That is not relativism, though. Well, or not any flavour of relativism I know of the top of my head. All variants of philosophical relativism I know of assert that things ARE relative. I.e., that some propositions or attributes of some entities/propositions/whatever fundamentally have no "true" or "false" answers by themselves, but depend on the framework (e.g., culture, philosophical system, etc) in which those are judged.
E.g., something being "beautiful" or "funny" has no objective yes or no answer, but depends on who you ask. E.g., moral relativism states that basically the same applies to ethics: there is no right or wrong per se, it just basically depends on the point of view of who you ask. If I'm some warlord using children slaves on my plantation and kidnapped sex slaves for my harem, it's ok if in my corner of East Bumscrewistan the culture says it's ok, and your western morals have no business telling me that it's wrong.
And honestly, it seems to me like neither atheism nor most forms of religion are even compatible with a relativistic view. For it to be really relative it would have to mean that literally neither "there is a god" nor "there is no god" can possibly be true by themselves, but basically it depends on the culture, place, time or person you ask. Not as in "the answer that they give you depends", but fundamentally there is no right or wrong answer, and there cannot be one.
And I'd say it takes a pretty deranged kind of magical thinking / solipsism derivative to actually believe that position. Because it would literally mean that your thoughts can make something real or not.
Now I suppose you could apply relativism to the morals of lying about it. As in, if everyone is ok with lying about religion, then it's not wrong. I don't think you'd find a place where people are ok with something boiling down to, "oh, he only lied because he wanted to trick me into sex/marriage/whatever other taking advantage", though.
But anyway, that's pretty much the extent to which you can go relativistic on religion's ass, IMHO.
Yes , I know it is not relativism, I just called it relativism for a lack of a good word. And I made it clear that this differs from the relativism of the sophists who actually say that truth does not exist objectively. I just chose a bad term, sorry for that !
I agree that relativism is not compatible with atheism, that's why I said that I am not a relativist in the sophist sense (and I add to that relativism in the post-modernist sense).
Because atheism "I don't believe in God" , may be reformulated to (God may or may not exist), since it is a suspended judgement about God. Which is itself a tautology (since it is always true that G or ~G ) .. which has itself to be absolutely and objectively true.
As in, if everyone is ok with lying about religion, then it's not wrong.
This is the sense in which I cannot do that, and I am still struggling with it.. I just don't think that moral relativism is true, what is wrong is wrong.
Besides, that goes against virtue ethics (stoicism and character building).
I don't remember if that was the reason I called it "relativism" when I posted the thread ... but some thoughts in that direction crossed my mind.
I don't think you'd find a place where people are ok with something boiling down to, "oh, he only lied because he wanted to trick me into sex/marriage/whatever other taking advantage",
That's right, I just can't wrap my head around this idea ... Telling the truth results in bad outcomes, lying yields good results with a sense of guilt.
On the other hand, it is not direct lying, my name is Mohamed, so people already presume that I am a Muslim, I don't have to lie about it. As long as I don't tell the truth, they already think I am a nonpracticing muslim, unless I tell them.
In Arabic there's a word for this : Tawriyah or Taqiyah (and Muslim scholars use them all the time to convert non-muslims).
Tawriya (means concealment) is to say something while you mean something else or presenting truth without stating it clearly, providing a room for misunderstanding. For example : " Did you do your homework? -sure" ... "sure" here can mean both "sure, i will do it" and "sure, I did it" ... the parent may misunderstand the answer for "I did it", while it only means "I will do it".
Taqiyah (means avoidance, comes from Taqwa : piety , and my name Taqi means "pious or avoiding the wrath of God"...etc) means not stating the whole truth in case you think someone is wrong about it. for example : the kid didn't do his homework, and his father says after seeing that some books are not on the shelf : "I see that you did your homework, good job !" , the child didn't correct this misunderstanding since it is good for him, this is Taqiya.
So, they use it all the time, it's even a technical term in their religion.
Mohamed even bribed some Arabs to convert to his religion, those who were paid for converting to Islam are called "Muallafah Quolubuhum" , which means "those whose hearts are to be reconciled with" . They don't believe, but they accepted Islam just because it pays them, and they are considered Muslims too.
But what I think about it, is that all of these is outright wrong, maybe I may tolerate with Taqiya, since it only means "not stating the truth in case of misunderstanding" ... While I can't accept the two others.
Thank you !