[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
....3) don't explosives have to be specially shaped into cutting charges in order to blast thru steel columns? ...
No but it helps and to cut larger members it is almost essential. (Bold assertion based on military engineering training)
....I fail to see a single scrap of real-world data that suggests a 'painted on' layer of combustible material can destroy steel.... isn't this an outrageous assumption?....
.. no doubt it is outrageous (or worse!! :D ) if the inference is it would work at the scale of WTC steel members.

In terms of the question "Demolition or not at WTC?" this whole thread is a derail/red herring. AFAIK there is no extant formed hypothesis as to how therm*te could be used in a demolition scheme which would be consistent with what happened at WTC on 9/11. So the legitimate role of this thread is to discuss therm*te from a hypothetical scientific perspective with no inferences that it is relevant to the WTC "collapses that actually happened".
 
Last edited:
If the Jones team were a private company, claiming to have a technology which could perform 'X' (in this case, it seems to be destroy structural steel with thinly painted on material) wouldn't a potential investor want to see some proof?
Wouldn't they need to demonstrate the technology actually working?

Or is this more in the realm of, say, cold fusion research, where the idea is to explore, and get government grants and university funding for more research?

I believe Jones, by saying 'we have nailed it!' is giving a false impression that they've demonstrated the proposed technology actually works. It would be honest to say, Dr. Jones, that you have taken but a tiny step in a long, long process to determine whether the technology could ever work.

From an investor's POV, you're a long shot at best sir. I think I'd rather invest in cold fusion....
 
If the Jones team were a private company, claiming to have a technology which could perform 'X' (in this case, it seems to be destroy structural steel with thinly painted on material) wouldn't a potential investor want to see some proof?
Wouldn't they need to demonstrate the technology actually working?

Or is this more in the realm of, say, cold fusion research, where the idea is to explore, and get government grants and university funding for more research?

I believe Jones, by saying 'we have nailed it!' is giving a false impression that they've demonstrated the proposed technology actually works. It would be honest to say, Dr. Jones, that you have taken but a tiny step in a long, long process to determine whether the technology could ever work.

From an investor's POV, you're a long shot at best sir. I think I'd rather invest in cold fusion....
...nhah...

Put your money on the horses if that desperate. ;)
 
Your math is clearly flawed, or I wouldn't be able to see individual welders working on the new buildings near ground zero from several miles away in NJ. By your math, the light from the welding would be trillions of times less intense at that distance.

Is my math flawed, or is your knowledge of physics non-existent? The area of a sphere if 4 * pi * r^2. If Em radiation is moving at a constant rate outwards, at the speed of light, and the energy in each wavefront is considered constant (from conservation of energy, plus symmetry considerations), then how can the power per unit area not drop off as 1/r^2 ?

If you think I punched in values for R(2 mm)^2 and R(200 m)^2 incorrectly, why don't you try it with your own calculator?

As we've already clearly established, the chip that jones examined is way to thin to have done anything at all to a column. The magic thermite would have to be layed on much thicker, and as such there would be larger chunks than 2mm knocked off the columns in the impact.
Ya think?

I stand by my idea that we'd see lots of them blasted out and ignited by the impact if there was enough to do any damage to the columns and it could be ignited at 430C.
Are we supposed to be impressed by this? I can tell that you won't lift a finger to do a single calculation to support your idea.
 
... calculation to support your idea.
You have that super program to calculate some number but you failed too? Where is your total termite needed and joules to destroy the WTC? You got a program to do it, what numbers did you come up with?

So do you support the delusion paper of thermite made up by Jones as reality? Or do you support that impact, fire, and gravity collapse destroyed the WTC?

What is your stand on the selective element study of Jones and his conclusion that it was thermite, not just some rust and aluminum found in sample of debris that is like other fire debris at other fires?

A selective study done to support the finding of rust and Al in debris with a nut case conclusions implying the scenario of thermite being planted in the WTC to bring down the WTC. A delusion? Do you support this or what is your great scenario? You got anything beside jibber jabber and claims of some great program that can show the amount of thermite needed and the heat in joules that you can't show?

That is right, now you are just concentrating on WTC that burned a long time and fell due to gravity as your smoke and mirror 911Truth dumb idea.

But what is your take on the delusional thermite scenario that Jones supports? You said you could define the amount needed and the joules of heat requried but you will not do it; why?
 
I think you mean "authoritative work on the WTC red/gray chips". (Certainly, it's subject isn't even the dust, as a whole, so how could it be authoritative?)

In this layman's opinion, there are far too many questions to consider the Jones, et. al., paper authoritative. E.g., the screamingly obvious question of whether or not you can create Al/Si in platelet form. I leave it to domain experts to tell us whether the test used by Jones, et. al., is foolproof for identifying elemental Al. If it is, then it's probably academic as to whether or not the methodology to create Al/Si in platelet form can be determined.

Notice that I used the word "probably", in the last sentence. These sort of issues should be debated by domain experts, not "truthers" and "debunkers". If "truthers" and "debunkers" want to entertain themselves, fine, but as you can see from this thread, e.g., it's not very enlightening.

I repeat what I've said before: 911 truthers are fools if they go running to debunkers, media, or government, at the expense of taking this paper to domain experts. And domain experts are not going to pay any attention to the paper, unless they are directed there. The Bentham Journal that this paper was published in has only been around for less than 2 years. I expect that only a tiny fraction of the scientific community reads it "regularly". In it's less than 2 years of existence, there's only 12 articles.

If the paper holds up, then it's fine to try and push it further to government and media. If it doesn't hold up, why would any reasonable and honest person want to push forward something that's a mistake, in the name of "truth"?

(Another possibility is that the paper will simply be considered doubtful, with insufficient evidence to convince a community of domain experts, who are paying attention to it, one way or the other.)

It's true that there are questions but three that stand out in my opinion. Is there a nano-thermite present ? Is this a highly engineered example of a nano product ? Is it possible that this highly engineered product could have been n the WTC dust on 9/11 in an explainable way?

If the paper holds up then that means that 9/11 was an inside job- no less than that. After that it just depends on whether people actually WANT to know or not.
 
Last edited:
If the paper holds up then that means hat 9/11 was an inside job- no less than that. After that it just depends on whether people actually WANT to know or not.

There's no way something like that will go unnoticed. So Jones has set himself up to change the world, no matter what.

Big motza ball...
 
It's true tht there are questions but three that stand out in my opinion. Is there anano-thermite present ? Is this a highly engineered example of a nano product ? Is it possible that this highly engineered product could have been n the WTC dust on 9/11 in an eplainable way? ...

CARE TO FILL IN THIS GREAT BIG QUANTUM LEAP OF A FALSE DICHOTOMY BILL?

If the paper holds up then that means hat 9/11 was an inside job- no less than that. After that it just depends on whether people actually WANT to know or not.

Irrespective of whether Jones "proves" thermate or not there is no way that thermate played a significant part in assisting the "collapses which actually happened" at WTC.

Sure there is potential to use it in hypothetical scenarios but no one has put forward any workable suggestion as to how it could have been used in the actual collapse.

There is, AFAICS, only one small "window of opportunity" where rebuttal of claims of thermate use depend on statistical improbability. I will even tell you what it is. It is the use of thermate in the impact zone to cut the lower chords of floor joists. It would have to be after the crash impact so needs a team of suicide terrorists to do it.

All other possible uses in the "collapse that actually happened" can be rebutted by evidence which does not rely on improbability.
:) :D
 
The question is much simpler than this. How much was required, how it was applied, what it achieved -- are all subjective. The substantiated FINDING of nano-thermite is damning enough. Arson has been proved.
 
Jonesie mentioned sending the samples to an "Independent lab" on December of 2007 on 911blogger. ten months after it is documented that Basile had joined his little fantasy role playing club.

Well there you have it. Jones lies once again. There is nothing independent about having other truther "scientists" verify your results.

Why am I not surprised?

TAM:rolleyes:
 
The question is much simpler than this. How much was required, how it was applied, what it achieved -- are all subjective. The substantiated FINDING of nano-thermite is damning enough. Arson has been proved.

picture.php


Sorry, Wrong!!!

TAM:)
 
There are currently other labs and scientists testing the samples.

Cognitive dissonance is a bitch, eh TAM?
 
picture.php


Sorry, Wrong!!!

TAM:)

At the WTC we have 10 terrorists in two planes killing 4 pilots and flying their jets into the largest buildings in NYC with 66,000 pounds of jet fuel with the heat energy of 630 TONS of TNT and the 911Truth cult members says arson was done by super thermite which was made up by a physics prof with brain cancer published in a vanity journal?

Yes it was arson and kinetic energy impacts that doomed the WTC, but the super thermite is a delusion. Poor dolts can’t see fraud when it is clearly made up junk.

The terrorist act is too simple for simple cult members of 911Truth to grasp. Kill pilots, fly planes into large buildings. Too complex for 911Truth?

Jones made it up! 911Truth believers are too lazy to research and they are too blind by lack of knowledge to see Jones is a fraud.

Ignorance is bliss for 911Truth cult member chanting “super thermite”. What incompetence display by those simply buying and regurgitating the junk science of Jones who found rust and Al as he excluded all the other elements found and ignore the fact not one single piece of steel in the WTC showed any thermite damage. Zip. Good work 911Truth cult members; total lack of self-esteem and zero knowledge on 911 leads to delusional beliefs.
 
Last edited:
There are currently other labs and scientists testing the samples.

Cognitive dissonance is a bitch, eh TAM?

just remember all that you are saying when all is said and done Kreel, cause looking like a jackass will be a bigger bitch for you son. You know this is all gonna turn out to be crap, just like all the other "scientific" garbage the truther "scientists" put out.

Just remember.

TAM:)
 
There are currently other labs and scientists testing the samples.

Cognitive dissonance is a bitch, eh TAM?

I was wondering if Dr. Jones and Kevin Ryan would do it this way. The drip-drip-drip of one credentialled scientist after another confirming their findings will be devastating for the government story. This way it's not a story that comes and goes....it's ongoing and damning and puts the major media under steadily increasing pressure to pick up on the story which will be the final decapitating blow. Truthers may be on all the talk shows soon..
 
Last edited:
At the WTC we have 10 terrorists in two planes killing 4 pilots and flying their jets into the largest buildings in NYC with 66,000 pounds of jet fuel with the heat energy of 630 TONS of TNT and the 911Truth cult members says arson was done by super thermite which was made up by a physics prof with brain cancer published in a vanity journal?

Yes it was arson and kinetic energy impacts that doomed the WTC, but the super thermite is a delusion. Poor dolts can’t see fraud when it is clearly made up junk.

The terrorist act is too simple for simple cult members of 911Truth to grasp. Kill pilots, fly planes into large buildings. Too complex for 911Truth?

Jones made it up! 911Truth believers are too lazy to research and they are too blind by lack of knowledge to see Jones is a fraud.

Ignorance is bliss for 911Truth cult member chanting “super thermite”. What incompetence display by those simply buying and regurgitating the junk science of Jones who found rust and Al as he excluded all the other elements found and ignore the fact not one single piece of steel in the WTC showed any thermite damage. Zip. Good work 911Truth cult members; total lack of self-esteem and zero knowledge on 911 leads to delusional beliefs.


a good bit of that questionable amount of jet fuel burned up outside the towers. Watch video much????????????
 
Is my math flawed, or is your knowledge of physics non-existent? The area of a sphere if 4 * pi * r^2. If Em radiation is moving at a constant rate outwards, at the speed of light, and the energy in each wavefront is considered constant (from conservation of energy, plus symmetry considerations), then how can the power per unit area not drop off as 1/r^2 ?

If you think I punched in values for R(2 mm)^2 and R(200 m)^2 incorrectly, why don't you try it with your own calculator?


Ya think?


Are we supposed to be impressed by this? I can tell that you won't lift a finger to do a single calculation to support your idea.

How far away from a star do we have to be to no longer see it in the night sky then? Assuming these stars are spheres. Can you "punch in" those numbers for us Genius?
 
I'm no expert, just a regular guy. But it seems that this all boils down too:

Some tiny flakes of possible thermite like material found in 4 samples of questionable origin. That are claimed to come from the massive dust cloud on 9/11. Which then sat around for years in drawers and cupboards, till one day they were sent to known 9/11 conspiracy theorists only. Who then claimed to find the flakes of possible thermite like material and then published this in a 2 year old, little known journal, with seriously questionable practices and that is pay for play.

Not only that but this now somehow totally proves that there really is an NWO evil organization, that really did 9/11 just to play games with our heads and is out to enslave and kill us all in FEMA camps, while they live forever with immortality technology, etc, etc. While countless numbers of other people are in on it or know about it and are paid to keep quiet.

This is what they are trying to sell to everyone...
 
At the WTC we have 10 terrorists in two planes killing 4 pilots and flying their jets into the largest buildings in NYC with 66,000 pounds of jet fuel with the heat energy of 630 TONS of TNT and the 911Truth cult members says arson was done by super thermite which was made up by a physics prof with brain cancer published in a vanity journal?

Yes it was arson and kinetic energy impacts that doomed the WTC, but the super thermite is a delusion. Poor dolts can’t see fraud when it is clearly made up junk.

The terrorist act is too simple for simple cult members of 911Truth to grasp. Kill pilots, fly planes into large buildings. Too complex for 911Truth?

Jones made it up! 911Truth believers are too lazy to research and they are too blind by lack of knowledge to see Jones is a fraud.

Ignorance is bliss for 911Truth cult member chanting “super thermite”. What incompetence display by those simply buying and regurgitating the junk science of Jones who found rust and Al as he excluded all the other elements found and ignore the fact not one single piece of steel in the WTC showed any thermite damage. Zip. Good work 911Truth cult members; total lack of self-esteem and zero knowledge on 911 leads to delusional beliefs.

The problem with your theory is you have no evidence backing it up. A simple part number off of one of the engines or landing gear assembly would go a long way in helping your statement seem a bit more believeable. Perhaps arab names on a manifest would help you out a bit also. In fact a simple picture from one of the many cams in the boarding lounge at Dulles showing some of your phantom 'hijackers' actually boarding a flight would be enormously helpful to your credibility. Pfft...talk about make believe crap - you believe whatever they tell you, eh TAM?:p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom