Larry Lovage
Thinker
- Joined
- Oct 26, 2006
- Messages
- 220
From Shades's first page post, about the making of the documentary:
Shades has a habit of succumbing to the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. If Alisha Owen endured a longer period in solitary confinement than any other prisoner, it's not really an indication that she's an innocent put-upon. You only get solitary confinement for breaching prison rules, in other words for doing stuff after she had arrived at prison. It may seem to be a horrendous over-reaction to sentence someone to 9 to 20 years for 1st offence perjury (it certainly does to me), that doesn't mean that every piece of apparent mistreatment is all part of the same process.
I've emphasised a different bit. That's one of the very reasons to believe that the Yorkshire TV guys were getting carried away. Stories like this have a habit of snowballing, but the size of the snowball never has anything to do with the veracity of the original. When late on in the investigation, everywhere they look seems to be providing confirmatory evidence indicates to me that they're suffering from the confirmation bias that is all too familiar to this kind of investigation.In mid-1993, after The Franklin Cover-Up had been circulating for almost a year, the British-based TV station, Yorkshire Television, sent a top-notch team to Nebraska to launch its own investigation of the Franklin case. Yorkshire had a contract with the Discovery Channel to produce a documentary on the case for American television.
They spent many months in Nebraska, and also travelled this country from one end to the other, interviewing, filming, and documenting piece-by-piece the Franklin story as I had told it in the book. They spent somewhere between a quarter-million and one-half million dollars investigating the story, deploying probably a thousand times the resources and abilities that I personally had.
Over the year that I worked with them, I was amazed at the team’s ability to gather new documents and witnesses which kept opening up new and frightening facts about Franklin. They were a crack team. In the final weeks that they were in Nebraska,they expressed their certainty that they would win awards for this documented horror story of government-sanctioned abuse of children; and government protection of some of this country’s most powerful businessmen and politicians, who had been the chief acts in the Franklin story.
Shades has a habit of succumbing to the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. If Alisha Owen endured a longer period in solitary confinement than any other prisoner, it's not really an indication that she's an innocent put-upon. You only get solitary confinement for breaching prison rules, in other words for doing stuff after she had arrived at prison. It may seem to be a horrendous over-reaction to sentence someone to 9 to 20 years for 1st offence perjury (it certainly does to me), that doesn't mean that every piece of apparent mistreatment is all part of the same process.