[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
The thing that bothers me most about the Jones, et. al. paper is that, on the one hand, I've never heard of elemental Al ( + Si ) in platelet form, while all nanothermite powders that I am aware of have elemental Al in spherical particles. Not saying it can't be done, but how on earth could Jones, et. al, not have anticipated this issue, and at least noted that they hadn't resolved it, yet? I'm not a material scientist, but my money is on material scientists demanding more proof that elemental-Al/Si platelets can even exist.
Excellent post. I'll apologise now for having a go earlier (I was a bit tired and irritable from work) because with this post it's obvious that you have the ability to think and reason clearly, and come up with very good questions.

This is something that I have been meaning to get on about but haven't had a chance but seeing as you mention it.

All of the materials that I have seen for particulates of either Fe2O3 or Al have been crystals or spheres in the order of magnitude of 1µm. I haven't seen platelets of Al. I have no idea how you can manufacture platelets that small and have them contain both SiO2 and elemental Al and keep the platelet as a structure. Surely we would see individual particles of (elemental) Al just as clearly as we see sub-micron rhomboidal crystals of Fe2O3 in the red layer.

If as Jones claims the elemental Aluminium separates from these Al/Si/O platelets then he should be able to demonstrate, a before and after, 50,000x resolution shot, of the degradation (shape change) of theses platelets and clear distinct shapes of the now freed elemental Aluminium.

Why has he not done so?

Edit: Also note that the chip he claims the Al separated from is not one of the samples a-d, it's red layer spectrum is distinctly different and it did not have any detailed SEM work or photos produced (which would show Rhomboidal Fe203 and these platelets) before or after immersion in MEK.
 
Last edited:
...and that is the crux of your problem, alien. You are assuming that the material was not universally applied.

Once you crack the means with which the towers were demolished, the evidence discovered by Jones becomes insurmountable.

Government hacks - like the majority of posters in this thread - simply lack the power to deduce how the towers were demolished.

KreeL, if it was universally applied to the extent that it would effect the stability of the entire structure, you are talking about nearly the same mass as all the steel. On the order of 100,000 tons per building. I hope you can see that implementing your theory in practice would be an impossibility. This would also reduce the safety factor to a dangerously low level, at least in the core.
 
If, by "little chips", you mean chips the size of Professor Jones' sample, certainly not. They're hard to see with the naked eye - how could you see them in photos taken hundreds of feet away? Also, their range will be tiny, due to air resistance (drag).

Even thicker ones would have, I would guess, a range more like DIME weapons. Good for igniting kerosene fuel, perhaps, but lousy for emulating fireworks.

A chip the size of jones' sample, if it was thermite, would be easily visible from a long distance when ignited (thermite burns brighter than the sun) and air resistance wouldn't be an issue as the small chips would easily be blown out of the building by the large fireball.
 
Are nano-materials relatively heavier than their standard counterparts ? If the particles are ground so fine that they can enter even mcro-structures such as the human cell you could get an awful lot of them in a cubic inch.
Look up particles size distribution and packing density. That will answer your excellent question.

This is very relevant because for example if you were using 2 powders then you can never achieve full density because the particles will always leave gaps - packing density is a way of measuring a giving how dense a powdered material is.

Couldn't find a decent article on "Packing Density" so here's a quick

For example - get an ice cream tub. Fill it with marbles (of the same size) in the most efficient way possible (so most space is taken up). Now pour water into the tub. Take the marbles out. Pour the water into a measuring jug and take the reading. Put water back into the ice cream tub and fill to the top with water and then pour that into a measuring jug and take the reading.

The ratio between the two is the packing density of the marbles.

Now use marbles of different sizes. Does the packing density increase or decrease?
 
I've got another buzzword for your list: structural nanofoils, p. 6, here.



(emphasis mine)

One can imagine fuel tanks incorporating thick nanofoils, which "ignite with high heat" on impact, giving a spectacular fireball. In this case, there'd be no need to mess with the buildings at all.
No nanofoil needed for your doltish paranoid claim.



Why do you display such stupid statements? The impacts of flight 11 and 175 had large fireballs because that is what happens when the engines are running the jet is smashed while smashing the ground or a building. At least you have a delusion as big as Jones' paper.

Before you get your mind in overdrive the nanofoil is real, but your idea is pure poppycock save for adding to the idiotic scenarios of the dirt dumb 911Truth movement as you add more people responsible for 911.

Sorry, a jet at 470 and 590 mph with the engines running at and above cruise as they were on 911 give you a giant fireball. I can prove it, but I was beat by reality, and studies, and experience. At least you like to apologizes for the terrorist by implying other people beside 19 terrorists are murderers. Sad pathetic people makes up lies like Jones and 911Truth to satisfied some perverted bias they have. What is your anti-intellectual bias to make you spew delusions and make up lies?

Thermite? What a bunch of crap; standard products from a large building destroyed on 911 have been found and Jones leaves out all the possibilities so he can back in his nut case evidence to make his delusion real to those who lack knowledge and the capacity to think for themselves. At least you are making up your own perverted ideas on 911.
 
Last edited:
Look at the entire episode of 9/11. You would have to be daft to actually believe that some guys that were working out on a jungle-gym in the desert suddenly became capable of piloting heavy commercial aircraft and defeated the air defenses of the United States.

Its funny when Truthers post things that emphasize and underscore their level of ignorant with regards to how things work.

"...piloting heavy commercial aircraft..."? You think that's difficult? You are a fool if you do.

"...defeated the air defenses of the United States?" Now THAT was a brilliant statement. My dog makes an equally brilliant statement every morning when I let him out. "Defeating" 4 NORAD alert aircraft in an air defense system that I'll admit had become lazy and complacent and accustomed to watching an ocean radar horizon that hadn't even had Soviet bombers fly past for a number of years is not my idea of anything special, especially when you consider hijacking an aircraft and killing the pilots to take over the cockpit would have been the most difficult part of the evolution. After that, your only enemy is time and when your intentions are to crash the aircraft into some skyscraper or a military headquarters, you don't need much time for that with a weapon that travels 7 miles a minute.
 
Moderators, please take note: Galileo outright admits that his intention is to troll.

Uh, the Mods have stated that the rules of JREF do not forbid trolling.therefore Trolling a permitted within certain limits.
I strongly disagree with this policy, but the Mods call the shots.
 
If the analysis of the grey mterial and the thermite residue shows that the particles are at the nanometer scale (one billionth of a meter) that is almost as suspicious as the thermite itself.
No and thrice no. Please stop with this silly insinuation that nano is somehow special or that only thermite or some super special material can contain material of a nano-scale. It's blatantly not true.

We have been producing powders and other materials that have a nano-scale for decades, it is nothing out of the ordinary. Stop being sucked in by this nano-obsession and go and look at materials in the real world. There are thousands of applications that when you look at them very closely with a SEM have structures on the nano-scale.

I used to work for a company in the satellite industry and they were always at teh cutting edge of micro-electronics. We had a program of looking at the best method for attaching "fine wire gold bonds" - wires between electrical components http://electronicmaterials.usask.ca/images/photos/photo13.gif - they were forever reducing the size of these things and we had to make sure that the bond on the bottom of the foot was solid. Foot - http://archive.evaluationengineering.com/archive/articles/0406/images/xrayFIG2.jpg. The wire was only 17.5µm thick.

Now we had to mount, grind and polish these sections in order to get a view through the foot like a cross-section, examine it under the microscope. http://www.emeraldinsight.com/fig/2180250106005.png which is astoundingly difficult to do and takes great skill.

That was a nano-sized material and that was in 1997. There is nothing special about nano.

What size does a material have to be before it's classified as a nano material? I'm after a general figure Bill.
 
If these two statements are true what can be the explanation ?

the gray layers are composed of an opaque homogenous material,''--Hoffman
'' while the gray only contains iron and oxygen--Danish Professor ''

Sunstealer says there was also some Carbon though I'd say it was likely to have been very little given that the Danish guy did not think it worth mentining in his statement above.

We know that properties can change at nano-levels including a change in colour. So maybe the grey stuff IS actualy iron and oxygen- just a nano variety.

If that is true the jig is up.
 
Last edited:
Please forgive me if this has been covered already but I posted the following on another forum comments?

The tests performed by Harrit et. al. to eliminate the possibility the chips were ordinary paint were inadequate, they only performed two

I] –

We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A multimeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the formula:

Specific resistivity = RA / L
where R = resistance (ohms); A = cross-sectional area (m2); L
= thickness (m).

Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 10*10 ohm-m [31].

There a few problems:

1) though they had several chips they only tested one, since they reported a six fold variance for energy output there is no reason to expect other characteristics to be consistent.
2) The chip as they noted was very small, the size of a grain of sand. They reported having much larger ones. No explanation was given as to why the only chip tested was one of the smallest ones they had or if this could if have led to an erroneous reading
3) The title of the cited paper is “Zinc-ferrite pigment for corrosion protection” which suggests the table in it only covers a very specific class of paint. It costs GBP £14.50 “and VAT where applicable” if anyone is willing to spend the money OR has free access. The title also indicates no one should be surprised to find iron on paint.

emeraldinsight.com/Insight/viewContentItem.do;jsessionid=8C534FEDD35CAB1C15D085260A224173?contentType=Article&hdAction=lnkhtml&contentId=876638

4) They never explain why resistivity to electrical current should be considered a defining characteristic of paint. A Google search for: "specific resistance" paint omhs turned up only 2 hits. Though the terms were on the same pages the specific resistance of paint wasn’t discussed in either.
5) They never explain why low resistivity should be considered indicative of the material being a thermitic compound

II] –

Another test, described above, involved subjection of red chips to methyl ethyl ketone solvent for tens of hours, with agitation. The red material did swell but did not dissolve, and a hard silicon-rich matrix remained after this procedure. On the other hand, paint samples in the same exposure to MEK solvent became limp and showed significant dissolution, as expected since MEK is a paint solvent.

This is also problematic because they never tell their readers what types of paint were tested. Thus they fell fall short of demonstrating that MEK dissolves all types of paint. I just e-mail someone who sells the solvent and asked and will report back either way.
 
from what sunstealer says about the gray layer:
"The "gray layer" looks more and more likely to be a flake of oxidised A36 steel - they are making excuses for the amount of Carbon present and if it is correct that there is an Mn peak at just under 6KeV in samples a,b and d then that's the clincher right there."

so if there are layers and layers of oxidised A36 steel then i can see the what u are saying but i highly doubt that.

so since some chips are multiple layered (6 layers), could that rule out oxidised A36 steel between each layer? and would the picture sunstealer posts "seperated at birth be void when speaking of these multiple layered chips?
I think I've answered that in another post - see page 31 of this thread.

What people have to realise is that the samples that Jones has are not all of the same type. This is an indicator that all of his samples are not thermite.

The NIST photo that i refer to ONLY relates to samples a-d in Jones' paper - nothing more nothing less. So yes it is void when talking about the other chips but I think I covered that in the earlier post - page 31.

You have to start looking very closely at each individual chip and the EDS data associated with each one. Only then will you see that the chips are indeterminably different - you cannot take them as a whole.
 
Physical Structure of the Chips:-

Chips having distinctive and similar physical features were found in all four of the dust samples, ranging in length from from about 0.2 to 3 mm. Each chip has stratified layers of two types: a red layer and a lighter gray layer, where each layer is between roughly 10 and 100 microns in thickness. Despite their small size, the chips are readily visible in the samples because of their flat shapes, distinctive color, and layered structure. The chips are tough despite being as thin as eggshells.

Magnification reveals that the gray layers are composed of an opaque homogenous material, whereas the red layers have small particles embedded in a matrix of slightly translucent material.

At magnification of 50,000 the structure of the two types of particles is clear: small bright particles having a faceted shape and measuring about 100 nm in diameter, and larger particles having a flat and often hexagonal shape and measuring about 1000 nm across and 40 nm thick.

The particles are held in place and in close proximity to each other by the porous matrix. Soaking the chips in methyl ethyl ketone, a solvent that dissolves paint, caused the red layer to swell while remaining intact.

Up to this point, I have reviewed only characteristics of the chips revealed by macro- and micro-scopic visual examination, but already the implications are stunning: the chips are clearly a nano-engineered material with two types of extremely small particles, each highly consistent in shape and size, held in close stable proximity by a durable matrix which is laminated to a hard homogenous material. The student of energetic materials will appreciate that this description matches exactly that of a super-thermite in which the reactant particles are suspended in a sol-gel matrix applied to a substrate.
http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/thermite/explosive_residues.html#chip_structure
Dross - it's already been shown in the paper that

Fe-rich grains and Al/Si plate-like particles and that these particles are embedded in a carbon-rich matrix.
in the paper. There is no need to quote the whole of that section. It does not match exactly the nature of nano-thermite, far from it. Stop going to truther sites and learn about the word nano.

The person who wrote what you quote has never ever sat in on an SEM session otherwise they wouldn't be so wowed. I do a facepalm everytime I see people with zero experience start waxing lyrical about this and that - they plainly have no clue.
 
Last edited:
***********************************************************************
''...The chips are tough despite being as thin as eggshells.''
'' Magnification reveals that the gray layers are composed of an opaque homogenous material,''

'' the chips are clearly a nano-engineered material with two types of extremely small particles, each highly consistent in shape and size, held in close stable proximity by a durable matrix which is laminated to a hard homogenous material.''

'' The particles are held in place and in close proximity to each other by the porous matrix.''
http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/thermite/explosive_residues.html#chip_structure.
********************************************************

the gray layers are composed of an opaque homogenous material,''--Hoffman
'' while the gray only contains iron and oxygen--Danish Professor ''

Surely he iron would have oxidised over the last seven years ? Rusted away even. There has to be more to this ?
It is rust most likely in the form of Hematite, see postings on this page and all my others. For rust to occur you need oxygen and water. These samples will have been kept in bags away from water hence why the rust hasn't completely vanished.

Opaque homogenous material! WTF! Opaque! Is he saying the "gray layer" is see through? Honestly these people have absolutely no clue, the last thing you can describe that material as is bloody opaque!

He doesn't even comment on the cracks and their morphology in the "gray layer", clearly indicating a brittle material. oh /facepalm, it's too much stupid to comprehend.

:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp
 
Is the paint argument holding it's own ? I'm not sure that it is. The paint s all there is though as far as I can see. Concerned citizens reading this thread might be starting to form conclusions.
 
Not to make excuses for NIST, but they certainly had time and budget constraints. They also made other mistakes that worked against their conclusions.

Gordon's theory is pure conjecture and is refuted by the sound recordings (on videos) of the collapses. Any explosive that could sever steel would be heard clearly and blow out windows. Neither was observed. I cover this in my Open Letter to Richard Gage and compare sound levels to actual demolitions...easy to find on google.

Greg;

Thank you for the thoughtful comments.

I would say that the discovery of the nano-thermite shows that the explosions might not be picked up on tape, if that is really the case that they weren't. I heard a lot of loud noises that day.

Many windows were blown out by steel beams that flew 500 feet through the air.
 
metamars said:
One can imagine fuel tanks incorporating thick nanofoils, which "ignite with high heat" on impact, giving a spectacular fireball. In this case, there'd be no need to mess with the buildings at all.

No nanofoil needed for your doltish paranoid claim.

]Why do you display such stupid statements? The impacts of flight 11 and 175 had large fireballs because that is what happens when the engines are running the jet is smashed while smashing the ground or a building. At least you have a delusion as big as Jones' paper.

Reminds me of the argument/claims by some of the Truthers of a missile that was fired a nanosecond before impact with the WTC to help open a hole for the aircraft.

What a 500 or 1000 lb blast frag warhead is going to do to "open a hole" for a 90-ton compilation of aluminum and titanium and steel and fuel and people traveling at 7 miles a minute is really pretty funny to even think of.

But, that is the Truther Way.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand this. According to you, samples a-d are not thermite. Call this set A. Therefore, according to you, yet another chip, not a member of A, cannot be thermite.

If U is the universal set, then the multilayer chip is in U - A. But U - A contains thermite chips (well, I suppose that's debatable : - ), including a subset of multilayer thermite chips . Thus, U - A contains multilayer thermite chips, but you are claiming that the fact that Jones' multilayer thermite chip is in U - A is the reason that it is not thermite.

Contradiction
Sorry I wasn't clear enough. Chip seen in Fig 31 is significantly different to samples a-d, therefore he cannot claim that both are thermite. He is claiming that both are thermite. It's a no go.

Bearing in mind I have shown beyond any reasonable doubt that samples a-d are hematite and red paint then sample from Fig 31 must be looked at in more detail. Having done that then I can conclude that that one is even further away from what thermite can be.

The chips are obviously paint, but from different sources. Why is it so hard to imagine that amongst the dust samples collected are flecks of paint from many different sources.

The largest element reported in the dust was Titanium iirc (must find the link to the substantial report) due to all of the white paint present in the samples (TiO2)

(Unless you are now going to claim that multi-layer thermite chips did not even exist on 9/11 - good luck proving that.)
No, obviously not but how hard is it to realise that some one paints an item once every year, producing 5 layers of primer and 5 layers of paint and that a tiny bit of this flecks off and is collected in the sample? There are literally thousands of sources for this material to have come from or are truthers suggesting that the only building painted in NY is the WTC? One of the samples was collected from close to the Brooklyn Bridge - I bet there is a hell of alot of paint flaking off of that each year.

Would you be good enough to create a 6 layer paint chip, and take SEM pictures, and so on, to show to the world that you can create 6 layer paint chips that are dead ringers for Jones' ?
Why - any layered substance is going to show layers in a SEM.

Infact I'll do it and that's a promise. I will use the exact same paint that Jones used in the MEK test.......

...... damn, metamars, be a good chap will you and find the bit in Jones' report where it details what paint he used. Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom