CARINA LANDIN, Swedish Friend of the DEAD

Sven seems to want to get 10 diaries from each gender. Randi has said that she should not be told this information so each test becomes independent, but if she reads this forum, then she will already know.

Would it be best to tell Sven to change the ratio and then not tell the forum?
 
Something isn´t right....

:clap:

What do you know, we came to the same conclusion. I think we can say with some certainty that she has 2126/184756 odds by chance and the knowledge that there are 10m/10f alone. These are considerably better odds than the 6196/1048576 with a truly random distribution of male and female.

Does anyone else wonder if Ms. Landin might be reading this, and saying...hmmm?

edthedoc said:
So she says she can tell whether a diary was used by a man or woman. Smell perhaps? Looks like a cheap magician's trick.

...and it is that there is somewhere in the forums where to read, that "dont´t tell Carina it will be 50/50 mail/female diaries.." in discussions between Cramer and Randi.
Now there can´t be 50/50. You have to change it to 8-12 or 11-9 or something, Cramer... I have been reading that Carinas english ain´t to good, but it doesn´t mean that she is a complete idiot...
 
...and it is that there is somewhere in the forums where to read, that "dont´t tell Carina it will be 50/50 mail/female diaries.." in discussions between Cramer and Randi.
Now there can´t be 50/50. You have to change it to 8-12 or 11-9 or something, Cramer... I have been reading that Carinas english ain´t to good, but it doesn´t mean that she is a complete idiot...

Read up on the challenge application and thought that this was one of the weaknesses in the protocol. How about picking up a good old d20 dice from a PnP-rpg store. Instruct the archivist who agreed to help on the experiment to roll the dice to determine the amount of female (or male) diaries to be used, shuffle them, number them, pack'em in sealed envelopes & send them to Sven for testing. Goes without saying that even Sven shouldn't know the exact ratio and the diary envelopes should be unsealed only at the experiment location to prevent anyone from reading them.

If the dice rolls 20, roll again if both male and female diaries are needed.

I know that a simple piece of code on a computer would work as well as a random number generator, but I'm a bit old fashioned.
 
Read up on the challenge application and thought that this was one of the weaknesses in the protocol. How about picking up a good old d20 dice from a PnP-rpg store. Instruct the archivist who agreed to help on the experiment to roll the dice to determine the amount of female (or male) diaries to be used, shuffle them, number them, pack'em in sealed envelopes & send them to Sven for testing. Goes without saying that even Sven shouldn't know the exact ratio and the diary envelopes should be unsealed only at the experiment location to prevent anyone from reading them.

If the dice rolls 20, roll again if both male and female diaries are needed.

If I were designing the protocol, I'd probably try to get hold of about 15 male and 15 female, then randomly pick 20 out of the 30, this gives 5-15 diaries of each gender and should be enough to ensure a GOOD spread.
 
True.. Forgot to calculate odds. With a possibility of 18-19 diaries of the same gender guessing all diaries male or female would get a pretty good chance of passing.
 
Sven seems to want to get 10 diaries from each gender. Randi has said that she should not be told this information so each test becomes independent, but if she reads this forum, then she will already know.

Would it be best to tell Sven to change the ratio and then not tell the forum?

Accourding to a swedish sceptic-forum, she doesn´t want them to be 10 from each gender and she doesn´t want to know the amount either.

Duh.. I´m not allowed to post the url to the site until I have 15 posts so bare with this strange link below. (w w w.)

physto.se/~vetfolk/forum/viewtopic.php?t=595&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=45
 
o29--are you Swedish? They seem to be discussing us in that link, and I'd like to know what they're saying.
 
o29--are you Swedish? They seem to be discussing us in that link, and I'd like to know what they're saying.
First, they're discussing the probability of passing the test by chance. There's some discussion about whether it would be a good idea to include some empty diaries in the test. Finally some users are raising the question of why it's taking so long before a test is happening.
 
o29--are you Swedish? They seem to be discussing us in that link, and I'd like to know what they're saying.

Yes I am. That thread aren´t that much different than this one, actually. Math, some ridicule, some thought about the protocol and so on..

First, they're discussing the probability of passing the test by chance. There's some discussion about whether it would be a good idea to include some empty diaries in the test. Finally some users are raising the question of why it's taking so long before a test is happening.

That sums it up quite nicely, yeah.

/029
 
o29--are you Swedish? They seem to be discussing us in that link, and I'd like to know what they're saying.

I'm looking through the thread right now. Theer's some interesting mumbling about previous lives and the like.

There's an explicit mention of Carina wanting at least 5 male and at least 5 female out of the 20, but no more information than that (excellent, I'd say!).

There's also (towards the end of the thread) some discussion about how long it took to finalize the test and how it can't have been easy for Carina.
 
Hello
Here in Sweden we can read on several forums that Carina and the professor have sent in the testprotocol to the challange. Cant you Jeff Wagg look at it so the test can start.
 
Hello
Here in Sweden we can read on several forums that Carina and the professor have sent in the testprotocol to the challange. Cant you Jeff Wagg look at it so the test can start.

Hello Galerie.

You say the professor have sent in the testprotocol to the challange.

That is nice.
I suppose the tests may occur after the test protocol is finalised.
And this will only happen if they follow the challenge rules.

This is just a forum, and like all forums, it is just talk.
You can contact the challenge coordinator any time you want.
 
I have seen that J Wagg write here sometimes so I hope he can answer me if he got the protocol
 
I sent an email to him and got this back

Tell her yes, we’ve received the test protocol, and Sven-Ove will be contacting her abut doing a test.



James Randi.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom