Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
There's a very relevant issue that you're dodging here, incidentally. Of the people that you're actually dealing with on these boards, how well informed are they?

To poke at the hospitalization issue, for example... early on, when testing was barely available yet and was much more frequently being used on the most likely and serious cases, hospitalization related to positive tests was at roughly 10%, IIRC, just to give reference, and that was known by more than a few of those here, with all the caveats that that entails. You're not dealing so much here with random people who have no idea what they're talking about, in short, regardless of the warped logic that you might be trying to apply.

It's actually varied quite a lot in the USA since the start of the pandemic. Through April 2020, it was hard to get tested even if you were symptomatic. Hence perhaps only 1 in 20 that got C19 were tested since you mostly had to be hospitalized to get tested. And not clinically symptomatic was around half the infected. Basically, unless you were having real difficulty breathing, you stayed home. Most were never tested, and few went to the hospital where they were then tested. At that time high percentages, 10% to 15% of those that were hospitalized died.

This, of course, was in the USA where test rollout was quite delayed. Quite different in S. Korea for instance where trace and track was done from the beginning.
 
Well, it's the commonly used name, but is rather inaccurate seeing that there are two other countries in North America. US-ians (or USAans) is not necessarily dismissive.

The governments and people of Antigua and Barbuda, The Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Costa Rica, Cuba, Dominica, Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Grenada, Guatemala, Haiti, Honduras, Jamaica, Nicaragua, Panama, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, and Trinidad and Tobago collectively wave their hands.
 
The correct answer is 1% - 5%.

Republicans' answers were much better, 28% vs that 41%, for example. Why do the repubs have better information.?

If two people are asked how much a typical St. Bernard dog weighs, and one says 1,000 lbs. while the other says 2,000 lbs., the former isn't better informed. They're both depressingly wrong. Republicans don't win for having a blindly ignorant guess that's closer to the actual answer.

ETA: Again, the emoticon at the top is inadvertent. I'm not angry, just amused.
 
Last edited:
Gallup poll question:

"What are the chances someone who gets covid will need to be hospitalized?"

41% of Democrats who answered said it was over 50%. Another 28% of democrats put the chances at 20-49%. So, almost 70% of democrats answering have a greatly exaggerated view of covid's danger.

The correct answer is 1% - 5%.

Republicans' answers were much better, 28% vs that 41%, for example. Why do the repubs have better information.?


That is an example of how non scientist Bill Maher presented "Show me the science"...challenging ill informed people in power doing dumb things like keeping kids out of school for no good reason.



Anyone care to say how the Dems became so ill informed?
Where do they get their 'information' ?


Bill Maher reported that. You dont have to be a scientist to share actual data on the screen. He has more.

3 minutes:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LhUBifbQTBs

(its not all Bill Maher...it is some other guy's video mostly featuring Bill Maher)

Bubba, you might as well give up trying to explain anything to these pretend smart people. They will never accept that they have been misinformed no matter how much evidence there is. They are in complete denial about the high rate of false positives, the real meaning of these big scary numbers, etc.

Months ago the maker of one of the vaccines stated that once you are vaccinated, you have a very low chance of spreading it, but the media ignored that. Just like they ignore many other things that would not be good for their ratings. Hell, a guy at CNN got caught on camera admitting to wanting to keep people scared for ratings. I'm sure these pretend smart people here will not accept that either. Some just don't want to let it go.

This was never about Science. It was always politics and power. Yes, Covid is real, but this fear porn got out of hand long ago. I say that as someone who voted for Biden and not as some crazy Trump supporter. Now, go ahead pretend smart people and attack me.
 
Bubba <uninformed crapsnip>

Worldometer USA:
United States
Coronavirus Cases:
34,035,318
Deaths:
609,421
Worldometer:
Coronavirus Cases:
170,614,935
view by country
Deaths:
3,548,098

The actual experts agree that these numbers are under reported.

I'm not a pretend smart person; I have a learning disability, but I know how to recognize bull **** when it's shoveled and you are certainly shoveling it.
 
Last edited:
Here's a log of Gallop poll results involving Covid-19.

https://news.gallup.com/opinion/gallup/308129/public-opinion-covid-crisis-gallup-news-articles.aspx

They are grouped by category and date within the category. Interesting to see the way things changed over time. Here's an interesting one that outlines the change between democrats and republicans estimates of whether covid-19 was more lethal that the seasonal flu.

https://news.gallup.com/poll/311408/republicans-skeptical-covid-lethality.aspx

Given that the flu's lethality is 0.1% for those that get it, is covid-19 more lethal?

Poll in 2020
March: Dems: 74%, Reps: 42%
April: Dems: 87%, Reps: 40%

I guess that didn't fit in with Bill Maher's narrative.
 
I didn't realize that the survey Bubba cited was of members of this forum.

The information mike81 quotes has been extensively reported in the media I use. It's also been discussed here at length. Maybe he should try reading the thread in the science subforum instead of this one.
 
Yeah that's the go-to excuse but I don't buy it. Nobody calls Canadians or Mexicans "Americans", ever. North Americans? Maybe. But that's as close as you get.

In any case the term makes no sense. Nobody calls UK residents "UK-ians" or North Koreans "DPRK-ians".

Oh dear, you don't buy it...

America is a continent (well, 2 continents) not a country.

And I use UK-ians and UK-ia on here (and elsewhere) regularly - guess I'm jusy an equal opportunity mocker.

And you still haven't expalined why anyone outside of the US should know about some obscure comedian of yours. I mentioned Andy Zaltzman, in the context of John Oliver - I really don't expect you know who he is.
 
Bubba, you might as well give up trying to explain anything to these pretend smart people. They will never accept that they have been misinformed no matter how much evidence there is.

Well, start with some evidence and we'll talk.

Showing me that _other people_, somewhere, are wrong about some things is irrelevant. You have to who that _I'M_ wrong about those things. Do you understand the difference?

And you have to pick better sources. Some raving guy in a Youtube video or blog somewhere on the dark web isn't going to do it, especially if the guy in question doesn't do citations. What am I supposed to do? Take his word for it? Just because you have doesn't mean I should. You can't convince me by insisting that you're right.

So, again, WHAT evidence?
 
America is a continent (well, 2 continents) not a country.

Who. The hell. Cares?

Demonyms aren't based on continent. They are based on TRADITION. People from the United States of America are called Americans because of that last word in the country's name. That's it. Nobody else on Earth is called "American", so there's no confusion except for people who are trying to be edgy about it. Stop it.

And you still haven't expalined why anyone outside of the US should know about some obscure comedian of yours.

Of mine? I haven't made that argument, so why should I explain it?
 
It's not being edgy (whatever that is) - it's plain old extracting the urine. A thing we do all the time over here, including of ourselves (hence my use of UK-ian and the like).

Re the comedian bit: this all started when I asked who the **** Bill Maher is and why I should care; I didn't say anything about any other aspect of Merkinanian (is that better?) culture, other than the tendency of some folk to assume we all know about everything in the US...

Meanwhile: breakfast.
 
It's not being edgy (whatever that is) - it's plain old extracting the urine.

Doing the what? That's an interesting expression!

Re the comedian bit: this all started when I asked who the **** Bill Maher is and why I should care

Yeah but the fact that he's an American, or from anywhere else, shouldn't matter to that. That's what I responded to.

Meanwhile: breakfast.

Same.
 
Doing the what? That's an interesting expression!

"Taking the piss."

Though that does suggest he uses USian to annoy folks, which I hadn't figured. I don't much like the term, but I understand why some may think that "American" is inapt and choose a different term. I don't like it because it's clunky as hell, not because I think it's offensive.
 
"Taking the piss."

Though that does suggest he uses USian to annoy folks, which I hadn't figured. I don't much like the term, but I understand why some may think that "American" is inapt and choose a different term. I don't like it because it's clunky as hell, not because I think it's offensive.

I don't like it for both reasons, and I'm not even American.
 
Oh dear, you don't buy it...

America is a continent (well, 2 continents) not a country.

And I use UK-ians and UK-ia on here (and elsewhere) regularly - guess I'm jusy an equal opportunity mocker.

And you still haven't expalined why anyone outside of the US should know about some obscure comedian of yours. I mentioned Andy Zaltzman, in the context of John Oliver - I really don't expect you know who he is.

Wait...there are other countries? Why doesn't Fox News cover this?

:D
 
... In any case the term makes no sense. Nobody calls UK residents "UK-ians" ...

The very same poster you're challenging over his use of "US-ians" also uses "UK-ians" and has done so in this very thread. It's a clunky sort of quirk but I take it to be entirely lighthearted and don't believe it's intended to belittle anyone.

<edit> Okay, I'm just catching up here. Once again I'm safely ignored.
 
Last edited:
Months ago the maker of one of the vaccines stated that once you are vaccinated, you have a very low chance of spreading it, but the media ignored that.

Who, please, and when, and what exactly did they say?

The reason I ask is that the impression I have formed from media reports is that once you are vaccinated you have a very low chance of becoming seriously ill with Covid-19 (90-95% better off than unvaccinated) but your chances of catching and spreading it, although significantly reduced, are not improved to the same degree (maybe 60%-ish).

There have been a lot of percentages quoted over recent months for various effects of various vaccines, and they've varied quite a bit as data have been collected, so I'm interested to know what it was this person actually said, to understand what they meant by "very low chance", what they based it on and why you think what they said was ignored.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom