Can we calm down in this section please?

‘Kieth, Keith cool it a minute, while I try to stop this.

People, Who’s fighting and What War?

Who’s fighting and what war?

That cat over there, man, If he doesn’t stop beating people . . . .”


- - -

Another totally pointless post brought to you by your favorite cannibal.

:D



(agreed on the need to chill a bit)
 
I understand how frustrating this can all be, but always remember, somebody could be reading each thread as a newcomer to the CT situation, and we shouldn't just just everyone off the land. You amaze me with the amount of knowledge you have about the various scenarios, and it is disappointing to see the anger and bickering that some threads degrade to. Hopefully, we can all make a fresh new start together, and keep it all civil.
This is why you're an awesome moderator. I'm sure I'm not the only one who comes from the less cordial side of the Internet, and it's SOOOO tempting to just unload on some of these guys sometimes.

But from day one, it's been made crystal clear that such antics aren't tolerated here... and moreover, it's been made crystal clear WHY. Despite the frustration of knowing nothing is sinking in with the CT'ers who get schooled here, they're pretty much lost souls anyway. Where the difference is made is on the lurkers who might have come in sharing a similar viewpoint but read through a thread and comes to understand they were drinking hogwash.

That kind of education becomes moot when it turns into nothing but namecalling (which, admittedly, I'm not cured of. But at least I try to bite my tongue until we've been trolled first). If anything, it has the adverse effect when these truthers get viewed as sympathetic because of the piling on. It takes a special touch to remember this in the face of such abject stupidity, and I've honestly never seen anyone on the Internet who does as well as you CZ.

So thanks, keep up the good work, and I'll try even a little harder to keep the smart-ass part of me in check in the future. ;)
 
How about this experiment: A CTist starts a thread about some debunked nonsense we've all seen a million times before -- and no one responds! No one at all, not one post from JREFers! What do you think might happen? I'm imagining something like the first Twilight Zone, were Earl Holloman (sp?) finds himself utterly along and goes bezerk shouting "Is there anyone HERE?!? ANNNEEE-WOOOOONN???" It might discourage this type of poster (whose only purpose seems to be to get our collective goats, pardon the expression) and also might lower the perceived level of vitriol around here.


AMEN!

I was wanting to say the same thing - let's all just leave such junk as single post threads - but I always ended up on a long diatribe about how we've (myself included) lately been looking to poke at conspiracy fantasists for fun, and how that just becomes shrill after a while and decided I'd better back off until I can contribute something useful. But you beat me to it.

Look, everyone, I'm as frustrated as anyone else here with the utterly repetitious nature of the conspiracy fantasists offerings - observe the utter banality and cliched fantasist posts in these threads I'm in (PheonixNews.com story on Pat Curley (in the comments of the article), Ann Althouse's blog post on the Madison, Wi. Truther converence) - and I'm just as ready with the Snark Gun as the next person. But stooping to that level is undignified, and destroys credibility. I'm not sure I want my legacy in this and other forums to be "PWND LOL!!11". I'd rather be known as one of the rational guys.

That's why I haven't been participating too much lately. The threads here recently have been argumentative, with more heat than light. I've seen the same thing happening at other forums (SLC, for a 9/11 related blog, Neo-Neocon for a non 9/11 one) and I really sort of miss having calm, collected areas where intelligent people can have rational discussions (although with 9/11 conspiracy fantasies and fantasists involved, that may be asking a bit too much). I'm hoping that this forum can calm back down to the levels that other sub forums are at, and that this was once known for.

Please... I know it's a bit much for the new guy with barely any posts to his name to come in here and say all this critical stuff, but I say it because I like this place, and I don't want to see it get trashed by stooping to fantasists levels (Ick! PrisonPlanet!).

That's all. We now resume our normally scheduled program..
 
Ditto as well.

I haven't been on this forum that long, but I know I can definitely tone down my smartassedness. I'll work on it. Please be patient however; I don't change easily. *sheepish grin*
 
today-on-jref-a-view-by-uw.png
 
Well, I'd certainly like to go on record as reminding our new truther members that if this were some conspiracy forums that shall remain nameless, the opposing viewpoints and posts that they seem to be so proud of would cause them to be banned very quickly.

The fact that they are here, posting basically whatever they want within the rules, should speak volumes to them.
 
I have found myself hitting the back button on some typing I did in the last couple of days. It seems very clear that we have a couple of truthers here only to push our buttons. Although I can't seem to put them (or anyone) on ignore I'm beginning to think it might be wise.
 
Strangely enough, the man you are referring to in the OP is the one person here that can never offend me. He is very funny, in a good way, the phrase Conspiracy Liar is genius.
 
Yes, there are some recent posters here who simply post nonsense, ignore responses, and declare victory. They are only here to stir things up.

The good news is that Labor Day is three weeks away.
 
‘Kieth, Keith cool it a minute, while I try to stop this.

People, Who’s fighting and What War?

Who’s fighting and what war?

That cat over there, man, If he doesn’t stop beating people . . . .”


Gimme Shelter! Great doc. Many years ago, I had dinner with the guy who made that, Albert Maysles.
 
I know we all are passionate about this subject. We're all weary from the same nonsense, over and over again. Having everything we say ignored or misapplied. Quote-mining, slander, lies.
Maybe we should just give the new ones a "Welcome to the Forum" post, and ignore them until they come up with something original.
Then we tie rocks on them, and throw them in the river! No, wait, we politely point out the flaws in their position to them. Otherwise, we'll run out of rocks.

I tried this method recently in this new poster's thread (the one without the rocks):

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=89336

And, by golly, it takes a lot of patience to calmly answer their specific questions or incredulous suspicions with verifiable facts in the most polite way you can summon, only to have them gloss over your points, move the goal posts, (and/ ) or call you a liar.
 
I hope I'm not the only one who is noticing a bit of decline in the forum.

Whilst it is understandable with the increase in intellectually challanged posters who claim to be part of a rather benign 'revolution', threads like 'A responce(sic) from Dylan Avery' really smash many here over the head with the stupid stick. Avery is a symbol of humour, and very open to satire, but threads like that simply burn his flames of his favourite word of the moment, 'Ad Hom'.

I used to enjoy seeing both posts about the reason behind believing in a conspiracy, and on the other side, people debunking them, with a bit of humour inbetween. Now it just seems to consist of 'Conspiracy liars are **** LOL!'

One popular poster here, who I will not mention, rather than say he comes up with inventive new names for truthers, is currently annoying the hell out of me, and from a few private messages I recieved, pissing off others too.


I just noticed this post of yours in a thread I hadn't looked at lately:

"Pomeroo, I have to say this.

Shut up.

Your hatred of conspiracy theorists is bordering on psychotic.

At least have the guts to bring Avery and co on Hardfire and call them every name under the sun, in the meantime, unfortunatly, you are quickly becoming the image of a bitter, elitist man who is screaming at passing traffic. Idiots this, morons that, coke snorters this, fat rosie that, none of it makes you contribute anything to this forum."


Okay, you have reproached me before for my insulting tone toward our friends in the other camp. As I am in complete agreement with you on every issue except your distaste for me, I have refrained from responding. Now, we need to talk.

You see, the miscreants who fabricate vicious slanders of innocent people in order to absolve murderous fanatics of a horrible crime are not my "friends in other camp." Their stupidity masks the genuinely evil nature of their cause. I will gladly defend my contempt for them--"hatred" is too strong a term--as a rational judgment, not a borderline psychotic reaction.

As TAM pointed out, I live in New York City. My former girlfriend's apartment in Brooklyn Heights is right across the East River from Ground Zero. We could smell the acrid odor for months. I remember parking my car many blocks away, walking by the barricades and roadblocks to stare at mountains of twisted steel that demented lunatics (no names) now pretend didn't exist.

This isn't a game for me. I don't require a physicist to demonstrate that the steel wasn't "dustified." I know it wasn't.

When I call someone an idiot for insisting that no plane hit the South Tower, I'm being rude and uncivil. I'm also venting the emotions stored after many nights on the phone consoling a close friend who watched a plane hit the South Tower, and has been tormented by the memories ever since.

You want me to shut up? Sorry, I choose not to oblige you.

You want me to extend courtesy to a deranged lynch mob that spits on the graves of murder victims? "Malcolm Kirkman" would like the opportunity to "set straight" the mother of a young man whose life ended when the plane he was on was hijacked and flown into a building. Should I accord him the respect I would normally extend to anyone who isn't an indescribably cruel and ignorant monster?

You suggest that I bring Avery and Co. to 'Hardfire' and "call them every name under the sun." Uh, unless I've grown delusional, I DID bring Avery & Co. to 'Hardfire.' Remember? I also brought Jim Fetzer to 'Hardfire.' And Les Jamieson. I'm trying to prevent David Ray Griffin from squirming out of his committment. I don't insult people on the air because it isn't my style, civility being something I prize every bit as much as you do. My guests are entitled to a fair hearing.

I spotted Mark's contributions to this forum and immediately decided to do everything in my power to provide him with an audience. He and I have at least two more shows planned.

I have called, at last count, fourteen demolition companies in New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Connecticut to nail down the "pull it" nonsense. I have spent hours on the phone with Mike Newman of NIST. I managed, with considerable difficulty, to reach John Hotard of American Airlines to settle the issue of the airphones on Flight 77. I attempted, with limited success, to track down someone from the 9/11 Commission to explain the omission of Norman Mineta's testimony from the final report. I reached Chris Kojm, who was helpful but declined to appear on the show. Currently, I am arranging to post on this forum a paper by George Papcun that will lay to rest the absurd claim that calls from the doomed planes were "faked."

I take credit for flushing Willie Rodriguez out of his hole. My abrasive behavior toward this self-promoting fraud proved an effective means of persuading him to drop his pose and reveal his true character.

Nowhere have I claimed to be a big gun for the rationalist side. My contributions pale beside those of the brilliant R. Mackey, the invaluable Mark, Beachnut, Apathoid, Newton's Bit, TAM, Gumboot--I'm writing quickly and I'm going to neglect some very important names, so I'll simply apologize to anyone who deserves to be mentioned. But, you know something? I'm willing to stand my contributions alongside yours!

Why do I need a feud with you, of all people?
 
Pomeroo,
Please don't make this a personal argument between you and UW. Take it to PM if necessary - but even there, stay civil.

You know for a fact that people like Malcolm Kirkman are never going to do what they claim. He has been proven to be so wrong so often, and he doesn't stand by his promises. Let them go. Show the facts, and keep it civil, because becoming as angry as you do sometimes deprives you of this arena for airing your viewpoint. And that does nothing for your cause.

UW was speaking of a specific batch of posts on a specific couple of days - he wasn't the only one to express concern for you.
 
Pomeroo,
Please don't make this a personal argument between you and UW. Take it to PM if necessary - but even there, stay civil.

You know for a fact that people like Malcolm Kirkman are never going to do what they claim. He has been proven to be so wrong so often, and he doesn't stand by his promises. Let them go. Show the facts, and keep it civil, because becoming as angry as you do sometimes deprives you of this arena for airing your viewpoint. And that does nothing for your cause.

UW was speaking of a specific batch of posts on a specific couple of days - he wasn't the only one to express concern for you.

I hear ya talking but all I can do is stare at your cleavage. :D
 
Great post Pomeroo

I tip my hat to you.

:th:


Thank you very much. Undesired Walrus touches a nerve when he accuses me of harboring hatred for the twoofers. It is not my nature to be abusive with people. The anonymity of the internet somehow has the effect of a full moon on me and I start growing fur and sprouting fangs. But I'm not a hater--I've never been one. All disputes, in my opinion, can be talked out, given good faith on both sides.
 
Ron:

Your contributions, not only to the JREF CT subforum, but to debunking the ridiculousness that is 9/1 truth as a whole, have been numerous, and important. As you have posted above, you have gone on your own and talked to people, dug up important evidence, which is more than I have done.

Your passion about 9/11, and contempt for the truthers is not only understood, but shared by me and many others here. Like myself, and OTHERS here, you are human, and imperfect. As our best characteristics can often reveal our faults, so is the case for you. Your ability to articulate with extreme economy, the base, the essence, of what is at the heart of any manner, often also lets you, all to easily, label/invect/jab/mock with extreme precision and penetration...

...used occasionally, it is a work of art, used too often it can appear cruel and excessive...

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom