Can ID be disproven?

(continued from previous post.)
(emphasis mine)
Well, that the problem, innit? How could you possibly put a feature on that list until you had total knowledge of everything? How could you be certain that you hadn't simply overlooked something? Though you've taken a slightly circuitous path, you have run into the brick wall of trying to prove a negative.


Nope. You've nothing in your conjecture or hypothesis or testing regarded how you predicted feature x.

Take for example, if you found an organism without DNA, would that support ID? Not unless it explained how the designer did it. It might falsify lots of what is believed about Evo, but it would still not support ID.


Actually, if you are making the hypothesis that ID predicts feature x, even if it remains forever unsupported, that does not, of itself, support Evo. Evo must provide its own predictions, not rely on the failure of other possibilities.


Well, you can't get that list, for reasons I have explained, any more than I could give you a list of all things that are impossible.


Well, I knew you meant it to be funny because of the smiley, but I also recognized the light-hearted sarcasm. That's okay. I use sarcasm too. Sorry if I "strawmanned" you.
:rolleyes:


Yes, and my answer is a variety of similar responses: You're not testing ID. You're testing Evo for failure. The conjecture/hypothesis/theory of ID cannot rest upon asking for a list of where Evo stumbles. It must stand or fall on its own.


I think it is dead center. Look at what you have asked for: A list of the areas that Evo could potentially fail. In the search for truth, the only way to truly fail is to give up looking. Science, of which evolution is one part, is nothing more than a method of searching for truth. As long as you are still searching, you have not failed.

ID is not science because it does not seek truth. It seeks failure.


LOL. Well you got me there. That is indeed a tautology. I really need to proof-read my stuff better.

How about this then: "There is nothing real which cannot potentially be explained by natural means." If God is real, then even He could be explained by natural means.


I would say that it is incumbent upon the ID proponants to provide this class of organisms. You are asking Evo proponants to agree to a list of where evolution not only fails, but cannot succeed. I would say I've paraphrased you accurately.


I don't think you intended to say anything about what science is capable of, but that is certainly the result. Please be assured though that I do not intend this a a personal attack. You've been nothing but polite, and I've greatly enjoyed discussing this with you. If I've been overly harsh or sarcastic, I truly apologize. I try to save that for Iacchus. :p

Thanks for that, I've really appreciated reading your ideas , and it's definitely helped hone my critical thinking skills. Your levels of sarcasm and harshness have been highly appropriate. It's still my view that science seeks failure. If a theory cannot be falsified then it isn't really a scientific theory, but I can see that you disagree with that, so it's probably best if we leave it at that - thanks for the fascinating discussion, I shall mull over it some more, (I'll also get back to doing some work!).

Cheers
 
Thanks for that, I've really appreciated reading your ideas , and it's definitely helped hone my critical thinking skills. Your levels of sarcasm and harshness have been highly appropriate.
I'm glad. I do try to match my responses to the input I'm given, but I don't always do a good job of it. For the record, I'd say that you do the same.

It's still my view that science seeks failure. If a theory cannot be falsified then it isn't really a scientific theory, but I can see that you disagree with that...
No, I don't disagree with your explanation. It is correct to say that in the search for truth, there must be an option for "false". But science doesn't focus on what is false, it leaves it behind (well, it should anway). From what I've seen of ID proponants, they focus on what is false (or perceived to be false) in evolution. No time is spent on verifying or even explaining what is true.

...so it's probably best if we leave it at that - thanks for the fascinating discussion, I shall mull over it some more, (I'll also get back to doing some work!).

Cheers
What? You're not on the dole? :D
I hope you won't leave it at that for long. Come back soon with some more of your harebrained "theories". Me and the other atheist bullies will be waiting.;)

Regards
 
Thanks for that, I've really appreciated reading your ideas , and it's definitely helped hone my critical thinking skills. Your levels of sarcasm and harshness have been highly appropriate. It's still my view that science seeks failure. If a theory cannot be falsified then it isn't really a scientific theory, but I can see that you disagree with that, so it's probably best if we leave it at that - thanks for the fascinating discussion, I shall mull over it some more, (I'll also get back to doing some work!).

Cheers
I'd have to be of the opinion that science does seek failure; if a theory fails, it is probably not correct. If a theory can't have failure at all, it can't be tested to see if it is correct or not. Building a failure-proof theory is not as important as being able to test predictions against reality. Darwinian evolutionary theory did not arise in a vaccuum; before there were genes or DNA, it was on shaky ground other than saying "there might be a mechanism." Once it was discovered that there was a mechanism (the genes in the nucleus) and that it was based on pairing, evolution became a lot more likely as it's prediction had borne out. There was something central to an organism that was present in a single cell; enough to plan the entire somatic organism. That's what's lost in a lot of this conversation: the amazing amount of information in such a tiny package. There are trillions of cells in a human body; yet all of this information was organized by something that stretched out would be measured in nanometers in width and a few meters in length all packed into a single cell.
 
Meadmaker said:
The idea that "by chance" must mean "completely random" is not what ID claims. Evolution is a random process. On this point, I will claim some professional expertise. I know what a random process is, and evolution is one of them. ID claims that the probability of a random process giving rise to life as we know it is virtually 0. They do not claim that all probabilities are equal. This is what is commonly known as a "straw man" - stating that another viewpoint maintains a position which it does not.
The ID folks use at last two definitions of "by chance." One means "by random chance." The other means "by any naturalistic process." If they would make up their mind, it would help.

You may call evolution a random process, but to leave it at that is misleading, because you neglect to mention the parameters of the probability space over which it is defined.

~~ Paul
 
I disagree. Even if you could show precice evolutionary steps that led to the development of a flagellum, that would still not prove that those steps weren't guided.

But that would be theistic evolution, not ID. ID claims, without proof, that it can show that the steps must be guided. Behe claims that if you were to lay out a set of precise evolutionary steps that could lead to a flagellum, it would be obvious to anyone who saw that sequence of steps that it was so complicated that it would have to be the result of design.

To restate: If you say it is guided, that's theistic evolution. If you say it has to be guided, that's ID. The first is not scientific. The second....sort of. It's a hypothesis with precious little analysis and no experimental evidence.

Oh, and by the way, evolution is not and has never claimed to be random. Like all things on earth, it contains certain random elements inside a whole lot of cause-and-effect.

Back when I tracked nuclear missiles for a living (part of the infamous Star Wars project) we inserted random variables in all of our models. I don't have any problem at all saying that nuclear missile tracking is a random process, and it is a whole lot more predictable than evolution. I don't understand why there is such fear and loathing of that word.



It is indeed a God of the gaps. Well conceded.:D
What would you say the slight difference is?

It's related to the first point in this reply. A God of the gaps argument says, "I can't explain it, so I'll say God did it." ID says, "Your explanation is wrong, and I don't have any other explanation, so I'll say God did it." On the other hand, the "your explanation is wrong" part of ID is only supported by the gaps argument, so it is really, really, close to God of the gaps.
 
You may call evolution a random process, but to leave it at that is misleading, because you neglect to mention the parameters of the probability space over which it is defined.

~~ Paul

Good luck defining those parameters, but that's a good point.

My only real point of that whole post was that saying evolution happens "by chance" is in no way a straw man.

I see this all the time on these message boards. For some reason skeptics love to talk about "straw men". The conversation usually goes like this.

A: Your theory says X.
B: My theory does not say Y. When you said my theory says Y, that's a straw man!



Evolution is a random process, and the heart of ID is that the randomness of evolution is high enough that it cannot produce the structures we see in life. The weakness of ID is that it can't quantify that randomness, or the level of randomness that can be tolerated. The weakness of evolution is that it can't, either.

I don't want to say in the above that evolution and ID should be considered equals in every way, either. Evolution says a whole lot of useful things that have led to advances in our understanding of life on Earth. ID has resulted in people getting elected to school boards.

ETA: Happy Thanksgiving, everyone. For homework, contemplate the evolutionary advantages of the domestic turkey, which has successfully bred far more effectively than its wild cousins. Part 2: Is the domestic turkey an artifact of evolution, or design. Extra credit: Discuss how that applies to Butterball turkeys. Make sure to eat that brand, because I own stock in ConAgra foods. Moreover, I also own stock in Intuitive Surgical, which makes equipment for performing better heart bypasses, so when you eat Butterballs, I win two ways.
 
Last edited:
Good luck defining those parameters, but that's a good point.

My only real point of that whole post was that saying evolution happens "by chance" is in no way a straw man.

I see this all the time on these message boards. For some reason skeptics love to talk about "straw men". The conversation usually goes like this.

A: Your theory says X.
B: My theory does not say Y. When you said my theory says Y, that's a straw man!



Evolution is a random process, and the heart of ID is that the randomness of evolution is high enough that it cannot produce the structures we see in life. The weakness of ID is that it can't quantify that randomness, or the level of randomness that can be tolerated. The weakness of evolution is that it can't, either.

I don't want to say in the above that evolution and ID should be considered equals in every way, either. Evolution says a whole lot of useful things that have led to advances in our understanding of life on Earth. ID has resulted in people getting elected to school boards.

You still don't appear to understand. The idea is one of rules that reduce the randomness. We are not speaking of a carbon atom randomly colliding with some nitrogen and oxygen and hydrogen to make some sugar, and bam you've got a life-form. It is a mischarictarization of the argument to take the random from random process and provide it in its meaning as totally chaotic and directionless then tack this onto evolutionary theory as a label. There are probabilities here that are less likely, and in that wise it is not chaotic. Selection pressure prevents many mutations from surviving to birth, and selection pressure in general is not random; it is not intelligent either. It exists as a parameter that provides a measure of fitness for an organism.

Randomly eliminating members of a population would not be evolutionary theory. In that it is not random. Randomly throwing together genetic strands would also not be evolutionary theory; this also is not random.

The mischarictarization through absurd simplification of an opposing viewpoint is a specialty of emotional appeals, painting the other as a tottering charicature of its arguments. Taking one word and focusing on it as the sum total of the opposing argument is not good debate, and does constitute a pseudo-opponent that one is hacking away at. It does not address the true argument.
 
Meadmaker said:
My only real point of that whole post was that saying evolution happens "by chance" is in no way a straw man.
I disagree. There is a lot of straw hanging out of that man. By saying it is a random process, you are neglecting to mention the very part of the process that selects from the randomness.

Remember, something is a random process even if only part of the process is random. By not mentioning the other parts, you are misleading the listener.

~~ Paul
 
But that would be theistic evolution, not ID. ID claims, without proof, that it can show that the steps must be guided. Behe claims that if you were to lay out a set of precise evolutionary steps that could lead to a flagellum, it would be obvious to anyone who saw that sequence of steps that it was so complicated that it would have to be the result of design.
There's really no difference in those two statements, other than the level of detail they go into. One says evolution is too complicated to be unguided. The other says specific parts of evolution (like the evolution of a flagellum) are too complicated to be unguided. And both assume that it is impossible to find a non-supernatural explanation, so they are doing no more than predicting the failure of the evolutionary model at some level. I know that people like Behe like to learn enough about science to sound as if they understand evolution, but they do not. It just makes them better snake oil salesmen. It doesn't make ID snake oil any different from TE snake oil.

To restate: If you say it is guided, that's theistic evolution. If you say it has to be guided, that's ID. The first is not scientific. The second....sort of. It's a hypothesis with precious little analysis and no experimental evidence.
Again, I see no distinction between the two. Neither is scientific, one is just a more educated brand of unscientific. And you seem to understand that, based on the way you've described them. Like I said to Sphenisc, ID can't be a theory of why evolution is wrong. It has to be a theory of why ID is right.

Back when I tracked nuclear missiles for a living (part of the infamous Star Wars project) we inserted random variables in all of our models. I don't have any problem at all saying that nuclear missile tracking is a random process, and it is a whole lot more predictable than evolution. I don't understand why there is such fear and loathing of that word.
LOL. If you missile tracking was mostly random, it would have never tracked a single missle. Just as I said, inclusion of a few random variables does not make a system random. The reason that the word "random" is used with such fear and loathing is because ID proponants like to portray evolution as just throwing out a bunch of molecules and they fall into the shape of a human. You surely can understand why people who have studied the incredible complexity of evolution for many years would object to such a charactarization.

It's related to the first point in this reply. A God of the gaps argument says, "I can't explain it, so I'll say God did it." ID says, "Your explanation is wrong, and I don't have any other explanation, so I'll say God did it." On the other hand, the "your explanation is wrong" part of ID is only supported by the gaps argument, so it is really, really, close to God of the gaps.
LOL. So the difference is just that the gap they're trying to plug is smaller? Well, I can accept that.
 
You still don't appear to understand. The idea is one of rules that reduce the randomness. We are not speaking of a carbon atom randomly colliding with some nitrogen and oxygen and hydrogen to make some sugar, and bam you've got a life-form.


And since I never said, implied, or in any other way suggested that this is what is meant by "by chance", that is not very relevant, is it?


In fact, you have taken the words that I said, twisted them to mean something else, and now you are attacking the words that I did not say in order to show the weakness in the argument that I did not say.

And that is the very definition of "straw man".

Which is so ironic, since your purpose in twisting the words was to say that I was using a straw man argument.

In my X and Y description, X="evolution happens by chance" and Y="speaking of a carbon atom randomly colliding with some nitrogen and oxygen and hydrogen to make some sugar, and bam you've got a life-form"

Evolution really does happen by chance. It has no purpose. It is not "trying" to get anywhere. It just happens. Mutations occur. They occur randomly. Some of those mutations increase the probability of reproduction of the organism that has those mutations. (There's that "probability again. More randomness. Just because a beneficial mutation occurs doesn't mean it will ever be passed on. If a plant mutates in such a way as to better withstand drought, it won't pass those genes on if it happens to get eaten by an cow before it creates seed.) You agree with that, don't you? So which part of "by chance" is offensive?

Maybe it is the part that says there are no processes in place that make certain outcomes far more likely than other outcomes. In other words, "by chance" implies all outcomes are equally likely. Oh, wait...I never said that. "By chance" doesn't mean that. So, where did that come from. Oh, yeah. That's the straw man part.

Or maybe, as Paul says, the offensive part is saying "by chance", without mentioning that there are parts that are not random. But as he said, a process is random even if only part of the process is random, so saying "by chance" isn't misleading. It's perfectly accurate. If you read something into the statement that isn't there, you aren't being misled. At least not by external forces.
 
ETA:
Randomly eliminating members of a population would not be evolutionary theory.

Yes. It would be. Some traits, acquired through mutation or sexual reproduction, make some members of the population more likely to pass their genes on to others. It's a random process. The fact that it doesn't have a uniform distribution is irrelevant. You could have a plant that develops a wonderful mutation that would make it the most successful plant of the ages, and if it happens to sprout right next to a hungry stegosaurus, those genes don't get passed on. Randomness. Chance.

There were probably some pretty darned good mutations that happened right about 65,000,001 years ago, but they didn't make those dinosaurs more likely to survive asteroid impacts. Bummer for them.


This goes to my whole motivation for talking about this thread, trying to understand both ID and the opposition to it. And what I find is that ID itself has very little substance to it, but that the opposition to it is incredibly disorganized, in large part because they spend a lot of time arguing against the straw men that are not part of the theory. (Here, "theory" is being used correctly, actually.) Of course the greatest straw man of all is the "ID is just creationism" straw man.
 
And since I never said, implied, or in any other way suggested that this is what is meant by "by chance", that is not very relevant, is it?


In fact, you have taken the words that I said, twisted them to mean something else, and now you are attacking the words that I did not say in order to show the weakness in the argument that I did not say.

And that is the very definition of "straw man".

Which is so ironic, since your purpose in twisting the words was to say that I was using a straw man argument.
The stipulations of the unreasonable appearance by chance of life are based on total probability rather than on sequential and regulated reaction. The numbers often cited for the unlikelyness of random generation of life are based on these chances of random individual atoms coming together, rather than the process that we observe.
In my X and Y description, X="evolution happens by chance" and Y="speaking of a carbon atom randomly colliding with some nitrogen and oxygen and hydrogen to make some sugar, and bam you've got a life-form"

Evolution really does happen by chance. It has no purpose. It is not "trying" to get anywhere. It just happens. Mutations occur. They occur randomly. Some of those mutations increase the probability of reproduction of the organism that has those mutations. (There's that "probability again. More randomness. Just because a beneficial mutation occurs doesn't mean it will ever be passed on. If a plant mutates in such a way as to better withstand drought, it won't pass those genes on if it happens to get eaten by an cow before it creates seed.) You agree with that, don't you? So which part of "by chance" is offensive?
"By chance" is a deliberate misrepresentation and simplification of an identified opposing argument, and hence a strawman. Probability is different than random; one is a population analysis, the other is an individual within the population. Evolution does not happen to an individual organism; an organism is selected for or against by environmental pressures; the population evolves when this plus mutation changes the genetic composition as a whole. The individual changes are random; evolution is not. Evolution follows a set of internal rules which can be identified; in this respect it is hardly chance. It proceeds by a mechanism of chance, but is not itself completly chaotic. Thus saying evolution happens by chance is a deliberate misrepresentation and oversimplification.

Just so, I could say that you dating is discrimination. It really is, if you look at it: one determines what makes up a suitable dating partner. Can I then say you dating is the moral equivalent of race riots? Calling your dating discrimination would be a deliberate misrepresentation and oversimplification to elicit a reaction.

Maybe it is the part that says there are no processes in place that make certain outcomes far more likely than other outcomes. In other words, "by chance" implies all outcomes are equally likely. Oh, wait...I never said that. "By chance" doesn't mean that. So, where did that come from. Oh, yeah. That's the straw man part.
Precisely. That is the straw-man part of saying evolution is by chance. The implication is left hanging that it is completely chaotic. In that it is a misrepresentation. I'm glad to see we appear to have reached a consensus.
Or maybe, as Paul says, the offensive part is saying "by chance", without mentioning that there are parts that are not random. But as he said, a process is random even if only part of the process is random, so saying "by chance" isn't misleading. It's perfectly accurate. If you read something into the statement that isn't there, you aren't being misled. At least not by external forces.

So, you have any good discrimination coming up this Friday?
 
And both assume that it is impossible to find a non-supernatural explanation,
Theistic evolution doesn't make that assumption. It is just the belief that says evolution happened, but God did it.

I know that people like Behe like to learn enough about science to sound as if they understand evolution, but they do not.

I'm curious about this. I've been reading some papers by Behe and Dembski, and I haven't found any errors in them. They run off on wild speculation to fill in those gaps, but I just haven't seen anything in their writing that is an actual mistake about evolution. I have seen their work mischaracterized, and those mischaricterizations frequently have faults. See the previous discussion on "straw man".

Neither is scientific, one is just a more educated brand of unscientific.

Snicker. Yeah, that's more or less fair.

But, seriously, I would say that TE is a matter of faith, and never claims to be otherwise. ID claims to be otherwise, but can't prove anything.


LOL. If you missile tracking was mostly random, it would have never tracked a single missle.

Don't laugh too loud. But thanks for the money. Your tax dollars at work.


The reason that the word "random" is used with such fear and loathing is because ID proponants like to portray evolution as just throwing out a bunch of molecules and they fall into the shape of a human. You surely can understand why people who have studied the incredible complexity of evolution for many years would object to such a charactarization.

Do they? Or is that the straw man? It's true that preachers here and there might make that claim, and school board members. But is that a fair characterization of what scientists like Behe claim? (Yes, Behe is a real scientist. He publishes papers in peer reviewed scientific journals. One of those was even supportive of ID, I believe.)
 
ETA:


Yes. It would be. Some traits, acquired through mutation or sexual reproduction, make some members of the population more likely to pass their genes on to others. It's a random process. The fact that it doesn't have a uniform distribution is irrelevant. You could have a plant that develops a wonderful mutation that would make it the most successful plant of the ages, and if it happens to sprout right next to a hungry stegosaurus, those genes don't get passed on. Randomness. Chance.
Again, you do not appear to have understood. The individuals eliminated are not by chance. They are eliminated by internal factors interacting with the environment. The combination of internal factors is due in part to chance, but more in part due to this longstanding interaction of environment and population of individuals. The percentage of an organism that is purely random chance is quite small; the rest is due to the process of evolution operating over time (iterative application of changing selection pressure) so the truly random part of a generation is a very small percentage; perhaps less than one hundredth of a percent. You have better odds with evolution than any place in Vegas or any horse-racing joint.
There were probably some pretty darned good mutations that happened right about 65,000,001 years ago, but they didn't make those dinosaurs more likely to survive asteroid impacts. Bummer for them.
You appear to misunderstand an extinction event. It is a radical alteration in the selection pressures; it is not a rate of mutation driven event, it is driven by the new selection pressures. When these change drastically, the number of lifeforms able to survive these new pressures declines to where entire populations are eliminated until a new equilibrium is established.
This goes to my whole motivation for talking about this thread, trying to understand both ID and the opposition to it. And what I find is that ID itself has very little substance to it, but that the opposition to it is incredibly disorganized, in large part because they spend a lot of time arguing against the straw men that are not part of the theory. (Here, "theory" is being used correctly, actually.) Of course the greatest straw man of all is the "ID is just creationism" straw man.

No, ID is Creationism. It is dressed up, it has called a truce with heritable random attributes, but it is still Creationism. Find-Replace would not exhonorate Nixon from the Watergate scandal any more than it would change Creationism to not-Creationism.
 
Probability is different than random;

My math professors apparently did not understand the distinction.

So, you have any good discrimination coming up this Friday?

If I did, my wife would have an objection to it, and the parts you found at the end of the process would be about what you would expect to find left of a straw man.
 
My math professors apparently did not understand the distinction.
It is possible there was a miscommunication. Probability describes bands of possible outcomes. There are some which are improbable- the truly random would not have such things as probable or improbable outcomes but an even distribution. Once one speaks of probability, one speaks of more than one random event, and a distribution of probable outcomes is born. However, it is not totally random. A population is a distribution of possible outcomes; probability determines the likelyhood of various outcomes. It is not random. An event might be random; however, the distribution described in a population is not. Evolution is not an event; it is a description of a process of iterative selection pressure on a fluctuating population. The random portion is overblown by calling evolution a "chance" process. This mischarictarization is the essence of the strawman in calling evolution "chance" or "random." It is a disparagement, much like calling a theory of universal expansion "The Big Bang." An overly simplistic and charicaturing portrayal of an alternate position.


If I did, my wife would have an objection to it, and the parts you found at the end of the process would be about what you would expect to find left of a straw man.

I would assume this is an oblique attempt at characterizing me as somehow the purveyor of said strawman? However, it is the mischaracterization of the argument that I wish to address; so far, this appears to hinge upon a simplification and charicature of evolution as "chance." As with dating, or in your case marriage, called discrimination. Avoiding missing the point, I raise the issue again how is calling dating "discrimination" different from calling evolution "chance?"
 
Maybe if you explain it again, I'll get it. I'm a little slow sometimes.
I am not here to address any of your education to date; merely pointing out what might be assumptions drawn from an incomplete or cursory understanding of the thought involved. Many things seem plausable at a glance until looked at more closely; many things also seem counterintuitive until more accurately described. This is the case in calling evolution "chance": it is an attempt to push the concept into the counterintuitive. By calling it random or chance, it is characterized as counterintuitive, as there seems to be order in life. Creatures beget similar creatures; this does not seem random.

It is a poor method of argument, as it is more an appeal to the observers rather than a logical statement. I could equally argue that all words are meaningless beyond our understanding or common agreement, so anything you say is meaningless. It is, as I said, a poor argument.
 
Theistic evolution doesn't make that assumption. It is just the belief that says evolution happened, but God did it.
God is not supernatural? Could you describe what you mean by "God" then?

I'm curious about this. I've been reading some papers by Behe and Dembski, and I haven't found any errors in them. They run off on wild speculation to fill in those gaps, but I just haven't seen anything in their writing that is an actual mistake about evolution.
Wild speculation to fill in gaps is error. Conclusion not based on evidence is error. The concept of IC is most definitely error.

I have seen their work mischaracterized, and those mischaricterizations frequently have faults. See the previous discussion on "straw man".
Perhaps it has been mischaracterized by some. That does not diminish the fact that it is thoroughly unscientific. ID is not a theory and it does not adhere to the processes that science uses. At best, it can be seen as raising some good questions about evolution, which it makes no attempt to answer with other testable hypotheses. Many of the questions ID asks already have been answered, but Behe et. al. had not researched enough to know this.

But, seriously, I would say that TE is a matter of faith, and never claims to be otherwise. ID claims to be otherwise, but can't prove anything.
So TE is just adding "but I also believe in God" to everything that evolution says? Gosh, that's helpful.:rolleyes:

Don't laugh too loud. But thanks for the money. Your tax dollars at work.
The vast majority of your work was not at all random. You added one random variable. That does not make the tracking system "random". Same with evolution. There are a few random variables, like mutations. The vast majority of evolution is not random.

Do they? Or is that the straw man? It's true that preachers here and there might make that claim, and school board members. But is that a fair characterization of what scientists like Behe claim? (Yes, Behe is a real scientist. He publishes papers in peer reviewed scientific journals. One of those was even supportive of ID, I believe.)
I hate to harp on IC again, but it is a big part of what Behe uses to support his claims. IC essentially claims evolution is a random process which could not have resulted in such complex structures as the eye or the flagellum.

Perhaps Behe is a scientist. Even scientists can be blind when it comes to their religion, a la Blaise Pascal, Lord Kelvin et. al. So perhaps I should amend my statement to say that Behe is a scientist who is off duty when proposing ID.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom