Can relativism save you in a religious community?

MohamedTaqi

Thinker
Joined
Apr 15, 2020
Messages
188
Location
Casablanca, Morocco
Hi,

Well, this is my situation : I am an atheist in a religious country, I cannot make friends or date a girl without making it clear that I am non-religious. And it always end up by rejection. I still cannot find a wife, although I am in my thirties. I always try to convince myself that I am the one who rejects people, and I cope using methods from stoicism...

I just want to socialize with others, and get rid of this urge to correct them if, deep down, I think they are wrong (especially on religious matters)? I am not convinced that relativism is true, because I am sure truth is grounded on objective reality.

But I think that relativism is a healthy position, if you want to function normally in such a society, because I feel like I am a robot on the autistic spectrum.

I don't want to care anymore about what is true or what is logical, and I want to keep my convictions to myself. Can relativism help in such a situation?


Thank you,

Mohamed.
 
Last edited:
Hi Mohamed,

I don't envy your situation as I know I could not pretend to be religious, which is easy for me living in a country where this is comfortably accepted. Is leaving Morocco for a time not an option for you?

Can't really understand your question about relativism however.
 
Last edited:
Hi Mohamed,

I don't envy your situation as I know I could not pretend to be religious, which is easy for me living in a country where this is comfortably accepted. Is leaving Morocco for a time not an option for you?

Can't really understand your question about relativism however.


Thank you Thor !

No currently leaving Morocco is not an option, as I work and live here, may be I will move to the US (in case I have finished a prototype for a programming project to participate on YCombinator), but not now. The only thing I can do is find a way to cope. Which I am already doing.


As for relativism , this is the idea I have :

- Pain and suffering are an illusion created by our brain, in a sense, pain is not true.
- Nevertheless we act as if pain is a true thing, even if we feel pain inside a dream, we'd still behave as if it is were real. Because it helps avoid danger and survive.


Same thing here :

- Religion is not true, it is false
- Nevertheless, one can act as if it were true because it will help live and reproduce in one's society, because it helps to survive, get married and integrate oneself in society


If you noticed, I am not trying to rationalize religion, I am trying to rationalize adopting religion, instead of just living as an atheist. Knowing something is false does not mean that we shouldn't act as if it were true, in case we want to survive...

This is akin to the relativism of the sophists in ancient greece, with the difference that sophists claim that truth does not exist and that humans are the measure of all things... Socrates hated them because they were not concerned with what is true.

I am concerned with what is true, but I hate this, because it prevents me from profiting from and exhausting all the opportunities my society has to offer, for example : there are very beautiful girls that I tried to date, but they rejected me for a single reason : I am not religous.

Yesterday, I asked a girl out, she asked me if I do my prayers, I said that I am nonreligious, she said that she can't even talk to nonreligious people, let alone marrying them. I got two rejections this week so far.

This is exactly why I posted this thread, and I spent the whole day yesterday thinking about a way to rationalize converting back to religion, even though I don't believe in it. Then I thought about pain, desire, emotions : all these things are not real, they are just illusions to help us survive : Why not consider religion as such?

That, and pragmatism : on pragmatism , only what is useful is meaningful : If religion is useful here the it is meaningful...


But part of me cannot adopt these philosophies, it just seems wrong, and somehow comparing religion to pain and desire seems a kind of a false analogy..

Thank you again !
 
Last edited:
Hi Mohamed,

I don't envy your situation as I know I could not pretend to be religious, which is easy for me living in a country where this is comfortably accepted. Is leaving Morocco for a time not an option for you?

Can't really understand your question about relativism however.


It's not like there are no female atheists here, the few I know are revolutionists, militant communists and marxists who spend their time talking politics, smoking and drinking. I don't have anything against them, but I am not into that world. I'm just a jewish nice guy with glasses .. I don't smoke and I am not into communism.

Besides, I want to find a wife, and those girls do not even believe in marriage. The only thing that we have in common is that we are atheists.
 
Last edited:
Hi Mohamed,

I sometimes wonder if a good portion of religious people in religious areas are actually only pretending to believe to fit in. For example, in the area you live or in areas like Salt Lake City in the US which is mostly Mormon.

I heard this idea from a friend of mine who grew up as a Mormon in Salt Lake City. He went along with things, just so he would get invited to all the cool parties and included in the activities of the town. But he said he thought it might be like the WWE which is the American wrestling/entertainment company that puts on events that are essentially fake wrestling and fake fights. If you go to these events, everyone knows that they are fake, but they never say so and they pretend and act as if they are real. It actually becomes more entertaining (like a lot of movies) if you suspend your disbelief and come close to convincing yourself it is real!
 
That is not relativism, though. Well, or not any flavour of relativism I know of the top of my head. All variants of philosophical relativism I know of assert that things ARE relative. I.e., that some propositions or attributes of some entities/propositions/whatever fundamentally have no "true" or "false" answers by themselves, but depend on the framework (e.g., culture, philosophical system, etc) in which those are judged.

E.g., something being "beautiful" or "funny" has no objective yes or no answer, but depends on who you ask. E.g., moral relativism states that basically the same applies to ethics: there is no right or wrong per se, it just basically depends on the point of view of who you ask. If I'm some warlord using children slaves on my plantation and kidnapped sex slaves for my harem, it's ok if in my corner of East Bumscrewistan the culture says it's ok, and your western morals have no business telling me that it's wrong.

And honestly, it seems to me like neither atheism nor most forms of religion are even compatible with a relativistic view. For it to be really relative it would have to mean that literally neither "there is a god" nor "there is no god" can possibly be true by themselves, but basically it depends on the culture, place, time or person you ask. Not as in "the answer that they give you depends", but fundamentally there is no right or wrong answer, and there cannot be one.

And I'd say it takes a pretty deranged kind of magical thinking / solipsism derivative to actually believe that position. Because it would literally mean that your thoughts can make something real or not.

Now I suppose you could apply relativism to the morals of lying about it. As in, if everyone is ok with lying about religion, then it's not wrong. I don't think you'd find a place where people are ok with something boiling down to, "oh, he only lied because he wanted to trick me into sex/marriage/whatever other taking advantage", though.

But anyway, that's pretty much the extent to which you can go relativistic on religion's ass, IMHO.
 
... - Pain and suffering are an illusion created by our brain, in a sense, pain is not true.
- Nevertheless we act as if pain is a true thing, even if we feel pain inside a dream, we'd still behave as if it is were real. Because it helps avoid danger and survive.


Same thing here :

- Religion is not true, it is false
- Nevertheless, one can act as if it were true because it will help live and reproduce in one's society, because it helps to survive, get married and integrate oneself in society ...


That isn't relativism, as others have pointed out. That amounts to, as you say, pragmatism.

I'm not sure I agree with your analogy. Pain is pretty much real. It is a construct of our brain and our nervous sstem, yet that does not make it illusory. Religion on the other hand ... No matter how widespread the belief, that does not make the object of the belief true. But of course, I guess you've worked that elementary conclusion out, since you self-describe as athiest.

Also, whileas you sa, if you wish to adjust, pragmatism would lead you to pretense, yet the question remains, why would you even want to adjust with a society whose values you don't agree with? I can understand wanting to get laid, but why enter into long-term commitment with a woman whose values you don't agree with, and does not even respect your own different values? Sounds like a recipe for a life of unhappiness, IMV. I'd suggest holding on, till you found people you better gel with. Just my loose change, that, for what it's worth, YMMV, absolutely.
 
Hi Mohamed,

I sometimes wonder if a good portion of religious people in religious areas are actually only pretending to believe to fit in. For example, in the area you live or in areas like Salt Lake City in the US which is mostly Mormon.

I heard this idea from a friend of mine who grew up as a Mormon in Salt Lake City. He went along with things, just so he would get invited to all the cool parties and included in the activities of the town. But he said he thought it might be like the WWE which is the American wrestling/entertainment company that puts on events that are essentially fake wrestling and fake fights. If you go to these events, everyone knows that they are fake, but they never say so and they pretend and act as if they are real. It actually becomes more entertaining (like a lot of movies) if you suspend your disbelief and come close to convincing yourself it is real!


Yes, another similar example, we know that movies are just fake stories and yet we engaged with them with all our emotions and hopes.

The human mind can be tricked to forget that something is false, and just engaged in a some funny activities.
 
That is not relativism, though. Well, or not any flavour of relativism I know of the top of my head. All variants of philosophical relativism I know of assert that things ARE relative. I.e., that some propositions or attributes of some entities/propositions/whatever fundamentally have no "true" or "false" answers by themselves, but depend on the framework (e.g., culture, philosophical system, etc) in which those are judged.

E.g., something being "beautiful" or "funny" has no objective yes or no answer, but depends on who you ask. E.g., moral relativism states that basically the same applies to ethics: there is no right or wrong per se, it just basically depends on the point of view of who you ask. If I'm some warlord using children slaves on my plantation and kidnapped sex slaves for my harem, it's ok if in my corner of East Bumscrewistan the culture says it's ok, and your western morals have no business telling me that it's wrong.

And honestly, it seems to me like neither atheism nor most forms of religion are even compatible with a relativistic view. For it to be really relative it would have to mean that literally neither "there is a god" nor "there is no god" can possibly be true by themselves, but basically it depends on the culture, place, time or person you ask. Not as in "the answer that they give you depends", but fundamentally there is no right or wrong answer, and there cannot be one.

And I'd say it takes a pretty deranged kind of magical thinking / solipsism derivative to actually believe that position. Because it would literally mean that your thoughts can make something real or not.

Now I suppose you could apply relativism to the morals of lying about it. As in, if everyone is ok with lying about religion, then it's not wrong. I don't think you'd find a place where people are ok with something boiling down to, "oh, he only lied because he wanted to trick me into sex/marriage/whatever other taking advantage", though.

But anyway, that's pretty much the extent to which you can go relativistic on religion's ass, IMHO.


Yes , I know it is not relativism, I just called it relativism for a lack of a good word. And I made it clear that this differs from the relativism of the sophists who actually say that truth does not exist objectively. I just chose a bad term, sorry for that !

I agree that relativism is not compatible with atheism, that's why I said that I am not a relativist in the sophist sense (and I add to that relativism in the post-modernist sense).

Because atheism "I don't believe in God" , may be reformulated to (God may or may not exist), since it is a suspended judgement about God. Which is itself a tautology (since it is always true that G or ~G ) .. which has itself to be absolutely and objectively true.


As in, if everyone is ok with lying about religion, then it's not wrong.

This is the sense in which I cannot do that, and I am still struggling with it.. I just don't think that moral relativism is true, what is wrong is wrong.

Besides, that goes against virtue ethics (stoicism and character building).

I don't remember if that was the reason I called it "relativism" when I posted the thread ... but some thoughts in that direction crossed my mind.

I don't think you'd find a place where people are ok with something boiling down to, "oh, he only lied because he wanted to trick me into sex/marriage/whatever other taking advantage",

That's right, I just can't wrap my head around this idea ... Telling the truth results in bad outcomes, lying yields good results with a sense of guilt.

On the other hand, it is not direct lying, my name is Mohamed, so people already presume that I am a Muslim, I don't have to lie about it. As long as I don't tell the truth, they already think I am a nonpracticing muslim, unless I tell them.

In Arabic there's a word for this : Tawriyah or Taqiyah (and Muslim scholars use them all the time to convert non-muslims).

Tawriya (means concealment) is to say something while you mean something else or presenting truth without stating it clearly, providing a room for misunderstanding. For example : " Did you do your homework? -sure" ... "sure" here can mean both "sure, i will do it" and "sure, I did it" ... the parent may misunderstand the answer for "I did it", while it only means "I will do it".

Taqiyah (means avoidance, comes from Taqwa : piety , and my name Taqi means "pious or avoiding the wrath of God"...etc) means not stating the whole truth in case you think someone is wrong about it. for example : the kid didn't do his homework, and his father says after seeing that some books are not on the shelf : "I see that you did your homework, good job !" , the child didn't correct this misunderstanding since it is good for him, this is Taqiya.

So, they use it all the time, it's even a technical term in their religion.

Mohamed even bribed some Arabs to convert to his religion, those who were paid for converting to Islam are called "Muallafah Quolubuhum" , which means "those whose hearts are to be reconciled with" . They don't believe, but they accepted Islam just because it pays them, and they are considered Muslims too.

But what I think about it, is that all of these is outright wrong, maybe I may tolerate with Taqiya, since it only means "not stating the truth in case of misunderstanding" ... While I can't accept the two others.

Thank you !
 
Last edited:
That isn't relativism, as others have pointed out. That amounts to, as you say, pragmatism.

I'm not sure I agree with your analogy. Pain is pretty much real. It is a construct of our brain and our nervous sstem, yet that does not make it illusory. Religion on the other hand ... No matter how widespread the belief, that does not make the object of the belief true. But of course, I guess you've worked that elementary conclusion out, since you self-describe as athiest.

Also, whileas you sa, if you wish to adjust, pragmatism would lead you to pretense, yet the question remains, why would you even want to adjust with a society whose values you don't agree with? I can understand wanting to get laid, but why enter into long-term commitment with a woman whose values you don't agree with, and does not even respect your own different values? Sounds like a recipe for a life of unhappiness, IMV. I'd suggest holding on, till you found people you better gel with. Just my loose change, that, for what it's worth, YMMV, absolutely.


Yes, it is not relativism , sorry for my wording .

Pain is a real illusion, I don't think that pain is something that exists outside of our mind. In that sense I said that religion too is something that only exists in the minds of those who believe it.

Sure pain has material substrates in the brain, so does religion, both are only in our heads, not in the real Universe.

And both can be used to survive.

Sometimes, jokes and fake stories are used to survive in a group of people. Basically, when you tell a joke you tell a lie, but nevertheless it is useful in a group of friends.

Evolution made it that truth is not important, what is important is to live inside a group of people, it even uses tools that are only a product of the mind (like pain) to make us avoid danger.

I am still an atheist, more than that, I still think that probably God does not exist. I even can't come to terms with this idea I just had recently, because it goes against building a good character.

But maybe I am wrong, maybe this is what I ought to do, I'm just confused.
 
The tricks to attraction are complex. You live in a relatively close community where people will talk and news travels far.

And you yourself are awkward in society for the autism.

Concentrate on your work, your life and just be yourself. When a lady finds that attractive she will come to you. You present as non religious and another non religious person will see that as a plus. But she too has to keep up appearances for society meanwhile.

I found the woman who became my wife when I stopped looking. It just happened. Her family did the religion but she skips it, as I do by choice. She says she believes but doesn't practice the rituals at all.
And a generation ago that would have made an undesireable wife. Not so with me. Social pressure is the enemy.

It takes time to find a correct fit. Meanwhile just be yourself, the details sort themselves out.
 
The tricks to attraction are complex. You live in a relatively close community where people will talk and news travels far.

And you yourself are awkward in society for the autism.

Concentrate on your work, your life and just be yourself. When a lady finds that attractive she will come to you. You present as non religious and another non religious person will see that as a plus. But she too has to keep up appearances for society meanwhile.

I found the woman who became my wife when I stopped looking. It just happened. Her family did the religion but she skips it, as I do by choice. She says she believes but doesn't practice the rituals at all.
And a generation ago that would have made an undesireable wife. Not so with me. Social pressure is the enemy.

It takes time to find a correct fit. Meanwhile just be yourself, the details sort themselves out.


Thank you so much for your great advice, that's what a true stoic would do. (s)he would just do what they can control, and forget about what they cannot change.

I cannot change my society, all I can change is the way I look at my situation. Maybe it is a good thing in the end. Therefore I should not concern myself with it.

Maybe I am at an advantage, because this can give me an extra measure or tool to test who really loves me and who does not.

This is the way I tend to think about, but sometimes you just get bored with how things are going.

Thank you ! Best !
 
Depends how close to c you're moving at.


Thank you !

hahaha, Interesting how your signature reflects the general idea : "my views are nonsense ...so what?"

On pragmatism, atheism is meaningless if it is useless. I just can't help but imagine that pragmatism promotes some kind of relativism. What is useful to me is meaningful to me alone, what is useful to you is meaningful to you alone.
 
Last edited:
Pretending a belief in order to succeed in business or romance seems wrong to me. On the other hand if you are doing so to avoid persecution, injury, or death I believe it can be justified.

I'm reminded of the quote from Liam Devlin in The Eagle Has Landed:

"There is an old poem i know, which freely translated from the Irish says; I realized fear one morning, when the blare of the fox-hunters sound. When they are all chasing after the poor bloody fox, it's safer to be dressed like a hound."
 
Pretending a belief in order to succeed in business or romance seems wrong to me. On the other hand if you are doing so to avoid persecution, injury, or death I believe it can be justified.

I'm reminded of the quote from Liam Devlin in The Eagle Has Landed:

"There is an old poem i know, which freely translated from the Irish says; I realized fear one morning, when the blare of the fox-hunters sound. When they are all chasing after the poor bloody fox, it's safer to be dressed like a hound."

I agree with what you say but wonder if the OP urge to correct is really the main culprit. I have many friends and family who have beliefs I don't agree with. Long ago, but maybe not soon enough, I learned that it is not upon me to help everyone who I think is wrong. Just as I don't want to hear the good word from the proselytizer at my door, my friends and family don't want to hear how I think they've got things a bit wrong.

The real trick is to not take the bait when others try to pry about your beliefs. They don't really care what you believe, they are just looking to proselytize or preach. I turn such inquiries back on them as politely as I can and talk more about the impact of those beliefs than the foundations. Because often the foundations are weak and fragile, messing with them is like bugging a sore tooth. But talking about the positive impacts of their beliefs, and maybe how some with similar beliefs cause trouble with their wrongheadedness about such beliefs, leads to a more fruitful conversation.

My beliefs are my own. If people want to talk about beliefs they typically want to talk about their own beliefs. Let them, encourage them, lead them, but try not to correct them. My life has been a lot better since I took that position.
 
It's not like there are no female atheists here, the few I know are revolutionists, militant communists and marxists who spend their time talking politics, smoking and drinking. I don't have anything against them, but I am not into that world. I'm just a jewish nice guy with glasses .. I don't smoke and I am not into communism.

Besides, I want to find a wife, and those girls do not even believe in marriage. The only thing that we have in common is that we are atheists.


Just wondering if getting in touch with Maryam Namazie's "One Law For All" organisation for ex Muslims might be worthwhile for you. Could be they may be able to put you in contact with ex Muslim chicks near you - perhaps some who are not communist.

I do not object to you creative use of the relativism word by the way. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom