I don't have the time to carefully go through everything. I've already devoted far more time, this past week, than I should have, given my situation. However, I do try to skim intelligently, and focus on whatever is interesting and comprehensible. Sorry if I'm not doing your posts justice.
No problem.
Some problems:
1) The pictures in wikipedia show a white-ish material. The description says that it can have a red, blue or brown tint from impurities. Why did you not remark on this difference?
You are comparing things on a macro scale. I'm aware of impurities etc because Kaolin is also found with CaO and sometimes CaCO3 (calcium carbonate), gypsum and other materials - I allude to that I think in the post.
SEM photos aren't in colour because there is no light involved (for those that don't know)
2) The kaolinite platelets are much more densely packed than the Jones platelets
That is because the SEM photo show Kaolinite only - Remember Jones photos are of a material that has a Carbon matrix (binder) and Fe2O3 in too so it's not going to show groupings tightly.
The whole point of that SEM photo on the right is to show the characteristics of Kaolin platelets. Therefore you can compare the characteristics with the platelets in Jones' photos. That is they are thin sheets, roughly hexagonal and of the same size and in Jones' photos you get the same type of bunching of the platelets (which I've called sandwiching).
3) While I can make out a few candidates for non-platelet particles in the kaolite, it doesn't look like nearly as many as in the Jones photographs
No there won't be because the SEM photo is of the Kaolinite is of Kaolinite only (or very little else). Jones' photos have the Fe2O3 particles (bright white) and the carbon matrix. They talk of no other particles and I can't see any in the highest magnification SEM photo. That indicates there aren't any additional particles. You'd expect aluminium in some powder form and this will show itself usually as a spherical form if it's been man made, with sizes as small as 1µm.
4) You don't tell us what the very few candidates for non-platelets particles in the kaolite are made of. (Though I note that wikipedia says, " In many parts of the world, it is colored pink-orange-red by iron oxide". So, it should not surprise anybody if these candidates turn out to be iron oxide.")
OK - the bright white particles in Figs 8 and 9 of Jones' paper are iron oxide particles in a rhomboidal crystal shape and are sub-micron in size. I did comment on them, but not in detail because this is correct and that's what they state in their paper. It's impossible to come to any other conclusion when you take the shape and the EDS data in Fig 6 into account. They don't comment on anything else except the Carbon matrix so even if we found something else we wouldn't know what it was unless there was a better look and some EDS data.
The resolution on Fig 8 is not the best, however, if you look very closely on Fig 8 b) - locate the brightest crystal in the middle at the bottom - just to the left and slightly above you can see other "clump" of what appear to be crystals but it's impossible to tell what they are. They aren't Fe2O3, they look like they are Kaolinite if you use the grey shading as a marker or they could be SiO2. Without additional data it's impossible to tell.
5) You say that they are "similar in size", but while I see a scale in the Jones pictures, I don't see one in the kaolite picture. So, how do you know that they are "similar in size"? You mentioned something earlier about a mesh. Please elaborate.
Yes certainly - there is a scale there, it's hard to see, it's in the middle bottom of the screen (sorry I'm familiar with these things so I know where to look.
You can find plenty of Kaolinite SEM photos on the net. Sizes will range, because it's a natural. For manufacture in lots and lots of different materials, especially ceramics, (which is where most Kaolinite is used and of coarse Kaolin which is used in paper), then particle size distribution is critical. This is why the material is sieved. Different sieves have different sizes and this is where "
mesh size" comes in.
The US has a different scale to us so I can never remember which way it goes but a mesh size will obviously only let particles of a smaller size than the mesh through. By doing this you can tailor the
particle size distribution to get the best size for your product.
So if I want a size between 500mesh and 325mesh I'll sieve with those two. The 325 stops big bits and that gets thrown away. Then the sieved material goes into the 500mesh and that lets through all the really small bits and you chuck them. What you are left with is a distribution between 500 and 325mesh.
6) The wikipedia page says
Thus, it doesn't sound like it's a major constituent of paint, but just an additive.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but since it's used to extend TiO2, and TiO2 is used to make paints more opaque and skim milk whiter, as far as I can tell, the same should apply to kaolinite. Consequently, why would anybody make a red paint composed mostly of white pigment? The only answer I can think of is that it's much cheaper than the red pigment, and (perhaps) since the kaolinite makes the paint opaque, if the red is 'red enough', this is the cheap and effective way to go.
Wiki has only limited information - if you do any search for Kaolin/Kaolinite and paint you'll get thousands of pages with Kaolin in paint. Usually it's used as a replacement for Talc. And the bold part is you answering your own question.
Would you please show us photomicrographs of a
1) red paint made with kaolinite?
2) red paint made with kaolinite, with whatever primer you are currently touting?
The red paint or "red layer" as Jones calls it could either be paint or primer so i just use the word paint.
I've not looked for any SEM photos like that and I haven't found any when picking up a couple of SEM photos for the rebuttal post.
There isn't any need to imho. The SEM photos and the EDS data correlate so well that getting what you ask for gilding the lilly. I can try, but if the evidence I've come up with so far doesn't convince you then I doubt anything else will.
Note that
this link says that
were off when the break occurred. The SEM reveals telling information.
Yes, it does, but like any tool you have to be able to understand how, it works, hot to use, it what it's limitations are and also how to interpret or use what the image is showing and also what to look at. I've had access to a SEM since 1994 when doing a final year project on SiAlON (Silicon Nitride).
For example when looking at fracture surfaces, notably fatigue, it takes experience to know exactly what part of the fracture surface you look at in order to measure the length of striations which you can then use to determine crack propagation rates. One area right next to another will give you wildly different results. You have to be careful and not get sucked in with the size of what you are looking at.
Also, would you please tell us what the resistance of a red paint chip, made with kaolinite, is? ( I suppose that we need a range of values. )
No idea, I've not even looked at that part yet, it's a very obscure test and I have no idea why it was carried out when XRD would be 1000 times more useful, it's completely irrelevant imho. The information that I have shown clearly supports evidence that the material is Kaolinite and therefore it's up to others to refute that with their own data.
Secondly what type of paint do you want it with? Do you want that to be just the paint or do you want a layer of iron oxide attached to it aswell? Maybe some steel parent material attached to the oxide ala the chip that went to France?
The resistance of the chip is a complete red herring because unless the value obtained can be compared with paint with an iron oxide layer then you are going to get a different value.
Paint ≠ Paint with oxide layer ≠ Paint with oxide layer and steel substrate.
I've done the best I can with those. Feel free to ask more, I'll try and get a full answer to you.