Bush NSA spies on Americans

"High crimes and misdemeaners" iirc. We'll find a lawyer to fill in the blanks; some of them may be Democrats, and all we need is one.

courtesy of wkipedia
Procedurally, it is a two-step process. The House of Representatives must first pass "articles of impeachment" by a simple majority. The articles of impeachment constitute the formal allegations. Upon their passage, the defendant has been "impeached."

Next, the Senate tries the accused. In the case of the impeachment of a President, the Chief Justice of the United States presides over the proceedings. Otherwise, the Vice President, in his capacity of President of the Senate, or the President pro tempore of the Senate presides. This would include the impeachment of the Vice President him- or herself. In order to convict the accused, a two-thirds majority of the Senators present is required.

Following conviction, the Senate may vote to punish the individual only by removing him from office, or by barring him from holding future office, or both. Alternatively, it may impose no punishment. However in the case of executive officers, removal follows automatically upon conviction. The defendant remains liable to criminal prosecution. It is possible to impeach someone even after the accused has vacated his office in order to disqualify the person from such emoluments of office as a pension.
 
Yes, fine and dandy. But what high crime has been committed? Crime being the operative word. Or what misdemeanor? Again, if there is no law against the President using the NSA to spy on Democrats how can you impeach him?

Lurker
 
Yes, fine and dandy. But what high crime has been committed? Crime being the operative word. Or what misdemeanor? Again, if there is no law against the President using the NSA to spy on Democrats how can you impeach him?

Lurker
Not coming to hammy's defense, but... impeachment/removal of president is a political process, even though it has some of the trappings of criminal procedure, such as the constitutional words high crime and misdemeanor, and a Senate "trial." There need not be a prior conviction of a crime in a court of law, and real criminal procedure, with all its protections, is not included in the constitutional prescription or in practice (evidence: Clinton impeachment).

But then you've all let hammy take you down a pointless digression all over again. You ask if the president can legally spy domestically for political purposes, he starts rambling on about impeachment, which he correctly implies doesn't really involve questions of crime, in the legal sense, anyway, and he's got plenty of fish for his bait.

Don't be a sucker! Don't follow hammy's line of reasoning anywhere!
 
But then you've all let hammy take you down a pointless digression all over again. You ask if the president can legally spy domestically for political purposes, he starts rambling on about impeachment, which he correctly implies doesn't really involve questions of crime, in the legal sense, anyway, and he's got plenty of fish for his bait.

Don't be a sucker! Don't follow hammy's line of reasoning anywhere!
Yeah, I'm such a dunce.

Crimes ... conspiracy is a favorite ... trot out the facts, we'll find an illegality. What law did Nixon break?
 
Can the President use the NSA to spy on Democrats? Tap their phone lines for useful info for the campaign trail? As long as it is not used in court, right? I mean, that seems to be the logical extension of your argument. What would stop him, legally?

Lurker

I'd say no. Nixon would agree were he still above ground. However; political partisans who end up with great power do abuse said power in predictable ways. Witness the Filegate scandal during the Clinton presidency.

-z
 
Umm,no, I don't think Nixon did any B&E, Obstruction, that would have stuck (w/out the pardon).

Conspiracy re. B&E if you want to be that technical. But you're right, the main charges involved obstruction of justice.
 
I gotta get my flight bags packed now and get ready to fly out. No my arms won't get tired.

After re-reading through this thread I leave you with this thought:

Republicans seem to be willing to risk our constitutional rights to protect our lives from terrorists, yet Democrats seem to be willing to risk our lives to protect us from Republicans.

Are we caught between Iraq and a hard place?

Happy Holidays!

:D
 
Republicans seem to be willing to risk our constitutional rights to protect our lives from terrorists, yet Democrats seem to be willing to risk our lives to protect us from Republicans.
Since we claim to revere those who risk their lives to protect our Constitutional rights, repealing or ignoring those rights to protect our lives seems to contradict our patriotic propaganda.
 
Republicans seem to be willing to risk our constitutional rights to protect our lives from terrorists, yet Democrats seem to be willing to risk our lives to protect us from Republicans.

This statement deserves further examination. As far as the Republicans protecting us from terrorists... they have proven in the past that when they bend the rules, ostensibly for our safety, they cannot resist the temptation to instead (or also) use that position for shenanigans having nothing to do with making us safe.

So, I would say, "Republicans risk our constitutional rights and say it's to protect our lives from terrorists. Democrats risk lives to protect our constitutional rights."

That's even if you consider whistleblowing on wrongdoing to be life-threatening (what should happen instead, allow wrongdoing with impunity?) ... and if you consider the news media to be "Democrats".
 
This statement deserves further examination. As far as the Republicans protecting us from terrorists... they have proven in the past that when they bend the rules, ostensibly for our safety, they cannot resist the temptation to instead (or also) use that position for shenanigans having nothing to do with making us safe.

I'm not a Republican and I don't ask this question in their defense (or Democrats for that matter), but with regard to terrorism and shenanigans, are you taking another swipe at the WMD issue, or do you have other examples in mind?
 
I'm not a Republican and I don't ask this question in their defense (or Democrats for that matter), but with regard to terrorism and shenanigans, are you taking another swipe at the WMD issue, or do you have other examples in mind?
not the WMD issue, in fact... one example is COINTELPRO. Now, I accept President Johnson as well as Nixon were complicit there... but I think it's an excellent example of abuse of surveillance power.

I throw this at Republicans' feet because currently they are the only party demanding this amount of power.
 
not the WMD issue, in fact... one example is COINTELPRO. Now, I accept President Johnson as well as Nixon were complicit there... but I think it's an excellent example of abuse of surveillance power.

I throw this at Republicans' feet because currently they are the only party demanding this amount of power.
No, not really. The Democrats have always pushed for similar powers. One of the worst escalations of the War on Drugs, and concurrent violations of civil rights (such as expanded wire-tap powers) was during Clinton's presidency, and many bad laws were signed by him. The original Communications Decency Act, which would have greatly restricted speech on the Internet and many other places, was a creation of the Democrats (sen. Exon, to be precise). LBJ was responsible for just as much nastiness as Nixon when it came to chipping away at Constitutional protections.

Regardless of the various issues and principles that they pay lip service to; the primary goal of both parties is simply to increase their own power as much as possible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom