Sunstealer
Illuminator
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2007
- Messages
- 3,128
Excellent post. I'll apologise now for having a go earlier (I was a bit tired and irritable from work) because with this post it's obvious that you have the ability to think and reason clearly, and come up with very good questions.The thing that bothers me most about the Jones, et. al. paper is that, on the one hand, I've never heard of elemental Al ( + Si ) in platelet form, while all nanothermite powders that I am aware of have elemental Al in spherical particles. Not saying it can't be done, but how on earth could Jones, et. al, not have anticipated this issue, and at least noted that they hadn't resolved it, yet? I'm not a material scientist, but my money is on material scientists demanding more proof that elemental-Al/Si platelets can even exist.
This is something that I have been meaning to get on about but haven't had a chance but seeing as you mention it.
All of the materials that I have seen for particulates of either Fe2O3 or Al have been crystals or spheres in the order of magnitude of 1µm. I haven't seen platelets of Al. I have no idea how you can manufacture platelets that small and have them contain both SiO2 and elemental Al and keep the platelet as a structure. Surely we would see individual particles of (elemental) Al just as clearly as we see sub-micron rhomboidal crystals of Fe2O3 in the red layer.
If as Jones claims the elemental Aluminium separates from these Al/Si/O platelets then he should be able to demonstrate, a before and after, 50,000x resolution shot, of the degradation (shape change) of theses platelets and clear distinct shapes of the now freed elemental Aluminium.
Why has he not done so?
Edit: Also note that the chip he claims the Al separated from is not one of the samples a-d, it's red layer spectrum is distinctly different and it did not have any detailed SEM work or photos produced (which would show Rhomboidal Fe203 and these platelets) before or after immersion in MEK.
Last edited:
