John Freestone
Graduate Poster
Oh, go on then...something other than grammar...
I'm intruiged by RandFan and The Man's semantic battle over - as I see it - first existence, then the conscious apprehension of existence, then the meaning of events, then the apprehension of meaning, even the 'meaning' of 'meaning' (one of my favourite subjects!)...and I'm reminded that someone predicted at the beginning an infinite regression appearing somewhere. I kind of see both arguments regarding whether 'meaning' has any 'meaning' without consciousness or not, but they're utterly dependent, to my mind, simply on semantics, i.e. meaning, i.e. however the terms are defined. The Man seems to be able to equate meaning of events with their happening whether observed or not, by apparently associating 'meaning' very closely with 'cause and effect'. That's reasonable if that's how you see it. RandFan - or was it the other way round, forgive me if so - sees 'meaning' as an effect or property of consciousness. Is that right? I have to say that I define 'meaning' in that sense myself, so I'm with RandFan on that.
However, RandFan, I'm rather baffled by your other argument, that there is no difference between existence and non-existence without consciousness. I accept, of course, that in order to describe or perceive any difference, there has to be an observer or describer, and therefore that 'I' exists in order to make that distinction, but it also seems that (even using my current state of consciousness to do so) I can imagine a state of the universe in which things happen and things exist, and that in other places things don't happen that way, or things don't exist there - the earlier universe people have been talking about before the emergence of consciousness. I can only make sense of your argument so far in these two ways: that because I had to use consciousness to imagine that scenario, the earlier supposed existence of anything can't be thought or proven (i.e. to think or prove is an act of consciousness), or by saying that any 'meaning' or indeed 'existence' of anything depends on it having ulimately producing conscious beings. I can't find either explanation at all convincing compared with the customary one: there existed a universe, and then consciousness developed in it.
Well, I'll have a bit more of a read, but I'm not hoping too much after reading this: "The Mathematician is part of the world of phenomena, where thoughts are influenced by the thinkers from whom they emanate."
True, true...
I'm intruiged by RandFan and The Man's semantic battle over - as I see it - first existence, then the conscious apprehension of existence, then the meaning of events, then the apprehension of meaning, even the 'meaning' of 'meaning' (one of my favourite subjects!)...and I'm reminded that someone predicted at the beginning an infinite regression appearing somewhere. I kind of see both arguments regarding whether 'meaning' has any 'meaning' without consciousness or not, but they're utterly dependent, to my mind, simply on semantics, i.e. meaning, i.e. however the terms are defined. The Man seems to be able to equate meaning of events with their happening whether observed or not, by apparently associating 'meaning' very closely with 'cause and effect'. That's reasonable if that's how you see it. RandFan - or was it the other way round, forgive me if so - sees 'meaning' as an effect or property of consciousness. Is that right? I have to say that I define 'meaning' in that sense myself, so I'm with RandFan on that.
However, RandFan, I'm rather baffled by your other argument, that there is no difference between existence and non-existence without consciousness. I accept, of course, that in order to describe or perceive any difference, there has to be an observer or describer, and therefore that 'I' exists in order to make that distinction, but it also seems that (even using my current state of consciousness to do so) I can imagine a state of the universe in which things happen and things exist, and that in other places things don't happen that way, or things don't exist there - the earlier universe people have been talking about before the emergence of consciousness. I can only make sense of your argument so far in these two ways: that because I had to use consciousness to imagine that scenario, the earlier supposed existence of anything can't be thought or proven (i.e. to think or prove is an act of consciousness), or by saying that any 'meaning' or indeed 'existence' of anything depends on it having ulimately producing conscious beings. I can't find either explanation at all convincing compared with the customary one: there existed a universe, and then consciousness developed in it.
That's a pretty picture. Does it signify anything? I tend to suspect not. Organic Natural Number 5?By self-reference I am talking about the ability reinforce the interaction between the external and internal environments of some complex phenomenon, that has the ability to replicate itself in non-trivial ways.
Please look at my preliminary model http://www.geocities.com/complementarytheory/MonadCK.pdf , which demonstrates the relationss between Cybernetic Efficiency, distinction, and consciousness.
That all seems quite self-denying - one minute everything exists relative to my consciousness, the next I'm here because I was 'designed' by the forces of the universe. Nonsense.FOR EXISTENCE YOU MUST HAVE CONSCIOUSNESS.
This is the real theory of relativity. The heck with every motion being relative to the speed of light.
Everything is relative to consciousness. We cannot escape from this annoying reality. As Randfan brilliantly put it.....without consciousness, something and nothing become the same.
And the really good part is that everythng is relative to you. Yes you. You are the most important thing in your universe. Everything is seen through your eyes. Your thoughts are designed for you, depending on things of which you have no control....like your genetics. Your ability to reason is dependent upon your genetics, and if you can't reason well, you'd be the last to know it. Like you thinkers who try and argue the simple notion that existence is completely dependent on consciousness.
You are conscious, but you have no answer as to why. You think, in your delusion, completely free and independent. Yet in reality, you are a prisoner of your brain, something designed without your slightest input. You are not free. You were designed by the physical forces of the universe, you had no say in anything.
Everything is relative to your consciousness, the entire universe literally begins at your earliest recognition and ends with your last. Everything else you know, you know only when you are conscious.
You see, its all so relative.
About Non-locality and Locality please look at http://www.geocities.com/complementarytheory/OM.pdf
Well, I'll have a bit more of a read, but I'm not hoping too much after reading this: "The Mathematician is part of the world of phenomena, where thoughts are influenced by the thinkers from whom they emanate."
True, true...