Cop charged with shooting 3 transgender women, 2 male friends

Dessi

Species Traitor
Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
3,615
Location
Omaha, NE
Washington Blade:
An off-duty D.C. police officer charged with firing a pistol at three transgender women and two male friends last Friday was in handcuffs Tuesday morning as marshals led him into court for a preliminary hearing. [...]

Furr has been on the force for more than 20 years. He was charged on Friday with assault with a dangerous weapon and driving while intoxicated following allegations by the victims and witnesses that he shot at least three of five people sitting in a car about 5:25 a.m. on Aug. 29 at First and Pierce streets, N.W.

Two of three transgender women sitting in the car were hit by bullets and suffered non-life threatening injures, police said. One of two males in the car was also struck, suffering serious but non-life threatening wounds, according to police and witnesses.

Apparently the shooting was triggered after the officer approached one of the women for sex, he was turned down and became very angry. The preliminary hearing has been postponed until Aug 2.
 
Last edited:
One of the unfortunate dangers that TGs face. As if the officer's disgust wasn't bad enough. So sad, but thank goodness the injuries weren't life-threatening.
 
I THINK it means a person who was born a man genetically and later had sexual reassignment surgery.
That would be my assumption too, since one would refer to such a person as a "woman," assuming common courtesy of course.
 
Serious question - what's a "transgender woman?"
Its a synonym for a male-to-female transsexual (MtF). The term does not necessarily indicate that a person has had genital reassignment surgery.

Almost all the trans people I've ever known prefer the term "transgender" over "transsexual". Think of it this way: heterosexual, homosexual, bisexual, asexual, etc are sexual orientations, but "transsexual" is not. Transgender is a better word.

And almost all the MtF people I've ever known prefer the terms "transgender woman", "transwoman", or just "woman" over "male-to-female" which draws way to much attention too one's biological sex. "MtF" should be avoided outside of clinical settings, otherwise its equivalent to referring to a woman as "formerly Charles, now Jessica".

Always refer to transgender people with the pronoun that corresponds to their gender presentation. Example:
she is a transgender woman
he's a transgender man
 
Last edited:
Thanks. I was just curious, as one could logically make a case that a dude who gets (or plans to get) his equipment removed is still a dude, and could logically be called a "transgender man." It seems polite to call people what they prefer to be called.
 
Thanks. I was just curious, as one could logically make a case that a dude who gets (or plans to get) his equipment removed is still a dude, and could logically be called a "transgender man."
Please don't take this this personally, but there are absolutely no circumstances where its acceptable to refer to a pre-op transwoman as a dude or "transgender man". The former term is offensive to the extreme as well as being inaccurate, the latter term is a synonym for female-to-male transsexuals and makes no sense applying to male-to-female trans people.

For your amusement:
 
Last edited:
A friend was stabbed here, when the guy pestering her determined she had no interest in men.
Wasn't a life-threatening wound.
 
Thanks. I was just curious, as one could logically make a case that a dude who gets (or plans to get) his equipment removed is still a dude, and could logically be called a "transgender man." It seems polite to call people what they prefer to be called.

That would be if one wanted to be rude. The only times that this would matter in a non rude situation is with medical situations and possibly dating.

Of course there are people who use the word dude in a more gender neutral fashion. But that is not the case here as you seem to be putting a lot of emphasis on genital reconstruction.
 
Not trying to be defensive here, but there are absolutely no circumstances where its acceptable to refer to a pre-op transwoman as a dude or "transgender man". The former term is offensive to the extreme as well as being inaccurate, the latter term is a synonym for female-to-male transsexuals and makes no sense applying to male-to-female trans people.

For your amusement:

Wow... I had no idea.

I didn't think there were any Sizzler restaurants around anymore.
 
Apparently the shooting was triggered after the officer approached one of the women for sex, he was turned down and became very angry. The preliminary hearing has been postponed until Aug 2.

I think you mean September 2nd.

Well if we take the story at it's word, what we have is a drunken cop with a gun shooting at folks because he was refused sex. That has nothing to do with anyone being transgendered. He was arrested and will hopefully be prosecuted. What needs investigation is the fact that several of the victims of the shooting say they were handcuffed and treated like criminals by the police because they are transgendered. This story needs more information.
 
It sounds like he would have shot any woman that turned him down.

He needs to be in prison regardless.
 
I think you mean September 2nd.
Yep, thankies :)

Well if we take the story at it's word, what we have is a drunken cop with a gun shooting at folks because he was refused sex. That has nothing to do with anyone being transgendered. He was arrested and will hopefully be prosecuted. What needs investigation is the fact that several of the victims of the shooting say they were handcuffed and treated like criminals by the police because they are transgendered. This story needs more information.

As a matter of pure speculation, I'm thinking 3 possible scenarios:
1) drunk officer realizing he's hit on a transsexual, reacts with extreme violence. Not altogether different from the unfortunate Angie Zapata murder.
2) OR the cop is a tranny chaser and knowing hits on a transwoman, gets rejected and pulls a gun on 5 people.
3) OR the cop pulls a gun on 5 people without being aware of anyone's transgender status until well-after the crime.

I think the level of violence is much more consistent with the first scenario than the others.

Still, I agree, the article does not really state the motive of the shooting. Will be interesting see where this goes.
 
Not trying to be defensive here, but there are absolutely no circumstances where its acceptable to refer to a pre-op transwoman as a dude or "transgender man". The former term is offensive to the extreme as well as being inaccurate, the latter term is a synonym for female-to-male transsexuals and makes no sense applying to male-to-female trans people.

For your amusement:

Thanks. Look, if people want to modify themselves, up to and including changing their gender, that's fine. What's not fine is (looking at pondering turtle here) such people being offended by someone wondering what the hell the transgender people are supposed to be called.

I'm happy with the new knowledge that you've imparted - sincerely, thanks. If a man who cuts off his junk, or maybe just wears dresses and had a boob job, is "offended" by one of the unwashed masses not knowing exactly what to call him, tough ****.
 
Thanks. Look, if people want to modify themselves, up to and including changing their gender, that's fine. What's not fine is (looking at pondering turtle here) such people being offended by someone wondering what the hell the transgender people are supposed to be called.

I'm happy with the new knowledge that you've imparted - sincerely, thanks. If a man who cuts off his junk, or maybe just wears dresses and had a boob job, is "offended" by one of the unwashed masses not knowing exactly what to call him, tough ****.
Your righteous indignation (and insulting choices of words) aside, isn't it enough that you already know the person wants to be (or is; perspective, timing) a woman and thus would probably want you to refer to her that way? Call it a gesture of courtesy, if nothing else.

Your question was pretty reasonable but the above reaction is way out of proportion to the answers you received.
 
Please don't take this this personally, but there are absolutely no circumstances where its acceptable to refer to a pre-op transwoman as a dude or "transgender man". The former term is offensive to the extreme as well as being inaccurate, the latter term is a synonym for female-to-male transsexuals and makes no sense applying to male-to-female trans people.

OK. Again, how uninformed folks are supposed to know this is left to ... what, exactly? "Makes no sense" is totally subjective for those of us not in the know vis a vis "transgender" people. I could make a logical argument that one should call dudes with their junk intact "transgender men" as easy as the above argument. If people are offended by natural-born males being called "dude," that's their problem not mine.

Dessi - I will use your suggestions from here on, as your arguments are quite reasonable.
 
Last edited:
Thanks. Look, if people want to modify themselves, up to and including changing their gender, that's fine. What's not fine is (looking at pondering turtle here) such people being offended by someone wondering what the hell the transgender people are supposed to be called.

I'm happy with the new knowledge that you've imparted - sincerely, thanks. If a man who cuts off his junk, or maybe just wears dresses and had a boob job, is "offended" by one of the unwashed masses not knowing exactly what to call him, tough ****.
OK. Again, how uninformed folks are supposed to know this is left to ... what, exactly? "Makes no sense" is totally subjective for those of us not in the know vis a vis "transgender" people. I could make a logical argument that one should call dudes with their junk intact "transgender men" as easy as the above argument. If people are offended by natural-born males being called "dude," that's their problem not mine.

Dessi - I will use your suggestions from here one, as your arguments are quite reasonable.

I think you misjudged Dessi's tone. She didn't seem offended or say it was wrong to ask about proper terminology.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom