CARINA LANDIN, Swedish Friend of the DEAD

Proposed arrangement of a preliminary test of Carina Landin


Preparations 1
A few days before the test the archives and SOH select 15 diaries written by men and 15 written by women. As far as possible,diaries without handwriting on the outside are chosen. (If this cannot be avoided, the handwriting will be covered by SOH with some method approved by A.) Furthermore (in accordance with Landin’s wish) diaries older than the late 19th century are avoided as far ass possible. SOH ties up each diary with a string so that
it can be handled without being accidentally opened. A small piece of
cardboard is tied to each diary (a label will be attached to it later). SOH puts all diaries in a cardboard box which he seals, and they are then locked in by A.

---End of Quoted Material----------

I'm uncomfortable with the "tying up with string" procedure. It would be easy to include subtle differences in knotting or string position to signal the content of the diary.
I'm not suggesting that Sven Hansson would do anything wrong, but having someone who is aware of the relevant content involved in the sealing process calls it into doubt.
The person physically preparing the diaries should be blind to the content, and a method of securing that would be less individual should be chosen. Perhaps a velcro cinch strap positioned exactly across the middle.

I hope this test goes forward, it looks interesting.

Robert
 
Last edited:
SOH arrives an hour before the test, receives the cardboard box from A and
selects the 20 diaries that will be used in the test by tossing a coin. He is alone when doing this. If the coin-tossing results in less than 5 diaries from one of the sexes he interrupts and repeats the process. (Landin has
expressed a wish that the distribution should not be more skewed than that.)
If you have 15 male and 15 female diaries and select 20 from the group, it is not possible to have less than 5 if either sex. No big deal, it just means there could not be a case where the picking of the diraies would have to be repeated.

JD and A see to it that all who are present have a photocopy of the protocol. After this Landin and A jointly open the diaries (i.e. cut off the strings) and notes are made about the sex of the diarist. JD writes the official protocol, and the
others can check what he writes. When this has been done JD and A copy this protocol to all who are present.
The determination of the sex of each diary must be made before anything else happens. Otherwise it wqouls be impossible to start with the first step of selecting "15 diaries written by men and 15 written by women". Of course it is a great idea that after the test Landin will see the open diaries and make notes about the sex of the diarist, but the actual scoring must be based on the sex that was determined before the test.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure I understand the wholecoin flipping and so on. If I were doing the test I would do the selection like this:

Person A: (identifying diaries)
Finds 15 male and 15 female diaries
Lays out the diaries in a row on a table in any order
Makes a list including a general description, first name, and sex for each diary.
Seals each diary. A string with a tag seems fine because it is cheap, easy, and gives a place to mark each one without causing damage to the diaries.
Randomly assigns an identifier for each diary. I would use some stickers labeled A to Z plus AA, AB, AC, and AD. Draw the stickers out of a hat and put them on the diaries.
Records the identifiers for each diary on the list.
Arranges the diaries in order by identifier.
Person A is done. Person A has no contact with anyone else during the test. Person A keeps the list. No one else in the test will know which diaries are male and which are female.

Person B: (choosing diaries)
Has no contact with person A.
Randomly chooses 20 diaries and numbers them 1 to 20. I would have stickers labeled 1 to 20. Then draw slips of paper with the original identifiers (A to Z plus AA, AB, AC, and AD) out of a hat. Whatever letter is drawn, the next number label is put on the reverse side of the tag attached to the diary.
Records the letter identifier and a general description for each of the 20 diaries.
Person B is done. Person B has no contact with anyone else during the test.

In a pinch, person A and B could be the same person, but it would be preferrable that the person selecting and numbering the diaries is blinded from the person who know the sex of each diary.

Now the applicant can do the test. After the test, the diaries can be unsealed and the applicant can make notes and determine which ones she believes she got right.

To determine the score, the number from each diary is matched to the letter code identifier for the diary, then the letter code is matched to the original list created by Person A to determine the sex. If the sex for a diary recorded during the test matches the sex on the list, it counts as a hit. If there are discrepanacies between the applicants assment and the actual score, the labeling of each diary could be traced back (using the recording descriptions and video of each process) to see if there was an error in labeling.

It sounds kind of long winded and complex, but I think there needs to be something on each of the 30 diaries to identify it in a way that is not significant to any of the other testers. And it is cheap and simple. The selection rocess would take maybe 15 minutes and cost maybe $5. :)
 
It can be made better.
Person A selects the 30 diaries, notes the relevant details on a slip of paper. Puts that paper inside the diary. Then wraps the diaries in an identical way. Person A then mixes the diaries up. Please note that on the outside there no clues as to what is on the inside. A, B, C are not there. They are then delivered to the test site. Person A leaves before the applicant arrives.

The diaries are examined to make sure there are visible clues on the outside (if anyone suspects any clues the test is declared null and void). 20 are selected for the test. The other 10 are then divided into two piles of 5. One pile is not touched. (The method of selecting the diaries is not important). The other 5 are given to the applicant and are used to make sure that her powers are working OK. This is critical test, as an excuse afterwards is that the sunspots were interfering with her powers. She is given the option of conducting the test on another day.

Then the applicant can do the test. I leave you to work out what happens next.
 
A possible addition to the protocol would be to specify that each diary is to be plain on the outside - with no embossing or pictures as as already been mentioned..

Also if there's to be any writing or pictures on the outside (or maybe even if not) then the diaries should be wrapped in thick paper or sealed in a pastic bag, possibly with a small hole cut in it (to allow access to the back of the diary only) if she needs to make physical contact with the diary.
 
A possible addition to the protocol would be to specify that each diary is to be plain on the outside - with no embossing or pictures as as already been mentioned..
There is the problem that these are actual diaries that were not specifically created for the test. It could be difficult to locate a sufficient number of plain diaries in a library.

Or you could ask 20 people to spend a year creating a diary using the same kind of book and the same kind of ink, and then hold the test in a year's time.
 
Hence the next step of covering each diary - if the paper (or bubble-wrap?) is thick enough the texture of the diary is irrelevant, and a small hole that allows access to the back of the diary allows physical contact (if necessary).
 
Carina Landin is taking the test.

One relatively respectable newspaper in Sweden says;

"Svenskt medium kan vinna en miljon"

"Swedish medium could win a million"

According to the article she is taking the test today, in 5 minutes from
now. The test is supposed to take less than 3 hours.

"- Jag ska få känna på tjugo dagböcker skrivna av numera avldina personer
och sedan kunna berätta vilka som skrivits av kvinnor respektive män.
Prickar jag rätt på minst 16 personer går jag vidare, säger Carina Landin"

"- I will touch twenty diaries written by (at time being) diseased persons
and then being able to tell which were written by females and males
respectively. If I manage to pick 16 persons correctly I will continue (with
further testing [my addition]), says Carina Landin"

An even more interesting thing might be the following question and answare
which is very rare...

"Varför vill du motbevisa dina skeptiker? Räcker det inte med att du själv
är övertygad?

- Jag vill visa alla skeptiker att jag faktiskt har kontakt med de döda och
få folk att förstå att det inte finns något att vara rädd för. Och så känns
det bra att det är vetenskapligt skolade skeptiker som är med när jag
testas,..."

"Why do you want to convince your sceptics? Is it not sufficient that you
youself are convinced?

- I would like to show to all sceptics that I actually have contact with the
dead and make people understand that there is nothing to be scared of. And
it also feels good that there are scientifically schooled sceptics present
at the test, ..."

The article in whole, in swedish:
svd.se/dynamiskt/inrikes/did_13920127.asp

I am not trusted to make links so you have to copy paste that manually.
 
The paper says she could win the million, but is this actually an official JREF test, or just a local Swedish one?
 
Thanks for the welcome, case sensitive.

As stated, this is only the preliminary test, but it is the official JREF test (at least it says so in the paper).

One of the participants (responsible for filming) suffered from a heart attack yesterday, but they still decided to pull it off. So in one hour they should be done.

Alot of details are available in very nice format from the swedish (sv.wiki...) Wikipedia page for "Carina_Landin" (in swedish).
 
Sorry folks, this one was beneath the radar simmering for a long while, and suddenly it's happening. I'm not sure why, but the Swedish group didn't inform us of the date of the challenge, so we were caught a little unaware. As it was initiated before my time, I was out of the loop.

However, this is an actual preliminary challenge test. The protocol was approved by Randi, and the test is being conducted in Sweden by a Swedish Skeptics Group.
 
As stated elsewhere, she failed. And as several persons guessed; the explanations were many.

One poster (E Lannge) said:

"Förstår att du tycker det är skönt att det är över. Strongt av dig att ställa upp. 12 är inte dåligt. Bra gjort Carina!"

"I understand that feel good now that it is all over. You are strong that have the guts to participate. 12 is not bad. Well done Carina!"

The poster don't have a clue though. You can make the following experiment yourself; mix a deck of cards, deal down 20 face down cards in two piles, one for red and one for black. Count the number of correct cards. This is the outcome you would get if just guessing. By just doing that simple experiment (not involving any kind of math) you understand that 12 is really bad if you claim to have any powers beyond guessing.

(If you got more than 15 cards of one kind, just repeat the experiment.)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom