[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why not rewrite my analogy to conform to your version of the Truth ? Comparing the two could be interesting for everybody. I think the analogy itself works globally quite well.

A famous, important man is shot on live television and the shooter commits suicide. The important man later dies, also on live television, from his wounds. It is glaringly obvious what happened. The shooter even left a suicide note. Because the man is so famous and important, the government conducts a very thorough investigation including an autopsy and confirms the glaringly obvious. The government even makes the results available to the public. Nobody to date has been able make any challenges that stand up to the slightest bit of scrutiny.

However, there is a small group of really stupid and/or crazy people that make up wildly impossible conspiracy theories because they are really stupid and/or crazy and thus don't understand that if somebody gets shot he might die. Some of these stupid/crazy people insist that the man wasn't even shot, that the government in collusion with the media faked the footage. Some of the stupid/crazy people who aren't quite as stupid/crazy as the ones who say the man wasn't shot say that he was also poisoned by a huge conspiracy involving thousands of people and that's why he died. They found a substance in what they claim to be the man's blood that they claim to be a deadly poison. But they can't even prove that the blood belonged to the man. Furthermore, it doesn't even matter if they could because the substance they found was actually something innocuous that would be expected to be found anyway. Even worse for these really stupid and/or crazy people, this substance that they falsely claim they found has never killed anybody in the history of ever nor have they even attempted to prove that it could

So, while the vast majority of people can see the glaringly obvious, some really stupid/crazy people make up really stupid/crazy conspiracy theories to explain it because they are really stupid/crazy. They demand a new investigation to justify their really stupid/crazy ideas, but nobody outside of their little club and the one that likes to make fun it even pays attention. These people will never come close to accomplishing anything, ever. The only good they will ever do to the world is provide endless, unintentional comedy.

The end.
 
Last edited:
I think Bill must have me on ignore - can anyone quote this and get him to read post #1694 where I clearly debunk scientifically with mountains of evidence that Jones' sample a-d cannot possibly be thermite?

Or do truthers just ignore everything that isn't to their liking? My post shatters Jones' paper completely - there is just no other explanation for those platelets to be anything other than Kaolinite given the current data.

Any truther who wilfully reads and understands that post, who then continues to back Jones' paper is dishonest.

Bill et al - read that post - it's conclusive.
 
This post will form part of the rebuttal to Jones' paper. I've collated the information quickly in order to show JREF posters and any lurkers as soon as possible, but the evidence is quite damning.

Jones claims that samples a-d are essentially the same material and I agree with him. His paper's EDS spectra are very close and this confirms that the materials are identical.

We also have information from another source of Jones' chips namely a chip that has also had SEM and EDS analysis performed on them.

http://darksideofgravity.com/marseille.pdf

Comparing this report and Jones' we see from these SEM photo-micrographs that samples a-d are identical to the chip in the above report.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=861

We can now closely look at the morphology of the chips a-d and compare the structures therein to see whether there are any similarities between observed structures in the sample and known structures.

Jones' paper clearly examines these structures in samples a-d and notes

Until now.

The following photo-micrograph shows samples a-d (on the left) and Kaolinite (on the right).

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=857


Examining the two side by side clearly shows similarity in size, crystal shape and thickness between the two groups of plate-like particles. Note the exact same style of grouping where platelets have "sandwiched" together in the top middle of b) and the top left of c) in Jones' samples and the exact same phenomenon in the photo to the right. This indicates very strongly that these particles are indeed Kaolinite.

There are many such photo-micrographs of Kaolinite available.

Therefore it is now essential that we examine EDS data of known samples of Kaolinite and compare them with the EDS data generated in Jones' paper. Note that I also include data from the chip sent in the report linked earlier. I have scaled these SEM spectra as best I can in a short space of time in order that the KeV scale matches across spectra.

One of Jones' claims, as is that of the author of the above linked report, is that the EDS spectra of the red layer show signs of contamination



Gypsum is a naturally occurring mineral and aswell as being used in wall board or drywall is also used in the manufacture of paint. The following are EDS spectra from Kaolinite with Gypsum, Fig 7 c) of Jones' paper and finally slide/page 14 of the above link.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=858

It is abundantly clear that the spectra share more than enough characteristics to say that not only is gypsum present, but that Kaolinte is too.

The plate-like structures seen in the photo-micrographs, of both "thermite chip" samples, share not only the same crystalline morphology and grouping, but also the same EDS signature.

This means that there is very little doubt remaining as to what these platelets are. In light of this evidence it is safe to say that these platelets consist of Kaolinite, which does not contain any "elemental aluminium". The SEM examination in Jones' paper does not show any other particle type (other than the rhomboidal Fe2O3) and no other data in the EDS spectra for samples a-d indicate it's presence.

Therefore these samples CANNOT be thermite.


QED.

For Jones to now claim that elemental aluminium is present then the only way to confirm this is by XRD analysis or a suitable equivalent.

We can also say that because Kaolinite is present and that it is embedded in a Carbon based matrix with Rhomboidal Fe2O3 that a more likely explanation for the red material is paint.

When we look at the material that the "red layer" in the samples is attached to and the notable difference in the structure compared to the "red layer" along with it's EDS spectra it is clear to see that this is a form of Iron Oxide. The corresponding Carbon peaks and the possibility of Mn peak at 5.9KeV indicate the source of this oxide as being steel.

If you also not in the second photo on this page you can clearly see this oxide layer is also attached to a crystalline fibrous material that again does not share morphology with the "red layer" or the "gray layer". The French paper linked has EDS data of this layer. Notable we do not see the underside of the "gray layer/iron oxide layer" in samples a-d in Jones paper.


Addition.

We can also see the EDS spectra of pure Kaolin for comparison and untreated clay which will explain any queries with the Carbon peak also noting that Carbon is closely associated with Fe in steel.

http://www.scielo.org.ar/scielo.php?pid=S0327-07932007000200005&script=sci_arttext

We can also confirm the presence in other spectra by comparing them eg Fig 11a), Fig 14 (noting the correlating high Ca, O and S peaks - gypsum), etc.

masterful work my friend. i feel like a speck of dust compared to you.

i expect NO rebuttal from truthers, as they cannot handle the truth.
 
When and if they do respond Parky it will start the conversation- hopefully on a national scale which is wht we have been striving for all along. If they do not respond that will tell it's own story. I don't know why you guys are so afraid to go mainstream with this. We are all looking for the Truth after all.

Any comment on Sunstealer's amazing rebuttal to Jones' findings?

Do you have the courage to take it on?
 
The excellent work by Niels Harrit, Farrer, Jones and Ryan et. al in the recent journal article (Thermitic Material Discovered in WTC Dust) has paved the way for some very good media coverage in Denmark. At around 10:30 pm on Monday April 6, Harrit was interviewed for 10 minutes during the late news program on one of the two most respected Danish television channels (TV2). On Wednesday April 8, Harrit was interviewed for 6 minutes at 8:45 am during a live news and entertainment program on the same channel. In both cases, Harrit, and the claims of the article, were treated with refreshing seriousness and respect.

The first interview has been subtitled in English and loaded onto youtube:-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_tf25lx_3o&eurl=http://www.911blogger.com/&feature=player_embedded

bill:

I think you should inform Danish TV that they are being duped, so they have a chance to redeem themselves before the paper they produced is shown to be a fraud.

I think you owe that to them...right?

TAM;)
 
I think Bill must have me on ignore - can anyone quote this and get him to read post #1694 where I clearly debunk scientifically with mountains of evidence that Jones' sample a-d cannot possibly be thermite?

Or do truthers just ignore everything that isn't to their liking? My post shatters Jones' paper completely - there is just no other explanation for those platelets to be anything other than Kaolinite given the current data.

Any truther who wilfully reads and understands that post, who then continues to back Jones' paper is dishonest.

Bill et al - read that post - it's conclusive.

proverbial nail on head my friend.

TAM:)
 
Any comment on Sunstealer's amazing rebuttal to Jones' findings?

Do you have the courage to take it on?

I have a comment on this "amazing rebuttal". And that is

a) in Sunstealer's #1694 post, there is no link immediately after

"The following photo-micrograph shows samples a-d (on the left) and Kaolinite (on the right)."

b) in your post immediately preceeding this one, wherein you quote Sunstealer's 1694 post, there is a link, viz.,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=857

When I click on that link, I don't see anything.


Shouldn't an "amazing rebuttal" have non-disappearing links, which point to web pages that still exist?
 
I have a comment on this "amazing rebuttal". And that is

a) in Sunstealer's #1694 post, there is no link immediately after

"The following photo-micrograph shows samples a-d (on the left) and Kaolinite (on the right)."

b) in your post immediately preceeding this one, wherein you quote Sunstealer's 1694 post, there is a link, viz.,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=857

When I click on that link, I don't see anything.


Shouldn't an "amazing rebuttal" have non-disappearing links, which point to web pages that still exist?

So you didn't understand anything about the technical aspects of the paper and have to resort to nitpicking.
 
So you didn't understand anything about the technical aspects of the paper and have to resort to nitpicking.

Yes, an actual comment on the substance of the paper would have been more convincing.
 
I have a comment on this "amazing rebuttal". And that is

a) in Sunstealer's #1694 post, there is no link immediately after

"The following photo-micrograph shows samples a-d (on the left) and Kaolinite (on the right)."

b) in your post immediately preceeding this one, wherein you quote Sunstealer's 1694 post, there is a link, viz.,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=857

When I click on that link, I don't see anything.


Shouldn't an "amazing rebuttal" have non-disappearing links, which point to web pages that still exist?
The photo appears for me. One of the photo links didn't work so I edited it 30 seconds after posting to make sure it was there. You should see the photo in post #1694 http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4607894&postcount=1694.

The public JREF album is http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/album.php?albumid=181 - pic #4 is the one if you can't see it.

I've tried to make the post as concise and in a non-technical language as much as possible. Do you understand the information and what I have said in it? If there is anything you do not understand then please ask.
 
Last edited:
The photo appears for me. One of the photo links didn't work so I edited it 30 seconds after posting to make sure it was there. You should see the photo in post #1694 http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4607894&postcount=1694.

The public JREF album is http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/album.php?albumid=181 - pic #4 is the one if you can't see it.
I see it now, thanks.

I've tried to make the post as concise and in a non-technical language as much as possible. Do you understand the information and what I have said in it? If there is anything you do not understand then please ask.

I don't have the time to carefully go through everything. I've already devoted far more time, this past week, than I should have, given my situation. However, I do try to skim intelligently, and focus on whatever is interesting and comprehensible. Sorry if I'm not doing your posts justice.

Some problems:

1) The pictures in wikipedia show a white-ish material. The description says that it can have a red, blue or brown tint from impurities. Why did you not remark on this difference?
2) The kaolinite platelets are much more densely packed than the Jones platelets
3) While I can make out a few candidates for non-platelet particles in the kaolite, it doesn't look like nearly as many as in the Jones photographs
4) You don't tell us what the very few candidates for non-platelets particles in the kaolite are made of. (Though I note that wikipedia says, " In many parts of the world, it is colored pink-orange-red by iron oxide". So, it should not surprise anybody if these candidates turn out to be iron oxide.")
5) You say that they are "similar in size", but while I see a scale in the Jones pictures, I don't see one in the kaolite picture. So, how do you know that they are "similar in size"? You mentioned something earlier about a mesh. Please elaborate.
6) The wikipedia page says

Kaolin is used in ceramics, medicine, coated paper, as a food additive, in toothpaste, as a light diffusing material in white incandescent light bulbs, and in cosmetics. It is generally the main component in porcelain.
It is also used in paint to extend titanium dioxide (TiO2) and modify gloss levels; in rubber for semi-reinforcing properties and in adhesives to modify rheology.[6]

Thus, it doesn't sound like it's a major constituent of paint, but just an additive.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but since it's used to extend TiO2, and TiO2 is used to make paints more opaque and skim milk whiter, as far as I can tell, the same should apply to kaolinite. Consequently, why would anybody make a red paint composed mostly of white pigment? The only answer I can think of is that it's much cheaper than the red pigment, and (perhaps) since the kaolinite makes the paint opaque, if the red is 'red enough', this is the cheap and effective way to go.

Would you please show us photomicrographs of a
1) red paint made with kaolinite?
2) red paint made with kaolinite, with whatever primer you are currently touting?

Note that this link says that

Automotive paint can be compared to more than 40,000 samples in the National Automotive Paint File, helping identify color, make, model and year of an automobile. The melted ends of a hot filament break indicate that the headlights were on when an accident occurred. Sharp ends indicate the headlights
were off when the break occurred. The SEM reveals telling information.

Also, would you please tell us what the resistance of a red paint chip, made with kaolinite, is? ( I suppose that we need a range of values. )
 
Oh, well, at least "truthers" still have the CT that Jones is a disinfo agent, out to discredit their "movement." The wonderful thing about conspiracy theories is that you can explain anything that does or doesn't happen by putting whomever you don't like into the conspiracy.
 
Thanks Sunstealer!

I've posted a link on a twoofer channel about the 'Thermite Scientifically Confirmed in 911'

Suggest you guys spread this data around.

Happy Easter to all


To all you twoofers: stop the madness.
 
I have a comment on this "amazing rebuttal". And that is

a) in Sunstealer's #1694 post, there is no link immediately after

"The following photo-micrograph shows samples a-d (on the left) and Kaolinite (on the right)."

b) in your post immediately preceeding this one, wherein you quote Sunstealer's 1694 post, there is a link, viz.,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=857

When I click on that link, I don't see anything.


Shouldn't an "amazing rebuttal" have non-disappearing links, which point to web pages that still exist?

whoa! you nailed him. You PWNed him with that one.

TAM:)
 
I see it now, thanks.



I don't have the time to carefully go through everything. I've already devoted far more time, this past week, than I should have, given my situation. However, I do try to skim intelligently, and focus on whatever is interesting and comprehensible. Sorry if I'm not doing your posts justice.

Some problems:

1) The pictures in wikipedia show a white-ish material. The description says that it can have a red, blue or brown tint from impurities. Why did you not remark on this difference?
2) The kaolinite platelets are much more densely packed than the Jones platelets
3) While I can make out a few candidates for non-platelet particles in the kaolite, it doesn't look like nearly as many as in the Jones photographs
4) You don't tell us what the very few candidates for non-platelets particles in the kaolite are made of. (Though I note that wikipedia says, " In many parts of the world, it is colored pink-orange-red by iron oxide". So, it should not surprise anybody if these candidates turn out to be iron oxide.")
5) You say that they are "similar in size", but while I see a scale in the Jones pictures, I don't see one in the kaolite picture. So, how do you know that they are "similar in size"? You mentioned something earlier about a mesh. Please elaborate.
6) The wikipedia page says



Thus, it doesn't sound like it's a major constituent of paint, but just an additive.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but since it's used to extend TiO2, and TiO2 is used to make paints more opaque and skim milk whiter, as far as I can tell, the same should apply to kaolinite. Consequently, why would anybody make a red paint composed mostly of white pigment? The only answer I can think of is that it's much cheaper than the red pigment, and (perhaps) since the kaolinite makes the paint opaque, if the red is 'red enough', this is the cheap and effective way to go.

Would you please show us photomicrographs of a
1) red paint made with kaolinite?
2) red paint made with kaolinite, with whatever primer you are currently touting?

Note that this link says that

were off when the break occurred. The SEM reveals telling information.

Also, would you please tell us what the resistance of a red paint chip, made with kaolinite, is? ( I suppose that we need a range of values. )

You do realize that all that needs to be done is show significant doubt on Jones findings, with possible outcomes that were more likely than his, to prove that his entire paper is a worthless piece of biased OUTCOME HUNTING, rather than a truly scientific analysis, right?

TAM:)
 
um..the links work for me. i guess truther computers can't handle non-truther evidence images.

=)
 
This post will form part of the rebuttal to Jones' paper. I've collated the information quickly in order to show JREF posters and any lurkers as soon as possible, but the evidence is quite damning.

Jones claims that samples a-d are essentially the same material and I agree with him. His paper's EDS spectra are very close and this confirms that the materials are identical.







We also have information from another source of Jones' chips namely a chip that has also had SEM and EDS analysis performed on them.

http://darksideofgravity.com/marseille.pdf

Comparing this report and Jones' we see from these SEM photo-micrographs that samples a-d are identical to the chip in the above report.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=861[/qimg]

We can now closely look at the morphology of the chips a-d and compare the structures therein to see whether there are any similarities between observed structures in the sample and known structures.

Jones' paper clearly examines these structures in samples a-d and notes





Until now.

The following photo-micrograph shows samples a-d (on the left) and Kaolinite (on the right).

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=857[/qimg]


Examining the two side by side clearly shows similarity in size, crystal shape and thickness between the two groups of plate-like particles. Note the exact same style of grouping where platelets have "sandwiched" together in the top middle of b) and the top left of c) in Jones' samples and the exact same phenomenon in the photo to the right. This indicates very strongly that these particles are indeed Kaolinite.

There are many such photo-micrographs of Kaolinite available.

Therefore it is now essential that we examine EDS data of known samples of Kaolinite and compare them with the EDS data generated in Jones' paper. Note that I also include data from the chip sent in the report linked earlier. I have scaled these SEM spectra as best I can in a short space of time in order that the KeV scale matches across spectra.

One of Jones' claims, as is that of the author of the above linked report, is that the EDS spectra of the red layer show signs of contamination



Gypsum is a naturally occurring mineral and aswell as being used in wall board or drywall is also used in the manufacture of paint. The following are EDS spectra from Kaolinite with Gypsum, Fig 7 c) of Jones' paper and finally slide/page 14 of the above link.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=858[/qimg]

It is abundantly clear that the spectra share more than enough characteristics to say that not only is gypsum present, but that Kaolinte is too.

The plate-like structures seen in the photo-micrographs, of both "thermite chip" samples, share not only the same crystalline morphology and grouping, but also the same EDS signature.

This means that there is very little doubt remaining as to what these platelets are. In light of this evidence it is safe to say that these platelets consist of Kaolinite, which does not contain any "elemental aluminium". The SEM examination in Jones' paper does not show any other particle type (other than the rhomboidal Fe2O3) and no other data in the EDS spectra for samples a-d indicate it's presence.

Therefore these samples CANNOT be thermite.


QED.

For Jones to now claim that elemental aluminium is present then the only way to confirm this is by XRD analysis or a suitable equivalent.

We can also say that because Kaolinite is present and that it is embedded in a Carbon based matrix with Rhomboidal Fe2O3 that a more likely explanation for the red material is paint.

When we look at the material that the "red layer" in the samples is attached to and the notable difference in the structure compared to the "red layer" along with it's EDS spectra it is clear to see that this is a form of Iron Oxide. The corresponding Carbon peaks and the possibility of Mn peak at 5.9KeV indicate the source of this oxide as being steel.

If you also not in the second photo on this page you can clearly see this oxide layer is also attached to a crystalline fibrous material that again does not share morphology with the "red layer" or the "gray layer". The French paper linked has EDS data of this layer. Notable we do not see the underside of the "gray layer/iron oxide layer" in samples a-d in Jones paper.


Addition.

We can also see the EDS spectra of pure Kaolin for comparison and untreated clay which will explain any queries with the Carbon peak also noting that Carbon is closely associated with Fe in steel.

http://www.scielo.org.ar/scielo.php?pid=S0327-07932007000200005&script=sci_arttext

We can also confirm the presence in other spectra by comparing them eg Fig 11a), Fig 14 (noting the correlating high Ca, O and S peaks - gypsum), etc.

Would this not mean that we were dealing with highly engineered nano-kaolin ?
 
Last edited:
The material found by your "scientists" couldn't raise the temperature of the columns more that 48 deg C (assuming it was all 6 layers). Please at least come up with a possible scenario before spreading this nonsense. You have a both a civic resposibility and a responsibility to your activist organization to be somewhat sure of what you are talking about.

False. Likely source: Greening
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom