sphenisc
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2004
- Messages
- 6,253
(continued from previous post.)
(emphasis mine)
Well, that the problem, innit? How could you possibly put a feature on that list until you had total knowledge of everything? How could you be certain that you hadn't simply overlooked something? Though you've taken a slightly circuitous path, you have run into the brick wall of trying to prove a negative.
Nope. You've nothing in your conjecture or hypothesis or testing regarded how you predicted feature x.
Take for example, if you found an organism without DNA, would that support ID? Not unless it explained how the designer did it. It might falsify lots of what is believed about Evo, but it would still not support ID.
Actually, if you are making the hypothesis that ID predicts feature x, even if it remains forever unsupported, that does not, of itself, support Evo. Evo must provide its own predictions, not rely on the failure of other possibilities.
Well, you can't get that list, for reasons I have explained, any more than I could give you a list of all things that are impossible.
Well, I knew you meant it to be funny because of the smiley, but I also recognized the light-hearted sarcasm. That's okay. I use sarcasm too. Sorry if I "strawmanned" you.
Yes, and my answer is a variety of similar responses: You're not testing ID. You're testing Evo for failure. The conjecture/hypothesis/theory of ID cannot rest upon asking for a list of where Evo stumbles. It must stand or fall on its own.
I think it is dead center. Look at what you have asked for: A list of the areas that Evo could potentially fail. In the search for truth, the only way to truly fail is to give up looking. Science, of which evolution is one part, is nothing more than a method of searching for truth. As long as you are still searching, you have not failed.
ID is not science because it does not seek truth. It seeks failure.
LOL. Well you got me there. That is indeed a tautology. I really need to proof-read my stuff better.
How about this then: "There is nothing real which cannot potentially be explained by natural means." If God is real, then even He could be explained by natural means.
I would say that it is incumbent upon the ID proponants to provide this class of organisms. You are asking Evo proponants to agree to a list of where evolution not only fails, but cannot succeed. I would say I've paraphrased you accurately.
I don't think you intended to say anything about what science is capable of, but that is certainly the result. Please be assured though that I do not intend this a a personal attack. You've been nothing but polite, and I've greatly enjoyed discussing this with you. If I've been overly harsh or sarcastic, I truly apologize. I try to save that for Iacchus.![]()
Thanks for that, I've really appreciated reading your ideas , and it's definitely helped hone my critical thinking skills. Your levels of sarcasm and harshness have been highly appropriate. It's still my view that science seeks failure. If a theory cannot be falsified then it isn't really a scientific theory, but I can see that you disagree with that, so it's probably best if we leave it at that - thanks for the fascinating discussion, I shall mull over it some more, (I'll also get back to doing some work!).
Cheers