Coral Reefs Survive being Nuked and Water Temperatures of 55,000°C

I don't know, rp. Poptech was on a roll and nothing was working. I immediately recognized a troll and ditched all effort to talk smart with him. Others had that covered (feeding the troll?) and so I just looked at what they were saying for errors of communication concerning coral reefs. It's more productive to 'educate' the critical thinkers here than the wandering trolls.

I hang in the Bigfoot threads. We have our own versions of Poptech.

I *still* want to know where is all the Bigfoot roadkill, eh?
 
this could be the worst false analogy in the history of the universe....CO2 and nuclear weapons don't really work on the same time scale...

I really like the ridiculous tags.

glenn
 
Personally I think that if the last glacial maximum couldn't render coral reefs extinct Global Warming isn't likely to either. However, for the life of me I can't figure out how this proves or disproves the existence of Global Warming. It's kind of like arguing that, because rain won't cause skyscrapers to spontaneously collapse into black holes, thunderstorms don't exist.
No claim was made that this proves or disproves global warming, especially by me. What was stated is that coral reefs are very resilient to very traumatic events.

Aha. Could that also explain why coral dies when the water temp slowly rises, even as slow as the mentioned 0.006 degrees? Because it would not go down....
They actually bleach to survive.

Reef corals bleach to survive change
(Nature, Volume 411, Issue 6839, pp. 765-766, June 2001)
- Andrew C. Baker


[nitpick] PT's claim was a 0.6C change. [/nitpick]

ETA: He does appear to have changed it later. I was looking at the OP. Never mind.
0.6c over 100 years and 0.006c per year.
 
This part of the abstract interests me...

We found that 42 coral species may be locally extinct at Bikini. Fourteen of these losses may be pseudo-losses due to inconsistent taxonomy between the two studies or insufficient sampling in the second study, however 28 species appear to represent genuine losses. Of these losses, 16 species are obligate lagoonal specialists and 12 have wider habitat compatibility. Twelve species are recorded from Bikini for the first time.
 
The last paragraph of the paper seems to suggest that this study is not necessarily applicable to what Poptech has in mind...


Bikini Atoll provides a rare opportunity to examine the long-term impacts of nuclear testing on coral biodiversity. The scale and local intensity of this violent historical event are profound. If the disturbance event were to be repeated in the modern day, recovery would not be expected to be as high, due to the combination of additional stressors associated with climate change (Anthony et al., 2007; Lesser, 2007) and a possibly much altered atoll environment due to an additional 50 years of human occupation. Thus, in a twist of fate, the radioactive contamination of northern Marshall Island Atolls has enabled the recovery of the reefs of Bikini Atoll to take place in the absence of further anthropogenic pressure. Today Bikini Atoll provides a diverse coral reef community and a convincing example of partial resilience of coral biodiversity to non-chronic disturbance events.


References in this paragraph...

Anthony, K.R.N., Connolly, S.R., Hoegh-Guldberg, O., 2007. Bleaching, energetics, and coral mortality risk: effects of temperature, light, and sediment regime. Limnology and Oceanography 52, 716–726.

Lesser, M.P., 2007. Coral reef bleaching and global climate change: can corals survive the next century? Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 104, 5259–5260.
 
this could be the worst false analogy in the history of the universe....CO2 and nuclear weapons don't really work on the same time scale...

I really like the ridiculous tags.

glenn
Really?

Search for "macdoc and Hiroshima and Greenland"
 
The last paragraph of the paper seems to suggest that this study is not necessarily applicable to what Poptech has in mind...

If the disturbance event were to be repeated in the modern day, recovery would not be expected to be as high,
Absolutely nothing in their paper supports this conclusion.
 
Neither makes those conclusions in relation to the the Bikini coral reef.
You're so right! And I also can't find any scientific paper saying that it would kill you, personally, if you ate a teaspoonful of cyanide. So unless for some magical reason conclusions about people in general also apply to particular people, you should be safe enough doing that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom