I've said it before and I'll say it again: I do not understand the apparent American fascination for mechanical or electronic machines to do the voting on the ballot and the counting afterwards.
In Canada, federal elections use paper ballots hand-marked and hand-counted. Results sufficient for projections of which party will form the government are had within a couple of hours at most, and usually earlier than that.
Personally, I want to mark that ballot with my own hand and not rely on or trust a machine to punch a hole or count something electronically.
Several comments. (And yes, Americans historically have been fascinated by machine-based "improvements," whether they make sense or not.)
1/ How are Canadian fed elections administered? As one big election, or as many different elections at the provincial level? In the US, the presidential election, with attendant congressional elections, are really managed at the state level. While there are limits, some of which you are reading about in this thread, the states are largely able to handle their own mechanics, devices, and other means.
2/ Well, the US has 10 times the population of Canada, and this proportion has been very roughly constant since the 19th century. That complicates matters.
3/ But come to think of it, both Canada and the US are spread across 4 or 5 (?) time zones. We still deal with that per state, which has led to complaints in the western states, since the eastern states finish (and report) while the western states are still voting. The states can set their own voting hours, I think. (If I remember correctly, New York tends to open ballots 6 am-9 pm. Michigan 7 am-8 pm. And both are in the eastern time zone.) The losers in national elections in recent years tend to blame the media -- "your early misleading reports from the east discouraged my western voters who all stayed home making pouty faces" How does Canada deal with that fact?
4/ In New York I've voted on rather old machines, when one pushes down small levers for each name/ position and then throws a great big lever to register the whole megillah. In Michigan, we used paper and felt tip pens -- you fill in a blank next to the name /position you are voting for. Then you take it over to a machine which "reads" it. I have never dealt with chads and hope never to.
5/ Are there no histories of large scale vote fraud in Canada? With respect, I'd be surprised if Canadian parties are more honest than ours. Could be, of course. It just is hard to figure into a consistent picture of human nature.