Can relativism save you in a religious community?

Mohamed, what are you asking?

Is it, "can pretending to be religious lead to better outcomes for myself in a religious community, than not pretending?"


Good question, I am asking : "is it possible to rationalize reconvert to religion, by adopting pragmatism".

Are there any examples where one uses something they don't believe in : for example , an author may write a fiction story to make money.

Is it always necessary to believe in what we do?

Religion for me would be optimal, because I can use it to navigate my world comfortably, is it justified to practice religion in order to integrate yourself in your society?
 
Pretending a belief in order to succeed in business or romance seems wrong to me. On the other hand if you are doing so to avoid persecution, injury, or death I believe it can be justified.


An author for example writes fiction (fake stories) to entertain the audience ... is it the same as practicing religion to "entertain" (satisfy) people around you?
 
I agree with what you say but wonder if the OP urge to correct is really the main culprit. I have many friends and family who have beliefs I don't agree with. Long ago, but maybe not soon enough, I learned that it is not upon me to help everyone who I think is wrong. Just as I don't want to hear the good word from the proselytizer at my door, my friends and family don't want to hear how I think they've got things a bit wrong.

The real trick is to not take the bait when others try to pry about your beliefs. They don't really care what you believe, they are just looking to proselytize or preach. I turn such inquiries back on them as politely as I can and talk more about the impact of those beliefs than the foundations. Because often the foundations are weak and fragile, messing with them is like bugging a sore tooth. But talking about the positive impacts of their beliefs, and maybe how some with similar beliefs cause trouble with their wrongheadedness about such beliefs, leads to a more fruitful conversation.

My beliefs are my own. If people want to talk about beliefs they typically want to talk about their own beliefs. Let them, encourage them, lead them, but try not to correct them. My life has been a lot better since I took that position.


I agree with you, that's exactly how I want to look at it.

My beliefs are my own , but as far as society is concerned, I can just give them what they want : practice some cults, and call myself "muslim".

1- Give them two sentences.. (You don't have to pray every day.)
2- Fast one month a year
3- Give away 2% of what you have every year to charity.
4- Slaughter a sheep once a year (you can hire a butcher)
5- Say Salla Allah Alayhi Wa Sallam whenever you hear the name of a diceased man (you can actually skip this one most of the time).


I don't have to do 1 (since my name is already Mohamed) .. I can do 2 (since I can consider fasting an opportunity to practice stoicism) , I can do 3 (charity is always good), I can do 4 (it only comes once a year), and I can't do 5 (I just can't respect that man, I can just ignore and skip).

It's actually very easy for me, by the way : one of my uncles already said words that reveal he's nonreligious, he said once that religion is man-made, nevertheless, people hated what he said, but they just forgot that he said it, and none told him that he should divorce my aunt.


Anyway, that's how most atheists cope here.
 
Just wondering if getting in touch with Maryam Namazie's "One Law For All" organisation for ex Muslims might be worthwhile for you. Could be they may be able to put you in contact with ex Muslim chicks near you - perhaps some who are not communist.

:)



I remember I already tried to get in touch with the councel of ex-muslims in the UK (I think about 5 - 6 years
ago), I didn't contact maryam Namazie, I contacted a Moroccan atheist who works there...

Good idea, I didn't contact them for marriage back then, I contacted them because I was offering an freelance service.



I do not object to you creative use of the relativism word by the way.

I said 'relativism' because when I think about pragmatism, I see that it implies relativism (I don't know if others think of it that way), when I say that "what is useful is meaningful" , and "different people have different useful things", these statements entail that "what is meaningful is relative".

On the other hand, I think that my wording is a little bit ambiguous .

Thank you again :D !
 
I guess, I just have to forget about being an atheist, and just live a normal life, and avoid subjects that may raise issues.

My brother knows how to do that, he just switches to jokes and humour., and never takes these matters seriously.
 
An author for example writes fiction (fake stories) to entertain the audience ... is it the same as practicing religion to "entertain" (satisfy) people around you?


Not at all the same. I am myself a writer. Dull but very accurate technical writing, some pretty fair history writing, and bad fiction.

When I write fiction it is clearly labeled as such, so there is no intent to deceive. My audience clearly understands that the fiction is just stories.
 
I said 'relativism' because when I think about pragmatism, I see that it implies relativism (I don't know if others think of it that way), when I say that "what is useful is meaningful" , and "different people have different useful things", these statements entail that "what is meaningful is relative".

Still not seeing the connection there. What you're saying is:

P1: A is a B
P2: A is also a C
therefore
C: all B are C

Where A is "something useful", B is "something meaningful" and C is "something relative". Problem is, that's the canonical form of the Association Fallacy.

As a quick example of what's wrong with that kind of reasoning:

P1: Stalin was a Georgian
P2: Stalin was an evil person
therefore
C: All Georgians are evil people

But that's a red herring anyway. Because you could have just made the claim that meaningful is relative without the broken induction, and it would have been right anyway. Quite trivially, even. (E.g., "boghtlhInganpu', SuvwI'pu' moj, Hegh." definitely has a meaning for me, but it probably doesn't mean anything to you unless you're into Klingon.)

HOWEVER, there comes the real problem: that still doesn't connect to religion vs atheism. Both propositions have meaning or significance or whatever sense of "meaningful" you want.

But just meaning something doesn't mean it's true. E.g., the Klingon quote above means, "Klingons are born, live as warriors, then die." It definitely has meaning for me in more than one way. It's also quite trivially false, since Klingons don't actually exist.

It also doesn't mean it's necessarily a good idea.
 
Not at all the same. I am myself a writer. Dull but very accurate technical writing, some pretty fair history writing, and bad fiction.

When I write fiction it is clearly labeled as such, so there is no intent to deceive. My audience clearly understands that the fiction is just stories.


Agree, I am wrong ... false analogy.

The thing I wanted to emphasize though is that maybe what is true/false is not important on some occasions. It's not like I walk all day along thinking about God and Atheism.

Most of the time I am just working on projects, watching anime or playing video games..
 
But more generally, I'd advise caution when relativism is discussed in any context other than academic philosophy. There are people who know exactly what specific point they're trying to make about the philosophy of the mind or whatnot. Most people on the interwebs don't.

Most often -- in fact, almost invariably -- it's just lame handwaving to avoid calling a wrong opinion just that: wrong. Either by trying to not take sides in an argument between two other parties, or most often as an ad hoc argument for why you can't call MY opinion wrong. It's essentially the more pseudo-intellectual step up from just "everyone is entitled to their own opinion", to basically claiming that everyone is entitled to their own facts. Which, they're not.

Bonus points if it ends up boiling down to the following dumbassery, in some roundabout or implied way: YOU can't criticize MY statements, because everything is relative, but I can (directly or implied) call YOURS wrong, because apparetly relativism only applies in a narrow cone centered on me.

But basically it's like when you hear "quantum" in any context other than actual particle physics. It's an instant red flag.

With the corollary that whenever you feel a need to appeal to relativism, doubly so when it's done preemptively, essentially you have to ask yourself: why? Are you just trying to justify a position you can't otherwise?
 
Still not seeing the connection there. What you're saying is:

P1: A is a B
P2: A is also a C
therefore
C: all B are C

Where A is "something useful", B is "something meaningful" and C is "something relative". Problem is, that's the canonical form of the Association Fallacy.

As a quick example of what's wrong with that kind of reasoning:

P1: Stalin was a Georgian
P2: Stalin was an evil person
therefore
C: All Georgians are evil people

But that's a red herring anyway. Because you could have just made the claim that meaningful is relative without the broken induction, and it would have been right anyway. Quite trivially, even. (E.g., "boghtlhInganpu', SuvwI'pu' moj, Hegh." definitely has a meaning for me, but it probably doesn't mean anything to you unless you're into Klingon.)

HOWEVER, there comes the real problem: that still doesn't connect to religion vs atheism. Both propositions have meaning or significance or whatever sense of "meaningful" you want.

But just meaning something doesn't mean it's true. E.g., the Klingon quote above means, "Klingons are born, live as warriors, then die." It definitely has meaning for me in more than one way. It's also quite trivially false, since Klingons don't actually exist.

It also doesn't mean it's necessarily a good idea.


The form as you have just formulated it (i.e the first syllogism) is indeed an invalid argument, a non-sequitur fallacy. But that's not the argument that I meant. This is the argument in formal terms :

M => Meaningful
U => Useful
R => Relative

In predicate logic :

P1 : (For all x) ( Mx iff Ux ) [ for all x, ix is meaningful if and only if x is useful ]
P2 : (For all x) ( if Ux then Rx ) [ for all x, if x is useful then x is relative ] (which is a reformulation of "different people have different useful things")
C : (for all x ) (if Mx then Rx) [ For all x, if x is useful then x is relative]


So, the first premise is not only an "is" in the syllogistic sense , it is biconditional that goes both ways ... In syllogistic terms :


It is not "A is B"

It is actually : All A is B , and All B is A" .

But Arestotelian syllogisms don't cover these biconditionals..

You can say "a is B" where 'a' is a particular, not a set. But not, A is B, where A and B are two sets, you have to add 'All'. But as I said, these don't cover the biconditional (if and only if).

Thank you !

Best !
 
But more generally, I'd advise caution when relativism is discussed in any context other than academic philosophy. There are people who know exactly what specific point they're trying to make about the philosophy of the mind or whatnot. Most people on the interwebs don't.

Most often -- in fact, almost invariably -- it's just lame handwaving to avoid calling a wrong opinion just that: wrong. Either by trying to not take sides in an argument between two other parties, or most often as an ad hoc argument for why you can't call MY opinion wrong. It's essentially the more pseudo-intellectual step up from just "everyone is entitled to their own opinion", to basically claiming that everyone is entitled to their own facts. Which, they're not.

Bonus points if it ends up boiling down to the following dumbassery, in some roundabout or implied way: YOU can't criticize MY statements, because everything is relative, but I can (directly or implied) call YOURS wrong, because apparetly relativism only applies in a narrow cone centered on me.

But basically it's like when you hear "quantum" in any context other than actual particle physics. It's an instant red flag.

With the corollary that whenever you feel a need to appeal to relativism, doubly so when it's done preemptively, essentially you have to ask yourself: why? Are you just trying to justify a position you can't otherwise?



Yes, I should've just said 'pragmatism' , I agree that my wording was ambiguous and misleading. Thank you so much !

Sure, relativism is a self-refuting philosophy, that's why I am not a relativist myself ... If relativism is true, then saying that relativism is false is also as equal as seeing it is true : The fact that relativism is true is itself relative.

But I am not sure if pragmatism, on the other hand, is self-refuting : I can say that only what is useful is meaningful, and then say that pragmatism is meaingful because its useful.


But , what about saying that : Pragmatism is useless to someone who's not pragmatist? doesn't that mean that it is meaningless in that case?


Thanks again :thumbsup:

Mohamed
 
We had a presentation at my Sunday Assembly a while back about coming out, which in this case was not specific to the meaning regarding homosexuality.

One of two main takeaways I got out of it were that coming out is generally better for your overall well-being and usually lends itself to healthier relationships with others. The idea here is that being able to be honest about yourself with others and having others accept you tends to be less internally conflicting and builds trust.

The second, however, is that without people to support you and/or without a degree of self-sufficiency, coming out can be dangerous and degrading. The idea here is that being isolated or dependent provides a situation in which the risk for someone to attempt to harm you physically or mentally is provocatively low. In these cases it is usually recommended to try to gain a degree of independence and support before coming out, as by "dangerous" we mean "sometimes fatal".
 
By the way, pragmatism says : only what is useful is meaningful.

When we say "only", it is translated to a biconditional : "If and only if"

x is meaningful if and only if it is useful

Which is an if that goes both ways : "if x is meaningful then it is useful" AND "if x is useful then it is meaningful".

Check the first premise in the argument :

P1 : (For all x) ( Mx iff Ux ) [ for all x, ix is meaningful if and only if x is useful ]
P2 : (For all x) ( if Ux then Rx ) [ for all x, if x is useful then x is relative ] (which is a reformulation of "different people have different useful things")
C : (for all x ) (if Mx then Rx) [ For all x, if x is useful then x is relative]
 
We had a presentation at my Sunday Assembly a while back about coming out, which in this case was not specific to the meaning regarding homosexuality.

One of two main takeaways I got out of it were that coming out is generally better for your overall well-being and usually lends itself to healthier relationships with others. The idea here is that being able to be honest about yourself with others and having others accept you tends to be less internally conflicting and builds trust.

The second, however, is that without people to support you and/or without a degree of self-sufficiency, coming out can be dangerous and degrading. The idea here is that being isolated or dependent provides a situation in which the risk for someone to attempt to harm you physically or mentally is provocatively low. In these cases it is usually recommended to try to gain a degree of independence and support before coming out, as by "dangerous" we mean "sometimes fatal".



Agreed, homosexuals and atheists are the most despised and hated of all, especially here in north africa and the middle east. The Sharia Law says that atheists are to be executed by beheading, while homosexuals are to be thrown to their death from a high building (fortunately this Sharia cult is not applied in Morocco). No wonder people in our societies really hate them brother.

I know a homosexual guy who tried to commit suicide, I used to see him in high school about 13 years ago, but I didn't know he is gay back then .... the reason he wanted to kill himself is that they bullied and mocked him for that, he ended up hating himself.

Unfortunately he was not in my class, so my knowledge of him was limited, I didn't know he was gay at school, but after 2-3 years, I heard that he tried to kill himself.

After high school, I applied for an IT programming school, then I landed my first job in 2009 , my boss was a Moroccan who converted to christianity, and I met 2 atheists at the company, so that's about the time where I started to admit that I am an atheist too, and now after 11 years, I'm contemplating converting back to Islam, just to be able to get married without problems.

But it goes against my convictions.


Thank you ! Best !
 
Last edited:
A couple of thoughts, not well laid out:

Your uncle may see religion as man made but still not be an atheist. My mother has always said the same thing as your uncle, but is appalled that my brother is an atheist. I didn’t really know how to respond to this so I didn’t.

Your brother can use humor to deflect because he has that tool set. I get the impression that humorous conversation is not a tool set that comes easily to you. If I’m right, don’t try to use humor. Use something that is more natural to you. I suggested questions earlier, because you seem genuinely inquisitive, but you could try story telling or just simple answers that don’t reveal much. Heck, you could even feign ignorance or misunderstanding of the question if that works better for you, but I get that honesty is important.

With all that being said, finding like minded people to talk to is important. Not just online, but also in reality. But don’t limit yourself to people who are atheist, someone like your uncle, who may not be atheist, could be a good person to talk to about religion. I would just caution you to not assume that he will be happy to hear that you are a nonbeliever, nor that he would protect your beliefs from scorn or ridicule within the family.

I don’t envy your journey, but wish you well.
 
A couple of thoughts, not well laid out:

Your uncle may see religion as man made but still not be an atheist. My mother has always said the same thing as your uncle, but is appalled that my brother is an atheist. I didn’t really know how to respond to this so I didn’t.

He's probably not an atheist, but his views go against religion, which is considered blasphemous in our society.

As for my brother, he is probably an atheist (I never asked him) , but he is very clear about the fact that religions are man made.

To be honest, these two guys are not my type .. My uncle's a jerk, and my brother mocks me whenever he gets the chance even though he is younger...


I don’t envy your journey, but wish you well.

Thank you, I wrote this thread because I had an argument with my mother about marriage. And proudly got 2 bad'ass rejections after I tried to approach girls twice that week :cool: (I'm autistic, I don't even know whether I got rejected because of my bad skills or because of my opinions).

Now, I think I am okay , she will not raise the subject again any time soon. So, let me just focus on work.

Thank you !
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom