Business Astrology

Well, Karen's browsing here at the moment, perhaps she's just typing up her acceptance of the Challenge - and the answers to all those questions.

Then again, maybe not.

Rolfe.
 
Karen Boesen said:
MW: "Enjoy : http://www.skeptica.dk/mw/astrologi/randi.htm "

FYI: as ususal skeptica.dk `s websites about astrology are full of lies, manipulations, twisting of data etc. etc.

ENJOY!
But you, on the other hand, refuse to answer any questions whatsoever. Can you please point me to a reference (of which there has to be numerous, considering the seriousness of the crime) that points to the name of the murderer that works at skeptica.dk?

If you cannot back up this claim, you should not have put it forth in the first place. And again: Danish references (online) will be just fine, as I can read that with no problems.

Regards
-Øyvind
 
Karen,

Are you going to respond to my most recent question about your unfounded accusations that Morgens Winther is Joseph Mengele's grandchild and also a Nazi? I'm taking it that your silence means you have no evidence to support it and do not retract from this accusation. I wonder what the laws are in Denmark regarding this sort of nasty accusation...

Are you going to tell Cleopatra exactly how much you charge for you to answer questions here? You made such a huge fuss to tell us all that is what is required to get answers from you, so how about showing Cleopatra your price list when she asks for it. If you don't give her some straight information, it means you never had any answers worth selling in the first place.

Will you inform us of a reference, any reference, to anything anywhere about the "murderer" scientist in the Danish Skeptics? If I don't hear from you immediately then I take it that this is just another totally nasty fairy-tale you have invented.

Really, Karen, this is getting to be the usual thing we can expect from you, isn't it. Do you have the faintest idea how completely silly and unprofessional you sound these days? And I wonder how your fellow astrologers in your own association, and indeed the rest of Denmark, would view this kind of behaviour if they knew of it... No wonder you tell them not to come here!

regards
Zep

PS. dann, here's Karen's words on the Joseph Mengele issue again:
For instance the guy above, Mr. Winther, is the grandchild of Josef Mengele. One of the worst warcriminals in Europe during World War 2.
But THE FACT is that Josef Mengele - Winthers grandfather - was a creep. Winther is a creep as well. I believe that it runs in the family. At least their methods are the same.
 
I'm well aware of Karen Boesen's words, Zep. But when you ask her for proof, you should take into consideration what is relevant and what isn't. Mogens Winther's (or anybody's) grandparents? Boring! There must be a thousand skeptics with a grandfather guilty of everythng from misdemeanours to atrocities. What are you going to say to Karen Boesen if she is actually able to dig up dirt about somebody's grandfather? 'I stand corrected.'???
That would be absurd because the accusation itself is so stupid, not the lack of proof.
What would you do if she accused somebody of being gay? Or an atheist? Ask her to prove it?!
Unlike this one: "At least their methods are the same."
Now in this case evidence would be interesting!
 
dann said:
I'm well aware of Karen Boesen's words, Zep. But when you ask her for proof, you should take into consideration what is relevant and what isn't. Mogens Winther's (or anybody's) grandparents? Boring! There must be a thousand skeptics with a grandfather guilty of everythng from misdemeanors to atrocities. What are you going to say to Karen Boesen if she is actually able to dig up dirt about somebody's grandfather? 'I stand corrected.'???
That would be absurd because the accusation itself is so stupid, not the lack of proof.
What would you do if she accused somebody of being gay? Or an atheist? Ask her to prove it?!
Unlike this one: "At least their methods are the same."
Now in this case evidence would be interesting!
I quite agree about the need for relevance, and I also agree that the subject per se is quite irrelevant to Karen's claims, etc. What is REALLY important is that Karen is in the habit of tossing up all sorts of wild and unsupported claims, baseless accusations and personal invective, and refuses to support it or even be challenged on it. It is obvious that all she wants is to be able to vent her spleen at us without fear of reprisal.

The reality which escapes her is that that sort of behaviour doesn't wash on this board, as you know. So, from the beginning of this thread we have been politely trying to examine her claims and facts in exactly the same way that we do for all our debates here. And suddenly Karen realised that she was on a sticky wicket, and so she reverted to just dodging-and-weaving (eg. wanting to be paid to answer), and sidetracking (eg. the Mengele issue). It's quite clear that she is hoping that we will all give up on her, so that she can then claim that she "bested us" with her arguments - like Kent Hovind, it would seem she thinks that whoever has the last word, no matter how crazy that word is, "wins" the argument.

And so a few of us here are quite happy to continue to dog her steps, to reiterate the questions in search of fair answers. Of which there's quite a few still outstanding!

Btw, Morgens did inform us that his grandfather was actually interned in a KZ. And I note that, although Karen has conceded en passant and very indirectly that Mengele really had nothing to do with Morgens' family, she has yet to come right out and say that to us. She has had no hesitation in the past in producing her supporting data... So one would start to think that she is actually incapable of admitting her errors...or perhaps she wants that commentary deliberately left on the record here so she can boast about it to her astrological friends for some reason. Either way, it needs to be definitely resolved, don't you think?

And if she accuses people of being gay, atheist, or even as she has done to me personally, of being stupid, then yes, I do think she needs to be made to put up or retract. It will be a new experience for her!
 
I guess I agree with both of you here ;).

1) Yes, it is completely irrelevant who somebody's grandfather was. A mass murderer's grandson (and son, for that matter), can be a great man, and vice versa.

2) Yes it deserves note that KB repeats something that has been denied, without backing it up. It is a clear demonstration of KB's level of honesty.

Moreover, it is very interesting to see this preoccupation with heritage. I thought that according to astrology, people's character was in their horoscope, not in their heritage?

Hans
 
dann said:

I have to admit that I don't quite get this one:
I am not surprised that Karen Boesen accuses somebody of being the grandson of Joseph Mengele, infamous Nazi war criminal.
But what if he were?! Could you blame him for the atrocities of his alleged grandfather? Are we talking original sin?
Karen Boesen's accusation is absurd, no matter what!

Dann,

I agree. I don't give a flying fanny who MW's grandfather is.

What I'm trying to do is demonstrate that Karen seems to fling all these accusations at various people, then run away without backing up her claims.
I notice she has visited the board since my post and still hasn't addressed the issues raised by those here.
She has had her chance. She has lost this debate IMO.
More importantly, she has failed to demonstrate any evidence for business astrology. Indeed I think she has damaged what little credibility it had.
 
Zep said:
(...) it would seem she thinks that whoever has the last word, no matter how crazy that word is, "wins" the argument.
Well, it's even worse than that. Remember this one?
As said by Simonsen earlier: " your folk ( astrologers etc. ) are woo-woo`s, the sort of people, who the nazists looked at as " minor people": You can complain from now on and until the day you die. Noone will ever listen to you! "
Very nice person this Simonsen. Maybe I should also mention that he calls himself a socialist.
One thing is that she invents a quotation. Another thing is that she, the wife of a self-proclaimed Marxist, tells her American and therefore, in her opinion, anti-socialist audience what I allegedly call myself. Her opportunism is also extreme.
I don't go around calling myself a socialist, but I don't try to hide the fact that I am no friend of capitalism.
In the context, however, I found it irrelevant.
 
Dann : Mogens Winther's (or anybody's) grandparents? Boring!

Exactly - as I wrote, it has nothing to do with this discussion.

The problem about heritage in astrology is however not simple, according to Mundane astrology, a nation as such may get a horoscope, which is defined by the birth horoscope of e.g. the constitution, or e.g. the dictator / president.

In case of the United States, the horoscope is July 4 1776,

in case of the Third Reich, the nations horoscope was defined as April 20, 1889. (birthday today).

So to speak, the German Reich became an aries similar to Hitler, Aries means a warrior. (Remember Gibers quote - "All Germans were like Mengele, more or less")...


The same simplification was done by Karen, when she did forecast an electional succes of the Danish Social democrates.

Applying the birthday of that old party, she could see no negative Social democrate transits during the recent election - however the election became the worst disaster to that party since the 1930-s.

http://www.skeptica.dk/mw/astrologi/randi.htm

/MW
 
I, for one, am waiting with bated breath for more news about you murderous, socialist, ankle-biting Danish skeptics with Nazi ancestry.
"Have you heard?
It's in the stars,
Next July we collide with Mars."
 
What say I make up a digest of outstanding questions that Karen has yet to answer? I'll leave out the ones that are not to do with Karen Boessen or Business Astrology, thus shortening the list a bit. Then we can leave them to be worked through each time we hear from Karen. At least she can't then accuse us of changing the subject.
 
Zep said:
What say I make up a digest of outstanding questions that Karen has yet to answer? I'll leave out the ones that are not to do with Karen Boessen or Business Astrology, thus shortening the list a bit. Then we can leave them to be worked through each time we hear from Karen. At least she can't then accuse us of changing the subject.

Be my guest! :)
 
For the Danish/Scandinavian readers:

Annett Kofoed, one of the contributors to Karen Boesen's website presseofre.dk ('victims of the press'), is on TV Thursday, April 22.

Den halve sandhed
23:50-00:20 DR 2 (Underholdning)
Arbejdsmarkedet.
Lige siden Claus Hjort Frederiksen begyndte at doktorere på arbejdsløsheden i Danmark er det gået den gale vej med patienten. Den traditionelle kur virker ikke - arbejdsløsheden er steget.
Derfor har Den Halve Sandhed sat en flok alternative behandlere på sagen. Og der er store problemer i ministeriet. Auratyderen ser straks massive konflikter på ministeriets 2. sal. N. Den grønlandske shaman har kontakt med ånderne på Slotsholmen. Og numerologen fortæller hvad Beskæftigelsesministeriet bør hedde, hvis arbejdsløsheden skal ned.
Sendt første gang 16.4.
Genre Underholdning
Varighed 30 minutter


Enjoy!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom