model.
 
Last edited:
Governor DeSantis is forming an "integrity" committee and trying to convene a grand jury regarding the vaccines because he does not trust the CDC. Dr. Ladapo is part of this effort (Guardian). See also this link. DeSantis is putting wood on a fire that he should be stamping out.


In my vision of a suddenly enlightened (scientifically) and rational world, the epic irony would be DeSantis' committee indicting DeSantis for his role in causing needless deaths and suffering among his constituents.
 
Have they or you considered that without the vaccines, a viral wave could overwhelm the health care system and cause excess deaths by an indirect mechanism (all beds in intensive care being taken up as more people need various treatments). I can imagine that this would be difficult to model.

Not as far as I can tell. Looks like they just plugged in numbers into some unclear model. Appears they presumed any NPIs, formal or ad hoc, would be unchanged regardless of cases and deaths. This is not how societies respond. When cases rise rapidly and overwhelm a particular town/region, people respond and the measures people take elsewere in response adjust even if not anywhere near optimally. Zero evidence they did that.

And when it comes to the paper's discussion of limitations, the only thing mentioned was presumed to mean their results were understated. Sure.

Not even considering Paxlovid is not forgivable. It was nowhere mentioned in their paper. Obviously it would have played a major role allowing decreased NPIs while focusing on the older demographic where the deaths would otherwise be concentrated.

And their Confidence intervals were absurdly small. Less than +/- .2M total deaths.

Hard to believe they grokked what they wrote.

OTOH, there is a recent paper stating that the Pfizer vaccine relative risk reduction numbers are misinformation and they should be using absolute risk reduction, which was below 1% instead. Obviously, absolute risk reduction and the corresponding NNT is the best metric for testing a treatment for a diagnosed patient. But it is worthless for vaccines. The last I heard vaccines aren't given to patients with diagnosed Covid-19. :) For vaccines RRR based on future exposure is the standard metric. It tells you the risk reduction if you are exposed compared to an unvaxxed person that is similarly exposed. Pretty damned obivous what it means. Absolute risk reduction in a vaccine study depends on the average time and prevalance during the study. That has nothing to do with how effective a vaccine over different time intervals, prevelances, or should a surge occur. It's like if someone did a study of measles vaccines in the USA they would find a ARR of < .1% even if the RRR > 90% because there is very little measles around overall.

Zeez Louise, this is 8th grade arithmetic.
 
mighty might

From AP News: "“That will come with legal processes that will be able to get more information and to bring legal accountability to those who committed misconduct,” DeSantis said."

If Governor DeSantis had said "might have committed," I would still want to know what evidence currently exists even to make the allegation. However by leaving out the "might," he is prejudicing the outcome of any grand jury investigation or additional legal proceeding. It boggles the mind.
 
Last edited:
Pierre Kory's book on Ivermectin

Pierre Kory wrote a book called The War on Ivermectin, which Skyhorse is publishing Simon and Schuster is distributing, if I understand correctly. What are they thinking?!

"It is infuriating to see misinformation mongers being taken seriously," Timothy Caulfield, LLM, professor of health law and science policy at the University of Alberta in Edmonton, told MedPage Today. "This kind of book can do great harm. It legitimizes bad science and erodes trust in scientific institutions."

Here is a 2021 entry in Ivermectin from the Science blog "In the Pipeline," written by medicinal chemist Derek Lowe.
 
Last edited:
"Follow the Science" postcast with Derek Lowe

It's about 18 months old and is therefore somewhat dated. Yet it's a good discussion of ivermectin, the vaccines, and viruses.
 
300%

On the Thursday 29 December Jesse Watters program, a guest host (Katie Pavlich) was slamming boosters. In a segment (starting around 3:30) a study using workers at the Cleveland Clinic is claimed to involve more than 51,011 subjects. The segment referenced Yale workers claiming that vaccine was only 30% effective at preventing infection. Her most interesting claim is that each booster increase the risk of getting Covid-19 by 300%. This was put on screen:

"Among 51011 working-aged Cleveland Clinic employees, the bivalent COVID-19 vaccine booster was 30% effective in preventing infection..."

With respect to the question 30% effectiveness, I would counter by asking what the same study showed about hospitalizations and deaths, but see below. I am a little bit less sure what is going on with the 300% claim, but this link to a CBS News story from last June might be a good place to start. I did not see 300% in the preprint discussed below, but I would like to know the origin of this number.

Getting back to the quote above, I found a preprint (not yet peer-reviewed) where this quote appeared here. These authors wrote, "There were too few severe illnesses for the study to be able to determine if the vaccine decreased severity of illness. Our study of healthcare personnel included no children and few elderly subjects, and the majority would not have been immunocompromised." They also wrote, "The bivalent COVID-19 vaccine given to working-aged adults afforded modest protection overall against COVID-19, while the virus strains dominant in the community were those represented in the vaccine."
EDT
See this link starting near 3:35 for Katie Pavlich's comments.
 
Last edited:
On the Thursday 29 December Jesse Watters program, a guest host (Katie Pavlich) was slamming boosters. In this segment (starting around 3:30) a study using workers at the Cleveland Clinic is claimed to involve more than 51,011 subjects. The segment referenced Yale workers claiming that vaccine was only 30% effective at preventing infection. Her most interesting claim is that each booster increase the risk of getting Covid-19 by 300%. This was put on screen:

"Among 51011 working-aged Cleveland Clinic employees, the bivalent COVID-19 vaccine booster was 30% effective in preventing infection..."

With respect to the chain about 30% effectiveness, I would counter by asking what the same study showed about hospitalizations and deaths. I am a little bit less sure what is going on with the 300% claim, but this link to a CBS News story from last June might be a good place to start. I did not see 300% in the preprint discussed below, but I would like to know the origin of this number.

Getting back to the quote above, I found a preprint where this quote appeared (not yet peer-reviewed) here. These authors wrote, "There were too few severe illnesses for the study to be able to determine if the vaccine decreased severity of illness. Our study of healthcare personnel included no children and few elderly subjects, and the majority would not have been immunocompromised."

Looks like the 300% is some sort of interpretation of the charts at the end of the preprint. The charts aren't well explained in the paper but nothing in the paper suggests a 300% increase between unvaxxed and vaxxed.
 
data in the figures and tables

From Table 2, for last prior infection phase with Omicron BA.1/BA.2, the adjusted hazard risk (HR) is 8.73; with delta, it is 22.93, with pre-delta, it is 20.83, and with no known prior infection, it is 27.86.

From Table 2 for one, two, and three prior vaccine doses, the adjusted hazard risks are 1.70, 2.63, and 3.15, respectively.

From Figure 2 (a Simon-Makuch plot) at 98 days, there is a progressive increase of the cumulative incidence of Covid-19 from about 0.02 at zero doses, to about 0.03 at one dose, to about 0.048 at two doses, to about 0.058 at three doses. If we compare 3 doses to zero doses, then the ratio is about 300%. That is my best guess about where the value used in the Jesse Watters program came from. More discussion of these values from the authors might be helpful as the article moves from preprint to final form.

The authors also noted that "We were unable to distinguish between symptomatic and asymptomatic infections, and had to limit our analyses to all detected infections."
 
Chris,

It looks like I screwed up. Just looked at the initial summary/abstract which was focused on the bi-valent booster efficacy. Then looked at the chart showing showing a high correlation between number of vaxxes and covid infections in the last 3 months. Since the bi-valent booster showed some efficacy, the large numbers associated with higher numbers of jabs seemed completely nuts. My poor excuse is that I've mostly been focusing on the FTX/crypto situation as what happened appeals to my geekiness and business practices associated with bubbles.

But in reading the paper I'm now quite intrigued. That having the largested number of jabs means one is 3 times as likely to get covid than someone unvaxxed is striking. The study authors were surprised too and found a paper showing a similar report. Probably as a result of the surprise. Surprised researchers tend to check their processes and math for any errors so it's probably not that type of error.

If true, this would be trivially easy to duplicate in any population where more testing is done. The problem right now in the USA is that most all testing occurs at the point of hospitalization. Pretty large set of studies showing covid hospitalizations are more likely for unvaxxed. This study cohort testing went beyond that but still didn't capture most or many assymptomatic infections.

What are the possible causes?

Viral evolution towards specifically evading vaccination immunity combined with some ADE that reduces the initial response. However, the continued, lower, hospitalization and death rates suggest that the delayed immune response more than makes uf for the initial ADE.

In any case this really, needs study. Retrosptective information is readily available in those cohorts where PCR testing rate is high with only minor symptoms. Kaiser in Calif. comes to mind.

EtoA: Discussion of this study might be better in the Covid Science thread. Could well be a real effect.
 
Last edited:
Could it not just be due to the fact that those who know they are more vulnerable to catching it and/or getting a serious case if they do are more likely to get vaccinated?
 
Could it not just be due to the fact that those who know they are more vulnerable to catching it and/or getting a serious case if they do are more likely to get vaccinated?

Probably not in the study. N was 50k but they were relatively young, healthy workers. The number of hospitalizations and/or deaths was so small, which they noted, it wasn't significant enough for the authors to report.

In San Diego County vaxxed were hospitalized/died at about 40% of the unvaxxed. They were heavily skewed to the elderly. So if this study is correct, it suggests vaxxes substantially increase the probability of infection but also decreases even more the risk of serious illness.
 
a head scratcher

I agree that this needs further thought and study. In addition to the important distinction between infections and hospitalizations, their study does not discriminate between symptomatic versus asymptomatic infections. For these reasons, I am disinclined to change my present stance, which is to continue getting boosted on a regular basis.
 
I agree that this needs further thought and study. In addition to the important distinction between infections and hospitalizations, their study does not discriminate between symptomatic versus asymptomatic infections. For these reasons, I am disinclined to change my present stance, which is to continue getting boosted on a regular basis.


There has been a shift if vaccine efficacy.

This Minnesota dashboard is interesting. Looking that the middle age group most representative of the Ohio study there is a big shift from pre-omicron to post. They also have a "last 60 days" selection which shows a further efficacy reduction with boosted rates slightly higher for cases. Usual caveats. Observational, those most likely to be boosted may be more likely to work in higher exposure environments.

Still, marked change between pre-omicron, omicron, and last 50 days. However, hospitalizations lower for vaxxed and deaths, among the elderly, much lower. But not as marked as pre-omicron.

I also will get any new boosters as recommended. Already had the bi-valent.

https://www.health.state.mn.us/diseases/coronavirus/stats/vbt.html

One problem I have with their charts is they don't define the period "rates" are over. it clearly isn't daily or monthly and also isn't cumulative for the selected period. Might be yearly. Pathetic that they don't define the time period for the "rates"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom