Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
By the use of critical thinking skills.

You should try it.
Well, I have offered to meet some members here and I will.That would seem to be evidence that I am real and they are real. We are interested in ancient monuments. I volunteer as guide. Also as guide to good beer and food. As one does.

Not my first rodeo in regard to actually meeting real people.
 
Well, I have offered to meet some members here and I will.That would seem to be evidence that I am real and they are real. We are interested in ancient monuments. I volunteer as guide. Also as guide to good beer and food. As one does.



Not my first rodeo in regard to actually meeting real people.
Now I want to know which thread this was meant for. [emoji2]
 
Quibble - Much of the time, germs of truth in sources like that aren't all that hard to pick out. It's just that, all too frequently, it's trivialities blown way out of proportion and then spun wildly out of reasonability. To poke at an example, vaccines aren't 100% safe, for example. Friggin' duh. Those sources repeatedly fearmongering with anecdotes about extremely rare cases where said vaccine *might* have caused a more serious adverse reaction without even a hint of acknowledging the larger picture, which ends up showing that said vaccine reduces net risks of serious harm quite significantly, doesn't lead to skeptics dismissing the truth that actually is there, just the thoroughly dishonest narrative being spun.

Oh, don't get me wrong- I agree with what you said here.
My point was, rather, that there can be a tendency among sceptics to dismiss, almost automatically, anything originating from a site like Natural News.
I find this problematic in two ways: firstly, that if something is dismissed that is actually true, this provides credibility for the rest of the content when this is revealed, and also then ammunition for those attempting to defend the wider claims.
Secondly, proper critical thinking is not based on what I might call lazy assumptions. Whilst the possibility that any particular claim coming from a known CT site being true is remote, there is still a chance that it might be right. If we close ourselves off from opposing viewpoints before even looking at what they've got to say, we are then not practising critical thinking. I would argue that automatically dismissing the source of a claim is basically confirmation bias, and that it also leads to an information bubble, where the only input is that which fits our preconceptions.
Those germs of truth, then, may not be so noticeable if one hasn't actually bothered to go on the website and read the actual articles. Granted, there's only so much of that a rational person can stand, but it's always worth going to the source of these claims.
 
Oh, don't get me wrong- I agree with what you said here.
My point was, rather, that there can be a tendency among sceptics to dismiss, almost automatically, anything originating from a site like Natural News.
I find this problematic in two ways: firstly, that if something is dismissed that is actually true, this provides credibility for the rest of the content when this is revealed, and also then ammunition for those attempting to defend the wider claims.
Secondly, proper critical thinking is not based on what I might call lazy assumptions. Whilst the possibility that any particular claim coming from a known CT site being true is remote, there is still a chance that it might be right. If we close ourselves off from opposing viewpoints before even looking at what they've got to say, we are then not practising critical thinking. I would argue that automatically dismissing the source of a claim is basically confirmation bias, and that it also leads to an information bubble, where the only input is that which fits our preconceptions.
Those germs of truth, then, may not be so noticeable if one hasn't actually bothered to go on the website and read the actual articles. Granted, there's only so much of that a rational person can stand, but it's always worth going to the source of these claims.

You want us to check crank sites every time? No, there are more efficient methods of dealing with nonsense. I don't have to give Alex Jones, for instance, any benefit of the doubt in case this time, out of thousands of claims, it'll be true. Credibility of a source is important.
 
Natural News is basically whale.to with slightly fewer Holocaust denial articles. And whale.to has an internet law about citing it.
 
Oh look, more from RFK Jr.

Do you understand how VAERS works? You know it isn't deaths from the vaccine right?
 
Tragic story from another group on a young mother with twins and being coherced by employer to get the jabs, this is where she is now...

I am hearing stories of blood clots, heart conditions, onsets of MS, nerve damage, tinnitus, seizures, major fatigue and lord only knows what else....

Yeah, get those jabs...

She was cohered by her employer, and another woman in the office. She was told they didn't care what her opinion was, but they could not have an unvaccinated person interfacing with the public and "possibly" catching it and spreading to others. They said they might be able to give her another job, but there was no guarantee. So, in a moment of weakness she agreed to go to the Dept of Health, get the shot, get the card proving it, to make the problem go away.

Two days later she got up out of bed at 4AM when one of the twins was crying, and promptly had her left leg give out under her. She recalls when she woke up her left leg tingled, (like it was asleep), but as soon as she put weight on it, she went down to the floor.

After her sister got to the house to take care of the kids, Tim took her to the E.R. Doctor evaluated her and said they don't know specifically why, but the nerves are affected like she had an onset of M.S. By noon, her right leg was affected. At this point she is home, but in a wheelchair with a litany of tests schedules. She's paranoid to breast feed, and scared as hell if they have more kids if what happened will hurt them, and blames herself. It's a painful situation to watch.

47 y.o. Fernanda Hernandez Vega from Tolleson Arizona died from a pulmonary embolism due to COVID on July 13. She was not vaccinated due to concerns about potential side effects. She leaves a husband, 4 children & 10 grandchildren
 
47 y.o. Fernanda Hernandez Vega from Tolleson Arizona died from a pulmonary embolism due to COVID on July 13. She was not vaccinated due to concerns about potential side effects. She leaves a husband, 4 children & 10 grandchildren

So yet another lie.
 
Oh, don't get me wrong- I agree with what you said here.
My point was, rather, that there can be a tendency among sceptics to dismiss, almost automatically, anything originating from a site like Natural News.

I figured, but thought that it was still worth saying, given the wording that had been used.

I find this problematic in two ways: firstly, that if something is dismissed that is actually true, this provides credibility for the rest of the content when this is revealed, and also then ammunition for those attempting to defend the wider claims.
Secondly, proper critical thinking is not based on what I might call lazy assumptions. Whilst the possibility that any particular claim coming from a known CT site being true is remote, there is still a chance that it might be right. If we close ourselves off from opposing viewpoints before even looking at what they've got to say, we are then not practising critical thinking. I would argue that automatically dismissing the source of a claim is basically confirmation bias, and that it also leads to an information bubble, where the only input is that which fits our preconceptions.

I think that, when it comes to those issues, the nature of the dismissal matters. "This source is thoroughly untrustworthy" is not actually a claim that everything from it is false. After all, many thoroughly untrustworthy sources use true things as a base to spin wildly and happily jump onto anything that supports the narratives that they're pushing (and those things could possibly even be true). Rather, it's simply making clear that that particular source contributes little to nothing in and of itself when it comes to passing the "Cool story, bro" mark. This comes with an underlying need to be able to back up why the source is objectively very untrustworthy, of course, and such certainly does need to be able to pass scrutiny. That doesn't actually run foul of either of the concerns that you raise.

On the other hand, you seem to be addressing variations of "X is wrong because it's from Y source" with your points. When it comes to addressing that, your points are fair, but very much dependent upon that argument actually being made when it comes to the dismissal in the first place. That may well not be clear, of course.


Those germs of truth, then, may not be so noticeable if one hasn't actually bothered to go on the website and read the actual articles. Granted, there's only so much of that a rational person can stand, but it's always worth going to the source of these claims.

To some extent. As noted before, though, many of the germs of truth are banal, trivial truths, abused wildly. There's generally not much point or need to verify that sort at the "source." There are other cases, though, like, say... Bubba citing Natural News earlier in the thread as it (very dishonestly) poked at a particular table in an actual paper as it tried to refute and ridicule conclusions in that paper that happened to have the side effect of showing Natural News' scaremongering to be nothing more than just that. The germs of truth were less obvious there, but were mostly limited to some accurate quotations that were wildly abused, other than the usual banal, trivial truths that were abused wildly. Still, that case was at least more worthy of review than Caroline13 falling for (or trolling with) VAERS scaremongering attempts.
 
Last edited:
do you know how many people die each year in traffic accidents after drinking water?

On a similar note: Dihydrogen monoxide is involved in some way in an incredible number of dead American citizens, yet the government refuses to act to stop Big Pharma from using it in its products.
 
I think that, when it comes to those issues, the nature of the dismissal matters. "This source is thoroughly untrustworthy" is not actually a claim that everything from it is false. After all, many thoroughly untrustworthy sources use true things as a base to spin wildly and happily jump onto anything that supports the narratives that they're pushing (and those things could possibly even be true). Rather, it's simply making clear that that particular source contributes little to nothing in and of itself when it comes to passing the "Cool story, bro" mark. This comes with an underlying need to be able to back up why the source is objectively very untrustworthy, of course, and such certainly does need to be able to pass scrutiny. That doesn't actually run foul of either of the concerns that you raise.

On the other hand, you seem to be addressing variations of "X is wrong because it's from Y source" with your points. When it comes to addressing that, your points are fair, but very much dependent upon that argument actually being made when it comes to the dismissal in the first place. That may well not be clear, of course.

Again, agreed.
My little mantra when it comes to assessing claims is 'check the source, check the evidence, check your own cognitive biases'.
If the source is known to be untrustworthy, then my policy is not to dismiss the claim, but rather to treat it with an extra amount of caution. As you mentioned with Natural News, the evidence they provide needs extra scrutiny, as their track record is miserable, and they are known for wilfully misrepresenting the facts. That's just the first step, though:I think it still important, if we're discussing a particular claim from such a site, that the counterarguments rest more on the content of the piece, rather than just the general reputation of the site.
It's also good practice- hones the critical thinking skills- plus it provides a useful insight into the methods employed by these sites to persuade the gullible to accept their claims. Know your enemy and all that.

As a side note, 'Mindf*ck' by Christopher Wiley, is a great book about Cambridge Analytica. It provides a really good insight, from an insider, into how they were able to manipulate public opinion by playing on emotive, conspiratorial tendencies. Scary stuff, but highly recommended.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom