• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Chomsky refused entry to the West Bank by Israel

I remember when Chomsky was called a "self-hating Jew" because he opposed policies of the Israeli government.

I reckon some things never change.
 
A friend of mine who was brought up in Israel spends a lot of time campaigning against them. He lives in France, and I've always been surprised that he never has any problems visiting his mother in Israel. He's probably regarded as a "self-hating Jew" by the authorities, as well.
 
Chomsky will get access to Israel as he has done in the past. Jpost and Haaretz reported this, but in usual fashion, the BBC omitted this part.

Like the US, Israel has many liberal universities as well. Don't get all the whinging about this. And reputation? This is the high-time for Israel-bashers no matter what course of action Israel takes. No victim card here, simply that this is a ongoing trend...
 
Last edited:
I'm surprised they let him into Israel in the first place, since he is such a self-hating/Judenrat/Hellenist faux-Jew.
 
Chomsky will get access to Israel as he has done in the past. Jpost and Haaretz reported this, but in usual fashion, the BBC omitted this part.

Omitted it, you say? But the fourth sentence in the BBC story says: "An Israeli interior ministry spokeswoman said it was to trying to clear the matter up and allow Prof Chomsky to enter." I guess four whole sentences was too much to wade through?

No victim card here, simply that this is a ongoing trend...

It's an ongoing trend to refuse entry to people who disagree with aspects of government policy?
 
Given how all the reports quote Israeli officials saying they're trying to get him into the country, I wonder if Chomsky tried to enter but had his paperwork seriously out of whack.
 
How does Noam "Holocaust denial doesn't make you an anti-semite" Chomsky even gain entry to Israel proper?
 
How does Noam "Holocaust denial doesn't make you an anti-semite" Chomsky even gain entry to Israel proper?

exactly. i was under the assumption that Israel denies even Jews entry into Israel, based on their political opinions. its the ultimate form of censorship.

"Agree with us..or we no let you into our country".
 
Last edited:
How does Noam "Holocaust denial doesn't make you an anti-semite" Chomsky even gain entry to Israel proper?

Actually, you will find that he visited Israel several times already. There is no reason not to allow him to visit, irrespective of his opinions. An astonishingly stupid move by someone in either the interior ministry or the army. (The army is responsible for approving visits in the Wesk Bank.)
 
Prof. Chomsky was attempting to enter via Jordan, to deliver a lecture at Birzeit University.

Denying him access seems rather silly, and is likely to prove highly damaging to Israel's reputation.
Absent the term "highly damaging" I tend to agree with you. Just another mudpie hitting the wall.
 
stupid? yes.

astonishing? no.

Israel never seems to pass up an opportunity to do something stupid, these last few years.

Israel is never stupid. It has blossomed in a pit of surrounding Islamic uncivilisation. That is no mean feat. We have done it by controlling the American political system. You know this.
 
Omitted it, you say? But the fourth sentence in the BBC story says: "An Israeli interior ministry spokeswoman said it was to trying to clear the matter up and allow Prof Chomsky to enter." I guess four whole sentences was too much to wade through?
Guess my sentence is too much to wade through as well. I said he will get access to Israel as he has done in the past, which the newpapers mentioned, but the BBC didn't. The BBC presents this story as if this is a new development and as if Chomsky hasn't given lectures in Israel in the past.

Sorry, I was under the impression that the Britian was the place where English originated from....

It's an ongoing trend to refuse entry to people who disagree with aspects of government policy?
Could very well be. I do think that there should be some restraint overall with these entry refusals, albeit the army does tend to make things difficult, but not impossible, and I doubt people like Chomsky understand this concept.

I do, however, agree that there should be some limitations on how many of these self-proclaimed liberals of the left-leaning persuasion are allowed into Israel, and when I mean limitations, I mean a balance between the different types. How to provide this balance, is beyond me. One can whinge all they want about censorship if one lets in x number of university speakers, political activists, etc. instead of y number of a certain part of the political spectrum, the end of the matter is, and this is where I rarely agree with Dershowitz, is that I don't want Israel to turn into the US or UK education system where leftists have an overwhelming influence in said systems.

I don't like this whole pitting of the right against the left and usually steer clear of it, but in some cases one has to bring up these sensitive issues.

As for Chomsky himself deeming this a 'fascist action', I think Chomsky would even find the concept of a toll booth fascist :p
 
Last edited:
Israel is never stupid. It has blossomed in a pit of surrounding Islamic uncivilisation. That is no mean feat. We have done it by controlling the American political system. You know this.

Still working this side of the bridge, eh?
 
People are very hostile on this forum. Why is this? The rule says be civil and polite but you can break the rules. I don't understand.

Chomsky is not a good Jew. He criticizes his own too much. He should not be allowed to flourish.
 
People are very hostile on this forum. Why is this? The rule says be civil and polite but you can break the rules. I don't understand.

Chomsky is not a good Jew. He criticizes his own too much. He should not be allowed to flourish.

The secret to really fluffy scrambled eggs is to mix them with a little milk and add just a pinch of baking powder to them before you put them in the pan. And instead of mixing them with a fork, turn them with a spatula.
 
This thread is about Chomsky and Israel. Most forums do not allow such Off Topic material.

But regarding your comment about being Chomsky being a self-hating Jew. I doubt that is naturally the case. It rarely is. We just call them 'self-hating' to try and prevent them from spoiling our plans. Chomsky is sadly highly regarded in Gentile circles.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom