[Continuation]Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
And yet, no one is suggesting that science necessarily be held to that standard. The existence of computers, cell phones, automobiles, planes, and trains that all have invaluable function are ironclad evidence that useful science has been done, yet even these don't necessarily verify all of the hypotheses that claim to explain how they function, because of the practical difficulty of reverse engineering them completely enough to test the myriad hypotheses required to be proven in order to engineer them in the first place. To the average person, they might as well be magic, even though we know they are not. They're the result of layer upon layer upon layer of science.
Odd. Because I DO know how such devices operate. And I didn't have to "reverse engineer" anything. Start with a diode. Once you have a diode one can build a transistor. Once one can build a transistor, one can build a logic gate. Once one can build a logic gate, one can build a register. Once one can build a register, one can build a CPU. There is nothing mysterious about it. Want circuit diagrams? Why? Not a chance you would understand them anyway.

Where things get dicey, and where vastly more skepticism is required, are when the unknowns are numerous,
What are the vaccine unknowns?

the financial conflicts of interest are replete,
Yet "big pharma" does not make much from vaccines. How do you explain that?

and the potential risks to human health and life are enormous
Would you rather let millions die from the virus, because they already have, and continue to die. It is almost as if you have an agenda to depopulate.

such as claims made about viral pandemics, and their medical response.
Your answer is no response at all. Let people die. Do nothing because that always works, right?

Scientists are corruptible and fallible,
So are you. So is everyone.

and often get it drastically wrong in these cases, and so the relative verifiability of immunobiology is much much more important than say, the ability we have to verify the science behind the functioning of commuter trains.
My sister is an immunobiologist. She goes postal about anyone who posts such crap.

The problem with the pseudo-skeptics on this forum, is that they have absolutely no sense of the important distinction between the lack of verifiability of scientific claims made (on all sides) about the current pandemic, versus the verifiability of how computers, cell phones, automobiles, planes, and trains work.
Wrong. Your problem is that nobody here will blindly accept your garbage ideas (with one or two exceptions). You simply cannot accept that other people do not harbour the superstitious ideas that you actively cultivate.

"Scientific" claims about the pandemic made by "authorities" are as sacrosanct to the pseudo-skeptic as scientific claims made about the internal combustion engine invented in 1794, when no such comparison is warranted.
None of that is true. If you were to present actual evidence that the vaccine is harmful in some way, then people would consider it. So far, all you have managed to present is the fact that you do not understand it. How is your ignorance supposed to convince anyone of anything?

You have a real issue with acknowledging that it is even possible that anyone knows more about anything than you.
 
How do you do "science" when you lack basic reading comprehension? Or is it that you're just dishonest? I never said that the "only valid science" is in what can be personally observed or verified. Show where I said that. What I said was, non-falsifiable claims are not scientific claims, and most medical scientific claims are not practically falsifiable without tens of millions in capital and lab equipment. This means, that for all intents and purposes, for most people, most medical scientific claims are not practically falsifiable, and thus we must rely on faith in those who claim either experimental results, or those "experts" who perform meta-analysis on the experiments of others.

This obviously doesn't invalidate all of the science that has been done which cannot be independently verified. Only the least charitable interpretation of what I said could possibly be construed that way. It means that the less independently verifiable scientific hypotheses are, the more skepticism needs to be employed with regard to its claims, even if those claims are backed by large consensuses of expert peers.

How do I know this is true? By the long list of "peer-reviewed safe" toxic drugs and procedures under class action at any given time, and by personal anecdote.

Perhaps you can figure out how this relates to the fact that Anothony Fauci is a liar before congress, and funded Peter Daszak's EcoHealth Alliance which performed Gain-of-Function research on bat coronaviruses in Wuhan, China, which was to be ground zero of the Covid pandemic. Do you deny any of the above? All of it? Done any research into it at all? Dispute the definition of Gain-of-Function?

Of course you can always fall back on the favorite ploy of arguers (especially, it seems, very conservative ones) and say that if you did not say those exact words you did not say what is alleged. But in post #1330, in your argument that reproducibility is necessary, you quite clearly used the word "you," in a way that makes it appear you require personal verification to raise an opinion beyond faith. Unless you now contend that faith is valid science, it appears you have said what you say you did not. If you now consider this an unwarranted assumption, the mistake just might be yours, even though your denial of this very assertion asserts it again.
 
Last edited:
How do you do "science" when you lack basic reading comprehension? Or is it that you're just dishonest? I never said that the "only valid science" is in what can be personally observed or verified. Show where I said that. What I said was, non-falsifiable claims are not scientific claims, and most medical scientific claims are not practically falsifiable without tens of millions in capital and lab equipment. This means, that for all intents and purposes, for most people, most medical scientific claims are not practically falsifiable, and thus we must rely on faith in those who claim either experimental results, or those "experts" who perform meta-analysis on the experiments of others.

This obviously doesn't invalidate all of the science that has been done which cannot be independently verified. Only the least charitable interpretation of what I said could possibly be construed that way. It means that the less independently verifiable scientific hypotheses are, the more skepticism needs to be employed with regard to its claims, even if those claims are backed by large consensuses of expert peers.

How do I know this is true? By the long list of "peer-reviewed safe" toxic drugs and procedures under class action at any given time, and by personal anecdote.

Perhaps you can figure out how this relates to the fact that Anothony Fauci is a liar before congress, and funded Peter Daszak's EcoHealth Alliance which performed Gain-of-Function research on bat coronaviruses in Wuhan, China, which was to be ground zero of the Covid pandemic. Do you deny any of the above? All of it? Done any research into it at all? Dispute the definition of Gain-of-Function?
How do you do anything at all with such a short memory?
There is no science but those hypotheses that you can directly reproduce, individually. All else are merely the claims of others, even if they're from a noisy and overwhelming consensus of "experts". I have witnessed this first hand, via numerous examples of the abject failure of "modern medicine", and so-called peer-reviewed meta analysis.
Now I'm sure you will resort to a lot of "practically" and "for all intents and purposes" weasel words here, about how what you said wasn't what you actually said, but, you know...for all intents and purposes, practically speaking, that's exactly what you did say. Ken Ham would be proud of you, my boy.

C'mon, though, what I really want to hear is more about how Fauci is literally a Bond villain. (Which, presumably, makes you Bond)
 
There is no science but those hypotheses that you can directly reproduce, individually. All else are merely the claims of others, even if they're from a noisy and overwhelming consensus of "experts". I have witnessed this first hand, via numerous examples of the abject failure of "modern medicine", and so-called peer-reviewed meta analysis.

And the hypocrisy is stunning. Look at all the elements of modern daily life - computers, cell phones, automobiles, plane travel (hell, even travel by train), construction (exactly what is in that bonding compound?), clothing (how long will that dye last?) - it just goes on and on and on - that would be impossible to personally verify completely, which is what is being argued. It's just an impossible standard.

And yet, no one is suggesting that science necessarily be held to that standard.

The two highlighted sections seem to be irreconcilable.

ETA: Ninja'ed, but so what?
 
Still haven't quite figured out how that whole "science" thing works, eh? I mean, seriously, if you have to re-define science itself to support your POV, that might be a clue...

No, it's true. If you can't find the Higgs-Bosun in your backyard, it doesn't exist.
 
Of course you can always fall back on the favorite ploy of arguers (especially, it seems, very conservative ones) and say that if you did not say those exact words you did not say what is alleged. But in post #1330, in your argument that reproducibility is necessary, you quite clearly used the word "you," in a way that makes it appear you require personal verification to raise an opinion beyond faith. Unless you now contend that faith is valid science, it appears you have said what you say you did not. If you now consider this an unwarranted assumption, the mistake just might be yours, even though your denial of this very assertion asserts it again.

Let me be explicitly clear. When it comes to issues of peer-reviewed medical safety, I have zero faith. In other words, neither can I independently verify nor do I trust the claims of experts or authorities, or even consensuses of experts and authorities. This has nothing to do with my trust in the claims behind the aeronautics of airplanes, for instance, nor is it comparable. You may find this irrational and "anti-scientific", but I have my reasons. It's as anti-scientific as the failed, false, and intellectually and morally bankrupt peer-reviewed safety claims for all of the bad drugs and bad procedures that are currently in litigation.
 
The two highlighted sections seem to be irreconcilable.

What I said isn't irreconcilable. Parroting meta-analysis isn't science, it's a faith-based exercise. Just because you have faith in "science" that you haven't independently verified, doesn't make it less scientific, or you less faithful.
 
Odd. Because I DO know how such devices operate. And I didn't have to "reverse engineer" anything. Start with a diode. Once you have a diode one can build a transistor. Once one can build a transistor, one can build a logic gate. Once one can build a logic gate, one can build a register. Once one can build a register, one can build a CPU. There is nothing mysterious about it. Want circuit diagrams? Why? Not a chance you would understand them anyway.

What are the vaccine unknowns?

Yet "big pharma" does not make much from vaccines. How do you explain that?

Would you rather let millions die from the virus, because they already have, and continue to die. It is almost as if you have an agenda to depopulate.

Your answer is no response at all. Let people die. Do nothing because that always works, right?

So are you. So is everyone.

My sister is an immunobiologist. She goes postal about anyone who posts such crap.

Wrong. Your problem is that nobody here will blindly accept your garbage ideas (with one or two exceptions). You simply cannot accept that other people do not harbour the superstitious ideas that you actively cultivate.

None of that is true. If you were to present actual evidence that the vaccine is harmful in some way, then people would consider it. So far, all you have managed to present is the fact that you do not understand it. How is your ignorance supposed to convince anyone of anything?

You have a real issue with acknowledging that it is even possible that anyone knows more about anything than you.

Indeed, like millions of people and probably several more on this thread, I have solved Heisenberg's equation for a Hydrogen atom, I have looked at the band structure of silicon and some other semiconductors, looked at how doping affects that, laid out and diffused some planar transistors, laid out a CMOS inverter, and then used that in NAND gates for an 8-bit adder...

And all that was undergraduate-level work.


In my work in industry, I have designed multiple high-voltage transistors, not just the layout but the doping profiles and oxide thicknesses and required processing conditions to get those to work.

There are also loads of details that need to be got right (plasma etching is fiendishly complicated, for example, and I'm impressed at the expertise people have) but it's still amenable to the scientific method.

None of this is mysterious. It does involve some work to understand it, but it's really ridiculous that Tippit dismisses these as being inherently bewildering.
 
None of this is mysterious. It does involve some work to understand it, but it's really ridiculous that Tippit dismisses these as being inherently bewildering.

Right. Nothing is mysterious, everything is known with certainty. You design transistors, everyone can design transistors. Nothing is mysterious, the certainties of transistor design are equivalent to the certainties of immunobiology. All knowledge is binary. We either know everything, or nothing. Or, in your case, everything.
 
Mercola lies. Mercola is a lying piece of **** that cares for nothing and no-one but his own profits, and happily spreads nonsense to take advantage the rubes that are gullible enough to buy it. I bet he sleeps well at night too knowing that he has siphoned millions out of people's pockets to line his own. Such an *******. **** Mercola. **** him right up his lying piece of **** arse.

**** him.

Quoted for truth. I would only add more asterisks if anything. Mercola sucks.
 
They call it "peer" because that's all those shills do: They PEER at some guy's science gobble de goop and then claim they RE-VIEWED it so it's okay enough to get more grant shekels from the J

Never mind from who. Besides (and Gen. Tippit will bear this out), peer has another meaning altogether. You know what I mean, ya barnyard-minded conspirators.

I got one of my headaches. Make it go away, Father Tippit. Tell us again about hypothesis & confirmation & how it's better'n ole dum science-ism.
 
Indeed, like millions of people and probably several more on this thread, I have solved Heisenberg's equation for a Hydrogen atom, I have looked at the band structure of silicon and some other semiconductors, looked at how doping affects that, laid out and diffused some planar transistors, laid out a CMOS inverter, and then used that in NAND gates for an 8-bit adder...

And all that was undergraduate-level work.


In my work in industry, I have designed multiple high-voltage transistors, not just the layout but the doping profiles and oxide thicknesses and required processing conditions to get those to work.
I enjoyed that. Laying down the masks. Etching your very own IC on layers of substrates in stages. It was fun. And interesting in itself. And educational. All things our proponent opposes. Part of the fascination for me is how we laid out all of it in gross scale, but when we got to fab, it got so tiny that we were working on hi-res microscopes. That was so cool decades ago. But, the tech has moved on. Still, a good learning experience. One that is apparently ignored by Tippit for some reason that he cannot explain. I defer to Tippit to explain that. Or not.

There are also loads of details that need to be got right (plasma etching is fiendishly complicated, for example, and I'm impressed at the expertise people have) but it's still amenable to the scientific method.
Sure. My past in education informs me that one can educate anyone, except those that refuse to learn. Nobody can do anything about that.
None of this is mysterious. It does involve some work to understand it, but it's really ridiculous that Tippit dismisses these as being inherently bewildering.

Particularly when he has subject matter experts to hand. I do not mean just me, there is a sea of subject matter experts and he is still having none of it because we are somehow all part of some over-arching conspiracy.

It would be funny to witness any consult with his doctor.
 
What I said isn't irreconcilable. Parroting meta-analysis isn't science, it's a faith-based exercise. Just because you have faith in "science" that you haven't independently verified, doesn't make it less scientific, or you less faithful.
Accepting science that you have not personally verified is not done on faith (if by faith you mean concluding without sufficient evidence). The process of science is trustworthy based on its vast, vast success, which is the evidence that takes faith out of the picture. This does not mean that science doesn't make mistakes that have to be corrected (but what other process does a better job of identifying and correcting those mistakes?).
 
Accepting science that you have not personally verified is not done on faith (if by faith you mean concluding without sufficient evidence). The process of science is trustworthy based on its vast, vast success, which is the evidence that takes faith out of the picture. This does not mean that science doesn't make mistakes that have to be corrected (but what other process does a better job of identifying and correcting those mistakes?).

Jebus, apparently. We should all believe in jebus.

The whole notion is absurd.
 
Accepting science that you have not personally verified is not done on faith (if by faith you mean concluding without sufficient evidence). The process of science is trustworthy based on its vast, vast success, which is the evidence that takes faith out of the picture. This does not mean that science doesn't make mistakes that have to be corrected (but what other process does a better job of identifying and correcting those mistakes?).
When your epistimology is based on crap your cousin Butch shared with you on facebook, and nonsense from propaganda sites, what could go wrong?
 
Accepting science that you have not personally verified is not done on faith (if by faith you mean concluding without sufficient evidence).

Yes it is. How could it not? If something isn't verified, then it is taken on faith. The existence of evidence does not necessarily equal verification, or an absence of faith.

The process of science is trustworthy based on its vast, vast success, which is the evidence that takes faith out of the picture.
Is there or is there not a vast record of failure with regard to peer-reviewed drugs that have later been proven unsafe? Need I provide you with the history? What can we say about the evidence indicating to peers that each of those drugs were safe?

This does not mean that science doesn't make mistakes that have to be corrected (but what other process does a better job of identifying and correcting those mistakes?).

None. But there are distinctions to be made between actual science and meta-analysis, just as there are distinctions to be made between well-known and well-verified hypotheses and not well known and not well-verified hypotheses.

The truth value of a scientific hypothesis is independent of its verifiability, and your unverified faith that the evidence supports it.
 
Last edited:
Yes it is. How could it not? If something isn't verified, then it is taken on faith.
The distinction your comment ignores is the one between personally verified and verified. I was talking about personally verified, but your comment says verified.

And, again, not personally verifying something leaves out a vast chunk of modern life.
The existence of evidence does not necessarily equal verification.
I never said it did. The existence of sufficient evidence does necessarily equal solid grounds for accepting a hypothesis.

Is there or is there not a vast record of failure with regard to peer-reviewed drugs that have later been proven unsafe?
Not compared to the record of success.

None. But there are distinctions to be made between actual science and meta-analysis.
Besides the fact that science and meta-analysis are not things parallel such that they can be compared, what distinction do you see as relevant between science and meta-analysis?
 
Let me be explicitly clear. When it comes to issues of peer-reviewed medical safety, I have zero faith. In other words, neither can I independently verify nor do I trust the claims of experts or authorities, or even consensuses of experts and authorities. This has nothing to do with my trust in the claims behind the aeronautics of airplanes, for instance, nor is it comparable. You may find this irrational and "anti-scientific", but I have my reasons. It's as anti-scientific as the failed, false, and intellectually and morally bankrupt peer-reviewed safety claims for all of the bad drugs and bad procedures that are currently in litigation.


It's odd to me that in this single case you completely abandon the notion that Capitalism might just work.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom