In a November 2020 article for the Office for Science and Society, McGill University science communicator Jonathan Jarry sees Sears as part of the conspirituality trend, a phenomenon which he describes as combining New Age spirituality and conspiracy theory beliefs of "a group secretly control[ling] the political and social order and also that humanity is on the verge of a paradigm shift in consciousness". Jarry notes that Sears was "recently censored on YouTube for spreading unfounded conspiracy theories" and that "JP Sears [uses] his massive online platforms to discredit public health measures against COVID-19 and to open the door to grand conspiracy theories. Distrust is the name of the game, and he does it with comedic flair." Sears has claimed that vitamin D provides protection against COVID-19 and has referred to face masks as "face suffocators".
In January 2021, following up on Office for Science and Society piece, Vice reported that in November, on election day, Sears had joined with Mikki Willis, producer of COVID-19 misinformation videos Plandemic, anti-vaccine promoter Del Bigtree, former United States president Donald Trump's ex-wife Marla Maples, and a "large crowd" at the home of film producer Stephen Huntsman in Austin, Texas to pray for Trump. The agenda of the meeting "making an implicit protest against COVID safety guidelines by meeting together indoors and apparently maskless, and sending a combined positive energy in the direction of the then-president", to discuss Willis's upcoming film, and to discuss a plan to create a resort on nearby Lake Travis. According to Vice, Sears "appears increasingly redpilled, producing harder-edged videos mocking lockdowns and other COVID restrictions and increasingly implying those lockdowns are just a pretext to limit human freedom" and notes claims by Sears regarding "potential voter fraud" during the 2020 United States presidential election.
In February 2021, Sears appeared as a speaker at the Health Freedom Summit, an online event featuring speakers "promoting anti-vaccination, anti-mask, and pro-homeschool views".