Conspiracy of Silence

Instead of discounting it read the book.

The journal is legit, it was analysed by forensic types. I know these facts are inconvenient but they are facts nonetheless.

If it's legit, why hasn't DeCamp built a criminal case from it?

Why hasn't he won a single case that involved examining the evidence?
 
So without any real motive, a huge number of people, including King's cousin, got together and concocted a story for no apparent reason against a man they had never met, whose friends were jailed for running a gay prostitute ring.

Do you know how ridiculous that sounds? Its a conspiracy theory that is laughable
 
So without any real motive, a huge number of people, including King's cousin, got together and concocted a story for no apparent reason against a man they had never met, whose friends were jailed for running a gay prostitute ring.

Do you know how ridiculous that sounds? Its a conspiracy theory that is laughable

Strawman fallacy.
 
Instead of discounting it read the book.
Sorry, not going to waste my time on the video or the book. I read the Grand Jury reports. That works for me. If there's new evidence that would justify a prosecution, they should present to the DA. If that doesn't work and they're still convinced that they have something damning, they should bring it to a reputable news outlet. Who wouldn't want that story?

Until then, this is just another bogus 1980s tale of satanic ritual child abuse. I don't know how old you are, but these were a dime a dozen from 1985-90. There was the similar Tawana Brawley hoax in New York in 1987. It's all very sad. Get over it. Next.
 
So without any real motive, a huge number of people, including King's cousin, got together and concocted a story for no apparent reason against a man they had never met, whose friends were jailed for running a gay prostitute ring.
No motive? You obviously haven't read the Grand Jury reports. Please do.
 
It's not a fallacy. You are suggesting a huge conspiracy with no motive comprised of people that didnt even know each other.

Yes. It is.

Straw man

This fallacy takes its name from the image of someone stuffing some clothes with straw and then beating seven bells out of the resultant opponent, supposing thereby that they have somehow won a fight. The fallacy occurs when an argument is countered by taking a weaker form of it and showing where it fails, assuming that this means the original argument has also been defeated.

Take an example:

You say we should invest more in public health services, but taking everyone's money off them and deciding what they should spend it on for them is nothing less than totalitarianism.
We could render this as a syllogism as follows:

P1: Investing more in public services is equivalent to taking everyone's money and deciding how it should be spent for them;
P2: This is equivalent to totalitarianism;
P3: Totalitarianism has been refuted previously;
C: Therefore, the idea of investing more in public services is refuted.
Even if we accept P2 and P3, which we needn't, the important point is that P1 is false and does not accurately describe what was originally claimed. By making two different ideas equivalent the argument becomes easier to address but, since the refutation deals with one idea and the argument with another, nothing is actually accomplished. The argument is mischaracterized or misrepresented in order to make it easier to tackle, but by doing so it isn't tackled at all.

Another example could be this:

You advocate the death penalty but I doubt that anyone will accept televised hanging of people on meat hooks.
Here the idea of what the death penalty involves is mischaracterized (we would hope) by supposing that anyone advocating it is actually asking that people be publicly hung on meat hooks. Since (again, we would hope) this measure would not be accepted, the argument is considered defeated. A simplistic and deliberately repugnant version of the death penalty is used to discredit the idea when the person suggesting it probably said nothing of the sort; as a result, the refutation is unsuccessful.

This fallacy is unfortunately very common and some politicians tend to be adept at its use. It can be used in humour but perhaps the most important lesson to learn from it is not to unwittingly or otherwise make straw men of other people's ideas ourselves.
source
 
Sorry, not going to waste my time on the video or the book. I read the Grand Jury reports. That works for me. If there's new evidence that would justify a prosecution, they should present to the DA. If that doesn't work and they're still convinced that they have something damning, they should bring it to a reputable news outlet. Who wouldn't want that story?

Until then, this is just another bogus 1980s tale of satanic ritual child abuse. I don't know how old you are, but these were a dime a dozen from 1985-90. There was the similar Tawana Brawley hoax in New York in 1987. It's all very sad. Get over it. Next.

Don't forget the Mark DeTroix affair in Belgium, where some kids were kept in basements for powerful people to pop in and rape occasionnally.
 
Belgium was rocked during 1996 by a child-sex scandal that raised fundamental questions about the country's police, judicial, and political systems. Marc Dutroux, who had been released on parole in 1992 after serving just 3 years of a 13-year prison sentence for the abduction and rape of under-age girls, was arrested in mid-August--more than a year after two eight-year-old girls were kidnapped near Liège. In the following weeks, the bodies of both as well as those of two girls aged 17 and 19 were discovered on property owned by Dutroux. Two other girls Dutroux had admitted kidnapping--one 14 and the other 12--were found alive by police.
Investigations into the Dutroux case, which revealed incompetence, rivalry, and patronage on the part of the authorities, gave renewed energy to the stalled five-year inquiry into the murder in Liège in 1991 of André Cools, former deputy prime minister and leader of the French-speaking Socialist Party (PS). The latter led to a new wave of arrests, including those of three suspects who had been questioned and then freed in 1993. Among those charged was former PS regional and federal minister Alain Van der Biest.
The two investigations revealed rivalry between local and national police forces and between differing legal courts and jurisdictions. The degree of public concern prompted King Albert II to make a rare departure from royal protocol in early September and demand a full investigation into the Dutroux case. He made it clear that he also expected the fullest possible light to be shed on the search for the killer of Cools. The outcry over the girls' abduction and murder prompted immediate calls in autumn for the return of the death penalty, which Belgium had formally abolished just weeks earlier.

Large organised powerful pedophile rings exist in governments.
 
[definition of satanic/ritual abuse]
http://www.apologeticsindex.org/s05.html
Well, we've shown how all your other sources are bogus, but no one's mentioned this one yet. Do you know what the word "apologetics" means, and if so, do you know anything about the people who are regulars here at the JREF Forum? If so, you'd know that carries no weight. We asked what you meant by "satanic" child abuse, and you have failed to provide any evidence that it has even ever existed.
 
Well, we've shown how all your other sources are bogus, but no one's mentioned this one yet. Do you know what the word "apologetics" means, and if so, do you know anything about the people who are regulars here at the JREF Forum? If so, you'd know that carries no weight. We asked what you meant by "satanic" child abuse, and you have failed to provide any evidence that it has even ever existed.

A better place to start for some context:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satanic_abuse
 
Heres an example of wikipedia:

In 2003, nineteen year-old Sabine Dardenne gave her first interview to the press. She stated that, based on her observations during her 79-day-long captivity, she thought that Dutroux acted alone.

Dutroux was tried for the murder of An Marchal, Eefje Lambrecks and Bernard Weinstein, a suspected accomplice.
 
Transcript of the 1999 Bonacci vs King civil hearing:

http://www.whale.to/b/aq3.html

Edited to add:

From the transcript:

MR. DECAMP: May it please the Court, a very, very brief opening statement. What I want to establish here today, Your Honor, if at all possible, is the entire picture or scene in which Mr. Bonacci lived and prove to this Court's satisfaction the stories he tells in his petition are in fact true and the trauma that results from those stories is in fact very real. And even, Your Honor, we would hope that the Court, after hearing some of the evidence and information today for the first time ever, would maybe even on its own initiative take some appropriate action to correct some other wrongs or launch some other investigations that may be needed, Your Honor.

THE COURT: That's not within my authority. So I can't do that. But I can award damages. And that's why we're here today.

bolding mine

So the awarding of damages by default in this case proves nothing and is meaningless in criminal terms.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom