[Continuation]Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
Accepting science that you have not personally verified is not done on faith (if by faith you mean concluding without sufficient evidence).

Yes it is. How could it not? If something isn't verified, then it is taken on faith. The existence of evidence does not necessarily equal verification, or an absence of faith.
K. So you take it on faith that vaccines do not work. No science. just faith.

"Faith" is the excuse people give for believing daft ideas for which there is 0 evidence.

Are you certain that is the route you wish to travel?
 
Is there or is there not a vast record of failure with regard to peer-reviewed drugs that have later been proven unsafe? Need I provide you with the history? What can we say about the evidence indicating to peers that each of those drugs were safe?


I remember as a kid there was a young lady in the small village I grew up in who was a victim of Contergan. Had these tiny crippled arms and was riding around on a special bicycle. Of course as little rascals we made fun of her, but not seriously. It was a sad picture, although she was in good spirit.

A crude joke/play-on-words at the time was "Conterganixfür", meaning or sounding like "it wasn't his fault".
 
I remember as a kid there was a young lady in the small village I grew up in who was a victim of Contergan. Had these tiny crippled arms and was riding around on a special bicycle. Of course as little rascals we made fun of her, but not seriously. It was a sad picture, although she was in good spirit.

A crude joke/play-on-words at the time was "Conterganixfür", meaning or sounding like "it wasn't his fault".
That's a display of scumbaggery. You are somehow proud of it?
 
Tippit said

Is there or is there not a vast record of failure with regard to peer-reviewed drugs that have later been proven unsafe?



Doesnt matter. That was before now.

Here now is proof that the "vaccine" is really safe, and has no long term downside.


Dont mistake this proof for dodging or moving goalposts.


Paul2 said

Not compared to the record of success.



Not to mention the group think (local version of peer review) confirmation factor !
 
LOL Dude, your whole activity here is making fun of people you think are (mentally) crippled.
Godh, after all this time, you cannot figure out the basics. That is sad.


And you are an adult.
Yup, I am a parent. I have two of which one is an adult and the other is close to an adult. Neither buy your BS and neither will. While neither are members here, Both complain about why I tolerate such BS.

I stopped these activities long before adulthood. Children can be cruel, as we all know.
Irrelevant. Actually, a bit of an odd claim to make.

Bottom line here is that you are so disconnected from reality that nobody should pay any heed to whatever you spout. We all know that it is merely what your handlers fed you.
 
LOL Dude, your whole activity here is making fun of people you think are (mentally) crippled. And you are an adult. I stopped these activities long before adulthood. Children can be cruel, as we all know.



I have noticed this too. Plus he constantly disingenuously twists what people say.


Typical example of constant disingenuous spin:

by abaddon View Post
That's a display of scumbaggery. You are somehow proud of it?


which was him twisting this:


C E said:

Of course as little rascals we made fun of her, but not seriously. It was a sad picture, although she was in good spirit.



The lie in this case being:


by abaddon:

You are somehow proud of it?
 
Last edited:
The distinction your comment ignores is the one between personally verified and verified. I was talking about personally verified, but your comment says verified.

If something is verified, but not personally verified, then you are placing faith in some external entity or entities who claim verification. This should be obvious, and neither does it mean such faith is irrational, or not evidence-based. The credibility of the claim depends on a lot of things, including the reputations and expertise of the original scientists, the reputations and expertise of the peers in a peer-review process, the number of such people, whether or not such claims or evidence supporting the claims are contested, the reputations, experience, and numbers of people doing the contesting, etc...

And, again, not personally verifying something leaves out a vast chunk of modern life.
Of course. Much of life is spent delegating trust, as opposed to conducting/verifying experiments. We can't all be experts on everything, so we delegate. In many cases, trust is misplaced, even in consensuses of experts.

Not compared to the record of success.

This is debatable. Most gains in healthspan have been improvements in sanitation, hygiene, and nutrition, not proprietary drugs or medical procedures. The scientific method as it applies to modern medicine only seeks to test those hypotheses which make claims about proprietary, patentable substances or devices in a for-profit system, with little-to-no regard for the Hippocratic Oath. There is a built in and inherent selection bias. If it is safe and effective but not patentable or profitable, then it simply won't be tested, or worse, it will be actively discredited in favor of more lucrative, revenue-generating "therapies".

Besides the fact that science and meta-analysis are not things parallel such that they can be compared, what distinction do you see as relevant between science and meta-analysis?

Science and meta-analysis are joined at the hip. Scientists do science, and peers (presumably experts) analyze the results.
 
If something is verified, but not personally verified, then you are placing faith in some external entity or entities who claim verification.
It's problematic to used the word "faith" for the case in which something is not verified, because it conflates the distinction between the faith being the result of trust in the larger process, as opposed to the specific scientific issue in question, and trust without anything behind it.

This should be obvious, and neither does it mean such faith is irrational, or not evidence-based. The credibility of the claim depends on a lot of things, including the reputations and expertise of the original scientists, the reputations and expertise of the peers in a peer-review process, the number of such people, whether or not such claims or evidence supporting the claims are contested, the reputations, experience, and numbers of people doing the contesting, etc...
Agreed. But none of those points were even implied in your original statement:
There is no science but those hypotheses that you can directly reproduce, individually. All else are merely the claims of others, even if they're from a noisy and overwhelming consensus of "experts".

Continuing:

Of course. Much of life is spent delegating trust, as opposed to conducting/verifying experiments. We can't all be experts on everything, so we delegate. In many cases, trust is misplaced, even in consensuses of experts.
If you had claimed "most cases," you might have something. "Many" is vague enough to not really be functional in an argument.

This is debatable. Most gains in healthspan have been improvements in sanitation, hygiene, and nutrition, not proprietary drugs or medical procedures.
That may be true but it is irrelevant, as our disagreement is only about drugs. Whether other health gains are massive in comparison doesn't say anything about the proportion of drugs that have been successful or unsuccessful.
The scientific method as it applies to modern medicine only seeks to test those hypotheses which make claims about proprietary, patentable substances or devices in a for-profit system, with little-to-no regard for the Hippocratic Oath. There is a built in and inherent selection bias. If it is safe and effective but not patentable or profitable, then it simply won't be tested, or worse, it will be actively discredited in favor of more lucrative, revenue-generating "therapies".
This is also irrelevant as to whether the drugs that do come to market are mostly safe and effective or not.

Science and meta-analysis are joined at the hip. Scientists do science, and peers (presumably experts) analyze the results.
I have no idea what your point is about this, given that you originally said,

But there are distinctions to be made between actual science and meta-analysis. . . .
Are they joined at the hip, or is there a relevant distinction that makes meta-analyses not actual science?
 
It's problematic to used the word "faith" for the case in which something is not verified, because it conflates the distinction between the faith being the result of trust in the larger process, as opposed to the specific scientific issue in question, and trust without anything behind it.

Faith and trust are essentially the same thing. You seem to have a problem with the first word, maybe because it has a religious connotation that doesn't apply here.

Agreed. But none of those points were even implied in your original statement:

I still stand by my original statement. The fact that you can function in a world built around science without personal verification of every underlying hypotheses doesn't mean that you're doing science. It means that you trust that science was done by someone else, or that a given underlying claim or hypothesis for a technology that you utilize is scientifically accurate. Note that just because you may not be a scientist also does not mean that you aren't doing science. All of us conduct experiments, with some degree of control, virtually every day.

That may be true but it is irrelevant, as our disagreement is only about drugs. Whether other health gains are massive in comparison doesn't say anything about the proportion of drugs that have been successful or unsuccessful.
Ok.

This is also irrelevant as to whether the drugs that do come to market are mostly safe and effective or not.

The specific point that I was making, is not just that many drugs are unsafe in spite of the peer-review process, but that effective naturopathic remedies are typically not tested due to the selection bias inherent in the for-profit, proprietary system which is a byproduct of the structure of our intellectual property laws.

I can cite many, many examples of this, some are outrageous. For instance, the treatment of insulin for type II diabetics is nothing less than barbaric, akin to bloodletting. Type I is an autoimmune disorder that prevents the pancreas from producing insulin. These patients will literally die without insulin supplementation. However, type II is a disease of insulin resistance, caused by the production of too much insulin, as the result of too frequent eating of insulin-producing foods eg: sugars and other carbohydrates. Treating this disease with insulin supplementation as opposed to diet and nutrition is akin to throwing gasoline on a fire, causing even more insulin resistance. Yet this malpractice is still being done in 2021 (insulin is expensive, and profitable).

I have no idea what your point is about this, given that you originally said,

Are they joined at the hip, or is there a relevant distinction that makes meta-analyses not actual science?

They are both a part of the scientific method, but peer review is a layer of abstraction on top of scientific trials, which means we should be more skeptical of peer-review, especially where it concerns for-profit medical science with its attendant selection biases, confirmation biases, and financial conflicts of interest.

I'm not so much worried about the peer-review done at SpaceX, for instance, because if a rocket explodes in flight that is their problem, not mine.
 
Last edited:
Faith and trust are essentially the same thing. You seem to have a problem with the first word, maybe because it has a religious connotation that doesn't apply here.
That's where it originated for me, but it still seems useful to distinguish when confidence has been earned and when it hasn't been.


I still stand by my original statement. The fact that you can function in a world built around science without personal verification of every underlying hypotheses doesn't mean that you're doing science. It means that you trust that science was done by someone else, or that a given underlying claim or hypothesis for a technology that you utilize is scientifically accurate.
Your original statement goes much further, as it says that science doesn't happen, it doesn't exist, there is no science unless you carry it out yourself:
There is no science but those hypotheses that you can directly reproduce, individually. All else are merely the claims of others, even if they're from a noisy and overwhelming consensus of "experts".

Note that just because you may not be a scientist also does not mean that you aren't doing science. All of us conduct experiments, with some degree of control, virtually every day.
[/quote]
The specific point that I was making, is not just that many drugs are unsafe in spite of the peer-review process, but that effective naturopathic remedies are typically not tested due to the selection bias inherent in the for-profit, proprietary system which is a byproduct of the structure of our intellectual property laws.

I can cite many, many examples of this, some are outrageous. For instance, the treatment of insulin for type II diabetics is nothing less than barbaric, akin to bloodletting. Type I is an autoimmune disorder that prevents the pancreas from producing insulin. These patients will literally die without insulin supplementation. However, type II is a disease of insulin resistance, caused by the production of too much insulin, as the result of too frequent eating of insulin-producing foods eg: sugars and other carbohydrates. Treating this disease with insulin supplementation as opposed to diet and nutrition is akin to throwing gasoline on a fire, causing even more insulin resistance. Yet this malpractice is still being done in 2021 (insulin is expensive, and profitable).

They are both a part of the scientific method, but peer review is a layer of abstraction on top of scientific trials, which means we should be more skeptical of peer-review, especially where it concerns for-profit medical science with its attendant selection biases, confirmation biases, and financial conflicts of interest.

I'm not so much worried about the peer-review done at SpaceX, for instance, because if a rocket explodes in flight that is their problem, not mine.
I'm hitting diminishing returns. I'll let you have the last word.
 
btw, the "peer review" of the original SARS-COV2-PCR test "paper" took one day with the wacky main author Christian Drosten sitting on the board of the publishing "magazine":

https://cormandrostenreview.com

“External peer review of the RTPCR test to detect SARS-CoV2 reveals 10 major scientific flaws at the molecular and methodological level: consequences for false positive results”, which we herewith submit for publication in Eurosurveillance.

Lol. Well, look on the "bright" side, pseudo-skeptics. False positives deflate the IFR.
 
“External peer review of the RTPCR test to detect SARS-CoV2 reveals 10 major scientific flaws at the molecular and methodological level: consequences for false positive results”, which we herewith submit for publication in Eurosurveillance.

Lol. Well, look on the "bright" side, pseudo-skeptics. False positives deflate the IFR.
Suddenly it seems you find some real peer review that you don't even need to enclose in scare quotes, and ta-daaa! science happens without you having watched it. It's so hard to know the difference between science and "science." I guess you had to be there.
 
Wow, so since it wasn't actually a paper and it wasn't published in an actual magazine, where did you see it?


Where did I see it?

bruto, this paper is the foundation of the whole "SARS-COV2"-PCR test thing. Its main author Christian Drosten has designed the original rtPCR-Test for this "novel virus". He is not only a "professor" (although he never taught, his seat is sponsored by very rich "donors") at the Charite in Berlin, he's also a "pop-star".

That you don't know this says a lot about your level of awareness about the general topic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom