Coral Reefs Survive being Nuked and Water Temperatures of 55,000°C

.- --. .-. . . -.. ? / .... --- .-- / -- .- -. -.-- / -- --- .-. . / --- ..-. / - .... . ... . / -- . ... ... .- --. . ... / -... . ..-. --- .-. . / - .... . / -- --- -.. ... / -.. --- -. .----. - / - .... .. -. -.- / .. - / ..-. ..- -. / .- -. -.-- -- --- .-. . ..--.. / .- -. -.. / -.. --- / .-- . / .- .-.. .-.. / ..- ... . / - .... . / ... .- -- . / - .-. .- -. ... .-.. .- - --- .-. ..--..
 
Personally I think that if the last glacial maximum couldn't render coral reefs extinct Global Warming isn't likely to either. However, for the life of me I can't figure out how this proves or disproves the existence of Global Warming. It's kind of like arguing that, because rain won't cause skyscrapers to spontaneously collapse into black holes, thunderstorms don't exist.
 
wh3n 7h3 7r0££$ £34v3

•••

Some reef systems have been developing for thousands of years...of course new reef systems will start and some are migrating to deeper or cooler waters ven now - but complex reef systems are far more than just the coral....

The Cuban reef systems - perhaps the last remaining Caribbean complex are very at risk with warming.

I recall wading into the water to wash off a cut on the dry end of the island ( eastern ) and the water was not warm....it was HOT. Like a bathtub - hot.

Marine ecosystems are very complex and we fool around with keystone structures at our peril if we wish to keep bio-diversity.

Already jellyfish are a plague in many areas.

It's not just climate - it's other anthro abuse as well

http://esciencenews.com/articles/2009/06/09/jellyfish.joyride.a.threat.oceans
 
The Cuban reef systems - perhaps the last remaining Caribbean complex are very at risk with warming.

I recall wading into the water to wash off a cut on the dry end of the island ( eastern ) and the water was not warm....it was HOT. Like a bathtub - hot.


I agree with your thoughtful post, but your hot water experience might not be related to the issue of climate change (warming). Between tides, water in certain coastal areas can heat up dramatically under intense solar radiation. Most Cuban reefs are offshore fringing-type with a lagoon between them and the shore. The water that you waded into probably had a higher temp than that out where the reefs are. Those fringing reefs have open ocean on one side and a lagoon on the other. Anyway, if the water is bathtub hot out on those reefs then there will probably be bleaching events.
 
I agree with your thoughtful post, but your hot water experience might not be related to the issue of climate change (warming). Between tides, water in certain coastal areas can heat up dramatically under intense solar radiation. Most Cuban reefs are offshore fringing-type with a lagoon between them and the shore. The water that you waded into probably had a higher temp than that out where the reefs are. Those fringing reefs have open ocean on one side and a lagoon on the other. Anyway, if the water is bathtub hot out on those reefs then there will probably be bleaching events.

Mr. Parcher, I owe you an apology. From this post I now understand that you *do* know what you are talking about.

However, you either seem to be absent-minded or you know so much and assume that most people do know what you are talking about whilst they do not.

So, my apologies for mistaking you for a troll and for treating you the way I did.

Now, please, what are bleaching events?
 
Bikini Corals Recover From Atomic Blast (The University of Queensland, Australia)

They survived water temperatures of 55,000°C degrees, yet they are surely doomed to extinction from a 0.6°C increase in temperature.

So...you're essentially a troll who starts threads using outrageous claims in a sad bid for attention?
Thanks for being so blatant about it.
I won't waste any time responding in future.
 
Mr. Parcher, I owe you an apology. From this post I now understand that you *do* know what you are talking about.

However, you either seem to be absent-minded or you know so much and assume that most people do know what you are talking about whilst they do not.

So, my apologies for mistaking you for a troll and for treating you the way I did.

Now, please, what are bleaching events?


I didn't think you thought I was trolling. I thought you were trolling. LOL

I can't assume what people do or don't know in this thread because there are already plenty of very informed posts in this thread.

Bleaching is a stress reaction in corals and other organisms that harbor endosymbionts. That Wikipedia link will also provide a link to coral bleaching. The corals expel the symbionts from their tissue and the result is the appearance that the coral has been bleached (because the underlying carbonate skeleton is usually white). Bleaching is generally associated with elevated water temperature, and gets worse the longer the temp remains elevated.
 
I didn't think you thought I was trolling. I thought you were trolling. LOL

I can't assume what people do or don't know in this thread because there are already plenty of very informed posts in this thread.

Bleaching is a stress reaction in corals and other organisms that harbor endosymbionts. That Wikipedia link will also provide a link to coral bleaching. The corals expel the symbionts from their tissue and the result is the appearance that the coral has been bleached (because the underlying carbonate skeleton is usually white). Bleaching is generally associated with elevated water temperature, and gets worse the longer the temp remains elevated.

Aha. Could that also explain why coral dies when the water temp slowly rises, even as slow as the mentioned 0.006 degrees? Because it would not go down....
 
Could that also explain why coral dies when the water temp slowly rises, even as slow as the mentioned 0.006 degrees? Because it would not go down....


I'm sorry, I wasn't paying attention to that proposal. What is the question? An increase of average surface temp of 0.006C over what span of time?
 
I'm sorry, I wasn't paying attention to that proposal. What is the question? An increase of average surface temp of 0.006C over what span of time?
:P

In this thread it was mentioned more than once that a permanent increase by 0.006C per year would not harm coral reefs.

I have no idea as to the truth of this claim.
 
:P

In this thread it was mentioned more than once that a permanent increase by 0.006C per year would not harm coral reefs.

I have no idea as to the truth of this claim.


[nitpick] PT's claim was a 0.6C change. [/nitpick]


ETA: He does appear to have changed it later. I was looking at the OP. Never mind.
 
Last edited:
[nitpick] PT's claim was a 0.6C change. [/nitpick]


ETA: He does appear to have changed it later. I was looking at the OP. Never mind.

If you read the thread, the more I pestered him, the more 0's appeared, so I am starting with the lowest number mentioned :)
 
In this thread it was mentioned more than once that a permanent increase by 0.006C per year would not harm coral reefs.

I should start by saying that many people will use the terms "destroyed" or "harmed" when they are observing drastic ecological change.

In real time, that is a very low yearly increase in temp. You may not even notice the feeling of the change as you swam in the ocean every day of your life. After 30 years, the water has become 0.18 degrees higher than it was. I don't think you could distinguish a 0.18 degree difference if you ran an experiment with feet in two different buckets of water. But, what the hell does that have to do with anything?

Coral scientists (those who actually make the scientific observations) living in a time of 0.006 annual increase may not be able to observe the natural selection changes that are happening while working in the field. It could require the ability to compare exactly what was going on (say) 30 years prior to compare it to present day. My humble opinion is that this kind of increase would cause a very gradual change in the biodiversity and ecology of a given coral reef. The reef might be quite different in (say) 100 years, but we would still call it a coral reef.

That whole bit is only about the reef itself and known responses to short-term temp increases. Coral reefs are intimately connected with inshore and oceanic conditions and ecologies. So that increase could cause effects on other related environments which cause more change (harm) to the reef than the temp increase alone.
 
Seems some people don't understand climate event excursions... :rolleyes:

If I cook my ant colony for one day - does not matter how many days I don't cook them - they're dead....it's extremes that impacts fixed colonies not ****ing averages....
 
Thanks William. This thread could have been shorter had you joined earlier. But my estimation of you now is that you are more likely to educate than to bicker :)
 
I don't know, rp. Poptech was on a roll and nothing was working. I immediately recognized a troll and ditched all effort to talk smart with him. Others had that covered (feeding the troll?) and so I just looked at what they were saying for errors of communication concerning coral reefs. It's more productive to 'educate' the critical thinkers here than the wandering trolls.

I hang in the Bigfoot threads. We have our own versions of Poptech.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom