What sort of numpty is Jones? The man cannot even read a simple request. I don't give a flying <rule> what the paint was used on I want to know what it is. Manufacturers data sheet?
It's plainly obvious that he is dishonest when he pulls crap like that. Knowing Jones they probably had a wonder over to the stadium and peeled a bit of paint off.
This thread has run it's course as far as I'm concerned, because it's become infected with the crazy and good posts are lost in the sea of ever deepening rubbish. Time to go elsewhere.
Since you have claimed to have identified some of the constituents of the chips, with great certainty, I should think that producing similar SEM, etc., should be quite easy for you, even without knowing the exact type of paint. You said
(emphasis mine)Bearing in mind I have shown beyond any reasonable doubt that samples a-d are hematite and red paint
You didn't specify any particular type of red paint, implying that there should be multiple types of red paint that will look just like Jones' "paint chips". Indeed, perhaps you were implying that all paint chips consisting of red paint and primer would look like Jones', upon close examination. Were you?
Furthermore, you (or somebody else) could call BYU maintenance, and ask them about the stadium paint. I completely agree that Jones, et. al., should have identified it clearly, in their paper, but they didn't.
I have to wonder if, in fact, you are basically guessing re Jones' chips. Were you perhaps exaggerating, and instead you merely suspect, or believe wholeheartedly, that a small minority of red paint chip varieties will look like Jones' sample, and thus you will have to make many batches before you can re-create the Jones' type? Are you afraid of having to make many types of red paint chip before you hit the right one?
Perhaps Mackey's comment pooh-poohing the notion of the grey layer being "primer" has caused you to doubt?
Recall Mackey's words:
I surmise that the magnetic effects have nothing to do with hematite or aluminum, but are instead are caused by pure iron, due to flakes of the steel columns themselves (or some other incidental source of iron) stuck to the paint fragments. Rust layers and spall matches this effect perfectly.
Would you be so kind as to comment on this? Also, is it too much to ask that you also show us some detailed pictures of "Rust layers and spall" stuck to red paint? The Jones' pictures show relatively even layers, but I am suspicious about rusty paint chips being anywhere near this even. You could help settle the matter by also producing SEMs of rusty paint chips.