Mogens Winther
Scholar
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2004
- Messages
- 68
"YES; One can see incest in a horoscope!!! Why on Earth is that a problem? ....
The problem, my dear Karen, is the risc of your astrological amateur detectives / therapists inducing false memory into your clients.
Let me quote http://www.religioustolerance.org/ra_rep05.htm
"Dr. van Koppen is highly critical of the therapists' role in the creation of these accusations. ..."
"To "help" the clients recover the memories, a variety of techniques are used: hypnosis, guided imagery and dream interpretations. "
and further : "Unfortunately, this so-called "recovered memory therapy" leads to pseudo memories, memories about events that never took place."
"This in often turn leads to accusations, which may include charges of infanticide, against the client's parents. "
"The lives of the falsely accused I listened to have been ruined, whole families have been driven apart. All because of nonsense." Very few charges lead to convictions. There have been more than 500 such cases in the Netherlands in recent years, and only one conviction. The latter based on a confession. "
And that is one of the reasons why all you amateur jungians etc are so dangerous.
Not to forget : the risc of inducing selfattribution, a phenomena described by e.g. Susan Blackmore.
A well known phenomena of horoscope <> incest goes back to the Woody Allen case - :
The US astrologer Donna Cunningham is not in doubt, the planets have about mr Allen being guilty -
"Based on my years of work with incest survivors, his tight Mars-Pluto-Venus t-square with Mars in the 5th is not inconsistent with a more compulsive, sinister sexual pattern, especially as the Sun of the boy he was accused of molesting conjuncts that Mars. "
http://www.mountainastrologer.com/scorpio/299cunningham.html
And Karen, maybe I should remind you about the Pluto Mars press letters - as published from your astrological collegue, Karl AAge (treasurer and cofounder of Karens ISBA) during the media coverage of last summers tragical Mia murder case ?
/MW