Can we calm down in this section please?

The fact that doubt remains about what happened on 9/11 speaks for itself - . . .

[snip]

What precisely does it say, then?

I only ask because it is unclear to me what having some people question an event actually is supposed to mean. While I think you make points worth considering, this argument is not one of the good ones.

Let me illustrate:

"The fact that doubt remains about what happened [during the holocaust] speaks for itself - "

"The fact that doubt remains about what happened [during the moon landings] speaks for itself -"

"The fact that doubt remains about [whether the world is round] speaks for itself - "

"The fact that doubt remains about what happened [during any given demonstration of psychic powers] speaks for itself -"

-----

In short, any doubt on any subject doesn't actually say much of anything. It all comes down to whether the evidence supports any given theory.
 
Apollo20:

Please take the time to address my comments, as I find sometimes you do, other times you do not...and that is fair given you tend to get alot more things thrown at you than I.

1. I am sure there are many foul mouthed, etiquetteless Brits as well, I do not think all Canadians should be judged by the few. That said, I will admit, that over all, we might seem a little less refined than Brits...perhaps too long away from the motherland. You are fortunate you chose Canada, where you can maintain your other citizenship. Had you moved to the USA, you would have to give up your British Rights, and assimliated into the USA.

2. I think most people "get" where you stand on NIST. I think that you have issues with things it left out, more so than what was included. My question on this, however, is why, given their MANDATE, do you think they left things out? Do you think they purposely left elements untouched out of FEAR of what they would find, or because they wanted to focus their time and resources on the areas they were mandated to investigate/cover?

3. Your suggestion that people who propose ridiculous baseless theories on the collapses of those buildings are to be commended, is very odd. As a scientist of sorts, I am all for the idea of brain storming, and thinking outside the box. I have entertained your idea of alternate sources of heat within the pre-collapsed WTCs, and find it a valid area for more research. I have a great interest in the suggestion that the microspheres may have been from heated blood. DO you honestly give praise to people who come up with nonsense that fits their agendas, simply because it is in opposition to the accepted theory on something? What, of these proposterous theories, such as no-planes/cgi, CD, etc...do you actually have scientific evidence to back them up?

TAM:)
 
Thanks for giving this some thoughts, people. It might be good to get some practise in for keeping the place nice when we change over to the new educational focus.


You're not going to set an exam are you? :eek:

(Apologies if someone already said this, but I'm trying to catch up and there's A LOT of catching up to do!)
 
NoZed Avenger/Cuddles:

Your list of topics that might be construed as in dispute is a little specious I would say.

I am not the only person to question the validity of NIST's Report in areas such as the loss of insulation or the neglect of certain chemical reactions.

Even the esteemed Prof. Bazant believes the NIST Report should have dealt with the actual collapse which is why he continues to study it!

TAM:

1. Just to clarify my last post, you should know that I also feel like a stranger when I go "home" to Britain. That's the curse of being an immigrant: you dont feel that you really "belong" in your new country, but if you stay there more than about 10 years, you dont feel you belong back home either. Canadians mock my Brit accent when I'm in Canada... but Brits say I sound "American" when I go home!

2. See above where I mention what Bazant said about the NIST Report. This was an opinion he expressed in a conversation I had with him about 4 months ago.

3. I am really not concerned if people have "crackpot" theories about anything. People should be free to believe whatever they want, as long as they don't advocate violence or harm to anyone. I find the very idea of a "thought crime" as abhorrent, .... dont you?

As I said before, if a theory has any merit it will gain support, if not, it will die. The more aggresive JREFERs would do well to meditate on this. Verbally abusing "Truthers" only serves to strenghthen their beliefs which is the opposite of what is intended I am sure!
 
I am really not concerned if people have "crackpot" theories about anything. People should be free to believe whatever they want, as long as they don't advocate violence or harm to anyone. I find the very idea of a "thought crime" as abhorrent, .... dont you?

I don't see why you'd even ask the question. I recall no JREFers saying that truthers should not be allowed to hold their views, however warped they may be. Doesn't mean we won't oppose those views and even ridicule them but to the best of my knowledge no one has called for the outlawing of truther claims.

Meanwhile, truthers regularly call for the trials and executions of all "traitors" and their "enablers" (ie. us) and some even issue warnings as to what will happen to us when the revolution occurs. So it could be argued that truthers are in fact calling for violence and harm. But regardless, I say let them whine. Such vile threats do their side no favours.

As for feeding into their beliefs by opposing them, the same could well happen if they are not opposed. Many people are easily swayed by a cleverly-packaged message and the absense of a rebuttal could be interpreted as meaning there is no rebuttal.
 
The more aggresive JREFERs would do well to meditate on this. Verbally abusing "Truthers" only serves to strenghthen their beliefs which is the opposite of what is intended I am sure!
Substitute Apollo20 for JREFERs and JREFERs for "Truthers".
See any similarities, there, Pot?

Your black friend:
Kettle
 
As I said before, if a theory has any merit it will gain support, if not, it will die.

Oh, wouldn't that be wonderful if it were true!!

Unfortunately, lots of people believe in all types of unproven nonsense like psychics, homeopathic medicine, telekinesis, ID, Astrology, and plenty of other junk that's been around forever, and doesn't appear to be going away anytime soon.

Merit or not, there are people who do not have critical thinking skills and will believe what they want because they are ignorant, because it brings them comfort, or - in case of conspiracy theories - because it gives them a sense of purpose and makes them feel important.

You are correct though; verbal abuse will not change their minds. But then again, ignoring them will not either. Ignoring them will also let their nonsense go unchallenged. There is no merit to the "squibs" argument made by conspiracy theorists, yet hundreds (thousands?) believe this. Shouldn't somebody explain this to others entering the 9/11 conspiracy fray?

I can not speak for anyone but myself, but I have no delusions that the arguments I engage in will sway my CT counterpart. I just hope that years from now, when people type '9/11' into google and get page after page of conspiracy nonsense, they also see the arguments against them as well.

Apollo20 - I've seen you post here quite a few times, but I have not been able to figure out what it is that you beleive. Can you explain what your position is on the events of 9/11? Do you believe explosives were used in the towers, or WTC7? I'm jsut curious.

Thanks
 
Apollo20:

3. I am really not concerned if people have "crackpot" theories about anything. People should be free to believe whatever they want, as long as they don't advocate violence or harm to anyone. I find the very idea of a "thought crime" as abhorrent, .... dont you?

As I said before, if a theory has any merit it will gain support, if not, it will die. The more aggresive JREFERs would do well to meditate on this. Verbally abusing "Truthers" only serves to strenghthen their beliefs which is the opposite of what is intended I am sure!

I do not object to people having any ideas in their mind, they are entitled to have such ideas.

However, having such ideas, and promoting them as the truth, with out evidence, I find slanderous at the very LEAST. As to whether slander is harmful or not, well that is up for debate. As well, many of the truthers, and some of their leaders have called for the execution of people such as Dick Cheney, Bush. Some such as Kevin Barrett think that all of us debunkers should join them in the Gallows. Many of the truthers have called for a new revolution, to overtake the USG etc...All of these, to me, are promoting violence.

I agree that there are some posters here, members of the JREF CT subforum, who are very angry, and exhibit their hostilities in the form of verbal abuse on some of the more annoying and persistent truthers...I do not condone the activity, but for some of them, at least, i understand it.

The problem with your suggestion that only theories that have merit will catch on, others dying off, is that with the cult mentality of the truth movement, along with the power of the internet, this does not hold true. Like a virus, even the most bizaare of the truther theories spreads and invades the minds of the naive and gullible. I and others argue and debate repeatedly over these issues, even the most silly ones, so that at least their is a place to straighten it out, for those who stumble on to the truther nonsense.

TAM:)
 
3. I am really not concerned if people have "crackpot" theories about anything. People should be free to believe whatever they want, as long as they don't advocate violence or harm to anyone. I find the very idea of a "thought crime" as abhorrent, .... dont you?


People are free to believe whatever they want, but other people are free to laugh at you. Sorry, them.
 
Civilized Worm:

Och Aye!

Apollo you are a clever guy, nobody is disputing this, in fact I would go as far to say I actually admire your blunt and sometimes brutal posts, but and there is always a but,just as a layman, a scabby offshore engineer can I ask you a serious question?

Why should I not react? Why should I not fire up at people who call me a sheep, call me defenders of mass murderers, and call me a shill? Why should I show any form of civility to anybody that makes me out as though I don't care for the 3000 victims?

Why should I not react and be appalled when I am continually accused of supporting the deaths of innocent people?

I make nothing from this Frank, nobody pays me a penny, so why should I not be appalled at people who use this event to promote themselves and profit from it?
 
NoZed Avenger/Cuddles:

Your list of topics that might be construed as in dispute is a little specious I would say.

I am not the only person to question the validity of NIST's Report in areas such as the loss of insulation or the neglect of certain chemical reactions.

Even the esteemed Prof. Bazant believes the NIST Report should have dealt with the actual collapse which is why he continues to study it!


Then we simply may not be communicating. My point isn't about the underlying truth or falsity, but the form of your argument on that one point.

Essentially, the "controversy = must be something to it" argument [paraphrase] is a restatement of "where there's smoke, there's fire."

Sometimes, there's just more smoke.
 
Stateofgrace:

Believe me, I do not go out of my way to upset anyone .... but I will not shy away from saying what I believe.

I consider 9/11 to be a very terrible tragedy, one that many people have not yet come to terms with for whatever reason....

Some people have called me every name under the sun. I try not to let that bother me because I dont believe such people are speaking the truth.

Basically, I guess, I dont take anything personally even when it is obviously intended that way.

As for people "making a profit".... isn't that how the world operates... 9/11 is not immune from the forces of avarice and enmity that drive the great capitalist machine we call the U.S?

Where there's muck there's money.......
 
Apollo, cherrypicking and misquoting like a tinhatter.

<snip>But, worse yet, there is a least one NISTIAN Apologist who appears to be unable to understand the simple meaning of simple words!

Oh, look. What was that I read on another thread about certain types of people using neologisms? How fitting.

Apollo, I have a far greater knowledge and comprehension of words, grammar, sentence structure, language, debate, argument, critical thinking, rational thinking and persuasive writing than you can ever hope to have. You really do not want to go there.

But that is no excuse for your cherrypicking, misquoting, and misrepresentating my words, as you did.

In post 265 I stated:

"I do not consider myself to be a Canadian, but I do live here"

This generated the ridiculous response:

"You live here by choice, Apollo. And since you are here by choice but do not consider yourself Canadian, that makes you an even bigger fool for hanging around."

Now this is a really, really PATHETIC thing to say and demonstrates a complete lack of understanding of what it means to be an immigrant!

No, Apollo, what is really pathetic is that you are spouting complete and utter nonsense. You have misrepresented your post to which I was responding, and you have misrepresented my response.

Gee, why am I not surprised?

In your post, you were blathering on about the Canadian political system - utilizing your usual juvenile antics, of course, and suggesting that TAM is a fool, etc. Be honest and use the quote function so that the posts are linked and properly quoted instead of just cherry-picking like your fellow conspiracy fantasists do.

And, for the record, I am a first-generation Canadian, and my entire family are immigrants, so get off your soapbox.

Here is the way it really went:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2859122&postcount=269


Apollo20 said:
I do not consider myself to be a Canadian, but I do live here.....

You live here by choice, Apollo.

Apollo20 said:
Canadian politics sucks and you know it. If you still believe in it you are a fool!

And since you are here by choice but do not consider yourself Canadian, that makes you an even bigger fool for hanging around. You've been here since the late 60s, haven't you? Now that you are no longer employed, what's stopping you from moving back to the U.K. or to whatever other country you feel best suits you? (And which country do you think would suit you best?)

Apollo20 said:
The leaders of each party are not chosen on merit. Look at how Kim Camp-bell was selected (not elected) over Charest (who is now a Liberal!) after Dullmoony stepped down as leader of the Regressive Conservative Party; and Dion selected (not elected) after Martin. And how about Bouchard jumping from the PCs to the Bloc. They are all spitting in the face of the electorate.

I agree that the leaders of any particular party are not necessarily chosen on merit. Is it different in any other country?

Your juvenile antics in referring to people with stupid plays on their names are unworthy of a rational adult... oh, wait.

You know, occasionally you make a valid point, but you self-destruct so quickly with childish nonsense within the same post so as to make it difficult for anyone to even bother to try to find the valid point among the ranting, arrogant, juvenile and self-serving portions of the post, thus many of your posts attract nothing but ridicule, or are simply ignored.

For instance, I agree that 'crossing the floor' should not be allowed because I think that it does a grave disservice to the constituents in a riding who elected the member on the basis that the member purported to hold certain views, with which those who voted for her/him agreed, and the member purported to run on a particular platform with which those constituents agreed. I think it is wrong for members to be able to resile from the very positions upon which they were elected, and I think it is wrong for members to be allowed to cross the floor for purposes of political expedience.

But you devolve into childish nonsense so often that it is easy to miss the occasional rational bits, which are easily lost among your diatribes of fury without fire.

Apollo20 said:
These days, to most Canadian politicians, democracy is a Joke!

Evidence, please.

Apollo20 said:
Party means having a good time doesn't it? And now we have Mr. Harper making major decisions about the future of Kanada and he is the leader of a MINORITY government.

That is another good example of "fury without fire". You started with a deliberately obtuse statement, followed it with a childish play on words, and ended not with a bang but a whimper.

You're supposed to be an adult and a chemist. Come on, Apollo, start acting the part, already. You do yourself no favours by acting like a five year old here. To quote a great Canadian band, many of your posts here tend to be "a whole lot of feathers but not much chicken."

Start exhibiting some of that professionalism that you once had.

Apollo20 said:
And, by the way, which Party is Belinda in, I forgot?

You haven't been paying attention, Apollo. Belinda's going back to her daddy's company because the whole politics thing hasn't worked out for her as she intended. No surprise, that.

Like I said, stop cherrypicking and misrepresenting others. It's dishonest.


<snipped out the life story>
Thus, even after 30+ years of living in Canada, I still feel like a stranger in a strange land. But that's not to say I don't LIKE living in Canada or that I want to move back to the UK. It's too bad that someone would fail to understand this, but perhaps I should not be surprised that a native born Canadian, who never lived outside of North America, would be so insensitive to this.

*sniff* I had no idea you were so sensitive, Apollo. One would never guess it from your abrasive and obnoxious behaviour here. Something about dishing it out and not being able to take it leaps to mind.

And, for the record, I have travelled far more extensively than most people, and I suspect, far more than you. Want to compare passports? I have quite a collection.

And I never heard the term "BS", [...] until I started hanging out with Canadians..... then I understood why Canadians are so fond of that expression... they are, so often, full of it!

Ah, yes, paint an entire country of 30 million people with that broad brush, Apollo. It makes you look so intelligent. It is apparent who here is "full of it". And, by the way, what exactly is "crass" about two letters of the alphabet?

(Brits tend not to use such crass language)

:dl:

Ohhhh, boy. Now, I'm beginning to doubt that you are even British. One of the more popular Brit cusswords is considered far too crass for the majority of Canadians. I'm sure you know which one I am referring to.

(I used to be shocked when I heard it roll so easily off of Brit tongues but hanging around with Brits inured me to it after a while. ;) )

Now, Pomeroo, to address your post, I HAVE been over my problems with the NIST Report MANY times. I do not wish to go over this again so that you can claim once more, no doubt in another thread, that you do not know my position. How many times do we need to go around the same spiral staircase?

It is you who built the spiral staircase when a straight one would have been preferable. Don't blame others for getting dizzy when you insist on going round and round without ever getting to the point.
 
Pomeroo:

Before commenting on your last post I have to clear up some BS posted by a misguided individual who is very good at jumping to conclusions about me, and making inane put-down remarks while offering no technical input of their own...



Now, Pomeroo, to address your post, I HAVE been over my problems with the NIST Report MANY times. I do not wish to go over this again so that you can claim once more, no doubt in another thread, that you do not know my position. How many times do we need to go around the same spiral staircase?


The reason I raise this issue over and over is that no one can state with any assurance the exact nature of your problems with the NIST Report. You carefully avoid responding to the very specific questions I ask.

Let's try again:

You and NIST agree that planes hit the Twin Towers.

You agree with NIST that the resultant fires weakened the structural steel sufficiently to cause the inward bowing observed on all videos.

You agree that the floor-trusses failed, leading to a global collapse.

You agree that there was suficient energy available for a gravity-driven collapse.

Indeed, you have gone beyond the NIST Report in discovering additional sources of heat.

You seem to have a problem with NIST's contention that the removal of insulation by the impacts of the planes facilitated the transfer of heat to the steel. You never get around to clarifying your position. If you're not claiming that no fireproofing was dislodged, what point are you making?

This is precisely where you've left everyone here confused.


And Pomeroo, you know VERY WELL that I have nothing but respect for the NIST scientists that wrote SOME of the better sections of the NIST Report; and I have NEVER said or implied that NIST scientists are intentionally deceiving us or are incompetent scientists. So please STOP trying to put words into my mouth!



Why would I put words in your mouth, Frank? I don't work for NIST. I have no emotional ties. In a dispute between you and NIST, I'd root for you. Again, your point escapes me. Is NIST guilty of bad science or intent to deceive? Why not put your own words into your mouth and clear up this mystery?

You disparage the NIST Report regularly without ever quite telling us what's wrong with it. Okay, they overlooked certain chemical reactions. Fine--we get the idea. Now, does that invalidate the conclusion that the impacts of the planes and the resultant fires caused the buildings to collapse? Were those reactions necessary to account for what happened? Are you challenging the report in a fundamental way, or simply offering a modification?

WHAT ARE YOU SAYING, FRANK?



And you keep asking me to "put it all together" etc, etc.... Well, Pomeroo, this shows that you have no understanding of RESEARCH. Why do you think that the NIST study of WTC 7 is still not complete. Why don't you write to NIST and ask them to "put it all together" and tell us what's the scoop with the collapse of that building... I mean, when is NIST going to tell us what "PULL IT" means?

Pom, old chap, do I detect a DOUBLE STANDARD here?


No, Frank, you do not detect a double standard here and it's inconceivable that you think you do. If the report on building 7 has not yet been released, it suggests that the agency hasn't completed its work.
Is there another explanation?

"Pull it," as you know, does NOT mean "blow up the building."


Are you saying that your work is incomplete and you still reserve judgment on the cause of the collapse? Are you confident in, to put it baldly, rejecting the Impact-Fire Damage Theory?



Where are you going with this stuff, Frank? I believe that I had told you some months ago that I mentioned to Mike Newman of NIST that you had some reservations about the final report. He asked what you felt the agency had gotten wrong. I didn't know what to tell him then and I still wouldn't be able to articulate your criticisms today.

If we are blindly adhering to a flawed orthodoxy, what would you replace it with?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom