Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008

You are wasting time with this disingenuous attempt to portray John Fund, a respected columnist for the Wall Street Journal, as a partisan hack. Fund isn't even a Republican. Yes, it is legitimate to take the official tally for Palm Beach County as strong evidence of vote fraud.

The fundamental problem here is that despite being shown evidence that Fund should not be trusted as a source, you carry on pretending that there is evidence Fund is an honest and thorough reporter. Similarly, I'm about to give you a couple of links and you are going to decide, based on their content, that the information on those pages was made up by wacky, crazy, loony-left moonbat hippie yippie dippie tie-dyed upside-down space cases on acid.

http://www.projectcensored.org/newsflash/voter_fraud.html
http://www.ideamouth.com/voterfraud.htm

If sloppy work like that of Fund must be accepted as canonical by us then such slop from the other side must be too. Assuming that we are being simply gullible rather than merely biased, of course.

Now those links actually have some advantages over Fund if you think about it. They have links to other sources, even though the sources are not always that reliable themselves. That beats unsupported claims that don't even make sense. In addition they are freely available so every party to the discussion can read them.

Stop warning and start learning.

It seems to me that if you believe Fund has provided strong evidence the Democrats cheated in Palm County, then if you are consistent you now also have to believe that Republicans cheated all over the place.

Now you might be tempted to cherry pick one or two of the weaker claims on those pages, mock them, declare victory, and so avoid ever engaging with the stronger claims. Please resist this temptation. We have already stomped some of Fund's weaker claims, so a supporter of Fund has no right to complain if some of the other side's evidence is wonky.

Lastly, if you think we should give up on presenting partisan tripe as evidence and discuss reliable reports we can do that too.
 
The fundamental problem here is that despite being shown evidence that Fund should not be trusted as a source, you carry on pretending that there is evidence Fund is an honest and thorough reporter. Similarly, I'm about to give you a couple of links and you are going to decide, based on their content, that the information on those pages was made up by wacky, crazy, loony-left moonbat hippie yippie dippie tie-dyed upside-down space cases on acid.

http://www.projectcensored.org/newsflash/voter_fraud.html
http://www.ideamouth.com/voterfraud.htm



These links are worthless. They present a farrago of nonsense fabricated by leftwing loons. Of course you don't believe me: What I'm saying is inconvenient to your prejudices. But these articles recycle all the rubbish invented by the far-left blogosphere and refuted by serious investigators. The extremely liberal "Cleveland Plain-Dealer" ran a series on the fraud allegations and found no substance to any of them.

No, Bush did not get more votes than there were registered voters. No, Bush was not expected to lose the 2004 election. In the aggregate of all national polls, he led by 2-3 points on the eve of the election. No, Kerry did not recieve 54% of the vote in Ohio--he would have won the state if he had (duh!). Nobody in the Kerry camp thinks their candidate won Ohio. No, there was no fraud in Warren County. It is a heavily-Republican county (Bob Dole got 66% in 1996) and Democrat supervisors present during the lockdown saw nothing suspicious. Diebold machines were used in precisely TWO counties in Ohio, and Kerry won the larger of them. And on and on...

You refuse to read the definitive articles on the flawed exit polls written by Democrat pollster Mark Blumenthal (pollster.com).


If sloppy work like that of Fund must be accepted as canonical by us then such slop from the other side must be too. Assuming that we are being simply gullible rather than merely biased, of course.

Now those links actually have some advantages over Fund if you think about it. They have links to other sources, even though the sources are not always that reliable themselves. That beats unsupported claims that don't even make sense. In addition they are freely available so every party to the discussion can read them.



It seems to me that if you believe Fund has provided strong evidence the Democrats cheated in Palm County, then if you are consistent you now also have to believe that Republicans cheated all over the place.

Now you might be tempted to cherry pick one or two of the weaker claims on those pages, mock them, declare victory, and so avoid ever engaging with the stronger claims. Please resist this temptation. We have already stomped some of Fund's weaker claims, so a supporter of Fund has no right to complain if some of the other side's evidence is wonky.

Lastly, if you think we should give up on presenting partisan tripe as evidence and discuss reliable reports we can do that too.



You are a far-left fanatic and no evidence that runs counter to your insulated worldview will ever suffice for you. Your cherished myths are articles of faith. To understand the statistical case for fraud in Palm Beach County, you should read the relevant chapter in Fund's book. You are too ideologically-blinkered to do that.
 
These links are worthless. They present a farrago of nonsense fabricated by leftwing loons. Of course you don't believe me: What I'm saying is inconvenient to your prejudices. But these articles recycle all the rubbish invented by the far-left blogosphere and refuted by serious investigators.

Yet you don't see that this stuff is no better and no worse than Fund's rubbish.

You are a far-left fanatic and no evidence that runs counter to your insulated worldview will ever suffice for you. Your cherished myths are articles of faith. To understand the statistical case for fraud in Palm Beach County, you should read the relevant chapter in Fund's book. You are too ideologically-blinkered to do that.

I guess when you only have one note, you have to play it over and over again.
 
Yet you don't see that this stuff is no better and no worse than Fund's rubbish.



Not quite. I see that Fund is a respected columnist for the Wall Street Journal, whose work has NOT been "discredited" by the fabrications of far-left screamers. I see that Loo's rubbish is incompetent drivel.



I guess when you only have one note, you have to play it over and over again.


You must be reading my mind. Now, that's projection!
 
Are you related to this Ron Wieck, pomer?

http://www.ronwieck.com/

Hope you don't mind my asking but if you do then feel free to ignore the question.


I don't mind the question. No, I am not Ron Wieck the state senator from Iowa. I am Ron Wieck the chess player and bon vivant from New York.

Oddly enough, last year someone sent me e-mails addressed to "Senator Wieck." There are all sorts of nuts on the net, so I didn't pay much attention. But after the third one, I asked, "What's with that 'Senator' business?" The guy told me that he had assumed I was a senator, and that is how I came to know of the existence of my namesake.
 
My point in reviving this thread is that since the elections weren't stolen, does this mean that the caging conspiracy was successfully prevented or defeated, or was this all just a politically motivated and unsubstanciated conspiracy theory?
 
Last edited:
My point in reviving this thread is that since the elections weren't stolen, does this mean that the caging conspiracy was successfully prevented or defeated, or was this all just a politically motivated and unsubstanciated conspiracy theory?

I do believe that for the most part it was politically motivated to put doubt into people as to the results of the next election if it went to the other party, assuming that he people who would push it were from the other side of the isle.

For the other group, no election would ever be seen as legitimate to them given their pre-assumed distrust for the election system. Hence the occasional Ron Paul supporter who will push that the primaries were unfair against him.
 
My point in reviving this thread is that since the elections weren't stolen, does this mean that the caging conspiracy was successfully prevented or defeated, or was this all just a politically motivated and unsubstanciated conspiracy theory?

False dichotomy. The Democrats won by a much larger percentage than the voting machines registered, and in fact not a single person in the country other than John McCain voted for John McCain. So far from this being an unstolen election, in fact this was the greatest heist in history.

But I'm sure Skeptigirl has a more sensible interpretation.
 
My point in reviving this thread is that since the elections weren't stolen, does this mean that the caging conspiracy was successfully prevented or defeated, or was this all just a politically motivated and unsubstanciated conspiracy theory?

I agree that it's a false dichotomy, and I think there's an alternative hypothesis which covers the facts. Mind you I haven't kept a grip on this issue in the last few years, so my impressions may be out of date.

I've never seen any coherent explanation for the exit poll anomaly in the 2004 election, other than grass-roots electoral fraud to pad the Bush vote in Republican-controlled electorates. The fact that the anomaly was confined to Republican strongholds which did not use hand-counted paper ballots, but was found in electorates with many different electronic voting systems, rules out any other sensible hypotheses I or anyone else on these forums have come up with.

This meshes with the fact that any number of local exploits for various electronic voting systems have been published and/or demonstrated, but nobody has presented any evidence that existing electoral systems can be, or have been, hacked en masse from a central point or distributed with malicious software. (As opposed to culpably insecure software which can be trivially hacked without leaving traces).

For those curious, I'm agnostic about whether such vote rigging made any difference in the 2004 election but I've never seen any convincing figures that show that any plausible level of manipulation could have been decisive. Toss together caging and possible electronic vote rigging and it's conceivable Ohio might have been stolen, but from memory even if you go that far, that alone still didn't decide the election. Currently I lean towards the view that there was a substantial amount of small-scale, local electronic vote fraud in 2008 as well as other highly unethical attempts to influence the vote (such as caging) but that Bush probably would have won the Presidency without them.

The incentives to engage in such acts in the 2008 Presidential elections were, I think (I'm open to persuasion on this point) significantly less than in 2004. Firstly there was more public awareness of the problems with voting machines by 2008 and many districts had dumped electronic voting or significantly tightened up their systems. Secondly the election was obviously going to be an Obama landslide rather than a cliffhanger so small-scale electoral fraud would be unlikely to make any difference to the Presidential outcome. If it's not going to make any difference, there's less incentive to do it.

If that theory's right I'd expect that there were still some dirty electorates in the 2008 election, but fewer than in 2004, and I'd expect that any difference they made to the Presidential race was swamped by the volume of Obama votes. Quite possibly the elections for local dogcatcher or whatever were rigged at the grass-roots level in some places - the incentives for such manipulations are obviously still there.

Ideally this would be testable by sending people in to electorates which yielded the most suspect 2004 exit poll results to audit their machines and ballots, immediately after the election was held. If you'd find evidence of fraud anywhere that's where I'd expect to see it. Failing that, exit polling suspect areas could yield more circumstantial evidence of funny business, but as we've seen before most USians won't accept circumstantial evidence of funny business in US elections as being real evidence. "It can't happen here" and all that.
 
I refuse to take seriously the opinions of anybody on American politics who uses the term USians, since that use of that term is evidence of a dislike for the USA in general.
 
False dichotomy. The Democrats won by a much larger percentage than the voting machines registered, and in fact not a single person in the country other than John McCain voted for John McCain. So far from this being an unstolen election, in fact this was the greatest heist in history.

But I'm sure Skeptigirl has a more sensible interpretation.

I voted for John McCain, so I'm sure he got at least two votes.
 
It's testable alright, Palast suggested he had evidence, why hasn't he come out with it ?
 
It's testable alright, Palast suggested he had evidence, why hasn't he come out with it ?

I googled "palast caging emails", which scarcely qualifies as a stroke of genius, and the top three hits were this article by Palast claiming that vote caging is a felony under the Voting Rights Act, this other article on former AG for Arkansas Tim Griffin resigning as the threat of an investigation into his vote caging activities loomed, and a wikpedia article about caging in the 2004 and 2008 elections with copious references.

So when you said...

Any news on Craig Palast and his 500 emails? I couldn't find anything.

...I guess you hadn't looked very hard.

It looks like vote caging was business as usual in the 2008 election, but it didn't significantly affect the outcome of the Presidential election.
 
I googled "palast caging emails", which scarcely qualifies as a stroke of genius, and the top three hits were this article by Palast claiming that vote caging is a felony under the Voting Rights Act, this other article on former AG for Arkansas Tim Griffin resigning as the threat of an investigation into his vote caging activities loomed, and a wikpedia article about caging in the 2004 and 2008 elections with copious references.

So when you said...

...I guess you hadn't looked very hard.

did you see the dates attached to these articles?

Please pay attention, I was asking for any "news" meaning any new development since last time, about the story in the OP.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom