Consciousness.....a basic rule of physics

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, go on then...something other than grammar...

I'm intruiged by RandFan and The Man's semantic battle over - as I see it - first existence, then the conscious apprehension of existence, then the meaning of events, then the apprehension of meaning, even the 'meaning' of 'meaning' (one of my favourite subjects!)...and I'm reminded that someone predicted at the beginning an infinite regression appearing somewhere. I kind of see both arguments regarding whether 'meaning' has any 'meaning' without consciousness or not, but they're utterly dependent, to my mind, simply on semantics, i.e. meaning, i.e. however the terms are defined. The Man seems to be able to equate meaning of events with their happening whether observed or not, by apparently associating 'meaning' very closely with 'cause and effect'. That's reasonable if that's how you see it. RandFan - or was it the other way round, forgive me if so - sees 'meaning' as an effect or property of consciousness. Is that right? I have to say that I define 'meaning' in that sense myself, so I'm with RandFan on that.

However, RandFan, I'm rather baffled by your other argument, that there is no difference between existence and non-existence without consciousness. I accept, of course, that in order to describe or perceive any difference, there has to be an observer or describer, and therefore that 'I' exists in order to make that distinction, but it also seems that (even using my current state of consciousness to do so) I can imagine a state of the universe in which things happen and things exist, and that in other places things don't happen that way, or things don't exist there - the earlier universe people have been talking about before the emergence of consciousness. I can only make sense of your argument so far in these two ways: that because I had to use consciousness to imagine that scenario, the earlier supposed existence of anything can't be thought or proven (i.e. to think or prove is an act of consciousness), or by saying that any 'meaning' or indeed 'existence' of anything depends on it having ulimately producing conscious beings. I can't find either explanation at all convincing compared with the customary one: there existed a universe, and then consciousness developed in it.

By self-reference I am talking about the ability reinforce the interaction between the external and internal environments of some complex phenomenon, that has the ability to replicate itself in non-trivial ways.

Please look at my preliminary model http://www.geocities.com/complementarytheory/MonadCK.pdf , which demonstrates the relationss between Cybernetic Efficiency, distinction, and consciousness.
That's a pretty picture. Does it signify anything? I tend to suspect not. Organic Natural Number 5?

FOR EXISTENCE YOU MUST HAVE CONSCIOUSNESS.

This is the real theory of relativity. The heck with every motion being relative to the speed of light.

Everything is relative to consciousness. We cannot escape from this annoying reality. As Randfan brilliantly put it.....without consciousness, something and nothing become the same.

And the really good part is that everythng is relative to you. Yes you. You are the most important thing in your universe. Everything is seen through your eyes. Your thoughts are designed for you, depending on things of which you have no control....like your genetics. Your ability to reason is dependent upon your genetics, and if you can't reason well, you'd be the last to know it. Like you thinkers who try and argue the simple notion that existence is completely dependent on consciousness.

You are conscious, but you have no answer as to why. You think, in your delusion, completely free and independent. Yet in reality, you are a prisoner of your brain, something designed without your slightest input. You are not free. You were designed by the physical forces of the universe, you had no say in anything.

Everything is relative to your consciousness, the entire universe literally begins at your earliest recognition and ends with your last. Everything else you know, you know only when you are conscious.

You see, its all so relative.
That all seems quite self-denying - one minute everything exists relative to my consciousness, the next I'm here because I was 'designed' by the forces of the universe. Nonsense.

About Non-locality and Locality please look at http://www.geocities.com/complementarytheory/OM.pdf

Well, I'll have a bit more of a read, but I'm not hoping too much after reading this: "The Mathematician is part of the world of phenomena, where thoughts are influenced by the thinkers from whom they emanate."

True, true...
 
Color is just a perception, the firing of perhaps certain neurons in ones visual cortex. Such perception does not require light. I can visualize the color of my car and I dream in color (just as I sometimes perceive myself to be conscious while dreaming), hallucinations or hallucinogenic chemicals (so I’ve been told) can also stimulate the perception of color without light.
Valid points. Not meaning to move goal posts but this is the biggest flaw in your argument in that we can't even prove that the material world exists in the first place. If we can experience everything without materialism then there might not even be a material world. But I'm happy to stick with my argument.

Let's stick with the material world. Yes. There is no color without perception but there is no electro magnetic waves that will cause us to perceive color without light.

And of course, this brings us back around to my claim and you are making my argument for me. Color is only a perception. By your own argument, without perception (consciousness) there is no color.

You keep repeating that but have yet to provide any supporting examples...
You don't have any? Really? Come on dude. That's just being willfully obtuse.


Cogito ergo sum. We can argue the "I" and that is fine but we can't argue whether there is some thinking going on.
  • You are conscious.
  • Because you are conscious you are capable of perceiving meaning.
  • Sans any conscious being there is no meaning.
 
Last edited:
However, RandFan, I'm rather baffled by your other argument, that there is no difference between existence and non-existence without consciousness. I accept, of course, that in order to describe or perceive any difference, there has to be an observer or describer, and therefore that 'I' exists in order to make that distinction, but it also seems that (even using my current state of consciousness to do so) I can imagine a state of the universe in which things happen and things exist, and that in other places things don't happen that way, or things don't exist there - the earlier universe people have been talking about before the emergence of consciousness. I can only make sense of your argument so far in these two ways: that because I had to use consciousness to imagine that scenario, the earlier supposed existence of anything can't be thought or proven (i.e. to think or prove is an act of consciousness), or by saying that any 'meaning' or indeed 'existence' of anything depends on it having ulimately producing conscious beings. I can't find either explanation at all convincing compared with the customary one: there existed a universe, and then consciousness developed in it.
(emphasis mine) Excellent post. I said early on it is largely a POV.

What is "difference"? Isn't that an observed quantity? Differences can only be stated on the basis of a comparison or categorization. Right?

If we assume that there is nothing to perform the comparing and/or categorizing then please to tell me what difference there is? It always comes back to the fact that you have to imagine the difference. No imagination? No difference.
 
Last edited:
(emphasis mine) Excellent post. I said early on it is largely a POV.

What is "difference"? Isn't that an observed quantity? Differences can only be stated on the basis of a comparison or categorization. Right?

If we assume that there is nothing to perform the comparing and/or categorizing then please to tell me what difference there is? It always comes back to the fact that you have to imagine the difference. No imagination? No difference.


If by difference you mean a value judgement, then I agree. If you simply mean differentiating, I disagree. Tricky's favorite example of sedimentary self-sorting in streams comes to mind.
 
Oh, go on then...something other than grammar...

I'm intruiged by RandFan and The Man's semantic battle over - as I see it - first existence, then the conscious apprehension of existence, then the meaning of events, then the apprehension of meaning, even the 'meaning' of 'meaning' (one of my favourite subjects!)...and I'm reminded that someone predicted at the beginning an infinite regression appearing somewhere. I kind of see both arguments regarding whether 'meaning' has any 'meaning' without consciousness or not, but they're utterly dependent, to my mind, simply on semantics, i.e. meaning, i.e. however the terms are defined. The Man seems to be able to equate meaning of events with their happening whether observed or not, by apparently associating 'meaning' very closely with 'cause and effect'. That's reasonable if that's how you see it. RandFan - or was it the other way round, forgive me if so - sees 'meaning' as an effect or property of consciousness. Is that right? I have to say that I define 'meaning' in that sense myself, so I'm with RandFan on that.

However, RandFan, I'm rather baffled by your other argument, that there is no difference between existence and non-existence without consciousness. I accept, of course, that in order to describe or perceive any difference, there has to be an observer or describer, and therefore that 'I' exists in order to make that distinction, but it also seems that (even using my current state of consciousness to do so) I can imagine a state of the universe in which things happen and things exist, and that in other places things don't happen that way, or things don't exist there - the earlier universe people have been talking about before the emergence of consciousness. I can only make sense of your argument so far in these two ways: that because I had to use consciousness to imagine that scenario, the earlier supposed existence of anything can't be thought or proven (i.e. to think or prove is an act of consciousness), or by saying that any 'meaning' or indeed 'existence' of anything depends on it having ulimately producing conscious beings. I can't find either explanation at all convincing compared with the customary one: there existed a universe, and then consciousness developed in it.

A fine synapses of the discussion, John Freestone, without detracting from the ‘meaning’ of that discussion, and RandFan’s augment that baffled you was what began our discussion. Which is all I was essentially arguing but I just followed were the semantics of the discussion went. I do notice that in spite of your ascription to the ‘meaning’ of ‘meaning’ as professed by RandFan, you use precisely the argument I was using, in both cases, equating existence with “things happen”, even without consciousness, something RandFan did not assert directly yet still implied with his affirmation of cause and effect without consciousness. The primary difference is I never asserted my position as the correct or only one and even asserted that the two positions on the ‘meaning’ of ‘meaning’ were not necessarily mutually exclusive, but just as an arguable position on something RandFan continually asserted as inarguable.


If one asserts that the ‘meaning’ of ‘meaning’ is not “utterly dependent, to my mind, simply on semantics, i.e. meaning, i.e.” then one must be confused about the meaning of semantics or mean something other then the ‘meaning’ of ‘meaning’.
 
Valid points. Not meaning to move goal posts but this is the biggest flaw in your argument in that we can't even prove that the material world exists in the first place. If we can experience everything without materialism then there might not even be a material world. But I'm happy to stick with my argument.

Ah but that is not a flaw in the argument, but essential to the argument. Were the material world provable one way or the other then there would be little to argue about.

Let's stick with the material world. Yes. There is no color without perception but there is no electro magnetic waves that will cause us to perceive color without light.

And of course, this brings us back around to my claim and you are making my argument for me. Color is only a perception. By your own argument, without perception (consciousness) there is no color.

You don't have any? Really? Come on dude. That's just being willfully obtuse.

Ok first you want to “stick with the material world” then you argue that I am making your argument for you because “Color is only a perception”. Talk about moving the goalpost. Perception and the material world, these are the aspects of color. If you do not know where the goal post actually are (usually on both sides of the field) then you should not attempt a field goal.



Cogito ergo sum. We can argue the "I" and that is fine but we can't argue whether there is some thinking going on.
  • You are conscious.
  • Because you are conscious you are capable of perceiving meaning.
  • Sans any conscious being there is no meaning.


Nope, there is just no perception of meaning.
 
(emphasis mine) Excellent post. I said early on it is largely a POV.

What is "difference"? Isn't that an observed quantity? Differences can only be stated on the basis of a comparison or categorization. Right?

If we assume that there is nothing to perform the comparing and/or categorizing then please to tell me what difference there is? It always comes back to the fact that you have to imagine the difference. No imagination? No difference.

Not necessarily difference is exemplified in cause and effect. When forces are opposing and equal the effect tends to be compression (and no net force). When not equal or there is a “difference” between opposing forces then a net force is the result, in some cases cause and effect can be the non-conscious expression of difference.
 
Last edited:
Ah but that is not a flaw in the argument, but essential to the argument. Were the material world provable one way or the other then there would be little to argue about.
Stating that it is essential to the argument is just gainsaying. You are not advancing anything here.

Ok first you want to “stick with the material world” then you argue that I am making your argument for you because “Color is only a perception”.
Yes, and that is consistent with an acceptance of a material world. No moving of goal posts. According to you, without perception of color there is only electromagnetic radiation. No color.

Talk about moving the goalpost. Perception and the material world, these are the aspects of color. If you do not know where the goal post actually are (usually on both sides of the field) then you should not attempt a field goal.
This is just rhetoric. It's a waste of your time.

Nope, there is just no perception of meaning.
This is nonsense. Please to show me "meaning" without perception? You just state these things and they are utter nonsense. Where is "meaning" in the natural world sans consciousness? Outside of the context of consciousness the word has no meaning.
 
Last edited:
Not necessarily difference is exemplified in cause and effect. When forces are opposing and equal the effect tends to be compression (and no net force). When not equal or there is a “difference” between opposing forces then a net force is the result, in some cases cause and effect can be the non-conscious expression of difference.
And how is that quantified? I have no idea what a "non-conscious expression" is. I seriously doubt such a thing exists but even I accept such a proposition of what value is it without something to perceive the expression? On the other hand, I suspect we are arguing past each other.
 
Last edited:
(emphasis mine) Excellent post. I said early on it is largely a POV.

What is "difference"? Isn't that an observed quantity? Differences can only be stated on the basis of a comparison or categorization. Right?

If we assume that there is nothing to perform the comparing and/or categorizing then please to tell me what difference there is? It always comes back to the fact that you have to imagine the difference. No imagination? No difference.
I think I have to say that this is a fairly reasonable point of view philosophically. It is possible that nothing exists except as projected by a consciousness, or that there can be no judgement of a difference between existence and non-existence without consciousness. I just don't think it's a particularly strong POV. It's like saying that life might all be one big dream. We could make a list of possible ontologies, surely, and assert that disproving them will be impossible: aliens are keeping us in their personal zoo, etc.

It seems a weak argument to me. I can imagine existence and non-existence as independent of my consciousness. I can hardly imagine otherwise.

I wonder if this is your actual belief that you're arguing, since you remind us that it's 'largely' a POV. It reminds me of a time when I wanted to discuss a similar idea, that consciousness might be fundamental to the universe, and many members took that hypothetical suggestion as my religious position and gave me a hard time about it. I think it's important - especially for sceptics - to be able to discuss ideas with the minimum of investment and defensiveness.

The question of colour also seems another semantic argument. To put it another way, I don't think it's really clear whether 'colour' exists or arises due to the physical characteristics of a surface, the presence of light or the processes in a brain - we use the name and classify colours as a product of all of these. And asking, therefore, whether something is still red when there's no light is, to my mind, a matter of opnion and prefered definition, as is the question of whether a tree falling in a forest makes sound when no-one's there. In a similar vein, we can infer from experience that pressure waves exist when we're absent, just as we can infer that the universe existed before we woke up this morning.
 
Stating that it is essential to the argument is just gainsaying. You are not advancing anything here.

No, just keeping it from going backwards.


Yes, and that is consistent with an acceptance of a material world. No moving of goal posts. Without perception of color there is only electromagnetic radiation. No color.

So is our perception of color without light as in a hallucination or dream, just the firing of certain neurons.

So what is it that we perceive as color from “a material world”? It is not just electromagnetic radiation but specific characteristics of that radiation (wavelength) also the characteristics of the source or reflection of that radiation. Chemical interactions and electron energy states can depend on those characteristics even given our lack of perception.

This is just rhetoric. It's a waste of your time.

Not at all, you are using as your augment aspects that you have not fully considered. Since we can have the perception of color without light, your assertion now has become that without perception there is no color, which is as equally invalid as your assertion of no light no color.


This nonsense. Please to show me "meaning" without perception? You just state these things and they are utter nonsense. Where is "meaning" in the natural world sans consciousness? Outside of the context of consciousness the word has no meaning.

You seem to revel in repeating yourself and perhaps trying to get others to do so as well. Just as color (the representation of wavelength) has meaning without our perception of ‘color’ other words can and do represent things that are not themselves entirely dependent on our perception of them, although the words might be.
 
And how is that quantified? I have no idea what a "non-conscious expression" is. I seriously doubt such a thing exists but even I accept such a proposition of what value is it without something to perceive the expression?.

Well thanks for the edit, as it makes the reply easier. Expression was a poor choice of words on my part. Quantification, would have been a better word, which is just ‘value’ specifically the ‘value’ of the net force.

On the other hand, I suspect we are arguing past each other?.

So it would seem, I think it breaks down to this: you assert that without consciousness there is no ‘meaning’ while I assert that without ‘meaning’ “sans consciousness” you would not have what you perceive as consciousness. Both assertions fit within the current definitions of ‘meaning’.
 
I think I have to say that this is a fairly reasonable point of view philosophically. It is possible that nothing exists except as projected by a consciousness, or that there can be no judgement of a difference between existence and non-existence without consciousness. I just don't think it's a particularly strong POV.
God forbid we are every disallowed an opinion.:) I respect what you think but I don't have any basis to agree.

It's like saying that life might all be one big dream. We could make a list of possible ontologies, surely, and assert that disproving them will be impossible: aliens are keeping us in their personal zoo, etc.
No. I don't think it's like that at all. I'm only saying that without consciousness there is nothing perceived and nothing quantifying or comparing. Therefore there is no perceived difference.

I wonder if this is your actual belief that you're arguing, since you remind us that it's 'largely' a POV. It reminds me of a time when I wanted to discuss a similar idea, that consciousness might be fundamental to the universe, and many members took that hypothetical suggestion as my religious position and gave me a hard time about it. I think it's important - especially for sceptics - to be able to discuss ideas with the minimum of investment and defensiveness.
Without referencing my actual POV. I agree with you completely. That said, it might just be a POV but bear in mind that only those capable of POV can have one. Tautological I know but I don't know how best to express it.

The question of colour also seems another semantic argument. To put it another way, I don't think it's really clear whether 'colour' exists or arises due to the physical characteristics of a surface, the presence of light or the processes in a brain - we use the name and classify colours as a product of all of these. And asking, therefore, whether something is still red when there's no light is, to my mind, a matter of opnion and prefered definition, as is the question of whether a tree falling in a forest makes sound when no-one's there. In a similar vein, we can infer from experience that pressure waves exist when we're absent, just as we can infer that the universe existed before we woke up this morning.
I don't find your argument compelling. If we accept that electromagnetic radiation exists a priori, and I do, that doesn't mean that color exists a priori. Yes, pressure wave exist and have cause and effect relationships with the environment but sound is a perception.

That said, I really appreciate the tone of your posts. These debates have raged long before we stumbled into them and will continue long after. I think they are important regardless of one's POV.
 
Last edited:
Well thanks for the edit, as it makes the reply easier. Expression was a poor choice of words on my part. Quantification, would have been a better word, which is just ‘value’ specifically the ‘value’ of the net force.

So it would seem, I think it breaks down to this: you assert that without consciousness there is no ‘meaning’ while I assert that without ‘meaning’ “sans consciousness” you would not have what you perceive as consciousness. Both assertions fit within the current definitions of ‘meaning’.
Fair enough. I'm willing to move on.

Thank you.
 
<Snip>

The question of colour also seems another semantic argument. To put it another way, I don't think it's really clear whether 'colour' exists or arises due to the physical characteristics of a surface, the presence of light or the processes in a brain - we use the name and classify colours as a product of all of these. And asking, therefore, whether something is still red when there's no light is, to my mind, a matter of opnion and prefered definition, as is the question of whether a tree falling in a forest makes sound when no-one's there. In a similar vein, we can infer from experience that pressure waves exist when we're absent, just as we can infer that the universe existed before we woke up this morning.

That is the real rub of it, John, “we can infer that the universe existed before we woke up this morning” or infer that it simply came into existence for us just as we woke up this morning in such a way that “we can infer that the universe existed before we woke up this morning”. The requirement of the consistency of the latter to the former makes the former the only relevant inference and the additional inference of the latter superfluous.
 
You've introduced that "paper" in the "Deeper than primes" thread so why bring it up here? Why don't you answer the questions raised in that thread?

And the "non-locality" theme, you've brought that up numerous times in nearly every thread you started, and you've never been able to clarify it.

Hint: don't download the "paper", don't try to read it, it's a load of nonsense.

Dancing David,

I believe that you can decide what you wish or not wish to read, without any advice from me or any other person.

If you wish to communicate with me, my suggestion is to read http://www.geocities.com/complementarytheory/OM.pdf .
 
About Non-locality and Locality please look at http://www.geocities.com/complementarytheory/OM.pdf


So you can't say it here in common language. That is suprising. It took me about 500 words to cover the big band event.

So you don't know what you think, eh, Doron?

I know what non-locality means in conventional language, you haven't an ability to discuss consciousness, do you? I will try not to bait you.
 
Dancing David,

I believe that you can decide what you wish or not wish to read, without any advice from me or any other person.

If you wish to communicate with me, my suggestion is to read http://www.geocities.com/complementarytheory/OM.pdf .

I read enough to know, you don't read any biology, neurology or psychology. I see that I am correct in my assumption that you are using a private idiomatic expression of language. You haven't a single part in the first five pages of that paper that even mentions abrain, and plenty of thinsg without evidence.

Again, I will try not bait you. Try to express your central premise about non-locality and consciousness in five paragraphs of fifty words.

And then try to read some neuropsychology.
 
So... nothing exists except elementary particles ?

I would say that some terms have greater pragmatic meaning than others, If you have a good pragmatic defintion of consciousness, I will probably agree to it. And yes, in a very basic sense all that exists is the universe. Some arrangements of thoughts have valid ability to describe and predict the behavior of the universe. others less so.
 
Oh, i was hoping for better than that.

Why, lol.

Um, that is like saying that the car engine 'is all the processes in a car when it is not turned off', you were saying it was a useful term.

Levels of consciousness/awareness or levels of arousal is a different subject from what people generaly refer to as 'consciousness'. And in fact i went through something recently where I was given a benzodiazeoine, apparently I was able to respond to requests, but have only vague dream like memories of the time.

So part of what is consciousness, the ability to [process and respond to verbal requests was present but another part of consciousness, the ability to form memories, was not.

Which is precisely why I agree that "consciousness" is useless below a certain level. Certainly in the context of trying to reproduce consciousness in a machine, or understand the mechanisms (or even the content) of our own, it holds little value.

But at a higher level, it is that very imprecision or vagueness that makes it so useful in common discussion.

So when I define it like that, I am saying two things:

First, if you wish to reduce consciousness to its components in any useful way, you have to start with exactly "what is going on in the brain of you and I" -- and nothing more. I have always said that if one simply defines the components of their thoughts, so that they are forced to describe just what is there, then things like the HPC evaporate entirely.

Second, it is not useful to say things like "dogs are conscious, but fish are not." I find that to be incredibly arbitrary due to the fact that "consciousness" is so vague a term. However, it is useful to say "she was unconscious after being hit by a rock, but she has regained consciousness." Typically we don't say "her brain has regained most normal functioning, and she is able to communicate with other humans to some extent once more."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom