[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
What sort of numpty is Jones? The man cannot even read a simple request. I don't give a flying <rule> what the paint was used on I want to know what it is. Manufacturers data sheet?

It's plainly obvious that he is dishonest when he pulls crap like that. Knowing Jones they probably had a wonder over to the stadium and peeled a bit of paint off.

This thread has run it's course as far as I'm concerned, because it's become infected with the crazy and good posts are lost in the sea of ever deepening rubbish. Time to go elsewhere.

Since you have claimed to have identified some of the constituents of the chips, with great certainty, I should think that producing similar SEM, etc., should be quite easy for you, even without knowing the exact type of paint. You said

Bearing in mind I have shown beyond any reasonable doubt that samples a-d are hematite and red paint
(emphasis mine)

You didn't specify any particular type of red paint, implying that there should be multiple types of red paint that will look just like Jones' "paint chips". Indeed, perhaps you were implying that all paint chips consisting of red paint and primer would look like Jones', upon close examination. Were you?

Furthermore, you (or somebody else) could call BYU maintenance, and ask them about the stadium paint. I completely agree that Jones, et. al., should have identified it clearly, in their paper, but they didn't.

I have to wonder if, in fact, you are basically guessing re Jones' chips. Were you perhaps exaggerating, and instead you merely suspect, or believe wholeheartedly, that a small minority of red paint chip varieties will look like Jones' sample, and thus you will have to make many batches before you can re-create the Jones' type? Are you afraid of having to make many types of red paint chip before you hit the right one?

Perhaps Mackey's comment pooh-poohing the notion of the grey layer being "primer" has caused you to doubt?

Recall Mackey's words:

I surmise that the magnetic effects have nothing to do with hematite or aluminum, but are instead are caused by pure iron, due to flakes of the steel columns themselves (or some other incidental source of iron) stuck to the paint fragments. Rust layers and spall matches this effect perfectly.

Would you be so kind as to comment on this? Also, is it too much to ask that you also show us some detailed pictures of "Rust layers and spall" stuck to red paint? The Jones' pictures show relatively even layers, but I am suspicious about rusty paint chips being anywhere near this even. You could help settle the matter by also producing SEMs of rusty paint chips.
 
I wonder if mark Basile became a member of Scholars for Truth AFTER he analsyed Stephen Jones's samples ? It would be very telling if he had not been a member before he saw the samples but became a member after he had analysed them..

If the test had been done properly, there would be no identification associated with it and Basile wouldn't have a clue as to where the sample came from or what organization to join based on what the tests showed.
 
Suppose we had to stop considering the paint as an alternative for the thermite chips ? Is that it then ? Does that mean that the Jones paper becomes the autoritative work on the WTC dust- meaning , as it does that 9/11 was an inside job ?
 
I wonder if mark Basile became a member of Scholars for Truth AFTER he analsyed Stephen Jones's samples ? It would be very telling if he had not been a member before he saw the samples but became a member after he had analysed them..
Archive.org has Basile on the list at February 19th 2007. That's their first record of the page, so he may have been a member for longer.
 
Big Oops.

I thought about this some more, and realized that my 1/4,000 figure is way off. First of all, 200 * 200 is 40,000.

Secondly, the intensity is in units of energy / time * area. If you pick your units such that you 200 m = 1 metamars (to make up a cool name for a unit of length), if you follow my spurious logic for calculating relative intensity, clearly something is wrong, as you would get the same value.

What I had done was calculated the relative intensity at 200 m vs. 1 m. But a 2 mm chip will have a dropoff more like

(.002)^2 / 200^2 = .000004 / 40000 = 0.0000000001

or 1 / 10,000,000,000

Your math is clearly flawed, or I wouldn't be able to see individual welders working on the new buildings near ground zero from several miles away in NJ. By your math, the light from the welding would be trillions of times less intense at that distance.

As we've already clearly established, the chip that jones examined is way to thin to have done anything at all to a column. The magic thermite would have to be layed on much thicker, and as such there would be larger chunks than 2mm knocked off the columns in the impact. I stand by my idea that we'd see lots of them blasted out and ignited by the impact if there was enough to do any damage to the columns and it could be ignited at 430C.
 
You didn't specify any particular type of red paint, implying that there should be multiple types of red paint that will look just like Jones' "paint chips". Indeed, perhaps you were implying that all paint chips consisting of red paint and primer would look like Jones', upon close examination. Were you?

But you're missing the point. He shouldn't have to specify, had Jones' paper been any good, it would have specified EXACTLY what was used, and how everything else was ruled out. It didn't, and that's one of the many reasons the paper is a failure.
 
Since you would not believe me if I told you....I suggest you google it and find out for yourself. It's a rewarding experience to gain knowledge through your own research.

Welcome to the truther version of 'A Wizard Did It'.
 
My guess is that several posters could add a couple pages if they would care to tell us how cognitive dissonance feels right now.

This is explosive stuff (no pun intended). :cool:

Let's just wait and see if Jones' "findings" resonate in the real scientific community.

Be careful not to get too ahead of yourselves, that's a pretty big matzo ball hanging out there.
 
Suppose we had to stop considering the paint as an alternative for the thermite chips ? Is that it then ? Does that mean that the Jones paper becomes the autoritative work on the WTC dust- meaning , as it does that 9/11 was an inside job ?

I think you mean "authoritative work on the WTC red/gray chips". (Certainly, it's subject isn't even the dust, as a whole, so how could it be authoritative?)

In this layman's opinion, there are far too many questions to consider the Jones, et. al., paper authoritative. E.g., the screamingly obvious question of whether or not you can create Al/Si in platelet form. I leave it to domain experts to tell us whether the test used by Jones, et. al., is foolproof for identifying elemental Al. If it is, then it's probably academic as to whether or not the methodology to create Al/Si in platelet form can be determined.

Notice that I used the word "probably", in the last sentence. These sort of issues should be debated by domain experts, not "truthers" and "debunkers". If "truthers" and "debunkers" want to entertain themselves, fine, but as you can see from this thread, e.g., it's not very enlightening.

I repeat what I've said before: 911 truthers are fools if they go running to debunkers, media, or government, at the expense of taking this paper to domain experts. And domain experts are not going to pay any attention to the paper, unless they are directed there. The Bentham Journal that this paper was published in has only been around for less than 2 years. I expect that only a tiny fraction of the scientific community reads it "regularly". In it's less than 2 years of existence, there's only 12 articles.

If the paper holds up, then it's fine to try and push it further to government and media. If it doesn't hold up, why would any reasonable and honest person want to push forward something that's a mistake, in the name of "truth"?

(Another possibility is that the paper will simply be considered doubtful, with insufficient evidence to convince a community of domain experts, who are paying attention to it, one way or the other.)
 
Partial translation of interview with Niels Harrit, regarding the Bentham paper.

1:02 Interviewer: What are those chips?

1:04 Niels Harrit: Its nanothermite. That is a, let me take the last part of
the word first. A thermite is a chemical expression for compound that is
pulverized aluminum and rust, pulverized rust. Its an old invention from
1893 and if you can get the compound to react, then it develops an
enormous amount of heat. 2500 degree. Iron is formed in the process
and the hot iron, you can use to melt other iron, you can also use it to
weld railroad tracks.

An old fashion thermite, it develops heat, but in a nanothermite, the
particles are so small and they react with each other so fast that it
beings to reassemble, or it becomes an explosive. You also have the
opportunity to mix other components in, it is more complicated than
just iron and rust, there is more things in it, that makes it an explosive.

2:19 Interviewer: We are going to watch a clip. What are we going to watch?

2:23 Niels Harrit: We going to watch the collapse of the north tower.
Where you can see the explosions directly.
It's like a mushroom cloud everything, is ejected up in the
air.
There is some of those 30 tons steel beam that is ejected
110m away.
There is some of those explosions that is ejected out of
the window, that has speeds of 100 mph.


3:10 Clip of the collapse of the north tower is showed and yellow arrows point to “scribs” below the crush zone.

3:24 Niels Harrit: Ok, the issue about ejection up in the air, pay attention to
the fragments, it is giant steel beams we talking about.
They are ejected up in the air in some large,
it's called parabolic, arch formed, trajectories.


3:34 Interviewer: There was two yellow arrows that indicated
something below the crush zone?

3:39 Niels Harrit: It is obvious explosions, that are set off to early, its
complicated business these things. They (The
scribs/puffs) are well below the crush zone.
The argument where you imagine that the puffs coming
out from the side should be caused by the collapsing floors
are clearly disproved by those yellow arrows.


3:59 Interviewer:If there is some that think, that those that believe in this
are very crazy, can you understand this?

4:04 Niels Harrit: Hehe, If we going to look at what happened. then there
has been a crime, ok?, there is 3000 people that died that
day and there has never been a judicial investigation, police
investigation of that event.
There has never been any evidence presented, there is no
one charged in this case. The police, FBI has
not charged anybody. Nobody is wanted, so i do not know
who is the crazy?


Source:
URL:---.youtube.com/watch?v=nP810ssxyo4

Regards
Scientiae Confidimus

The bolded parts are not about the "Bentham paper". It's pure unscientific and unsubstanciated speculation, that has nothing to do with thermite.

See, their paper isn't about the samples, it's about validating anyway possible their crazy controlled demolition theory. These guys are not scientists, they're ideologues, they have a political agenda to push.
 
Quite the contrary. You believe that an office fire is more devastating to structural steel than thermate. What room at the asylum are you living in again?

Here it is Kreel. Specify the amount of thermite used because there is zero evidence of any thermite used on any steel at the WTC; it would stand out. Thermite was made up by Jones and it is the dumbest ideas since beam weapons and nukes used to bring down the WTC. So you picked the dumbest idea to use for your idiotic delusion. How dumb does the idea have to be for you to fall for it?

Next please tell us the amount used. The office fire is bigger and even the jet fuel is bigger. But you failed to do the work to understand 911. Failure is the paper and your ideas on 911 because you can’t tell me how much thermite was used and all the idiotic scenarios by 911Truth Hoffman and Jones are brain dead stupid. And you can’t explain any real scenario or amount, or the heat in joules released by your failed brain-dead thermite stupid scenario. Zero ability to do the math or specify the amount of thermite used. Office fires have more heat energy; and you can’t figure it out. Why? You failed to gain and education in over 7 years? You don’t think for yourself but you post lies, hearsay, failed opinions and fantasy.
 
And domain experts are not going to pay any attention to the paper, unless they are directed there. The Bentham Journal that this paper was published in has only been around for less than 2 years. I expect that only a tiny fraction of the scientific community reads it "regularly". In it's less than 2 years of existence, there's only 12 articles.

Maybe the best way to get "attention" would be to publish in a better peer-review journal?
 
I've alluded to the magnetism of different oxide layers or products before, so search hematite, maghemite and my name and you'll get the post in this thread.

With Jones' chips it's slightly more difficult, because we can't see the underside of the "gray layer".

That seems to be another issue Jones has left open, then. If Marseille's analysis is really the same as Jones', I'd guess the chips are from the same source , so it would be odd if Jones' chips didn't also have the metal crystals on the bottom -- especially since that would explain why all the chips could be collected with a magnet. If Jones' chips DO have metal crystals hanging on them, that would a "curious" omission from the paper, wouldn't it.

I still think we could cut to the chase if someone could get some paint samples from the actual WTC steel, if there are still some in that hanger at JFK.
 
Hi fellas,

Couple of questions:

1) anyone know what the ignition temp for ordinary paint flakes might be?
2) Is there any documentation to show that real thermite can be engineered to ignite at 430c?
3) don't explosives have to be specially shaped into cutting charges in order to blast thru steel columns? I fail to see a single scrap of real-world data that suggests a 'painted on' layer of combustible material can destroy steel.... isn't this an outrageous assumption?
4) Do common paints contain 'nano' engineered materials?

ps Jones at least gave a clue about the paint they used as a control. We know for a fact now that there WASN'T a sincere attempt to match it to WTC paints, nor to determine the composition of WTC paints, before and after fires, in order to eliminate them as a source of the grey/red chips.

All that needs to be done then, is for an independent lab to get hold of some WTC paint chips and look at the composition. Any suggestions for how this might be accomplished?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom