Conspiracy of Silence

From Shades's first page post, about the making of the documentary:
In mid-1993, after The Franklin Cover-Up had been circulating for almost a year, the British-based TV station, Yorkshire Television, sent a top-notch team to Nebraska to launch its own investigation of the Franklin case. Yorkshire had a contract with the Discovery Channel to produce a documentary on the case for American television.

They spent many months in Nebraska, and also travelled this country from one end to the other, interviewing, filming, and documenting piece-by-piece the Franklin story as I had told it in the book. They spent somewhere between a quarter-million and one-half million dollars investigating the story, deploying probably a thousand times the resources and abilities that I personally had.

Over the year that I worked with them, I was amazed at the team’s ability to gather new documents and witnesses which kept opening up new and frightening facts about Franklin. They were a crack team. In the final weeks that they were in Nebraska,they expressed their certainty that they would win awards for this documented horror story of government-sanctioned abuse of children; and government protection of some of this country’s most powerful businessmen and politicians, who had been the chief acts in the Franklin story.
I've emphasised a different bit. That's one of the very reasons to believe that the Yorkshire TV guys were getting carried away. Stories like this have a habit of snowballing, but the size of the snowball never has anything to do with the veracity of the original. When late on in the investigation, everywhere they look seems to be providing confirmatory evidence indicates to me that they're suffering from the confirmation bias that is all too familiar to this kind of investigation.

Shades has a habit of succumbing to the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. If Alisha Owen endured a longer period in solitary confinement than any other prisoner, it's not really an indication that she's an innocent put-upon. You only get solitary confinement for breaching prison rules, in other words for doing stuff after she had arrived at prison. It may seem to be a horrendous over-reaction to sentence someone to 9 to 20 years for 1st offence perjury (it certainly does to me), that doesn't mean that every piece of apparent mistreatment is all part of the same process.
 
From Shades's first page post, about the making of the documentary:I've emphasised a different bit. That's one of the very reasons to believe that the Yorkshire TV guys were getting carried away. Stories like this have a habit of snowballing, but the size of the snowball never has anything to do with the veracity of the original. When late on in the investigation, everywhere they look seems to be providing confirmatory evidence indicates to me that they're suffering from the confirmation bias that is all too familiar to this kind of investigation.


And if you watch the rough cut of the documentary that's out there:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4946110250157218995&q=Conspiracy+Of+Silence&hl=en

(this is a higher quality version than the one that's linked at the beginning of the thread)

you'll see that this is almost certainly what happened. Almost nobody with an opposing view will talk to them and so they get sucked into the conspiracy more and more. And they take the testimony of the witnesses on face value - possibly because they don't have a story if they don't.

Their fundamental mistake was to make a documentary of the conspiracy theory rather than a documentary about the conspiracy theory. I'm sure that as soon as sombody outside the production team saw it they pulled the plug.

The video does make interesting viewing if you're interested in seeing how professional documentary film-makers can get things badly wrong.

Edited to add:

Given that Shades of PDoherty didn't bother with citing his sources, here's where he was quoting from:

http://www.informationliberation.com/?id=8516

If you scroll down, you get to DeCamp's account of the filming, which the quote was taken from, and there's some more context there.
 
Last edited:
Given that Shades of PDoherty didn't bother with citing his sources, here's where he was quoting from:

http://www.informationliberation.com/?id=8516

If you scroll down, you get to DeCamp's account of the filming, which the quote was taken from, and there's some more context there.
[/FONT]

3. When the broadcast tape was sent to the United States, Customs officials seized the documentary and held it up as being ‘pornographic material’. Attorneys for Discovery Channel and Yorkshire TV were able to get the documentary released. Then, the lawyers went through the film for months, making this or that change or deletion, so that the documentary ultimately advertised to be shown on the Discovery Channel on May 3, 1994, would survive any claims of libel or slander that any of the individuals identified in the documentary might attempt to bring. The lawyers had cleared the documentary for broadcast.

4. During the several months that the documentary was being prepared and advertised for showing, major legislation impacting the entire future of the Cable TV industry was being debated on Capitol Hill. Legislation, which the industry opposed, was under debate for placing controls on the industry and the contents of what could be shown. Messages were delivered in no uncertain terms from key politicians involved in the Cable TV battle, that if the Conspiracy of Silence were shown on the Discovery Channel as planned, then the industry would probably lose the debate. An agreement was reached: Conspiracy of Silence was pulled, and with no rights for sale or broadcast by any other program; Yorkshire TV would be reimbursed for the costs of production, the Discovery Channel itself would never be linked to the documentary; and copies of Conspiracy of Silence would be destroyed.

So, a documentary that could be labelled "pornographic", from which it took lawyers several months to remove anything libelous or slanderous, was later used as a cudgel in an ongoing debate about legislation on the content of Cable TV.

Um, yeah, I smell a conspiracy.
 
So, a documentary that could be labelled "pornographic", from which it took lawyers several months to remove anything libelous or slanderous, was later used as a cudgel in an ongoing debate about legislation on the content of Cable TV.

Um, yeah, I smell a conspiracy.

Yes, and that's just DeCamps account from sources he "can't disclose". Yorkshire TV and The Discovery Channel have not commented on this at all.

The rough-cut versions of the documentary does contain some quite detailed descriptions of sexual abuse - quite unecessarily in my opinion.
 
Quote:
Eighty children initially came forward as a result of newspaper publicity of the raid and subsequent stories in the local news
Initially four victim/witnesses involved in the satanic cult/sex/drug ring were cooperative. Two of the four victim/witnesses, Troy Boner and Danny King, recanted their testimony.

Quote:
One of the children who recanted his testimony was Troy Boner, a young teenager. Troy Boner recanted after his brother, Shawn Boner, died allegedly of suicide by a Russian Roulette gunshot wound on January 17, 1991. Troy Boner told John De Camp, attorney for some of the witnesses, that his brother was afraid of guns.

Quote:
Years later, on October 27, 1993, Troy Boner made a sworn statement in which he said that he had recanted his original testimony because, "I truly believed and still do believe that it was a situation where I must either ‘lie or die’, and at the insistence primarily of the Federal Bureau of Investigation officials who were dealing with me at that time, specifically Mr. Mott and Mr. Culver."

Quote:
Alisha Owen was convicted of first offense perjury in 1991 and was sentenced on August 8, 1991, to nine to 27 years in prison. During her prison term, she was in solitary confinement for a period longer than any female citizen in the history of the State of Nebraska.

Quote:
In September, 1997, television show "Inside Edition" reported that Johnny Gosch was still alive. Johnny Gosch is a highly publicized 1982 kidnap victim from West De Moines, Iowa, who has also been named as a victim in the Franklin child abuse matters, as described below.

One week after this show was aired, Nebraska authorities picked up Alicia Owen, and without explanation, said she must serve out the remaining lengthy sentence in prison. In spite of this, Alisha refused to recant. Alisha is still incarcerated. Alisha’s parents are raising Alisha’s daughter, Amanda Jayne, who according to Alisha was sired by Omaha Chief of Police, Robert Wadman. Alisha was 15 years old when she had Amanda.

On November 9, 1990, Alisha Owen’s brother was found dead in a correctiony
.


For the sake of completeness, all these unsourced quotes from Shades of Grey (aka PDoherty) are from a report written by Ted Gunderson which was in an email forwarded to apfn.org in June 2000 by Ellen Lacter. The email can be found by scrolling down this page:

http://www.apfn.org/APFN/RING.HTM

Here is Gunderson's description of the report:

The enclosed report describes in detail:

1. Urgent recent developments in the Franklin satanic cult/sex/drug ring
case, involving a key witness, Russell Nelson, whose life may now be in
danger.

2. Franklin connections to new evidence of corruption linking the FBI,
CIA, some top political figures, missing children, including kidnap
victim Johnny Gosch, CIA MK-Ultra Mind Control, and Iran-Contra.

3. Two June, 2000, arrests of possible CIA American terrorists in Mexico.

4. Notice of the suspicious "suicide" of John Millis, Staff Director of
the House Intelligence Committee, which has received inexplicably little
media attention.


and the synopsis:

Russell (Rusty) Nelson: Russell Nelson, central figure in the Franklin
Credit Union scandal (1989 to present), has evidence, including
photographs, that implicates prominent law enforcement and political
figures, including two past U.S. presidents, in crimes of child abuse,
pornography, kidnapping (e.g., missing-child Johnny Gosch), drug
smuggling, money laundering, illegal campaign financing, and illegal
activities by the FBI and CIA. There appear to be ties to Iran-Contra.
Since 1989, much of the evidence has been confiscated from Rusty Nelson.
Some of the evidence remains hidden. In May, 2000, Nelson was taken
into custody for a parole violation in Nebraska and is to be extradicted
to Oregon, away from the watchful eyes of his attorney, family, and
friends. Ted Gunderson (this writer and investigator of the Franklin
cover-up) and Nelson's attorney, John De Camp (Author of "The Franklin
Cover-Up") believe Nelson's life is in danger. This report is in an
effort to prevent his being "suicided", or otherwise suspiciously
killed.

Kelly Ford: Kelly Ford is the daughter of Brice Taylor, who has written
two books documenting her victimization by satanic abuse, CIA MK-Ultra
Mind Control, and prominent political figures (Brice Taylor is a pen
name for her legal name, Susan Ford). In court, on June 23, 2000, Brice
Taylor lost her daughter to state conservatorship following her
testimony regarding satanic abuse and MK-Ultra mind control of her
daughter and herself, and political corruption to the highest levels of
our government. Brice Taylor is concerned that while Kelly is under
state conservatorship, her influential abusers will have access to her
and may threaten or harm her to ensure that she does not attest to the
abuses against both herself, her mother, and family.


There is another version of the report on Gunderson's website

http://www.tedgunderson.com/FrontPage News/The Gunderson Report.htm

Note the confimation bias and determination to spin this into a huge conspiracy, taking in ever more unlikely ideas.

 
So I noticed that this page about the incident has a comment facility, so I left a comment saying briefly that the film doesn't really stack up and including a link to this thread. It was deleted, so I posted the link again and asked why the last post had been deleted. This second post was also deleted, but this time I got a reply:

chris @InformationLiberation said:
Maccy: I deleted your post because I did not want it on the site. While I appreciate your sentiment, the content in that thread was, to say the least, insensitive to the victims involved in this case. We cannot support content such as that and we do not wish to link to it. Hopefully you understand.
I posted a new reply:

maccy @InformationLiberation said:
Chris,

Thanks for explaining. I won't post that link here again. Obviously I disagree with you opinion of the thread, but I won't argue the point here. Now that you know where the thread is you're more than welcome to join it and debate the issues with me and the other posters, should you so wish.

I'm going to make a quick post about what has happened here on the same thread so, again, you're welcome to come and discuss your decision.

That's it from me. All the best.

Maccy
Obviously, it's their right to feel this thread is offensive and to delete comments - and I trust that nobody is goign to harrass them by posting more comments on that page.

Nevertheless, I think its worth taking a closer look at http://www.informationliberation.com/

InformationLiberation is here for the expressed purpose of liberating information. Our site should be treated simply as a catalog of information of real significance, which, unfortunately, is predominantly ignored by our mass media for reasons few fully understand. We strongly believe in freedom of thought and freedom of opinion. We are not here to "push" our beliefs onto you. You have a right to believe what ever you want to believe.

That said, obviously InformationLiberation does not necessarily agree with, or endorse, everything on our web page. We often post articles specifically because we disagree with them. Unlike some, we trust and respect our readers ability to discern the truth for themselves without some authority figure telling them what to believe. Fortunately for us all, once presented with the truth, human beings have an innate ability to discern what is and isn't true, and, through reason and self-reflection, can begin to understand exactly how and why they had been deceived.

"All truths are easy to understand once they are discovered; the point is to discover them." - Galileo
http://www.informationliberation.com/?about

So it isn't a question of not trusting their readers to make their minds up, it's a question of "insensitivity". I would suggest that accusing top officials in the Whitehouse of participating in a satanic paedophile ring is pretty insensitive, but there you go...

And, personally, I consider all the stuff about Johnny Gosch to be deeply insensitive and actively manipulative of his relatives. And also, by extension, to the memory of Hunter S Thompson.

http://www.informationliberation.com/index.php?id=15874
http://www.informationliberation.com/index.php?id=16762

Oh, and here's a particularly sensitive account of the JonBenet Ramsey case (title "The Ramsey's Search for a Patsey Contibues")

http://www.informationliberation.com/index.php?id=15257

 
Last edited:
However, if you should find yourself in a horror movie you should always listen to the children. In those cases, their on the ball.

As someone who has kids underfoot most of the day (there is a brief respite when they are in school), I can tell you they will tell the most ball-faced lie if it keeps them from getting in trouble. They will also do it if they want to be praised.

"What happened to the DVD player?!"

"Nelson did it!" "Did not, Steven did it!"

..and so on.
 
I can't help but be reminded of the Brass Eye Paedophile special:

Part one:


Part two:


Part three:


PLEASE NOTE: This programme is a satire on the media and public hysteria surrounding paedophilia and also the willingness of public figures to spout misinformed nonsense if it's in the script they've been given to read. Chris Morris, the man responsible, pushes things as far as he can in terms of taste. Some people may find this distressing or offensive. Although this programme is not in any way pornographic or obscene (it was boradcast on mainstream TV in the UK) it's probably best not to watch it at work.
 
Last edited:
I can't help but be reminded of the Brass Paedophile special:

Part one:


Part two:


Part three:


PLEASE NOTE: This programme is a satire on the media and public hysteria surrounding paedophilia and also the willingness of public figures to spout misinformed nonsense if it's in the script they've been given to read. Chris Morris, the man responsible, pushes things as far as he can in terms of taste. Some people may find this distressing or offensive. Although this programme is not in any way pornographic or obscene (it was boradcast on mainstream TV in the UK) it's probably best not to watch it at work.

LOL@maccy

That was such a great show.

And it really showed up just what twits alot of celebs can be when they are just given a few cue cards to read from.
 

# Create more fear because of the Child Molester 'Out There'.
# Create the illusion that the Child Molester cannot be cured and ostracise them from society.
# Create more violence and murders by inciting people to attack and kill known Child Molesters.
# Create the illusion to Child Molesters that it is okay for them to rape children - because they want to be raped

Damn, that's one efficient conspiracy. Promote both the fear of child molesters, and child molestation itself, all in one go. The mind boggles.
 
The main thing in the video that concerns me is that a 17 year old girl was sentenced to EIGHTEEN years in prison for perjury. The alleged perjury was her saying she had been abused but she never to this day has retracted her claim of abuse.


She was indeed paroled, however when a fellow accuser starting making accusations again, she was hauled back to jail despite it being nothing to do with her.

Again, for completeness, I can't find any reference to Alisha Owen being sent back to prison after her release.
 
Again, for completeness, I can't find any reference to Alisha Owen being sent back to prison after her release.

From the dates he posted originally, I'm pretty sure this being sent "back" to prison was actually her being sent to prison in the first place. She wasn't sent away until after all her appeals were exhausted, which took until about 1996.


ETA: see my post here for relevant quotes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom