Merged Concerns over baby killer ignored? / Nurse Lucy Letby killed babies in her care

ISTM the difference between Dr Dewi Evans and Dr Sandie Bohin, and Dr Shoo Lee's panel, is that whilst they were asked to review a large number of babies' medical notes by Chester Police (and Evans was referred via the National Crime Agency - he did not choose himself, as is claimed)
Dr Shoo Lee has instructed his 'panel of experts' to find an alternative cause of death. That is known as 'witness shopping' and advocacy.
Did he actually instruct them to find "an alternative cause of death"?

If so, then yes, that would be bad.

But do you have any source for this?
 
Did he actually instruct them to find "an alternative cause of death"?

If so, then yes, that would be bad.

But do you have any source for this?


I provided a direct quote from Dr Shoo Lee earlier on in the thread. This comes directly from his opening statements at the press conference. From the horse's mouth, so to speak.

Herewith, again.

1739112212503.png
 
Last edited:
That doesn't say that he instructed his panel to find an alternative cause of death.


They would hardly be present at McDonald's presser unless they did.

The professor of 'Bioengineering' is best known for his recyling of cars. He's an engineer not a paediatric expert. Unlike the one at the trial.
 
ISTM the difference between Dr Dewi Evans and Dr Sandie Bohin, and Dr Shoo Lee's panel, is that whilst they were asked to review a large number of babies' medical notes by Chester Police (and Evans was referred via the National Crime Agency - he did not choose himself, as is claimed) Dr Shoo Lee has instructed his 'panel of experts' to find an alternative cause of death. That is known as 'witness shopping' and advocacy.
The other difference between them is that Dewi Evans has a long and rather "interesting" history of getting things wrong. It's worth reading the "career" section of his Wikipedia page:

 
They would hardly be present at McDonald's presser unless they did.

The professor of 'Bioengineering' is best known for his recyling of cars. He's an engineer not a paediatric expert. Unlike the one at the trial.
Huh? You just said that Dr Lee "instructed his 'panel of experts' to find an alternative cause of death" and that "I provided a direct quote from Dr Shoo Lee earlier on in the thread. This comes directly from his opening statements at the press conference. From the horse's mouth, so to speak."

Yet when your quoted tweet does not say what you said it did you resort to assumptions and insinuations.

DON'T DO THAT!

If you want to be taken seriously, quote people, or paraphrase them, ACCURATELY.

If you keep doing this kind of thing I may start to distrust your retelling of this case.

Up until now, I have considered you to be pretty well versed in the case so, unlike others, I have not claimed that you are telling fibs or making any crazed leaps of logic.

The only thing that I have faulted you for so far is treating this as some kind of game in which if you don't play by some exacting rules then you lose. For me, some of the problems I had were that you insisted that if certain procedures weren't followed then you (or the defence in this case) just lost the game. You were not the only one who did this. Smartcooky has also been a particularly egregious example of someone who insisted that he was right on the basis of extremely circumstantial or highly ambiguous evidence and apparently bad strategy by the defence.

I am still open to the possibility that Letby is guilty, as I have been the whole time, but more and more it looks as though the prosecution's case is increasingly threadbare and resorting to more and more underhanded tactics.
 
The other difference between them is that Dewi Evans has a long and rather "interesting" history of getting things wrong. It's worth reading the "career" section of his Wikipedia page:



The case has nothing to do with personalities. This is a fundamental fallacy. Letby was not convicted 'because of Dr. Dewi Evans'.
 
Huh? You just said that Dr Lee "instructed his 'panel of experts' to find an alternative cause of death" and that "I provided a direct quote from Dr Shoo Lee earlier on in the thread. This comes directly from his opening statements at the press conference. From the horse's mouth, so to speak."

Yet when your quoted tweet does not say what you said it did you resort to assumptions and insinuations.

DON'T DO THAT!

If you want to be taken seriously, quote people, or paraphrase them, ACCURATELY.

If you keep doing this kind of thing I may start to distrust your retelling of this case.

Up until now, I have considered you to be pretty well versed in the case so, unlike others, I have not claimed that you are telling fibs or making any crazed leaps of logic.

The only thing that I have faulted you for so far is treating this as some kind of game in which if you don't play by some exacting rules then you lose. For me, some of the problems I had were that you insisted that if certain procedures weren't followed then you (or the defence in this case) just lost the game. You were not the only one who did this. Smartcooky has also been a particularly egregious example of someone who insisted that he was right on the basis of extremely circumstantial or highly ambiguous evidence and apparently bad strategy by the defence.

I am still open to the possibility that Letby is guilty, as I have been the whole time, but more and more it looks as though the prosecution's case is increasingly threadbare and resorting to more and more underhanded tactics.


Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP> for breach of rule 0.


My stance is simply my opinion. I have at least set out my reasoning for having my opinion, backed up by citation and argument. I haven't demanded that anyone agree with me (unlike those two guys). You are most welcome to form your own opinion. I certainly won't be trying to force you to change it. I don't recall your ever giving the reasoning for your opinion. In a debate you are supposed to set out your stall. Failing to do so and then objecting when the other party does at least make the effort to debate a point is pretty poor show. So, tell us why you believe Letby is likely innocent.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The case has nothing to do with personalities.
Then I am sure you will stop your ad hominem attacks on the experts that Letby's defence has produced.

It would be annoying if I had to point out that Evans is the doctor about whom a judge said "this is a case in which both experts were clearly unsure about expressing an opinion about whether the injuries were non-accidental but both did so
because they had been asked to and were expected to do so.." I wonder what Dr Evans thought he was expected to do in this case?
 
Then I am sure you will stop your ad hominem attacks on the experts that Letby's defence has produced.

It would be annoying if I had to point out that Evans is the doctor about whom a judge said "this is a case in which both experts were clearly unsure about expressing an opinion about whether the injuries were non-accidental but both did so
because they had been asked to and were expected to do so.." I wonder what Dr Evans thought he was expected to do in this case?

That issue has already been addressed. That was a judge in a Family Law case. The party that Evans provided a report for was appealing a verdict and approached Evans for the report, which he provided. The family concerned lost their appeal. Parties win and lose cases all of the time. That means there will often be a losing expert report. It is a fact of legal life. I do not know a single barrister who has never lost a case nor been told off by a judge. It's like pointing out that Man Utd 'once lost'.

Don't you think it is a little bit pathetic that all Letby's defence can come up with is 'what a judge once said about Evans'?

As for your other point, Evans received the case notes completely anonymously. Dr. Sandie Bohin then also went through each case - appointed quite independently of Evans, by the Chester Police. She reconstructed her own analysis case by case. She didn't just tick off Evans'. Both were thoroughly cross examined. Ben Myers KC for Letby gave Evans a thorough grilling under cross-examination, so the jury knew all of the issues.

It was the court that decided the case not Evans or the police or the prosecution.
 
Last edited:
That issue has already been addressed. That was a judge in a Family Law case. The party that Evans provided a report for was appealing a verdict and approached Evans for the report, which he provided. The family concerned lost their appeal.
The Appeal was upheld. You can't get anything right, can you?
 
A completely different judge in a completely different case several years later said "Dr Evans makes no effort to provide a balanced opinion. He either knows what his professional colleagues have concluded and disregards it, or he has not taken steps to inform himself of their views. Either approach amounts to a breach of proper professional conduct." It's amazing he gets any work as an expert at all, except for the fact that he obviously produces whatever report he thinks (or knows) those paying him want to see.
 
A completely different judge in a completely different case several years later said "Dr Evans makes no effort to provide a balanced opinion. He either knows what his professional colleagues have concluded and disregards it, or he has not taken steps to inform himself of their views. Either approach amounts to a breach of proper professional conduct." It's amazing he gets any work as an expert at all, except for the fact that he obviously produces whatever report he thinks (or knows) those paying him want to see.


How would you explain all of these other guys? They were all cross-examined.


Letby’s defenders often portray the prosecution case as being a one-man crusade by the retired paediatrician Dr Dewi Evans, who has become something of a hate figure on the loony Letbyist fringe. In fact, his analysis was peer-reviewed and approved by the late Dr Martin Ward Platt, who can fairly be described as an eminent neonatologist, and was tested in court by neonatologist Dr Sandie Bohin, forensic pathologist Dr Andreas Marnerides, paediatric radiologist Professor Owen Arthurs, paediatric haematologist Professor Sally Kinsey, paediatric endocrinologist Professor Peter Hindmarsh, paediatric surgeon Dr Simon Kenney and paediatric neuroradiologist Professor Stavros Stivaros, as well as other medical experts and numerous doctors at the Countess of Chester Hospital. https://www.spiked-online.com/2025/02/08/the-devils-advocates/

And in fact 200 witnesses in all. Are they all useless as well?
 
I can't help wondering whether the doctor so named as Baby O's killer has now taken legal action so Taylor's now effectively gagged.
Mere unbridled speculation.
More likely he suspects he could actually have been responsible. If this is the case, he's not going to risk The Streisand Effect.
 
....because all of the world's leading experts in any given very specialised field of study must be complete strangers to each other or they will be biased 🙄


Well, one would have hoped that two of them weren't motorcar engineers, and one a stepped down head of RCPCH who advocated Letby's innocence even as of the time Dr Brearey first contacted her in her role. No wonder so many babies died or were harmed when the freaking regulator even refused to look into the doctors' concerns. Modi has a conflict of interest as the last thing she wants in Thirlwall rapping RCPCH's knuckles about baby murders during Modi's tenure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom