Cop charged with shooting 3 transgender women, 2 male friends

Please don't take this this personally, but there are absolutely no circumstances where its acceptable to refer to a pre-op transwoman as a dude or "transgender man". The former term is offensive to the extreme as well as being inaccurate, the latter term is a synonym for female-to-male transsexuals and makes no sense applying to male-to-female trans people.

For your amusement:

Hey Dessi,
I just watched the vid - thanks. While 'vaginoplasty' is a little freaky for me, again, I'm happy to use the preferred terms. The poster seems a little sensitive to the obvious question "are you a man or a woman?" Blaming others for asking this question seems petty.
 
I could make a logical argument that one should call dudes with their junk intact "transgender men" as easy as the above argument.
I can understand why someone would make the argument if they sincerely didn't know. Otherwise, there is no "argument" over which term is correct -- Transwoman is the terminology for MtF transsexuals.

If people are offended by natural-born males being called "dude," that's their problem not mine.
There are no circumstances where you should refer to a transgender woman as "dude", "him", or "a guy". If you do so consciously, they're going to be rightfully offended -- its degrading and extremely rude and I don't think you can excuse that by saying "their problem, not mine".
 
Last edited:
Dessi, you seem awesome, and i like you a lot. However...

Dessi said:
There are no circumstances where you should refer to a transgender woman as "dude", "him", or "a guy". If you do so consciously, they're going to be rightfully offended -- its degrading and there's no way to excuse the extreme rudeness of that behavior by saying "that's there problem, not mine".
1 - How would I know this? Really. I'm a pretty open-minded guy and I had no idea. You state that there is no "argument" as to which term is correct. I'm a dude who is reasonably up to speed on current events, and I had no idea about what you are saying.
2 - If I didn't know this, why would "dude" be an offensive term for a guy with a penis?
3 - If it's not penis related, how is someone supposed to keep track of whether it's been snipped or not, in terms of whether to use the term "dude?"
 
Hey Dessi,
I just watched the vid - thanks. While 'vaginoplasty' is a little freaky for me, again, I'm happy to use the preferred terms. The poster seems a little sensitive to the obvious question "are you a man or a woman?" Blaming others for asking this question seems petty.
Calpernia Addams is a very well-known trans activist. I can imagine she's particularly sensitive to trans issues since, in 1999, her boyfriend was murdered by his fellow Army mates when they learned he was dating a transwoman (wiki). After that story, she became very high-profile in the media and was the subject of some really really nasty attacks from all sides.

Its a very very sensitive topic. A lot of tg people want to completely disown the very thought and memory of their biological sex, its a source of extreme discomfort. And it certainly doesn't help that nearly all anti-trans people refer to trans people, tg women in particular, with incorrect pronouns as a way to "put them in their place" and attack their identity on the most personal level possible.
 
Last edited:
Respectfully, maybe people refer to them with certain pronouns, based on common sense and / or their own cultural experience, with no thought whatsoever as to "putting them in their place".
 
1 - How would I know this? Really. I'm a pretty open-minded guy and I had no idea. You state that there is no "argument" as to which term is correct. I'm a dude who is reasonably up to speed on current events, and I had no idea about what you are saying.
2 - If I didn't know this, why would "dude" be an offensive term for a guy with a penis?
3 - If it's not penis related, how is someone supposed to keep track of whether it's been snipped or not, in terms of whether to use the term "dude?"
1) not a problem. Not everyone is familiar with the transgender community.
2) gender identity. People should be addressed with pronouns appropriate for their gender, which is determined by their gender identity. Genitals do not determine gender. "Dude/guy/he/him/his, Chick/miss/she/her/hers" are gender terms, not genital terms. A pre-op transwoman is a woman, not a "guy with a penis", she's not a guy at all.
3) who cares? Really, a person's genital are their business and do not affect the correct way to address and refer to them. If someone self-identifies as a woman or presents as one, regardless of whether they've had genital surgery or even if they don't pass particularly well, use feminine terms as appropriate; and if you don't know, just ask.
 
Last edited:
Please don't take this this personally, but there are absolutely no circumstances where its acceptable to refer to a pre-op transwoman as a dude
How are we to know she's not just a crossdresser?
 
It's a satellite moon;
It's a plagiarized tune;
The duck on the lake -
a decoy;

There's a sodium glare
In the puri-fi-e-ow-e-ow-ed air
And the girl in my arms
is a...

(Flanders and Swann, "Song for our Time". They omitted the last words for obvious reasons...)
 
How are we to know she's not just a crossdresser?
Correct answer is: use feminine pronouns anyway.

Proper etiquette when addressing crossdressers, drag queens, and drag kings is to use gender pronouns which are appropriate for their gender presentation (this is exactly how crossdressers refer to themselves and members of their communities). Some people don't mind what you call them, but some do; for what its worth, you run a 0% chance of offending a MtF crossdresser addressing her as "miss" rather than "sir". And if you don't know, just ask.
 
Last edited:
1 - How would I know this? Really. I'm a pretty open-minded guy and I had no idea.
If you are such an open minded guy, how have you managed to not know this until now? It is not that hard.

2 - If I didn't know this, why would "dude" be an offensive term for a guy with a penis?
"Dude" is not a polite way to address anyone, except maybe your personal male friends.

3 - If it's not penis related, how is someone supposed to keep track of whether it's been snipped or not, in terms of whether to use the term "dude?"
If it is not penis related, there is no need to keep track of whether a penis is there or not. Are you checking everyone's underpants before deciding on which pronouns to use to refer to them? If not, then it shouldn't be so difficult to determine who wants to be referred to as man or woman.

(It doesn't help that a few of them suffer from gender dystrophia (which I am probably misspelling.))
It's "gender dysphoria", and it is not just a few. All transgenders have "gender dysphoria" by definition, though the term is disliked and sometimes subverted as "gender euphoria".

How are we to know she's not just a crossdresser?
Makes no difference. She'd still wouldn't mind being referred to as a woman and likely would mind being referred as a "dude".
 
Correct answer is: use feminine pronouns anyway.

Proper etiquette when addressing crossdressers, drag queens, and drag kings is to use gender pronouns which are appropriate for their gender presentation (this is exactly how crossdressers refer to themselves and members of their communities). Some people don't mind what you call them, but some do; for what its worth, you run a 0% chance of offending a MtF crossdresser addressing her as "miss" rather than "sir". And if you don't know, just ask.

Well, OK. I see your point, but it isn't really that simple.
I know two TG persons, both M>F. Sam/Susan still has a deep voice and a beard.
Gloria has a new name, I don't remember what she used be known as. She prefers to wear suits, and is dating quite a fetching middle-aged lady.
I have several gay friends, and they are not sure how to approach this either.
Whatever works for them, I guess. I try and use the correct terms, but it is not really obvious what I should say.

V.
 
How are we to know she's not just a crossdresser?

In my younger days when I used to go to the bars there were obvious crossdressers, who came there because it was a place where they would not get beat up (they rarely passed at all...but who cared?). I learned that when a man is crossdressing he wants to use a female name. Everyone was fine with it...yet still...no free beer!
 
Last edited:
Just to get back to the opening post a moment, how come the police officer hasn't been charged with attempted murder?
 
2) gender identity. People should be addressed with pronouns appropriate for their gender, which is determined by their gender identity. Genitals do not determine gender. "Dude/guy/he/him/his, Chick/miss/she/her/hers" are gender terms, not genital terms. A pre-op transwoman is a woman, not a "guy with a penis", she's not a guy at all.

Not to add fire on oil,m or oil on fire, but as far as I can tell this has never been the culturaly taught things, at least not in the culture I was born with. (France / banlieu / Paris). There I learnt that the gender you are called in, is the one you are born in, "you gender=your sex". Only later transgendered began to ask to be called by the gender they feel they fit in, or at least it started to spread.

So if I see a transgendered man becoming a woman as a dude no matter if gender reassignement surgery happened or not, it is not because I am an evil bigotted, it is more because I am too old to change habits.

I would still call her a woman , because I know that's what he ask and I would be polite, but I would still personally (and silentely) consider him a man.

3) who cares? Really, a person's genital are their business and do not affect the correct way to address and refer to them. If someone self-identifies as a woman or presents as one, regardless of whether they've had genital surgery or even if they don't pass particularly well, use feminine terms as appropriate; and if you don't know, just ask.

True, albeit I would say only until and up to the point that they have a boyfriend or a girlfriend. At that point that info is not anymore their's only, but should be privy to the SO too.
 
If you are such an open minded guy, how have you managed to not know this until now? It is not that hard.

"Dude" is not a polite way to address anyone, except maybe your personal male friends.

If it is not penis related, there is no need to keep track of whether a penis is there or not. Are you checking everyone's underpants before deciding on which pronouns to use to refer to them? If not, then it shouldn't be so difficult to determine who wants to be referred to as man or woman.

It's "gender dysphoria", and it is not just a few. All transgenders have "gender dysphoria" by definition, though the term is disliked and sometimes subverted as "gender euphoria".

Makes no difference. She'd still wouldn't mind being referred to as a woman and likely would mind being referred as a "dude".

Ah. It's been a while since I had to look it up for a friend.
 
it seems to be the simplest and most obvious form of politeness that if someone is presenting as a woman, you call her a woman, and if someone is presenting as a man, you call him a man.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom