Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

CFLarsen said:


As usual, you cannot seem to just stick to the plain truth. It seems to be ingrained in you, this need to deceive.

I specifically pointed to you having the need to put me in your sig, so everyone can see how much you "ignore" me.

Which you don't. You have plenty of times addressed my posts, without anyone reposting them. I have no idea why you maintain this charade, but I guess you have your reasons.

None of the other posters, who have Ian on ignore, feel the need to boast about it in their sigs. That's why they are not obsessed with Ian. That's why you are obsessed with me.

That was my point, but you felt the need to distort it.

There is a very good reason why Clancie says in her sig that she has you on ignore. It's because she knows that you will not take a blind bit of notice and will follow her around the board all the time, and will continually respond to any comments she makes, inevitably to attack what she says and never to agree with her.

Now, if she didn't say in her sig that she has you on ignore, other posters might wonder why she just continually ignores you. They might for example think that she's unable to think of a good response. A clearly absurd thought given the vacuous content of the vast majority of your posts. But my experience with people on here suggests to me that they will are quite prepared to believe the most ludicrous things.

So that is why Clancie specifies in her sig that she has you on ignore. Seems like a good idea to me.
 
Darat said:


You've made a simple error here T'ai Chi because the forum search function does not include the "signature" which appears on every post a poster makes.

Looking at Clancie's post number the number of times her posts mention Claus is in fact 3116 (correct at time of composition).

So we would get 3116 posts from Clancie "about" Claus and only 612 (if your figure is correct) posts from Claus "about" Clancie.

Just goes to show why we have to be careful with “definitions”…

WOW! Are you being serious Darat?? Look at my post just above for God's sake! :rolleyes:
 
CFLarsen said:
But, other people have posters on ignore, but they don't see the need to make it known with every post they make.

The reason being is that you completely ignore the fact she has you on ignore. You've got this peculiar fixation on her. You just follow her around everywhere obsessively. What is your problem??

Why are you so obsessed with me, Clancie? Is it because I questioned your beliefs?

:rolleyes:
 
Ian,

What gave you that idea that I follow Clancie around "everywhere"?

If she has me on ignore, what does it matter if I address her posts, once in a while? If I really were obsessive, I would comment on each and every post she makes. I do not, far from it.

I think it is interesting that you do not ask Clancie how she can respond to what I write (and not just to her, mind you), if she has me on ignore. Why don't you do that?
 
BillHoyt said:
T'ai Chi,

You have been asked to account for not doing something any first-year stat student wouldn't have known enough to do: normalize the data. You changed your sig line in response and twice posted the same statement by way of lame explanation:

"See my comments below on why I didn't include content of sig files or consider (N/total posts)*100%.
__________________
http://www.library.adelaide.edu.au/.../stat_math.html"

Following that sig line link, we find a collection of papers, none of which appear to have anything to do with sig lines or reasons why one should not do data normalization. Please explain this lamest of dodges.

Jr., you refused to address the actual bulk of actual issues I raised, as usual.

Specifically, you refused to provide evidence, as usual, of evidence for your claims of what first year statistics students would supposedly do, etc.

Third, I didn't change my sig line in response to anything. Do you have actual evidence of the date which I changed my sig line? Do you have actual evidence I changed my sig line in response to anything? Actual evidence?

Yes, the collection of papers have nothing to do with sig lines or reasons why one should not "do data normalization"; they shouldn't, because I didn't put that link in my sig line for that purpose at all as you claimed. I like Fisher and found that archive a bit ago and thought that others who are interested in statistics, genetics, and history might like it.

See my comments below refers to subsequent posts.

I guess your mind tried saw two unconnected events and couldn't help but link the two events as one, which is very interesting in terms of beliefs, not to mention the statistical mistake of confusing correlation with causation.
 
CFLarsen said:

Lame, lame, lame.... Having a computer "write for you", so to speak, does not change the intention.


A sig file is not a post, no matter how much you'll try to make it so.


You use this a lot, T'ai Chi: If you cannot refute an argument, you simply call people believers, and reject their point altogether.


This from someone who regularly call people woo-woo. Grow up.


But why not a simple count?


Um I did use a simple count dude.


Who are you referring to? Please address people by their names.


I can use whatever name I wish, "a'ss h'ole". Simply observe some of the names Bill has addressed me with, hypocrite.
 
Interesting Ian said:

It's because she knows that you will not take a blind bit of notice and will follow her around the board all the time, and will continually respond to any comments she makes, inevitably to attack what she says and never to agree with her.

And we can and should update these counts every so often. Then we can get an idea of the rates involved. :)

It should be interesting..
 
Posted by Interesting Ian

There is a very good reason why Clancie says in her sig that she has you on ignore. It's because she knows that you will not take a blind bit of notice and will follow her around the board all the time, and will continually respond to any comments she makes, inevitably to attack what she says and never to agree with her.

Now, if she didn't say in her sig that she has you on ignore, other posters might wonder why she just continually ignores you. They might for example think that she's unable to think of a good response.....
So that is why Clancie specifies in her sig that she has you on ignore.
Exactly, Ian. Thank you.
 
Interesting Ian said:
You're psychic are you?

Nope. Clancie has responded to my posts without anyone reposting them.

What does that tell you, Ian? Use your reason.
 
CFLarsen said:


Nope. Clancie has responded to my posts without anyone reposting them.

What does that tell you, Ian? Use your reason.

Well let's for the sake of argument suppose what you say is correct. This doesn't mean to say I necessarily believe you, but let's suppose for the sake of argument it is true.

This still doesn't necessitate she hasn't got you on ignore. If you have someone on ignore, you can still click a button in order to read what that person has said. So maybe the vast majority of time she doesn't read any of your posts. But perhaps there's been one or two occasions in the past, where from the context of the conversation, she can gleam that you are telling some particularly nasty falsehoods about her, and she's succumbed to temptation and has clicked on this button to see precisely what you have said so she can put the record straight.

Her actions here are perfectly understandable and certainly doesn't mean that she hasn't got you on ignore or is continually clicking the button to see what you have said.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Well let's for the sake of argument suppose what you say is correct. This doesn't mean to say I necessarily believe you, but let's suppose for the sake of argument it is true.

This still doesn't necessitate she hasn't got you on ignore. If you have someone on ignore, you can still click a button in order to read what that person has said. So maybe the vast majority of time she doesn't read any of your posts. But perhaps there's been one or two occasions in the past, where from the context of the conversation, she can gleam that you are telling some particularly nasty falsehoods about her, and she's succumbed to temptation and has clicked on this button to see precisely what you have said so she can put the record straight.

Her actions here are perfectly understandable and certainly doesn't mean that she hasn't got you on ignore or is continually clicking the button to see what you have said.

"succumbed to the temptation"? Far from it, Ian.

Not for "sake of argument", Ian. Here is evidence that Clancie does not have me on ignore:

I have him on "Ignore" but he continues to post to and about me, almost daily, anyway.

How does she know that, if she has me on ignore? Use your reason, Ian.

And, of course, the classic:

http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/show...4775&perpage=40&highlight=praagh&pagenumber=2

Look for "SpiritDiscovery". Clancie replies to my post 26 minutes after I made it, without anyone reposting it.

How does she know what I post, if she has me on ignore? Use your reason, Ian.

Do you believe me, when I say that Clancie does not have me on ignore?
 
re:cold reading demos...So they weren't very good at TAM2, but I wonder what the best ones anyone's seen are? (Admitted cold readers, not "mediums").

Has anyone seen good cold reading demos of so-called "spirit communication" (not hot reads, like Randi's, second, demo in the UK)?

If it works as we're told that it does (and Michael Shermer said it was even easy for him, not even a professional mentalist, with just a quick read of "The Full Facts of....")....shouldn't there be some pretty good demos out there to compare with so called mediumship?

So...the "best ones".....what are they?
 
I have received a request to split this thread into a new thread, titled Mrs Piper Mediumship Discussion. I'm told that several of you support this; if so, please acknowledge, and I will be happy to split the thread for you.
 
Pyrrho said:
I have received a request to split this thread into a new thread, titled Mrs Piper Mediumship Discussion. I'm told that several of you support this; if so, please acknowledge, and I will be happy to split the thread for you.

Yes please - an excellent idea whoever came up with it! ;)
 
Its fine with me, too, with just one caveat....I'm trying to post -less- in Paranormal not more, so I hope my future contributions won't be missed too much (haha) if they dwindle out by necessity as more people jump in.
 
Ok, I will close this thread temporarily while I do the splits.

Hmm...that didn't come out quite right...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom