[Closed]Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center

Status
Not open for further replies.
Interesting. Yet I wonder how many on your list are on the government payroll in some way, shape, or form? Gee - appears to be all of them. If you can't spell 'Perdue{sic}' then look up their government grants and educate yourself.

According to your cult, everyone, no matter who is it, that doesn't play along with your cult, is on the gov't payroll. All the vicitims, every expert that disagrees, every person on the internet that disagrees, even me. We are all accused constantly of being paid off by the gov't.

Paranoid delusions and ridiculous nonsense like that don't cut it and only proves that your cult is full it.
 
Last edited:
You got a car AND a mansion!?!?!?!? Oh, my handler's going to hear about this one! All I got was a Yugo and a hotel room. Sheeze.

When I retired my deepest regret was losing the Black Helicopter.
 
***********************************************************************
''...The chips are tough despite being as thin as eggshells.''
'' Magnification reveals that the gray layers are composed of an opaque homogenous material,''

'' the chips are clearly a nano-engineered material with two types of extremely small particles, each highly consistent in shape and size, held in close stable proximity by a durable matrix which is laminated to a hard homogenous material.''

'' The particles are held in place and in close proximity to each other by the porous matrix.''
http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/thermite/explosive_residues.html#chip_structure.
********************************************************

the gray layers are composed of an opaque homogenous material,''--Hoffman
'' while the gray only contains iron and oxygen--Danish Professor ''

Surely he iron would have oxidised over the last seven years ? Rusted away even. There has to be more to this ?
 
Last edited:
Oh please dont leave out my new favorite
"nanofoil"
:dl:

I've got another buzzword for your list: structural nanofoils, p. 6, here.


Structural energetics. Formed in thick
sheets and rods, this material can bear loads
and act as structural members. The material
can be designed to ignite on impact or ignite
with high heat
for use in applications that
include missile skins and frames, shell casings,
and shape-charge liners.
(emphasis mine)

One can imagine fuel tanks incorporating thick nanofoils, which "ignite with high heat" on impact, giving a spectacular fireball. In this case, there'd be no need to mess with the buildings at all.
 
i found this interesting when one talks about these chips. they can be multiple layers.....
im wondering if that pic sunstealer has been posting would be valid with these chips that are 6 layers deep!!!!
Firstly let me say that I appreciate the questions and you asking them. The real loonytunes have turned up spouting nonsense and debasing the thread so I'm now only going to read and reply to anything sensible and I'll look to correlate some of the data in the paper using my posts on this thread.

Are you talking about Fig 31 on page 28 with regard to the 6 layers. (It would help if you could be more specific and lay your posts out a bit better so I can answer quicker - thanks).

People have to realise that there are a number of different chips in Jones' paper, that they are not all the same, nor did they have the same testing performed on them.

Samples and the tests performed.

a-d - Photo - EDS red - EDS gray - 1µm SEM analysis of red layer - BSE (one chip) - DSC
Unknown paint - MEK
Chip from sample 2 - Photo - EDS red - MEK - BSE
Chip Fig 31 - Photo - SEM photo - EDS gray layer (showing no Fe only C and O)

When you look at the data and compare the chips it's fair to say that samples a-d (c has a slightly different EDS red layer spectrum) are identical.

Chip from sample 2, we have no idea about because no detailed SEM work was performed and the EDS spectrum of the red layer (Fig 14) is completely different to samples a-d (Fig 7). They sidestep the issue by claiming S and Ca might be drywall contamination but don't show this. Therefore Sample 2 cannot be considered to be part of the same group as samples a-d.

Fig 31 chip. Again this is clearly different from the other samples - the optical photographs show this.

An example is shown in Fig. (31) which shows significant Pb along with C, O, Fe, and Al and displays multiple red and gray layers.
No other sample in the paper is showing significant Pb (Lead) in the red layer yet this chip was not considered for any testing in the DSC or with MEK.

Look at Fig 33 - EDS of the "gray layer" of chip in Fig 31. Now compare that with Fig 6 spectra. Notice the massive difference? The "gray layer" shows no Fe and a substantially higher C peak. This means that the "gray layer" in this chip is not an iron oxide.

So we have two clear distinctions between samples a-d and chip in Fig 31 - Significant Pb in the red layer, significant C in the "gray layer" but without Fe

Therefore this chip cannot be classified as being part of the samples a-d. Subsequently it cannot be claimed to be thermite.

And that neatly answers your question with regard to the "at birth photo". That photo is exactly what it is - a direct comparison between NIST experiment and the 4 chip samples a-d in Jones' paper. Nothing else, it does not compare to anything else. The chip in Fig 31 with the multiple layers does not compare to anything else. This fact should set alarm bells ringing because the two cannot both be thermite yet Jones is claiming they are.

So why do we have these discrepancies?

Well when we look at the source of the samples and then how these chips where separated then it's not hard to see that not all of the particles/chips come from the same source, namely the WTC columns.

This is blindingly obvious to anyone who has more than 2 minutes to think about it. How many sources of paint or other material are there in this New York area? Dozens, hundreds, thousands, millions? Could some samples not be from the WTC but for example the Brooklyn bridge or other skyscrapers? Only if you start off with the premise that all of the chips in Jones' paper are thermite will you have a problem with realising that there are significant discrepancies between chips in the paper therefore one of them cannot be what Jones claims.

What Jones et al should have done before they even started any experiment was to characterize the chips they have from each of the different dust samples - give each one a label and then group them by visual characteristic. This would also help to determine exactly which chips should go for further testing. Instead it looks like they have picked identical chips for SEM/EDS/DSC. I would have wanted that chip with the multiple layers as part of the samples a-d without a shadow of a doubt because it's different.


from a controlled demo line of thought, maybe these were premade in sheets and one could just wrap multiple layers of this stuff depending upon the thickness of the steel one wished to attack??
I'll give you the courtesy you deserver and not be rude even though I find the idea, well lets say strange. The gray layer in the red chips is brittle in nature - you can tell this by looking at Fig4 and Fig 5 b) and d). It's not going to transport well and certainly would not be able to be rolled up without cracking all of it into tiny pieces. At 20µm thick they are going to be incredibly fragile and prone to damage - infact they'll just fall apart. Which rules it out completely.

Have a think about the logistics of using that method - how big are the sheets? How do you transport them? They are around 20µm thick so how are they going to support their own weight and not get damaged in the handling process? How do you attach them to columns? etc, etc.

http://www.911blogger.com/node/19761

"Indeed, not all the chips are bi-layered as we noted in the paper!
See Fig. 31 for an example. Note that there is gray material on both
sides of the red material in the upper right area; I count six
distinct layers in this chip.
Dr. Basile has independently noted such
chips also, with multiple layers of red and gray. Why do such
multi-layered chips appear? There seems to be an important clue here,
worth exploring IMO."
Answered above. Yes it's an important clue and there is a precise, easily understood, down to earth explanation.

These multi-layered chips are not the same as samples a-d, therefore not thermite, they come from who knows where and are more likely to be paint on a sealant or epoxy that anything else. Do you scrape of all the paint to bear metal or wall everytime you paint something? No? Well how many layers do you think will build up over the years?

It's not hard to work out now is it?
 
One can imagine fuel tanks incorporating thick nanofoils, which "ignite with high heat" on impact, giving a spectacular fireball. In this case, there'd be no need to mess with the buildings at all.

So UA and AA are in on it? They would have to be for your little fantasy to work.
 
If a thermite coating was all over the columns, and could be ignited by the heat of the plane crash, wouldn't all of the little chips knocked loose in the impact and ignited by the fireball be easily visible? Thermite burns very bright white, the impact would have looked like a starburst firework.
 
Last edited:
I've got another buzzword for your list: structural nanofoils, p. 6, here.



(emphasis mine)

One can imagine fuel tanks incorporating thick nanofoils, which "ignite with high heat" on impact, giving a spectacular fireball. In this case, there'd be no need to mess with the buildings at all.


Go ahead boy genius, lets see you weld it into tanks/tubes/structural shapes

:dl:
Still waiting for a steel destruction demonstration.

One can imagine fuel tanks incorporating thick nanofoils,
No sorry. we cant imagine, we are not psyco/delusional. Your conspiracy grows by leaps and bounds. I can imagine thick nanofoil hats for moron truthers.


The Inflationary Model of Conspiracy Theories

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2320446#post2320446

part two

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2323813#post2323813
 
Last edited:
Professor Niels Harrit said the following:-

''The red part of the splinter contain carbon, oxygen, aluminum, silicon and iron, while the gray only contains iron and oxygen. Splinter are magnetic.''
http://www.911truth.org/article.php?story=20090406135508204


Does he mean that the grey material contains only iron and oxygen or is composed of only iron and oxygen ?

If it's the last one it is a recipe for rust and if it's the first one then what is the grey material itself ?

Maybe this is a crazy question but can somebody enlighten me ?
No the sample doesn't just contain Fe and O - look at Fig 6 and tell me what the peak with the C is?

Page 12 states

The four spectra in Fig.(6) indicate that the gray layers are consistently characterized by high iron and oxygen content including a smaller amount of carbon.

Why do you consistently fail to read this paper? What is it about the majority of truthers and their inability to read. Harrit is incorrect - his own bloody data and text in his own report that he co-wrote shows him to be incorrect - stop quoting people who can't read their own paper and quote from the report or comment on Fig 6. I'm almost of the opinion that the SEM and EDS data for samples a-d, along with some of the language was actually written by a materials engineer/metallurgist/SEM operator and then Jones et al changed some of it and added their own comments such as "intimate mixing" which no-one with a clue would ever use.

I can't find the specific reference as to why they dismiss the Carbon peak. But Fe and C is likely to be steel. Add in the O and it looks like oxidised steel. There is the possibility on an Mn peak at 5.9KeV on smaples a), b) and d) in fig 6. That would indicate steel without any doubt.

What are the alloying elements of A36 steel?

by wt% 0.29C max, 0.80–1.2Mn, 0.04P, 0.05S, 0.15–0.3Si, bal Fe. (P and S are always quoted because they are considered impurities and are detrimental to the properties of steel and are removed as much as possible in the steel making process - Mn is added so that Manganese Sulphide (MnS is formed) rather S segregating and forming FeS at grain boundaries (recognise the FeS anyone?) - Si is either for fluidity or grain refinement)

There is the issue of colour and magnetism of this "gray layer", but when you understand that steel exposed to high temperatures like those seen in the WTC that the oxidised layer becomes hematite which is dark in colour and magnetic. See here for details http://www-staff.lboro.ac.uk/~mprlh/

So what is the most likely conclusion?
 
If a thermite coating was all over the columns, and could be ignited by the heat of the plane crash, wouldn't all of the little chips knocked loose in the impact and ignited by the fireball be easily visible? Thermite burns very bright white, the impact would have looked like a starburst firework.

If, by "little chips", you mean chips the size of Professor Jones' sample, certainly not. They're hard to see with the naked eye - how could you see them in photos taken hundreds of feet away? Also, their range will be tiny, due to air resistance (drag).

Even thicker ones would have, I would guess, a range more like DIME weapons. Good for igniting kerosene fuel, perhaps, but lousy for emulating fireworks.
 
If, by "little chips", you mean chips the size of Professor Jones' sample, certainly not. They're hard to see with the naked eye - how could you see them in photos taken hundreds of feet away? Also, their range will be tiny, due to air resistance (drag).

Even thicker ones would have, I would guess, a range more like DIME weapons. Good for igniting kerosene fuel, perhaps, but lousy for emulating fireworks.

So you allege chips and reactions which cannot be seen with the naked eye took out columns a man cannot wrap his arms around?
 
as for the calcium:
"The large Ca and S peaks may be
due to contamination with gypsum from the pulverized wallboard
material in the buildings."
Please make an effort to at least make your posts easier to read - cutting and pasting with no formatting makes your posts almost unintelligible and it would be handy to put the page number of the report when you quote from it so we can find it easily (thanks), however, you ask good questions (a truther exception) and deserve a civil response.

One of the most ironic things about this paper is the lack of S in the majority of spectra. Truthers have been screaming about how S in thermite is able to liquefy steel (I wonder who that could be ;)) yet there is no significant quantity of S in the data.

We have had people saying that the only source of S is thermite and dismiss wall board and gypsum out of hand. Now we have Jones et al claiming that the S in their samples is not part of the thermite but possible contamination with gypsum!!

Truthers - which is it?

The whole point of adding S to thermite is to produce a higher flame temperature and make ignition easier, but guess what it's not in this 10µm layer of "thermite" - why not? It's been a crucial component of the thermite theory for ages. Why is it not there?

If they think that the Ca and S is contamination then they have the very tool to find out - a SEM. What they should do is go in at a higher resolution and find these particles they think are gypsum and confirm, not lazily wave it away with a possibility. It's these possibilities that alot of truthers then take up as definites when they are clearly not. What other sources of Ca and S could there be?

Well Ca is most likely Calcium Carbonate - it's widely used in a huge number of applications (including paint). Zinc Sulphate is also very common.

This is the exact reason why EDS/EDX/XEDS is not good for determining compounds and finding out what a material is. It does not distinguish between crystal types and only picks out elements. Using this data for any conclusion is not advised. With simpler samples you can determine compounds but it's best to use the built in semi-quantitative EDS/EDX/XEDS software. Jones et al have not done this.


What we really want is XRD analysis - this will tell us EXACTLY what this material is. I've found a place in the USA that will take posted samples from around the world and charge $40 for the service. These samples need to have that test performed.

Screwing around with the SEM is a pointless exercise with these samples, because it can only give so much information.
 
Mods:

Please move this to the mental pygmies section.

The people here have no interest in rational or scientific discussion.

I am very disappointed in the quality of the James Randi forum.

This person's argument reminds me of the guy who said he was going to launch a rocket to the sun. When told he's burn up before he got there, he replied that he already thought of that and he would launch at night.

He then asked if the discussion could be moved to the mental pygmies section.
 
These multi-layered chips are not the same as samples a-d, therefore not thermite,

I don't understand this. According to you, samples a-d are not thermite. Call this set A. Therefore, according to you, yet another chip, not a member of A, cannot be thermite.

If U is the universal set, then the multilayer chip is in U - A. But U - A contains thermite chips (well, I suppose that's debatable : - ), including a subset of multilayer thermite chips . Thus, U - A contains multilayer thermite chips, but you are claiming that the fact that Jones' multilayer thermite chip is in U - A is the reason that it is not thermite.

Contradiction

(Unless you are now going to claim that multi-layer thermite chips did not even exist on 9/11 - good luck proving that.)


they come from who knows where and are more likely to be paint on a sealant or epoxy that anything else. Do you scrape of all the paint to bear metal or wall everytime you paint something? No? Well how many layers do you think will build up over the years?

Would you be good enough to create a 6 layer paint chip, and take SEM pictures, and so on, to show to the world that you can create 6 layer paint chips that are dead ringers for Jones' ?
 
So you allege chips and reactions which cannot be seen with the naked eye took out columns a man cannot wrap his arms around?

This is so dumb a question that I am going to give you the opportunity to figure out what exactly is so dumb about it.
 
I don't understand this. According to you, samples a-d are not thermite. Call this set A. Therefore, according to you, yet another chip, not a member of A, cannot be thermite.

Would you mind not being so obtuse in this discussion?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom