Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
How they count Covid-19 deaths:

https://youtu.be/Tw9Ci2PZKZg

Less than 1 minute long. Oh I'm sure you people will continue living in denial or try to claim she means something other than what she clearly says

April 27, 2020.

You're more than a little out of date. I don't think that anyone here actually disputes that, especially very early on, things were a bit of a mess all around. Try working with more current information if you want to be even remotely convincing, though.
 
Last edited:
April 27, 2020.

You're more than a little out of date.

Your point? It explains how the deaths were being counted. Do you think they stopped counting them the way she says? Got evidence that they stopped counting that way? Oh that's right, you have to find some way to discredit what is so obvious to anyone thinking clearly.
 
Last edited:
Your point? It explains how the deaths were being counted. Do you think they stopped counting them the way she says? Got evidence that they stopped counting that way? Oh that's right, you have to find some way to discredit what is so obvious to anyone thinking clearly.
Nope. Just look at all the corpses.
 
Your point? It explains how the deaths were being counted. Do you think they stopped counting them the way she says? Got evidence that they stopped counting that way? Oh that's right, you have to find some way to discredit what is so obvious to anyone thinking clearly.

:rolleyes:

Yeah, as I posted before and you seemingly ignored, I've looked into the with and of claims notably more recently than that.

There are 4 points of special note to be made.

1) After the initial mess and once there was a chance to better review the cases, reviewing was done all over the world with regards to with versus of. Verdict - Overwhelmingly, it was of covid, not with covid. Not all, of course. There were also ambiguous cases where it was harder to determine and there were indeed rare cases in the official numbers like people who were shot and killed in domestic disputes who also tested positive who had been included. Which leads to 2.

2) In part due to political pressure from people like you, for better or worse, efforts were specifically made to remove the cases that had clear non-covid causes of death from the numbers once those reviews were made, unrecognized as those efforts are likely to remain among those who are invested in narrative over reality. The reduction of the numbers was, of course, effectively negligible and immediately negated because of the relative rarity of that category and the ever growing number of clear "ofs." Here's one example link - COVID-19 deaths unrelated to the virus being taken from total counts. To quote a bit of that that specifically addresses the challenge that you made -

These changes are taking place in two phases. Phase 1 will take place on June 17, and Phase 2 will roll out over the next few weeks.

Phase 1: Remove deaths where COVID-19 did not contribute to death from our death count. For Phase 1, this will result in seven deaths being removed from our current death count, including two suicides, three homicides, and two overdose deaths. Four of the deaths are from King and three are from Yakima. Additional non-COVID-19 deaths may be removed throughout the course of the COVID-19 outbreak.

Phase 2: Expand how we report deaths to identify whether we can confirm or rule-out COVID-19 as a contributing cause of death, including identifying probable and suspected deaths. As part of Phase 2, future COVID-19 death classifications will include whether:

1. COVID-19 contributed to the death (death certificate, testing, and other case information available to confirm);
2. COVID-19 probably contributed to the death (death certificate information available but testing information not available);
3. COVID-19 is suspected to have contributed to death (follow-up being conducted prior to ruling out or confirming death); or
4. COVID-19 did not contribute to the death (examples include homicide, overdose, suicide, car accident, or disease with clear exclusion of COVID-19 illness).

Nevertheless, that didn't stop the ongoing issue of 3.

3) Rightwing politicians literally made up stories about cases of clear "withs," which were seized on as part of the ongoing politicization of the issue. There was a much larger right-wing political effort for the sakes of, for example, minimizing and diverting blame away from Trump and the Republicans for how absurdly they screwed the pooch, appeasing Trump, protecting short-term profits and the supremacy of business owners over employees, and so on.

4) Going past all that noise, though, the multiple lines of evidence that are normally treated as most indicative of the larger picture and the large consensus of actual experts on the subject all firmly seem to point at the conclusion that any problem with overcounts is negligible compared to the problem of undercounting, regardless of how much right-wing propagandists worked to try to make all of us look at individual (hypothetical) trees instead of the actual forest.
 
Last edited:
The 1918-19 influenza pandemic didn't even have a known cause. The influenza virus was discovered in 1930 and the pandemic attributed to it.

Ultimately, it's the body count that matters with a disease.
 
Your point? It explains how the deaths were being counted. Do you think they stopped counting them the way she says? Got evidence that they stopped counting that way? Oh that's right, you have to find some way to discredit what is so obvious to anyone thinking clearly.

Ah. You’re back.

What are your thoughts concerning the number of dead over the kast years in the Netherlands, as I posted in post 1512?
 
How they count Covid-19 deaths:

https://youtu.be/Tw9Ci2PZKZg

Less than 1 minute long. Oh I'm sure you people will continue living in denial or try to claim she means something other than what she clearly says

Let me guess: you're trying to establish a distinction between "died OF covid" and "died WITH covid"?

It's an irrelevant distinction, since it works that way for a LOT of other diseases as well, including the flu.
 
The Dutch Government, medical professionals, statisticians, and opposition parliamentarians made up those numbers so CNN could have better ratings.

Thing is, some people actually believe that.

What kind of mental issue someone's got to have to make sense of something like this is kind of baffling to me.
 
More on Dr. Simone Gold

Aridas,

Thank you for those links. From the Guardian, "'She and her organization show a wilful ignorance of science and the scientific method, as well as a disrespect for accomplished scientific institutions and brilliant scientists,' said Dr Jeffrey Koplan, an epidemiologist and vice president for Global Health at Emory University who used to head the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)."
 
Two links from Johns Hopkins

Now consider the record low number of flu cases this season...

Ok, let us do that. "'Though caused by a different virus from the one that causes COVID-19, the flu is also a respiratory viral disease, so everything we are doing to slow transmission of COVID-19, such as wearing face masks, frequent handwashing and physical distancing, should also reduce transmission of flu,' says Eili Klein, Ph.D., associate professor of emergency medicine at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine" link


"The Johns Hopkins epidemiologist already knew that flu transmission would be reduced because people were following the public health safety precautions recommended to prevent acquiring the novel coronavirus.

With people still wearing masks, washing their hands frequently and physically distancing, he expected these measures to temper the flu this year. And, with most public schools — major transmission routes for flu — likely remaining closed, in addition to restaurant and business closures, there were even fewer opportunities for flu to spread." link
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:

Yeah, as I posted before and you seemingly ignored, I've looked into the with and of claims notably more recently than that.

There are 4 points of special note to be made.

1) After the initial mess and once there was a chance to better review the cases, reviewing was done all over the world with regards to with versus of. Verdict - Overwhelmingly, it was of covid, not with covid. Not all, of course. There were also ambiguous cases where it was harder to determine and there were indeed rare cases in the official numbers like people who were shot and killed in domestic disputes who also tested positive who had been included. Which leads to 2.

2) In part due to political pressure from people like you, for better or worse, efforts were specifically made to remove the cases that had clear non-covid causes of death from the numbers once those reviews were made, unrecognized as those efforts are likely to remain among those who are invested in narrative over reality. The reduction of the numbers was, of course, effectively negligible and immediately negated because of the relative rarity of that category and the ever growing number of clear "ofs." Here's one example link - COVID-19 deaths unrelated to the virus being taken from total counts. To quote a bit of that that specifically addresses the challenge that you made -



Nevertheless, that didn't stop the ongoing issue of 3.

3) Rightwing politicians literally made up stories about cases of clear "withs," which were seized on as part of the ongoing politicization of the issue. There was a much larger right-wing political effort for the sakes of, for example, minimizing and diverting blame away from Trump and the Republicans for how absurdly they screwed the pooch, appeasing Trump, protecting short-term profits and the supremacy of business owners over employees, and so on.

4) Going past all that noise, though, the multiple lines of evidence that are normally treated as most indicative of the larger picture and the large consensus of actual experts on the subject all firmly seem to point at the conclusion that any problem with overcounts is negligible compared to the problem of undercounting, regardless of how much right-wing propagandists worked to try to make all of us look at individual (hypothetical) trees instead of the actual forest.
Great post, thank you!
 
Your point? It explains how the deaths were being counted. Do you think they stopped counting them the way she says? Got evidence that they stopped counting that way? Oh that's right, you have to find some way to discredit what is so obvious to anyone thinking clearly.
Hospitals maxed out. Morgues maxed out. That didn't happen due to counting irregularities.
 
Hospitals maxed out. Morgues maxed out. That didn't happen due to counting irregularities.

And in the UK's first wave both "dying with" and "dying of" data were collected and later comparison found a 93% correlation.

("With" meant anyone who died within 28 days of a positive test and "of" was only those whose main cause of death assessed by their doctor was Covid19.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom