The disconnect from logic is breathtaking.
Nobody in any state government wanted to shut anything down on any level. This is why all of them waited for the CDC to at least hint this would bea smart move, and even then states like California, Illinois, and New York went purely with (Trump's) CDC guidelines instead of consulting with the world class medical schools within their borders. All we needed to do was lock-down hard for two weeks and then a soft lockdown as was applied for 3 to 6 months. What we got instead was ad hock with certain states on full lockdown being undermined by neighboring states that refused to do anything. Even in California some counties refused to enforce mask requirements. Most of these are in the Central Valley along the Interstate 5 and the East-West highways which lead to spikes, which lead to second and third lockdowns due to Emergency Rooms being overwhelmed.
Any rational person looking at the US response to COVID-19 sees no coherent response at all, let alone a master plan.