carlson test and debunking randi

idunno said:
I didnt want to mention but there were signs Achiles was gay as Power element also represents males and you have a loving combination with powerr which i interpreted as a love of Power but in this case is love for men.

Arthwollit the Aussie guy also has a similar combo. Maybe he is Gay, but at the time I did his chart I didnt mention that. I simply told him he loved Powr. Maybe he can tell us if he is Gay:cool:
Click to expand...

Claims such as this, made after the fact, are intellectually dishonest. As you believe everyone here to be dishonest, I submit your presence here is for the sole purpose to taunt, or otherwise antagonize members.

The facts are straight forward and undisputable; you were given many chances to prove your claim, you failed. Implying that everyone that participated is really the last bastion/stand of the discredited or otherwise disproven. And as your claims wrt astrology, un-provable.

QED

ALCON: Playing the “I didn’t lie” game is rather pointless, as he has publicly stated he feels everyone has been dishonest. I’d say the facts speak for themselves.
 
idunno said:
Regardless of astrology, twins that are raised separately will be more alike than twins that are raised together. The development of personality comes from many things, including astrological chart, genetics, and FAMILY makeup.
Click to expand...

My twins had the same family makeup and astrological chart, yet had different personalities by day 3. Not an age of three years, but three days.

Astrology cannot explain this difference.
 
Locknar said:
Claims such as this, made after the fact, are intellectually dishonest. As you believe everyone here to be dishonest, I submit your presence here is for the sole purpose to taunt, or otherwise antagonize members.

The facts are straight forward and undisputable; you were given many chances to prove your claim, you failed. Implying that everyone that participated is really the last bastion/stand of the discredited or otherwise disproven. And as your claims wrt astrology, un-provable.

QED

ALCON: Playing the “I didn’t lie” game is rather pointless, as he has publicly stated he feels everyone has been dishonest. I’d say the facts speak for themselves.
Click to expand...


ok but ask Arthwoliipot if he is Gay as he has a similar combo as Achiles.:D
 
Madalch said:
My twins had the same family makeup and astrological chart, yet had different personalities by day 3. Not an age of three years, but three days.

Astrology cannot explain this difference.
Click to expand...

Ill see what the more experienced Astrologers regarding twins will say to that:)
 
Madalch said:
My twins had the same family makeup and astrological chart, yet had different personalities by day 3. Not an age of three years, but three days.

Astrology cannot explain this difference.
Click to expand...

wait a minute. By day 3 we dont have a personalty yet let alone a self. This is ridiculous!!:mad:
 
Locknar said:
That seems rather pointless, as 1) you never made such a claim beforehand and may no posess "prior knowledge", 2) if he answers "no", you'll claim he is lying.
Click to expand...

You must have reasoning problems. I never made such claim, but he didnt tell us if he is Gay yet so whats the problem?:mad:
 
Locknar said:
Wrong, hardly a suprise.
Click to expand...

Wrong. Our personality is not developed before ages 23-25 same for the brain. A chart may indicate someone has strong self control but in adolescence the part of the brain connected with self control is still not well developed. Thats why teens are impulsive. AndI could go on...:D
 
idunno said:
Wrong. Our personality is not developed before ages 23-25 same for the brain. A chart may indicate someone has strong self control but in adolescence the part of the brain connected with self control is still not well developed. Thats why teens are impulsive. AndI could go on...:D
Click to expand...

You could go on and on...but you'd be wrong, so really what is the point? Perhaps on your planet, those under the age of 23 are simply mindless drones...on Earth, that is not the case.
 
Saying someone does not have a personality yet is competely different from saying that their personality is not completely formed yet...
 
Locknar said:
You could go on and on...but you'd be wrong, so really what is the point? Perhaps on your planet, those under the age of 23 are simply mindless drones...on Earth, that is not the case.
Click to expand...

Are you saying a University Psychology teacher, several Psychanalysis writers are wrong?
Ok...:)
 
Madalch said:
My twins had the same family makeup and astrological chart, yet had different personalities by day 3. Not an age of three years, but three days.

Astrology cannot explain this difference.
Click to expand...

My own personal case tells me all.
i was a bubbly extrovert kid and my best friend the shy one,.. Now things are reverted. But you seem to think 3 days or 3 years is enough to define if someone is..whatever:p
 
idunno said:
Are you saying a University Psychology teacher, several Psychanalysis writers are wrong?
Ok...:)
Click to expand...

If the University Psychology teacher is you - yes.

If the University Psychology teacher was one you had in school, I'd ask for a refund since he/she is obviously a fraud.

I do not know what a "psychanalysis writer" is so I can not specifically comment; I can say though, that any writer making such a claim is wrong.
 
idunno said:
My own personal case tells me all.
i was a bubbly extrovert kid and my best friend the shy one,.. Now things are reverted. But you seem to think 3 days or 3 years is enough to define if someone is..whatever:p
Click to expand...

I am not sure how you can claim to have been "a bubbly extrovert kid" or your best friend "the shy one"....as you JUST stated that personality does not develop/form until 23 years of age.

Of course, following your logic; at this point (assuming you are over 23 years old) your personality will remain static and unchanged through your life.
 
Locknar said:
I am not sure how you can claim to have been "a bubbly extrovert kid" or your best friend "the shy one"....as you JUST stated that personality does not develop/form until 23 years of age.

Of course, following your logic; at this point (assuming you are over 23 years old) your personality will remain static and unchanged through your life.
Click to expand...

You definetely have cognitive problems.
i had a bubbly personality as a kid but eventually became more introvert like my chart shows, before i even knew astrology.
So whats the point of telling me that a 3 day toddler is extrovert? He may change later:mad:

Even the changes in personality are shown in astrology cycles mate
 
idunno said:
You definetely have cognitive problems.
i had a bubbly personality as a kid but eventually became more introvert like my chart shows, before i even knew astrology.
So whats the point of telling me that a 3 day toddler is extrovert? He may change later:mad:

Even the changes in personality are shown in astrology cycles mate
Click to expand...

Well you were the one that agreed to try to predict the differences between the twin even though you knew their young age. Surely the chart should have told you what they would be like at their current age, and if not, you should have refused the challenge and given us the reasons for refusing. As it stands, you are just offering a post hoc rationalisation (excuse) for your failure.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top Bottom