W.D.Clinger
Philosopher
True.It's not what you don't know, it's what you know that ain't so.
Not only is that true, but it gets at the difference between hard-core skeptics and hard-core conspiracy theorists.
(People who believe coronavirus conspiracy theories are a bit of a special case, because most of them are not hard-core conspiracy theorists. I'll get back to this later. For now, let's just say "hard-core conspiracy theorists" refers to people who are not just inclined to believe, but also to promote multiple conspiracy theories of the sorts discussed in this subforum.)
Some hard-core conspiracy theorists, such as Alex Jones and Dr Joseph Marcola, have found ways to make money from their ideas. It is hard to tell, and mostly irrelevant, whether they actually believe the conspiracy theories they peddle.
Sincerely hard-core conspiracy theorists are motivated less by money than by the satisfaction of knowing what's really going on. It makes them feel special. Because they see through the mainstream cover stories, they feel superior to the sheeple and pseudo-skeptics whose beliefs are more ordinary.
To sustain that feeling, hard-core conspiracy theorists must know things the sheeple don't know. Indeed, they feel most special when they know things the sheeple deny. Because they are motivated to know things that aren't generally known, and to know things that most people believe to be false, hard-core conspiracy theorists are motivated to know things that aren't actually true.
Hard-core skeptics are pretty much the opposite of hard-core conspiracy theorists. Where hard-core conspiracy theorists take pride in knowing things most people don't know, hard-core skeptics take pride in not knowing things most people accept as obvious. Hard-core skeptics have to be convinced by evidence before they are willing to know something. That's what makes them feel special. The things they know can't make them feel special, because they're always the last to know. By the time they're convinced of something, just about everybody else has already known it for a long time.
So the intellectual life of hard-core skeptics is filled with disappointment from being the last to know things, which is kind of boring, while the intellectual life of hard-core conspiracy theorists is exciting, filled with the thrill of discovering and knowing new things the sheeple don't know.
That's true of everybody, but the balance between those two is not the same for everybody.Having said that, there is a lot that you don't know, and there is a lot that you know that ain't so.
Hard-core skeptics are heavy on the "don't know" side.
Hard-core conspiracy theorists are heavy on the "know what ain't so" side.
That's a nice example of Tippit knowing things that aren't common knowledge.Well said, except that we are the authentic skeptics. You are the pseudo-skeptics. We've set vanity and ego mostly aside, we accept never ending hatred and vitriol in order to attempt to show a divergent view of the way that the world really is, you are stalwart defenders of the authoritarian status quo. Your pseudo-skepticism costs you nothing to the extent that you benefit from it, right up until the point that the status quo turns on you, which I think is getting near.
From an opinion piece published years ago in Scientific American:
Social psychologist Karen Douglas at the University of Kent studies conspiracy theorists and suspects that her study subjects, in some cases, share attributes with those who believe in an impending apocalypse....
"One trait I see linking the two is the feeling of powerlessness, often connected to a mistrust in authority," Douglas says. Among conspiracy theorists, these convictions of mistrust and impotence make their conspiracies more precious—and real. "People feel like they have knowledge that others do not."
Relatively few studies exist on the individuals who start and propagate these theories. Douglas points out that research into the psychology of persuasion has found that those who believe most are also most motivated to broadcast their beliefs. In the Internet age, that's an easier feat than ever before.
Returning to things written in this thread:
Yes, conspiracy theorists prefer to "deal in speculation" even when the topic is very real. Hard-core skeptics try to avoid speculation.And some conspiracy theorists, unlike all of the types of cranks you mentioned, deal in speculation about things which are very real.
Yes, the job of a skeptic is to be skeptical, to remain unconvinced and perhaps even cynical until persuaded by evidence. That's sort of the opposite of authoritarian.We know less, because we're entering a dark age of censorship and persecution of even moderately divergent points of view. Anything that contradicts the official narrative must be mocked and ridiculed before it is cancelled. That is your job, the job of the authoritarian pseudo-skeptic shill - to be "skeptical" and indeed cynical of everything, except "authoritative" sources.
Mockery and ridicule are optional. Claims that defy arithmetic or logic or hard-won and well-established knowledge deserve to be mocked and ridiculed, but the mockery and ridicule have no evidentiary value unless they highlight errors in arithmetic or logic or facts.
Coronavirus conspiracy theories are believed by many people who are not hard-core conspiracy theorists. There are several reasons for that.
- A lot of people are genuinely afraid of needles. Conspiracy theories offer a seemingly more respectable justification for avoiding them.
- A lot of people are genuinely annoyed by having to wear masks. Conspiracy theories offer a seemingly more respectable justification for avoiding them.
- In several countries, notably the United States, professions of belief in certain coronavirus conspiracy theories have become a way to proclaim support for a political party and some of its leaders.
- Some news media promote coronavirus conspiracy theories for political reasons, just as some might promote the idea that an election was stolen.