Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008

I believe your statement would be considered projection, pomy.


Look, we can continue this unedifying tap dance for as long as you like. Bush ran well ahead of an unpopular Republican senatorial candidate in every county in Florida except Palm Beach. What happened there is pretty clear: Bush's vote simply disappeared without moving over to the Gore column. Your stubborn refusal to read Fund's book--at least, the relevant chapter--leaves you looking ridiculous. You have no idea of what you're arguing.
 
I've said it before and I'll say it again: I do not understand the apparent American fascination for mechanical or electronic machines to do the voting on the ballot and the counting afterwards.

In Canada, federal elections use paper ballots hand-marked and hand-counted. Results sufficient for projections of which party will form the government are had within a couple of hours at most, and usually earlier than that.

Personally, I want to mark that ballot with my own hand and not rely on or trust a machine to punch a hole or count something electronically.
 
You missed the link to some of the emails I take it? Or are you just challenging the volume? I think Palast has pretty much proved he did get some emails that were sent to .org instead of .com. The Republicans admitted Palast had an Excell file of addresses they sent the caging letters to and the only other way he could have had that was a leak. The emails are real. I don't know whether there are 500 but I have no reason to believe there aren't.

I remember you posting a link to an e-mail header and a jpeg of what Palast claims was an attachment.

If you posted a link to all 500 of the e-mails Palast claims to have, could you repost it?
 
Look, we can continue this unedifying tap dance for as long as you like. Bush ran well ahead of an unpopular Republican senatorial candidate in every county in Florida except Palm Beach. What happened there is pretty clear: Bush's vote simply disappeared without moving over to the Gore column. Your stubborn refusal to read Fund's book--at least, the relevant chapter--leaves you looking ridiculous. You have no idea of what you're arguing.
There is just no answer for your blind spot for the evidence against Fund. He's been discredited. You may be the only one in the thread who hasn't noticed.
 
I remember you posting a link to an e-mail header and a jpeg of what Palast claims was an attachment.

If you posted a link to all 500 of the e-mails Palast claims to have, could you repost it?
I never claimed there were 500 emails or that Palast has provided that evidence. Palast has provided evidence he received at least some emails including ones that implicated the Republican Party in illegally trying to purge voter roles of Democrats by way of caging. The Republican Party admitted it, the scandal reached into the Gonzales federal attorney firings and led to the Bush appointed attorney in Arkansas, Tim Griffin, resigning after it was revealed he was part of the illegal caging scam.

Raging Caging - What the heck is vote caging, and why should we care? by Greg Palast.
Last week, in her testimony before the House judiciary committee, Monica Goodling referred several times to “vote caging” possibly done by Arkansas’ soon to be ex-interim, never-confirmed U.S. Attorney Tim Griffin. Yet Goodling was questioned about this almost not at all, nor did the media do much more than report the words of the former liaison between the White House and Alberto Gonzales (why a “liaison” is required between two institutions with no boundaries between them is incomprehensible, but perhaps another story). Meanwhile, liberal talk radio, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., and the blogosphere went nuts. So, which is it: Is vote caging the most underreported part of this U.S. attorneys scandal or the most over-hyped?
So you can ignore this attempt to illegally purge voter registration roles as the Republican Party would so love to have people ignore, or you can take a serious look at the voter fraud involved.

I don't care if the number of emails was 5 or 500. Palast uncovered and provided enough evidence that Griffin resigned, the Republican Party made excuses but admitted Palast had an Excell file the Republicans could not explain other than Palast had indeed intercepted emails mis-addressed and now Gonzales has resigned because the fired federal attorneys could not be explained except that voter intimidation was the underlying reason.

Read the thread if you care about democracy.
 
If Mr. Palast really does have 500 e-mails and american democracy is under dire threat, then his refusal to release them tells you how much he cares about democracy.

I would also like to see where you claim the republicans admitted to vote fraud.
 
There is just no answer for your blind spot for the evidence against Fund. He's been discredited. You may be the only one in the thread who hasn't noticed.


You're comical. You refuse to read the book and rely on blinkered ideologues for your sources. You still can't comprehend the math behind the Palm Beach scandal and, frankly, it isn't that difficult.

It would be nice to wave a magic wand and discredit anyone whose research produces data inconvenient to your prejudices, but reality is indifferent to emotional needs.
 
If Mr. Palast really does have 500 e-mails and american democracy is under dire threat, then his refusal to release them tells you how much he cares about democracy.

I would also like to see where you claim the republicans admitted to vote fraud.


Palast is an egregious liar. He fills my mailbox with one sensational revelation after another and somehow the party of trial lawyers never finds anything worth taking to court. I replied to his latest e-mail by asking when we can expect to see his hard-hitting expose on the HillBillies' New Square shenanigans.
 
If Mr. Palast really does have 500 e-mails and american democracy is under dire threat, then his refusal to release them tells you how much he cares about democracy.

I would also like to see where you claim the republicans admitted to vote fraud.
The Republicans admitted the Excell file of addresses in black Democratic areas of Florida was their list. Monica Goodling testified under oath before Congress that the list was tied to a caging scheme and Tim Griffin resigned after the testimony. The links are in this thread. I'll hunt them down for you later. If you can't put these three things together you have a problem

In the meantime, it just so happens that a report investigating voter caging was published just last month. If you care to know the truth, read it. If you prefer to live in your "it can't happen here" state of mind, then I suggest you not open your eyes.

Caging Democracy: A 50-Year History of Partisan Challenges to Minority Voters; by Teresa James, J.D. Projectvote.org.

From the executive summary:
Voter caging is a term that drew public attention as a result of testimony provided by Monica Goodling, former White House liaison to the Department of Justice, to a 2007 House Judiciary Committee hearing on the firings of eight US Attorneys. Although public interest in voter caging is relatively recent, the practice is not new. Republicans have engaged in voter caging on the national and state level since the late 1950’s. According to many election observers, voter caging is a controversial political tactic that typically targets minority voters to directly disenfranchise them or suppress their vote by intimidation. Republican officials, on the other hand, maintain that voter caging is part of what they describe as “ballot security” measures necessary to combat voter fraud.

The following report reviews Republican voter caging operations during the last 50 years,
culminating with the unprecedented number of large voter caging operations conducted across the nation in the 2004 presidential election. ...



The author of the article since I think that is an important part of evaluating a source of information:
About Project Vote ... staff:
Teresa James, Counsel
Before joining Project Vote, Teresa James served as a legal editor with LexisNexis, a global legal and business information service. Her editing experience followed years in the practice of law at Legal Aid, a private law firm, and in her own practice. She is a graduate of Oberlin College and of Case Western Reserve Law School. During her time in college and in legal practice she maintained her community involvement with organizations such as the ACLU and the Lorain County Urban League . Teresa has served on the boards of the Oberlin ACLU and the Lorain County Legal Aid. She has also been active in Ohio community organizations involved in promoting open, fair, and transparent elections.


The report is worth a new thread so I'll start one.
 
Last edited:
Pomy, no one is relying on Palast as a source here. We're only citing what can be backed up with corroborating sources. Fund has no corroborating evidence for anything he claims and much of what he wrote in his book has been shown to be a fraud. You seem to have forgotten everything in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Pomy, no one is relying on Palast as a source here. We're only citing what can be backed up with corroborating sources. Fund has no corroborating evidence for anything he claims and much of what he wrote in his book has been shown to be a fraud. You seem to have forgotten everything in this thread.


No, you are pretending that Fund has been discredited. In reality, nothing of the sort has happened. You have forgotten that the fabrications of your far-left screamers are inadequate to make scholarly points. You chose to dismiss the statistical implications of the mysterious drop-off in Bush's vote in Palm Beach County. To understand the issue, you can either a) read Fund's chapter in which he explains what happened, or b) check out the Florida Board of Elections webpage and compare the 2000 Presidential and Senatorial results. The latter involves more than cutting-and-pasting, so it won't appeal to you.
 
I've said it before and I'll say it again: I do not understand the apparent American fascination for mechanical or electronic machines to do the voting on the ballot and the counting afterwards.

In Canada, federal elections use paper ballots hand-marked and hand-counted. Results sufficient for projections of which party will form the government are had within a couple of hours at most, and usually earlier than that.

Personally, I want to mark that ballot with my own hand and not rely on or trust a machine to punch a hole or count something electronically.

Several comments. (And yes, Americans historically have been fascinated by machine-based "improvements," whether they make sense or not.)

1/ How are Canadian fed elections administered? As one big election, or as many different elections at the provincial level? In the US, the presidential election, with attendant congressional elections, are really managed at the state level. While there are limits, some of which you are reading about in this thread, the states are largely able to handle their own mechanics, devices, and other means.

2/ Well, the US has 10 times the population of Canada, and this proportion has been very roughly constant since the 19th century. That complicates matters.

3/ But come to think of it, both Canada and the US are spread across 4 or 5 (?) time zones. We still deal with that per state, which has led to complaints in the western states, since the eastern states finish (and report) while the western states are still voting. The states can set their own voting hours, I think. (If I remember correctly, New York tends to open ballots 6 am-9 pm. Michigan 7 am-8 pm. And both are in the eastern time zone.) The losers in national elections in recent years tend to blame the media -- "your early misleading reports from the east discouraged my western voters who all stayed home making pouty faces" How does Canada deal with that fact?

4/ In New York I've voted on rather old machines, when one pushes down small levers for each name/ position and then throws a great big lever to register the whole megillah. In Michigan, we used paper and felt tip pens -- you fill in a blank next to the name /position you are voting for. Then you take it over to a machine which "reads" it. I have never dealt with chads and hope never to.

5/ Are there no histories of large scale vote fraud in Canada? With respect, I'd be surprised if Canadian parties are more honest than ours. Could be, of course. It just is hard to figure into a consistent picture of human nature.
 
Last edited:
How are Canadian fed elections administered? As one big election, or as many different elections at the provincial level?
Federal elections are administered by Elections Canada, an independent non-partisan agency which reports to Parliament. Federal elections are one large, national election.

For everything there is to know about federal elections in Canada head over to the Elections Canada web site. There's a huge amount of information and material there. In fact, there's probably more there than anyone would want to know... :D

But come to think of it, both Canada and the US are spread across 4 or 5 (?) time zones. We still deal with that per state, which has led to complaints in the western states, since the eastern states finish (and report) while the western states are still voting... How does Canada deal with that fact?
There have been similar complaints here. Some years back the voting hours in each province were staggered; polls in eastern provinces open later and close later than polls in western provinces to try and offset some of the time zone differences. Also, there are strict limits on the media in that they cannot report election results from other provinces until polls are closed in that particular province.

As an aside, campaign financing here is, as I understand it, quite a bit more restrictive than it is in U.S. presidential elections.

Are there no histories of large scale vote fraud in Canada? With respect, I'd be surprised if Canadian parties are more honest than ours.
None that I'm aware of offhand, but I'll freely admit it's an area I know little about. The A History of the Vote in Canada page on the Elections Canada web site would probably mention such situations. (Those history pages look to be pretty detailed — I should probably go through them myself!)

Speaking of voting, it's going to be a busy time the next couple of days. There's a provincial election for Newfoundland & Labrador on Oct. 9th, then Ontario holds its provincial election the next day.
 
Last edited:
Look, we can continue this unedifying tap dance for as long as you like. Bush ran well ahead of an unpopular Republican senatorial candidate in every county in Florida except Palm Beach. What happened there is pretty clear: Bush's vote simply disappeared without moving over to the Gore column. Your stubborn refusal to read Fund's book--at least, the relevant chapter--leaves you looking ridiculous. You have no idea of what you're arguing.

If we are the ones who have no idea what we are arguing, why are you the one sliding the goalposts around in response to our arguments?

The new goalposts say "Okay, the metal rod idea was stupid and Fund probably made it up out of whole cloth. However there is an interesting discrepancy in the number of Bush votes counted".

Now if we take Fund's numbers as accurate (yeah, I know, but for the sake of discussion we'll ignore all the obvious reasons not to) then yes, the totals do look odd.

The million dollar question, Pomeroo, is this. If a vote tally is off by the amount it was off in Palm, compared to a plausible guess at what the tally might have looked like, is that strong evidence of fraud?

Yes, this is totally a trick question. If you say yes, then we're going to go find precincts where Democrat candidates or left-wing proposals got unexpectedly low tallies. Then we're going to say that they must be strong evidence of fraud too.
 
Skepticism should be applied not just for those theories we don't believe

..But to those we'd like to believe as well.

Skeptics require evidence to believe in something like a conspiracy. To accept it just because we don't like Bush is not behaving in a skeptical manner.

Also, both sides cheated. It happens every election. However, it's not the candidates who generally cheat, it's overzealous county clerks and volunteers.
 
If we are the ones who have no idea what we are arguing, why are you the one sliding the goalposts around in response to our arguments?

The new goalposts say "Okay, the metal rod idea was stupid and Fund probably made it up out of whole cloth. However there is an interesting discrepancy in the number of Bush votes counted".

Now if we take Fund's numbers as accurate (yeah, I know, but for the sake of discussion we'll ignore all the obvious reasons not to) then yes, the totals do look odd.

The million dollar question, Pomeroo, is this. If a vote tally is off by the amount it was off in Palm, compared to a plausible guess at what the tally might have looked like, is that strong evidence of fraud?

Yes, this is totally a trick question. If you say yes, then we're going to go find precincts where Democrat candidates or left-wing proposals got unexpectedly low tallies. Then we're going to say that they must be strong evidence of fraud too.


Again, your refusal to read Fund's chapter on Palm Beach leaves you looking very silly. What on earth can "Fund's numbers" be? Are they different from the official tally? If so, let us ignore them. Assuming that there is no such animal as "Fund's numbers" and that you invented this red herring to mask your unwillingness to learn anything about the issue, we can proceed.

A Democratic congressman, who chose to remain anonymous for obvious reasons, has stated that the bizarre results can only be explained by fraud. Naturally, you and Skeptigirl will purposely miss the point and reflexively rage against his anonymity. That's fine, but what could be another explanation for this glaring statistical anomaly? Before you start fabricating, pause for a moment and reflect that you don't have the slightest idea of what the anomaly is.
 
Again, your refusal to read Fund's chapter on Palm Beach leaves you looking very silly. What on earth can "Fund's numbers" be? Are they different from the official tally? If so, let us ignore them. Assuming that there is no such animal as "Fund's numbers" and that you invented this red herring to mask your unwillingness to learn anything about the issue, we can proceed.

I haven't paged back through the thread to find Fund's numbers, then googled around to check them against reliable sources. Partially because I'm lazy, and partially because I want to get a straight answer out of your first regarding whether it's legitimate to take the numbers Fund claims as strong evidence of fraud.

A Democratic congressman, who chose to remain anonymous for obvious reasons, has stated that the bizarre results can only be explained by fraud. Naturally, you and Skeptigirl will purposely miss the point and reflexively rage against his anonymity. That's fine, but what could be another explanation for this glaring statistical anomaly? Before you start fabricating, pause for a moment and reflect that you don't have the slightest idea of what the anomaly is.

Actually unless my memory is faulty you pasted a chunk of text explaining the anomaly into one of your previous posts.

Now as I was saying, if Fund's numbers are accurate, are you absolutely sure that such numbers are strong evidence of fraud? I've warned you about where this is going.
 
..But to those we'd like to believe as well.

Skeptics require evidence to believe in something like a conspiracy. To accept it just because we don't like Bush is not behaving in a skeptical manner.

Also, both sides cheated. It happens every election. However, it's not the candidates who generally cheat, it's overzealous county clerks and volunteers.
This post is an example of someone coming into a thread at the end of 12 pages and assuming there is no evidence in the rest of the thread.

This thread is chock full of evidence Chao, I suggest you review some of it if you are really interested in the evidence based version of this story.
 
I haven't paged back through the thread to find Fund's numbers, then googled around to check them against reliable sources. Partially because I'm lazy, and partially because I want to get a straight answer out of your first regarding whether it's legitimate to take the numbers Fund claims as strong evidence of fraud.


You are wasting time with this disingenuous attempt to portray John Fund, a respected columnist for the Wall Street Journal, as a partisan hack. Fund isn't even a Republican. Yes, it is legitimate to take the official tally for Palm Beach County as strong evidence of vote fraud.


Actually unless my memory is faulty you pasted a chunk of text explaining the anomaly into one of your previous posts.

Now as I was saying, if Fund's numbers are accurate, are you absolutely sure that such numbers are strong evidence of fraud? I've warned you about where this is going.


Stop warning and start learning.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom