[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not true.


This peer reviewed scientific paper says their was.


Until a scientific paper is published to scientifically undermine it( as yet such ISNT the case), gill plate flapping and jumping up and down and screaming carries zero cerebral weight. None. Zilch. Nada.

Especially from you 19.99 Wal-mart starter kit teenage chemists around here
Thermite is not an explosive. The chips are not claimed to be a residue, but are postulated to be the actual material. However, without an example of real nanothermite to compare it to, they are only speculating. The fact that the refuse to identify the paint that they are using for comparison further proves that they have nothing. Since this is published in a vanity rag and not a recognized, legitimate peer-reviewed journal, it means nothing.
 
sorry to inform you, but a single paper by one group of scientists with a single set of UNVERIFIED, UNREPEATED results, does not proof make.

Try again later.

TAM:)

The experiments were repeated several times, read the paper. And the referees confirmed and verified the findings.

The Architects for 9/11 Truth have also confirmed the findings, as well as the Scholars for 9/11 Truth & Justice.

You are mixed up.

The peer reviewed study merely confimed what most 9/11 experts already had proven, that explosives took down the WTC.
 
Thermite is not an explosive. The chips are not claimed to be a residue, but are postulated to be the actual material. However, without an example of real nanothermite to compare it to, they are only speculating. The fact that the refuse to identify the paint that they are using for comparison further proves that they have nothing. Since this is published in a vanity rag and not a recognized, legitimate peer-reviewed journal, it means nothing.

So says you, a bucket with a huge hole in the bottom of it.

If its junk science, like you regurgitatingly state, i expect we will see a scientific rebuttal in short order....right??
 
Thermite is not an explosive. The chips are not claimed to be a residue, but are postulated to be the actual material. However, without an example of real nanothermite to compare it to, they are only speculating. The fact that the refuse to identify the paint that they are using for comparison further proves that they have nothing. Since this is published in a vanity rag and not a recognized, legitimate peer-reviewed journal, it means nothing.

thermite cuts through WTC steel beams like a hot knife through butter. You are just playing word games.
 
So says you, a bucket with a huge hole in the bottom of it.

If its junk science, like you regurgitatingly state, i expect we will see a scientific rebuttal in short order....right??
Since this vanity rag is not read by legitimate scientists, it won't happen. Nobody would want to waste the $600 to post a rebuttal for an unknown paper that the scentific community will never see. However, scientists like Dr. Greening have torn the paper apart and have attempted to contact Jones et al. Like the other times, Jones will not release all data pertaining to his experiments.
 
So says you, a bucket with a huge hole in the bottom of it.

If its junk science, like you regurgitatingly state, i expect we will see a scientific rebuttal in short order....right??

Not unless it gets on the scientific radar first. You really think anyone but a few people here at the JREF, and several hundred truthers are waiting with baited breath for the next issue of Bentham's Sham Journal to come out.

Oh My

TAM:)
 
T

The Architects for 9/11 Truth have also confirmed the findings, as well as the Scholars for 9/11 Truth & Justice.

submit the evidence to an independent lab for independent analysis. if they say there is thermite in there, then i will believe.
 
This is the same fraud the creationists pull.

Trying to do and end run around real science while dishonestly proclaiming themselves legitimate.

They think most people are as easily fooled by such tactics as they themselves are.
 
The experiments were repeated several times, read the paper. And the referees confirmed and verified the findings.

The Architects for 9/11 Truth have also confirmed the findings, as well as the Scholars for 9/11 Truth & Justice.

You are mixed up.

The peer reviewed study merely confimed what most 9/11 experts already had proven, that explosives took down the WTC.

1. INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED AND REPEATED!!!
2. Please provide your proof that the "referees" independently repeated and verified the tests that Jones performed on the chips. I certainly am not going to take your or Jones word for it.
3.The rest of your comment is pure crap.

TAM:)
 
Another thing that we know - from the NIST report and the experiment in Appendix D (where we get the nice photo from) we know that the steels natural oxide layer will spall (fall off in laymens terms) at 650°C. Therefore if the layer of red paint which Jones claims is thermite ever heated up then a 650°C the oxide layer would spall removing the thermite from contact with the steel. The oxide layer is brittle - we see that in Jones' own SEM photographs Fig 4 and 5 and we know that rust is incoherent (crystally) with the parent material so any thermal shock such as quick heating and it's going to spall.

We should congratulate Jones because the only piece of science Jones has done is to clear up the source or a source of his microspheres:

A source of micro-spheres in the WTC dust is burnt paint.

which means that anyone stripping paint with a blow torch whether it be at home or cleaning the Brooklyn Bridge or whatever, if they are stripping red paint they will be producing iron rich microspheres.

Thank you, you've been a lovely audience, good night and god bless (or be touched by his noodley appendage)

Good night

Bow.
 
This is the same fraud the creationists pull.

Trying to do and end run around real science while dishonestly proclaiming themselves legitimate.

They think most people are as easily fooled by such tactics as they themselves are.

You are acting like a flat-earther. Galileo vanquished them 400 years ago!

:k:
 
Has your open letter to Gage been published in a peer reviewed scientific journal? It has been over a year now, and plenty of time to do it.

I would even be impressed if it were published by a vanity journal.

I'll send that right in to a major journal as soon as you post your links.
 
If there was a conspiracy to doctor the tape, someone would have talked by now.

Do I even need to comment on the hilarity of this quote?

I'll let you guys continue your game of 'smack-a-troll', which is similar to 'whack-a-mole' but with a less intelligent victim..:flamed:

Back to Jones/Robertson in 2006, referring to the pools of molten metal (more 'proof of thermite, you see):
'this metal is primarily iron, not aluminum, it also contains traces of unusual trace metals, in unusual quantities anyway, such as Barium and ....Manganese and Zinc...in large quantities. And so these are consistent with a chemical reaction on a large scale'

Cut to 2009, what happened to all the Zinc which used to be proof of thermite? Now the official line is ABSENCE of Zinc is proof of thermite....

But it gets worse.. By carrying out the (highly improbable) almost complete application of this thermite material to structural steel, it would be found all over the place throughout both towers.
No question there.

How then, considering all the structural steel recovered after the collapses, was this material NOT observed by anyone? Remember, truthers, the INTACT steel that was found in large quantities was NOT melted away by thermite. It is not possible that some of the 'thermite paint' would not still be found on the steel. No way.

This is 100% incompatible with the latest paper of Jones et al.

It does not fit. So you must acquit. (nod to Johnny C)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom