I invoke my rights under the 5th Amendment.I was referring to our subtopic, not the entire thread. How is metaphysics not just idle chitchat?
~~ Paul
I invoke my rights under the 5th Amendment.I was referring to our subtopic, not the entire thread. How is metaphysics not just idle chitchat?
~~ Paul
But as we know, you can't prove a negative. How is it possible to show that there is no alternative explanation and there can be none? That is an impossible burden of proof. There are many things which we don't yet know, but few if any of them are unknowable. So it seems to plug the gap in knowlege by postulating a designer is simply giving up on finding alternatives.
As for the archaelology, I would bet that any class of artifacts would have been shown to be man made at some time. You may not have to prove the origin of every pottery shard (though lots of archaeologists do exactly that thing) but you'd have to show at some point that pottery was man-made.
I would have to see at least one clear cut example of IDer intervention before I could accept others. All I need is one, and you've got me convinced. But it can't be "we can't think of anything else it could be," because that just shows the limitations of what has been (so far) thought of. You have to show me evidence of the intercession.
Not sure I understand this. Being maladapted for its present environment is evidence for ID? Evolutionists consider that maladaptive features are strong evidence against ID. I suspect that I am misinterpreting you.
But what I would like is one real example, not a "what if" sort of example. Not trying to corner you here, but in order for me to understand what you are talking about, it would help to correlate the example to something that could be documented.
In that wise it is the "Could have made the universe five minutes ago" argument. We can never say it didn't happen so it must be so?
That is true, however, I have yet to see a single instance where ID provides a better answer than plain old evolution, sans ID. To postulate ID is to open up all sorts of unanswerable questions about the nature of the designer. So anyone pushing ID as the best available answer had better be ready to answer (with evidence) questions about the designer.By 'no alternative explanation' what I meant was 'of the currently available explanations, which manage to explain the observations, satisfy Occam's Razor etc, etc.' The set of such explanations is a relatively small set and can be exhaustively searched. This is the same procedure that applies to any successful theory, it becomes accepted as the 'current model' because it's the best of the currently available explanations. This doesn't imply that no alternative explanations will ever be presented.
Yes, because we know men exist. Lots of them. The same cannot be said of a creator.I agree and I may have interpreted your statement "They have to actually identify the hand of the creator." too literally then. The point is that it is possible to conclude something is man-made without being able to identify exactly who it was.
Hey, I admitted I could be mistaken about verterbrates, but of course you were nitpicking on the meaning of "vertebrate". I suspect you knew I meant that evolution would be falsified if fossils were found in sequences that were vastly inconsistant with what is known about evolution. But I gamely gave you the point anyway. I was wrong because I didn't think of primative vertebrates which are not the same thing as members of the Phylum Vertebrata. I admit my ignorance about many aspects of paleontology. Lucky that there are some who are not to keep idjits like me in line.Of course you would, but we've just had our little vertebrate coup de tat, so forgive if I'm a bit suspicious about what 'one clear cut example of IDer intervention ' means. There just doesn't seem to be a class of observations which everyone can accept as satisfying this condition, there is a tendency to move the goalposts.
I suspect that you know a number of them are designed because you have seen similar things that you know were designed. However, you might see something that looked designed which it turns out was not. As a geologist, I collect many beautiful crystals which look as if they had been carefully crafted and polished. They aren't.[ Digression : It seems incredibly easy for me to look around this room and identify designed objects, yet it's very hard for me to say how I know an object is designed. IR has nothing to do with it, I've no idea how most of them are put together anyway...]?
Sorry. That makes not sense to me. What is intelligent about designing something to go "downhill". And while it is true, as Dawkins suggests, that the general trend is to climb upwards, that does not mean that there are no exceptions. I think evolution explains those exceptions far better than ID.I think evolutionists regard maladaptive features as strong evidence against Creationism. To use a "Climbing Mount Improbable" analogy, according to Creationism organisms should have been created living at the peak of its local mountain. According to Evolution by Natural Selection things may not be at the peak, but the general trend should be to climb upward, (in this sense they are maladaptive; their 'location' is maladaptive, their 'velocity' is 'to adapt'.) ID would account for observations of organisms not only in the location sense but in the velocity sense, organisms that are heading 'downhill'.
I have not yet read it, but I probably will soon. I am a big fan of Dawkins.[If you're not familiar with Richard Dawkins' "Climbing Mount Improbable", I apologise for using the analogy, my guess is you'll get the gist anyway.]
There are certainly some things that EVO by NS can't account for. There used to be a lot more, but many of them have been solved (Thanks, Brother Mendel). While it would be easy (or lazy) to account for these gaps by postulating a designer, you open up that whole can of worms about the nature of the designer. If such an incredibly powerful thing exists, there had better be plenty of solid evidence for it. Don't give up on science until you've exhausted all the possibilities (and you will never exhaust all the possibilities.I'm not going to offer any real examples (if indeed I have any) without some concessions to the argument so far. [You've whipped away your goalposts once already, I'm not falling for the same trick twice.] Is this a class of observations which a) EVo by NS can't account for b) ID can?
That is true, however, I have yet to see a single instance where ID provides a better answer than plain old evolution, sans ID. To postulate ID is to open up all sorts of unanswerable questions about the nature of the designer. So anyone pushing ID as the best available answer had better be ready to answer (with evidence) questions about the designer.
Yes, because we know men exist. Lots of them. The same cannot be said of a creator.
Hey, I admitted I could be mistaken about verterbrates, but of course you were nitpicking on the meaning of "vertebrate". I suspect you knew I meant that evolution would be falsified if fossils were found in sequences that were vastly inconsistant with what is known about evolution. But I gamely gave you the point anyway. I was wrong because I didn't think of primative vertebrates which are not the same thing as members of the Phylum Vertebrata. I admit my ignorance about many aspects of paleontology. Lucky that there are some who are not to keep idjits like me in line.
But if you dont' know what an example of IDer intervention means, you should try to think about the exact mechanism by which he intervenes. Frankly, I can't think of any that do not involve big hands coming down from the sky and molding creatures like modeling clay. But I'm open to suggestions.
I suspect that you know a number of them are designed because you have seen similar things that you know were designed. However, you might see something that looked designed which it turns out was not. As a geologist, I collect many beautiful crystals which look as if they had been carefully crafted and polished. They aren't.
Sorry. That makes not sense to me. What is intelligent about designing something to go "downhill". And while it is true, as Dawkins suggests, that the general trend is to climb upwards, that does not mean that there are no exceptions. I think evolution explains those exceptions far better than ID.
I have not yet read it, but I probably will soon. I am a big fan of Dawkins.
There are certainly some things that EVO by NS can't account for. There used to be a lot more, but many of them have been solved (Thanks, Brother Mendel). While it would be easy (or lazy) to account for these gaps by postulating a designer, you open up that whole can of worms about the nature of the designer. If such an incredibly powerful thing exists, there had better be plenty of solid evidence for it. Don't give up on science until you've exhausted all the possibilities (and you will never exhaust all the possibilities.)
LOL. If you get one who knows his stuff, he could probably give you a few examples more precise than what I remember from my misspent college education. In my line of work, we use micropaleontology a great deal because it is extremely accurate about dating sediments. So let me say if you find any Bigenerina humbeli in the Cretaceous, that part of evolution will be falsified.Okay, I did know what you meant, but that's my point, how 'vastly inconsistent' is vastly inconsistent enough to get an evolutionist to turn round and say "Sorry, I can't explain that one."
No, because it cannot account for any class fo organisms that appear in the stratigraphic column before their predecessors. If you find one that does, then that particular part of evolution has been falsified (but not the whole thing). However, when this happens, you don't throw up your hands and say, "it must be God". You get back and try to find if your knowledge about first appearances of certain classes was wrong or incomplete. This has happened many times in evolution, such as with the discovery of the Ediacara fauna.I try and present a potential class of organisms which I think EVO by NS can't account for, but you say " the general trend is to climb upwards, that does not mean that there are no exceptions. " So I get back to asking, what potential class of organisms could there be that EVO by NS can't account for?
The Selfish Gene is my favorite, but perhaps because it was my first.[I'm a big Dawkins fan too - 'The Extended Phenotype''s a particular favourite.]
If it were completely random, it might be so; however, the changes in evolution are not random in the sense of all probabilities being equal; there are some that are more likely than others, and evolution does not argue that an organism arises ex nihilo in an instant. This is what is commonly known as a "straw man" - stating that another viewpoint maintains a position which it does not.That would be foolish. However, since we can never say it didn't happen, then we have to say it might be so. And indeed, the "five minutes ago" theory is a perfectly good, but not very interesting, theory. ("theory" is being used in the colloquial sense here.) Even if it happens to be true, the world was made to look like it was somewhere around 5 billion years old, so even if it only happens to be 5 minutes old, we can still study it as if it were older.
Is that the same as what ID states? No. Behe et. al. say the world looks like it was designed. They further say that the probability of it arising in that way by chance is virtually 0. Can you prove them wrong? No.
Shifting the burden. Evolution was shown to have mechanism, opportunity, and it was really geological discoveries that predated the discoveries of evolutionary theory; the age of the earth was appropriate to the rate of postulated and observed change. Essentially, things are evolving all around you. This is why ID often goes for the artificial "micro/macro" question of "kinds."But is ID disprovable? It sure is. Conceptually, it's easy. Evolve something.
This also is an incorrect statement. Darwin at least can say "we probably used this car with the warm engine" versus ID "it just happened."Going back to the "going from A to B" analogy, it seems to me that neither ID nor evolution can say how we got from A to B, where A and B are two different sorts of organisms. At this point they make two different statements.
Darwin: I don't know how we got from A to B, but I'm sure it could have happened without God.
ID: I don't know how we got from A to B, but I don't think it could have happened without God.
I agree with the first one, but it's hard to feel intellectually superior about it.
LOL. If you get one who knows his stuff, he could probably give you a few examples more precise than what I remember from my misspent college education. In my line of work, we use micropaleontology a great deal because it is extremely accurate about dating sediments. So let me say if you find any Bigenerina humbeli in the Cretaceous, that part of evolution will be falsified.
No, because it cannot account for any class fo organisms that appear in the stratigraphic column before their predecessors. If you find one that does, then that particular part of evolution has been falsified (but not the whole thing). However, when this happens, you don't throw up your hands and say, "it must be God". You get back and try to find if your knowledge about first appearances of certain classes was wrong or incomplete. This has happened many times in evolution, such as with the discovery of the Ediacara fauna.
But this did not disprove evolution (much as the creationists would like), but only one tiny aspect of evolution. But how can you ever falsify even one tiny aspect of ID? Consider the following hypothetical exchange.
IDman: The designer caused the dinosaurs to die out.
EVOman: No, the most evidence is for the fact that it was caused by a meterorite or comet impact.
IDMan: The designer sent the comet.
EVOman: We see comets and meteorites all around our solar system. They hit things with some degree of regularity
IDMan: But the designer set them in motion to hit at this precise time.
Obviously, that's an extreme example, but it does illustrate how ID proponants tend to shift the goalposts (a lot more than me!) when the "gaps" get closed up until they are proposing the most outlandish scenarios. They can claim that the designer sent specific cosmic rays to cause specific mutations (I've seen this one before). How could that ever be falsified?
If it were completely random, it might be so; however, the changes in evolution are not random in the sense of all probabilities being equal; there are some that are more likely than others, and evolution does not argue that an organism arises ex nihilo in an instant. This is what is commonly known as a "straw man" - stating that another viewpoint maintains a position which it does not.
Now that I've read a few of the works of Behe and Dembski, I can say that I have seen no reference to "kinds", nor have I seen a reference to a "micro/macro" question, artificial or otherwise. This is what is commonly known as a "straw man" - stating that another viewpoint maintains a position which it does not.This is why ID often goes for the artificial "micro/macro" question of "kinds."
ID doesn't say, "it just happened." ID says, "It didn't happen like that." This is what is commonly known as a "straw man" - stating that another viewpoint maintains a position which it does not.This also is an incorrect statement. Darwin at least can say "we probably used this car with the warm engine" versus ID "it just happened."
Sorry. That makes not sense to me. What is intelligent about designing something to go "downhill".
Tricky,
"They can claim that the designer sent specific cosmic rays to cause specific mutations (I've seen this one before). How could that ever be falsified?"
They disproved parts of evolution. The theory of evolution is so all-encompassing that various facets of it are almost compartmentalized. For example, finding a fossil out of sequence would not disprove that pathogens can evolve resistance to drugs. The questions are almost unrelated. But it is true, I didn't mention that all of evolution would not be falsified. My mistake (again!"No, because it cannot account for any class fo organisms that appear in the stratigraphic column before their predecessors."
Great, all we need now is an independent method of deciding on who's the predecessor. Personally, I feel this more a way of falsifying the geology than evoultion, but what-the-hey I'll run with it for a while.
But then you go on to argue that "This has happened many times in evolution...But this did not disprove evolution"
I don't understand how you reconcile these statements. I asked what "potential class of organisms could there be that EVO by NS can't account for."
You start to give me a class, then say examples of this class have already been discovered, but this 'did not disprove evolution'???
).Pretty funny. Not sure what you mean except perhaps you thought my example was ridiculous, but I've heard ID proponants say things very similar to my "hypothetical example", and you probably have too. I suppose "hypothetical" was the wrong word. I really meant that it wasn't "word-for word" what I had heard.I had to laugh at your hypothetical example, here's mine:
IDman: The designer caused the dinosaurs to die out.
EVOman: What really, gosh I never realised!
IDMan: The designer sent the comet.
EVOman: Yes I can certainly see that would be the case, thanks for explaining it to me.
IDMan: The designer set them in motion to hit at this precise time.
EVOMan: How could I ever have doubted the truth of ID, it's all so clear now.
Obviously, that's an extreme example, but it does illustrate how if evolution proponents paid more attention they might learn something!
[You were joking, right?!Using a hypothetical example to make claims about the real world does suggest a certain weakness of argument...]
Well, I have to find an example where ID makes a definite claim. They are as rare as hen's teeth. This was one I had actually heard, though it still isn't really a claim, because it doesn't address the mechanism for directing the cosmic rays. Do you have any examples of specific mechanisms that ID proponants have put forth?Tricky said:They can claim that the designer sent specific cosmic rays to cause specific mutations (I've seen this one before). How could that ever be falsified?
It can't, but it doesn't need to be, since it's not central to ID. How do you falsify the claim that the cosmic rays were essentially random and caused a random set of mutations?
Perhaps the mechanism cart is a bit ahead of the event horse. But the only "event" I can see ID proposing is that "the designer directed it". No specific event is ever described in a way such that a mechanism could be proposed. So about the only question you can ask is "how did the designer direct it"?Anyway this is waaaay down the line. It is nonsensical to argue about the mechanism by which events occurred, until there is evidence of those events (by which I mean intervention of an IDer). The only way we can have evidence of those events is to agree on what kind of observations would constitute evidence of those events.
LOL. Then ID won't progress, because there is no natural process which cannot potentially be explained by natural means. Lots of them are difficult, for sure. So it seems as if you are asking to define, "where does science give up?" I'm guessing they won't ever give up.Until we can agree on which observations are (I'll say it again), a potential class of organisms which EVO by NS can't account for, then I don't see how we can progress?
Oops. I pulled it off a paleo chart on my wall. We geologists are notoriously bad spelars. Once again, I apologize.BTW that's "Bigenerina humblei" not "Bigenerina humbeli" , but you were just trying to make my life difficult, right?![]()
I understand this. But it is not, in any sense of the word, science. It is a position of faith. In this case, it is "faith that humans will always be too ignorant to reconstruct some aspects of life".I don't understand what's so complicated about this.
I'll give a shot at addressing this in a different way. After all, not only have I seen this one, I've posted it, although I was quoting Behe. I once believed it, though.
ID is not a theory about how life originated. It doesn't say it happened by cosmic rays. It doesn't say it happened by creation. However, either one of those is compatible with ID. That isn't what ID is about.
ID is, in reality, a hypothesis about how life did not originate. ID says that the complexity of life is of such magnitude that it cannot have come about by chance. (Chance = any random process, not motivated by an intelligence).
To falsify ID, all you have to do is show how a random process can produce, for example, a bacterial flagellum. But you can't do that. At least not yet.
I disagree. Even if you could show precice evolutionary steps that led to the development of a flagellum, that would still not prove that those steps weren't guided.Now, it is important to understand what I am not saying here. I am saying that ID is falsifiable. The lack of falsification at the present moment doesn't mean that ID is true, or even reasonable. It is, however, falsifiable.
It is indeed a God of the gaps. Well conceded.(Roborama's last post was related to this, and it made quite a bit of sense. I think it is fair to say that ID is a God of the Gaps theory, although I think there is a slight difference.)
They disproved parts of evolution. The theory of evolution is so all-encompassing that various facets of it are almost compartmentalized. For example, finding a fossil out of sequence would not disprove that pathogens can evolve resistance to drugs. The questions are almost unrelated. But it is true, I didn't mention that all of evolution would not be falsified. My mistake (again!).
But in my failure to explain myself, you really see a point. Evolution makes predictions. It predict that you would not find fossils out of sequence, which is right most of the time. What predictions does ID make?
Pretty funny. Not sure what you mean except perhaps you thought my example was ridiculous, but I've heard ID proponants say things very similar to my "hypothetical example", and you probably have too. I suppose "hypothetical" was the wrong word. I really meant that it wasn't "word-for word" what I had heard.
Well, I have to find an example where ID makes a definite claim. They are as rare as hen's teeth. This was one I had actually heard, though it still isn't really a claim, because it doesn't address the mechanism for directing the cosmic rays. Do you have any examples of specific mechanisms that ID proponants have put forth?
Perhaps the mechanism cart is a bit ahead of the event horse. But the only "event" I can see ID proposing is that "the designer directed it". No specific event is ever described in a way such that a mechanism could be proposed. So about the only question you can ask is "how did the designer direct it"?
LOL. Then ID won't progress, because there is no natural process which cannot potentially be explained by natural means. Lots of them are difficult, for sure. So it seems as if you are asking to define, "where does science give up?" I'm guessing they won't ever give up.
Oops. I pulled it off a paleo chart on my wall. We geologists are notoriously bad spelars. Once again, I apologize.![]()
Yes, point made. I should perhaps be clearer in stating what aspect of evolution I would like to see tested. As a starting point, it's the claim that 'All organisms can be accounted for purely in terms of Evo by NS', (I'll include sexual selection in that - though to my mind it requires a certain level of intelligence - but what the heck, I'm feeling generous.)
I'm not sure I would diffrentiate between conjecture and hypothesis. I don't see any substantial difference between steps one and two above. Also I might change observations to include testing. But that's nitpicking. I'll accept the above a general processThe chain of reasoning involved in science generally runs.
Observations are made.
A conjecture is produced to explain the observations.
The conjecture is used to generate hypotheses (predictions).
The hypotheses are tested using new observations.
The conjecture is adjusted to account for the results of the hypotheses testing.
The cycle repeats.
After a sufficient number of cycles, the conjecture is regarded as 'well-attested' and merits the status of theory.
Well you see, that is really not step one. You are supposed to be making conjectures about ID, not negative conjectures about Evo by NS. (Let's just call it Evo to keep it short). That would be like saying, "I'm going to make conjectures that gravity must be designed because it can't explain magnetism".With ID
An organism is observed, which it is felt, is not explicable by Evo by NS.
(I'll take the bacterial flagellum as an example, with this caveat : I'm not saying the bacterial flagellum is inexplicable by EvobyNS, I'm merely explaining the kind of observation which might lead someone to propose the need for a new conjecture. It is possible for observations to be 're-interpreted' in such a way that a current theory can account for it, and the need for a new conjecture disappears.)
You could just as well say 'There exist some organisms which are the result of collision of parallel but slightly different universes'. You have said nothing to describe ID. You have just picked ID as the fallback position when you can't figure out Evo. You could have picked anything.Given the observations, a conjecture is proposed, roughly 'There exist some features in some organisms which are the result of intervention by an IDer'.
Except that if you tried to test gravitational theory by measuring the attraction of ping-pong balls for each other, you would conclude that it does not exist in small objects, since the effect would be unnoticable except with very sophistocated equipment.The next part of the process is to generate hypotheses. This is done by honing down the general claim of conjecture, to a specific testable prediction.
Asan example of this 'honing' process, from a theory of gravitation
If it's universal then it applies on earth.
If it applies on earth then it applies in my lab.
If it applies in my lab then it applies on my lab bench.
---
If it applies to all masses then it applies to masses about 20g.
If it applies to masses about 20g then it applies to ping-pong balls about 20g
If it applies to ping-pong balls about 20g then it applies to my ping-pong ball.
Now I can test predictions made by the theory of gravitation using my ping-pong ball in my lab. At each step a 'subconjecture' is generated until a final testable hypothesis is produced.
And you would probably conclude that ping-pong balls have no inherant gravity. After all, they don't attract each other. Your tests would verify this. You can't predict the tides by watching the water in your bathtub.Now I can test predictions made by the theory of gravitation using my ping-pong ball in my lab. At each step a 'subconjecture' is generated until a final testable hypothesis is produced.
Except thay you have no observations, not a single one, about ID. Again, you are not testing ID at all, but using it as your fallback position if your observations about Evo are inconclusive. This in a nutshell is the problem with those who support "teaching" ID in school. Their position is "ID must be correct because science can't explain everything." Substitute 'astrology' for 'ID' and they would go nuts. To give evidence for ID, the conjectures and experiments must be about ID, not about evolution.For ID, a general 'subconjecture' is that there will be more features which are not explicable by EvobyNS. [If this isn't the case, then a single observation is all we have, no patterns can be induced, and we have a single 'miraculous' event which is outside the scope of science.]
(emphasis mine)We then need a list of potential features which are not explicable by EvobyNS.
Nope. You've nothing in your conjecture or hypothesis or testing regarded how you predicted feature x.If this list is produced, then specific hypotheses can be generated - 'an organism with feature x will be discovered'. If 'an organism with feature x' is discovered, then bada-bing your conjecture is supported.
Actually, if you are making the hypothesis that ID predicts feature x, even if it remains forever unsupported, that does not, of itself, support Evo. Evo must provide its own predictions, not rely on the failure of other possibilities.The longer you wait without discovering such an organism, the less likely your conjecture becomes, and the more like the original theory is to be true.
Well, you can't get that list, for reasons I have explained, any more than I could give you a list of all things that are impossible.But, and here's the point, we need to work through the subconjecture stage before we get to the hypothesis (prediction) stage. If we can't get this ' list of potential features which are not explicable by EvobyNS' then the process grinds to a halt.
Well, I knew you meant it to be funny because of the smiley, but I also recognized the light-hearted sarcasm. That's okay. I use sarcasm too. Sorry if I "strawmanned" you.I suppose I was just trying to make it clear that I'm only defending my own arguments, not what any particular ID proponent happens to say. [ I don't really think that what you intended, I just thought it was funny and responded in kind.]
Yes, and my answer is a variety of similar responses: You're not testing ID. You're testing Evo for failure. The conjecture/hypothesis/theory of ID cannot rest upon asking for a list of where Evo stumbles. It must stand or fall on its own.Until it's clear what kind of potential events/observations couldn't be accounted for by the current theory, it not possible to produce an example which requires an alternative mechanism. Once that potential class is produced, observations can be made and (assuming observations are actually obtained), a mechanism to account for it can be produced. [It sounds like I'm harping on about this - I'm trying to make it clear exactly what I mean, by saying it in various different ways.]
I think it is dead center. Look at what you have asked for: A list of the areas that Evo could potentially fail. In the search for truth, the only way to truly fail is to give up looking. Science, of which evolution is one part, is nothing more than a method of searching for truth. As long as you are still searching, you have not failed.Sorry, that last characterisation of what I said is completely off-the-hook.
LOL. Well you got me there. That is indeed a tautology. I really need to proof-read my stuff better."There is no natural process which cannot potentially be explained by natural means", is tautological. If it requires other than natural means then it it is by definition not a natural process. If you want to use the word 'natural' then you'd better define it, are you contrasting it with 'artificial', 'man-made', 'supernatural' or what?
I would say that it is incumbent upon the ID proponants to provide this class of organisms. You are asking Evo proponants to agree to a list of where evolution not only fails, but cannot succeed. I would say I've paraphrased you accurately.I never said anything about science giving up; by 'we' I meant you and me, in this thread, discussing this topic. 'We' can't agree on what this class of organisms is, so I couldn't see how to progress.
I don't think you intended to say anything about what science is capable of, but that is certainly the result. Please be assured though that I do not intend this a a personal attack. You've been nothing but polite, and I've greatly enjoyed discussing this with you. If I've been overly harsh or sarcastic, I truly apologize. I try to save that for Iacchus.That was the point I was making, nothing about what science in general is capable of (I'll admit to an inflated sense of my own importance, but gee whizz I don't see my personal limitations in this area as the ultimate boundary of what science can achieve)
[Though I'll understand if you want to disagreed with that last bit.]