[Continuation]Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
You may do so, but this is a very important and fundamental aspect of skepticism. No-one who doesn't acknowledge that all knowledge is provisional can rightly call themself a skeptic.


Yes.

The highlite was about PseuSkeps not seeing that, and calling themselves skeptics anyway.


And scientists, unlike conspiracy theorists, acknowledge that all conclusions are provisional and may be modified
 
Last edited:
Yes.

The highlite was about PseuSkeps not seeing that, and calling themselves skeptics anyway.
You are not correctly identifying them. The fact that we acknowledge that knowledge is provisional does not mean that we must remain open to all alternatives, no matter how outlandish.

Every new conclusion must take into account what is already known. Newton had a very good, very functional set of laws of motion and gravitation. We can send space probes to the moon, using only Newtonian physics. But we acknowledge that Newtonian physics was not complete. Along came Einstein, who changed everything - except that he didn't. Every part of Newtonian physics can be derived within the framework of general and special relativity. Einstein does not invalidate Newton. Einstein extends Newton into domains it hadn't been extended to before.

All this is to say that new knowledge must be consistent with what is already known and either explain what is known more accurately, or extend what is known into new domains. It can't simply turn what is known on its head.
 
All this is to say that new knowledge must be consistent with what is already known and either explain what is known more accurately, or extend what is known into new domains. It can't simply turn what is known on its head.

It's not what you don't know, it's what you know that ain't so.

Having said that, there is a lot that you don't know, and there is a lot that you know that ain't so.
 
You are not correctly identifying them. The fact that we acknowledge that knowledge is provisional does not mean that we must remain open to all alternatives, no matter how outlandish.

Every new conclusion must take into account what is already known. Newton had a very good, very functional set of laws of motion and gravitation. We can send space probes to the moon, using only Newtonian physics. But we acknowledge that Newtonian physics was not complete. Along came Einstein, who changed everything - except that he didn't. Every part of Newtonian physics can be derived within the framework of general and special relativity. Einstein does not invalidate Newton. Einstein extends Newton into domains it hadn't been extended to before.

All this is to say that new knowledge must be consistent with what is already known and either explain what is known more accurately, or extend what is known into new domains. It can't simply turn what is known on its head.

I'll offer up a quibble related to the part that Bubba decided to emphasize at the end there, though. Scientists are humans, too, and can easily also believe irrational things (and potentially be confidently wrong), especially when their practice of the scientific method (not actually the same thing as skepticism, though they are related) is not applied consistently and when they're dealing with subjects where there are significant gaps in their knowledge.

I'll also offer up a bit of an addition to your first statement here. Some kinds of arguments and criticisms can be dismissed as unreasonable immediately. Bubba's questions about whether we truly know what's in the mRNA vaccines that we were actually injected with and his easily predictable follow-ups from there, like his argument that any skeptic not admitting that they aren't effectively omniscient means that they're actually pseudoskeptics both fall into that category.
 
Last edited:
It's not what you don't know, it's what you know that ain't so.

Having said that, there is a lot that you don't know, and there is a lot that you know that ain't so.
I prefer to trust the word of the people who have spent their lives and careers studying a subject than someone whose only motive is to sell me something.
 
I'll offer up a quibble related to the part that Bubba decided to emphasize at the end there, though. Scientists are humans, too, and can easily also believe irrational things (and potentially be confidently wrong), especially when their practice of the scientific method (not actually the same thing as skepticism, though they are related) is not applied consistently and when they're dealing with subjects where there are significant gaps in their knowledge.

I'll also offer up a bit of an addition to your first statement here. Some kinds of arguments and criticisms can be dismissed as unreasonable immediately. Bubba's questions about whether we truly know what's in the mRNA vaccines that we were actually injected with and his easily predictable follow-ups from there, like his argument that any skeptic not admitting that they aren't effectively omniscient means that they're actually pseudoskeptics both fall into that category.


Its so fun when they make up some lame bs and say it was you who said it.

Sit in the corner.
 
I'll offer up a quibble related to the part that Bubba decided to emphasize at the end there, though. Scientists are humans, too, and can easily also believe irrational things (and potentially be confidently wrong), especially when their practice of the scientific method (not actually the same thing as skepticism, though they are related) is not applied consistently and when they're dealing with subjects where there are significant gaps in their knowledge.
Of course. But science as a process is designed with error checking at its core. Every time it has been discovered that there is an error in science, it has been scientists that discovered it and scientists that corrected it. Not lawyers, not homeopaths, and not purveyors of supplements.

I'll also offer up a bit of an addition to your first statement here. Some kinds of arguments and criticisms can be dismissed as unreasonable immediately. Bubba's questions about whether we truly know what's in the mRNA vaccines that we were actually injected with and his easily predictable follow-ups from there, like his argument that any skeptic not admitting that they aren't effectively omniscient means that they're actually pseudoskeptics both fall into that category.
Yes, but it's important to acknowledge that sometimes they can only be dismissed as unreasonable immediately because we have already gone through the process of determining that they are unreasonable and we don't feel like doing all that again. When one has been open minded about a claim and gone through the sometimes long and arduous process of determining that the claim is false, one does not need to remain open minded about it unless given very good reason.
 
Of course. But science as a process is designed with error checking at its core. Every time it has been discovered that there is an error in science, it has been scientists that discovered it and scientists that corrected it. Not lawyers, not homeopaths, and not purveyors of supplements.

No argument there.

Yes, but it's important to acknowledge that sometimes they can only be dismissed as unreasonable immediately because we have already gone through the process of determining that they are unreasonable and we don't feel like doing all that again. When one has been open minded about a claim and gone through the sometimes long and arduous process of determining that the claim is false, one does not need to remain open minded about it unless given very good reason.

Fair enough.

Its so fun when they make up some lame bs and say it was you who said it.

Sit in the corner.

As boring and pointless an attempted comeback as usual. Feel free to return to your doghouse, then.
 
Last edited:
I'd have you know that skepticism is a constant search for truth. It's not perfect - even skeptics can be fooled and can be wrong. But the process of skepticism consists of constantly doing our best to be as truthful and honest as we can be. Skepticism is not a dogma. It is not a body of knowledge. It is a method - an approach to viewing the world through the lens of truth so we can navigate our way through times that can often be difficult and confusing. Skeptics take comfort in truth, but they are always aware of the ways in which they can be wrong.

Well said, except that we are the authentic skeptics. You are the pseudo-skeptics. We've set vanity and ego mostly aside, we accept never ending hatred and vitriol in order to attempt to show a divergent view of the way that the world really is, you are stalwart defenders of the authoritarian status quo. Your pseudo-skepticism costs you nothing to the extent that you benefit from it, right up until the point that the status quo turns on you, which I think is getting near.

Now, more than ever the rubber is starting to meet the road, and it matters more than ever who and what you trust.

Living through a pandemic is certainly difficult and confusing. But skeptics understand the need for expertise. We know that it is not possible to know everything about everything, but we have the humility to recognise that those who dedicate their lives and their careers to narrow scientific specialisations - such as virology and epidemiology - have more knowledge and understanding of these subjects than we do. We also understand that most scientists - unlike politicians or purveyors of health supplements - are generally honest and report facts accurately, because it is their job, their career, to do so. Do we have absolute assurance of this? No, we don't. But we have a pretty reliable trend. And we have seen examples of scientists who have lost their jobs, their careers, because they failed to uphold this principle of honesty.
Belief that scientists are somehow sanctified from human nature is naive and irrational. They have the same propensity to lie, to fabricate, to falsify, to steal, and to murder as any other human. Unfortunately they, being experts and thus gatekeepers of truth, have even bigger conflicts of interest than the rest of us, and yet they are no more noble than any of us. Why you would equate people who sell "health supplements" with politicians, yet deify corporate pharmaceuticals boggles the mind, and is an example of the exact opposite of authentic skepticism. Here is a quick lesson in basic economics - profit margins on proprietary and patentable substances have vastly higher profit margins than margins on basic non-patentable compounds, while simultaneously being less safe and less effective, and so the attendant conflicts of interest in order to promote the former and demote the latter are ever-present and ongoing, at every level of medical science. You would do well to contemplate this.

Skeptics recognise that the track record of science is very impressive. Scientists, unlike astrologers, make predictions that actually come true. Scientists, unlike homeopaths, acknowledge when they have been wrong about something, and change their point of view accordingly. Scientists, unlike Bigfoot hunters, actually produce verifiable evidence to support their conclusions. And scientists, unlike conspiracy theorists, acknowledge that all conclusions are provisional and may be modified in the future because of new information.

And some conspiracy theorists, unlike all of the types of cranks you mentioned, deal in speculation about things which are very real. Conspiracies, unlike bigfoot, actually exist. People are rotting in jail for the crime of conspiracy. This doesn't stop you from lumping everyone you disagree with into the same boat as "bigfoot hunters". But that's your problem, not mine.

Some scientists said some things at the beginning of this pandemic that turned out not to be true. Did they stick to their guns? No, they didn't. They corrected themselves and started saying things that were more true, because that's their job. Over the course of this pandemic, more and more true things became known, and now, two years later, we know a lot of true things about it. Do we know everything? No, we do not. But we're always searching for more true things to know.
We know less, because we're entering a dark age of censorship and persecution of even moderately divergent points of view. Anything that contradicts the official narrative must be mocked and ridiculed before it is cancelled. That is your job, the job of the authoritarian pseudo-skeptic shill - to be "skeptical" and indeed cynical of everything, except "authoritative" sources.

I don't even think you have figured out by now that I am not even "anti-vax", I'm against the use of force or coercion in the conducting of what amount to mass medical experiments.

Skeptics recognise the tremendous role that scientific expertise plays in the progress of civilisation and technology, and in understanding the wonderful and confusing universe that surrounds us. That is a recognition that is missing from mercola.com. It is missing from childrenshealthdefense.org. It is missing from @drtenpenny.

No, it's missing from the authorities that you deify and revere, the ones for which we have lost all trust.

That is what I'd have you know about skepticism and its role during the pandemic. Do I, after spending over an hour composing this post, think that I'll change your mind? I do not. Because the evidence does not support that conclusion.

Of course not. But the difference still remains, that you advocate force, and we do not. Some of you aren't even honest enough to admit that much. It's pathetic.
 
I prefer to trust the word of the people who have spent their lives and careers studying a subject than someone whose only motive is to sell me something.

That is priceless, for so many reasons that should be obvious to you, but aren't.
 
I don't have a great deal of time right now, so I won't do you the courtesy of a detailed rebuttal to your first post yet. I apologise for this and you can expect one at a later time.

That is priceless, for so many reasons that should be obvious to you, but aren't.
Do you think that someone whose only motive is to sell you something and make money off you is more reliable a source of information on a subject than a person who has spent their entire life and career studying that subject? Such a position would be, at best, irrational.
 
Do you think that someone whose only motive is to sell you something and make money off you is more reliable a source of information on a subject than a person who has spent their entire life and career studying that subject? Such a position would be, at best, irrational.

He disagrees about who it is who is trying to sell us something and is therefore unreliable. "Big Pharma" are the villains in his world.
 
That is priceless, for so many reasons that should be obvious to you, but aren't.

That's amusing coming from you.

Now would you get the shot already? Your silly little beliefs are getting in the way of my home improvement project. I now these are deeply held values of yours but I need my floor tile.
 
Last edited:
We've set vanity and ego mostly aside...

I, for one, am impressed with the humility with which you correct the overwhelming consensus of the world's medical science community, pointing out that they're all either complicit in a plot motivated by cartoonish evil, or too stupid to discern what a completely untrained amateur such as yourself has been able to piece together.

Yes, the total vacuum of vanity and ego as you tell us that you are among the very few too smart to be fooled by a global conspiracy of evil experts is truly inspiring.
 
I don't have a great deal of time right now, so I won't do you the courtesy of a detailed rebuttal to your first post yet. I apologise for this and you can expect one at a later time.

Do you think that someone whose only motive is to sell you something and make money off you is more reliable a source of information on a subject than a person who has spent their entire life and career studying that subject? Such a position would be, at best, irrational.


You mean, for instance, massive corporate pharmaceutical firms with captive government regulatory agencies? You have literally zero self-awareness.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
He disagrees about who it is who is trying to sell us something and is therefore unreliable. "Big Pharma" are the villains in his world.


Typically, everyone is trying to sell something. The rational approach is to apply the most skepticism towards those who have the most to gain. I am guessing you will have trouble figuring out exactly who that is.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I, for one, am impressed with the humility with which you correct the overwhelming consensus of the world's medical science community, pointing out that they're all either complicit in a plot motivated by cartoonish evil, or too stupid to discern what a completely untrained amateur such as yourself has been able to piece together.
Neither of those things has to be true. All that needs to be true is that the initial safety trials funded by the same companies that stood to gain from the sale of the EGTs be corrupted, or based on fabricated data or even flawed methodology. All of the subsequent meta-analysis would be worthless.

We have evidence from whistleblowers that this is the case. The FDA, CDC, and WHO are essentially captives of the pharmaceuticals (and worse).

Yes, the total vacuum of vanity and ego as you tell us that you are among the very few too smart to be fooled by a global conspiracy of evil experts is truly inspiring.
I’ve been a NWO CT ever since I learned how the fiat money/fractional reserve banking system worked in the early nineties. It occurred to me that a system of infinite money for elites inevitably leads to infinite corruption, and for the past three decades I’ve learned exactly how this works, so I have a perspective that you do not.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom