Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why have you switched from posting lies to posting common knowledge, Bubba?

At last check, Fauci obsessed CTs have been trying to character assassinate Fauci because, for example, Fauci dared to slight Trump by contradicting Trump's knowingly false claims about COVID and didn't bow to their many death threats. As part of that, they've tried hard to shift blame for COVID onto Fauci using whatever means they can, including, of course, guilt by utter unreasonability, which is what the Fauci funded the Wuhan Lab accusation boils down to.
 
Last edited:
Fauci funded the wuhan lab where the virus came from with US taxpayer money.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QH6-seSJMBo

Edited by xjx388: 
Edit for Rule 0/12


Have you managed to find those documents proving this claim yet?

I note that you have not hedged this claim about with get-outs like 'some people say', or 'I read it somewhere'. Does this mean this is one of the rare times when you actually believe what you're posting?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The US has 4% of the world's population and 28% of the coronavirus deaths

You're out of date Bubba, It hasn't been 28% for a long time. It is currently 17% and dropping. Seems the rest of the World is catching up to the USA.
 
I would also point out, though undoubtedly pointlessly for some, that the US is varied regionally. In Vermont, where some rational responses have occurred, and whose governor, as it happens, is a follower of Dr. Fauci, and even had him as a press conference guest, we lead the nation not only in vaccination numbers, but in the negative numbers of deaths and new cases.

While you're spouting furious nonsense and bloviating about things you don't know and can't understand, we're sitting pretty, masks off not because we falsely reject them but because we no longer need them.
 
The reduction in excess deaths below the COVID-19 deaths in the second wave is almost certainly due to COVID-19 mitigation measures (like lockdowns and improved hygiene) reducing other causes of death - for example Norovirus outbreaks and flu have been almost completely suppressed this last year.

By my previous counting, the first wave had about 70,000 deaths - about 20,000 more than those recorded on the death certificates for the first wave.

Which makes both waves very similar, but the second wave slightly worse.

Thanks for the detailed charts. The chart I used had baseline deaths based on the prior 5 years. Some variability there.
I hope you mean from 2015-2019 because you *really* don't want to use 2020 for any calculation of excess deaths in 2021 even in an average.

For Wks01-30 mine is that. For wks 31-53 it is 2014-2018 (as my 2019-20 chart started there) so it is the 5 years before. The differences are very minor unless you are including 2020 in the average (which would have a 20% effect of the difference in raising the 5-year average for April and May when it was high in 2020)

I used excess deaths w/o regard to Covid-19 labelled deaths. There's still a lot of "death from" vs. "death with" Covid-19 nonsense from deniers. And excess deaths captures all the effects of the pandemic including reductions in flu and traffic deaths from NPIs as well as additional deaths from delayed care/overdosing/etc.

Here's the graph I got from cumulating the weekly excess death numbers from Statista starting at Week 13 of 2020 until Week 19 of 2021.

[IMGW=640]https://dm2305files.storage.live.com/y4m-Ll4FmoryQSDXpRLBnw4pmm39uAhnOIrHoRXBjKm78U6PzLSLcvYf1iq2kx_Pnyxlv4MzoSmESPiCTHC8okZlVNUfKxUprjZTqO3TgJ-jxJhlFCCANFA7e5MMlhVhxn4DyO9hkeGWq-ON_8vngH7b32RWAqd6aME2QvY5uS4g9k?width=512&height=243&cropmode=none[/IMGW]

The peak of the first wave was at 59252 and the peak of the second wave was 112926. Arguably, it could also be looked at as the minimum between the two peaks v the excess deaths at the end (week 19 of 2021). In both cases the second wave had fewer excess deaths than the first.

But it's also clear from other data the Covid-19 specific deaths in the second wave are higher. The chart dips in the absolute numbers are most likely due to the dramatically reduced flu (it was in flu season) and other NPI reduced deaths and possibly from reduced deaths that would have occurred had no Covid-19 killed as many old/vulnerable people in the first wave.

To summarize, I believe Noah Carl's post is largely correct in pointing out the NY Times error.

N. Y. Times:
Britain had more daily Covid-related deaths during the surge involving B.1.1.7 than in the first wave, when there was less understanding of how to treat the disease and far fewer therapeutics that later helped cut mortality rates. Even after the vaccination campaign began, B.1.1.7 kept spreading rapidly among the unvaccinated.

Noah Carl:
However, it simply isn’t true that there were more COVID-related deaths “during the surge involving B.1.1.7”.

I would disagree with that. One can use the excess deaths to increase the estimate for the first wave by about 13,000 but that still doesn't get you to the second wave being smaller than the first.

the numbers in hospital ventilators is also consistent with the second wave being worse.

https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/healthcare#card-patients_in_mechanical_ventilation_beds
Screenshot 2021-06-02 171543.jpg



Now arguably the cumulative numbers are much closer, and Noah's data ends in Feb. but even there Noah seems more correct than the Times. And the Times' statement I bolded is clearly wrong.

The NYT statement is indeed incorrect. If one looks at death certificate data, it is true, although the ONS says that first wave had 12,408 non-Covid excess deaths that were probably due to Covid. However compared to Noah's pretence that the first wave was worse, it is pretty minor, as the cumulative totals were worse - and he's ignoring lots of other confounding factors.

It's like correcting someone for saying the US flag is Blue, White, and Pink and then saying it's not - it's green, white, and red.
 
I hope you mean from 2015-2019 because you *really* don't want to use 2020 for any calculation of excess deaths in 2021 even in an average.

For Wks01-30 mine is that. For wks 31-53 it is 2014-2018 (as my 2019-20 chart started there) so it is the 5 years before. The differences are very minor unless you are including 2020 in the average (which would have a 20% effect of the difference in raising the 5-year average for April and May when it was high in 2020)



I would disagree with that. One can use the excess deaths to increase the estimate for the first wave by about 13,000 but that still doesn't get you to the second wave being smaller than the first.

the numbers in hospital ventilators is also consistent with the second wave being worse.

https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/healthcare#card-patients_in_mechanical_ventilation_beds
View attachment 44724





The NYT statement is indeed incorrect. If one looks at death certificate data, it is true, although the ONS says that first wave had 12,408 non-Covid excess deaths that were probably due to Covid. However compared to Noah's pretence that the first wave was worse, it is pretty minor, as the cumulative totals were worse - and he's ignoring lots of other confounding factors.

It's like correcting someone for saying the US flag is Blue, White, and Pink and then saying it's not - it's green, white, and red.

These are the cumulative Excess deaths in 2020 and 2021 (up to and including week 19), for the Netherlands, set against the average of 2015-2019.
The actual numbers will be a little bit different as the weeks 1 and 52-53 are not included (these mostly being incomplete weeks in the year and the numbers are week based).

picture.php


Source: Central Bureau of Statistics.
Only the last five complete years before the running year are shown, so the 2015 numbers, which I could see until week 1 this year, have now been deleted from the site.
Seeing as 2015 was a thoroughly average year, this would not change a lot, if you'd omit that data.

Anyway.
2020 started very good, with the deaths being a bit less than average.
And then COVID happened!
My theory for the 2021 dip in excess deaths, which you can see, is the absence of the normal flue season, which would ordinarily have happened there.
 
These are the cumulative Excess deaths in 2020 and 2021 (up to and including week 19), for the Netherlands, set against the average of 2015-2019.
The actual numbers will be a little bit different as the weeks 1 and 52-53 are not included (these mostly being incomplete weeks in the year and the numbers are week based).

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1340&pictureid=12839[/qimg]

Source: Central Bureau of Statistics.
Only the last five complete years before the running year are shown, so the 2015 numbers, which I could see until week 1 this year, have now been deleted from the site.
Seeing as 2015 was a thoroughly average year, this would not change a lot, if you'd omit that data.

Anyway.
2020 started very good, with the deaths being a bit less than average.
And then COVID happened!
My theory for the 2021 dip in excess deaths, which you can see, is the absence of the normal flue season, which would ordinarily have happened there.


Similar happened in the UK and also in Sweden that I know of.

Screenshot 2021-06-02 190820.jpg
 
I hope you mean from 2015-2019 because you *really* don't want to use 2020 for any calculation of excess deaths in 2021 even in an average.

For Wks01-30 mine is that. For wks 31-53 it is 2014-2018 (as my 2019-20 chart started there) so it is the 5 years before. The differences are very minor unless you are including 2020 in the average (which would have a 20% effect of the difference in raising the 5-year average for April and May when it was high in 2020)

Agreed, However, adding in 20% of the excess deaths through to the 58th week of the pandemic doesn't alter excess deaths from my link. After doing this, there were 59252 excess deaths in the first wave and 55581 in the second wave in England and Wales.

I would disagree with that. One can use the excess deaths to increase the estimate for the first wave by about 13,000 but that still doesn't get you to the second wave being smaller than the first.

I cumulated the numbers from the start of positive excess deaths in 2020 which was about the first week in April from the Statitica website. See the earlier link. However, the baseline, as noted, is the average of the previous 5 years. There can be enough variation in baselines, depending on the years used, to flip the excess cumulatives.

However, this completely misses the argument made: that the Daily death rate was higher in the second wave than the first. In terms of daily excess deaths this is false. However, his article in lockdownskeptics remains misleading because cumulative deaths is more meaningful than daily deaths except for resource requirements.

Here's the exact quote from the NY Times:
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/28/opinion/covid-vaccine-variants.html
Britain had more daily Covid-related deaths during the surge involving B.1.1.7 than in the first wave

You mentioned ventilators:
the numbers in hospital ventilators is also consistent with the second wave being worse.
Not surprising. The second wave had many more hospitalized that were younger and and a smaller percentage of them died. Not to mention treatment was better by the second wave.
 
The US has 4% of the world's population and 28% of the coronavirus deaths

If we had a better president early in the pandemic we would have had fewer deaths. The morons who voted for that stupid bitch Trump are to blame for those deaths.
 
If we had a better president early in the pandemic we would have had fewer deaths. The morons who voted for that stupid bitch Trump are to blame for those deaths.

Essentially correct. How Trump and his bootlickers aren't in prison for his handling of that alone...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom