Browne wrong again and the police pay: Hunter Horgan

Mulatto: Of mixed Caucasian and African American heritage.

Which means absolutely nothing. The average African American has 80% African and 20% European ancestry. It a hollow term for someone who thinks of skin pigment as some defining feature of ancestory.

In this case, Browne threw that in to indicate someone who might have lighter skin, as a result of his Caucasian heritage, than some African Americans.

The article reported Browne claimed the man was "killed by a young mulatto." It's unclear what she meant by it because someone whose mother is white and father is black can still be "dark-skinned" based on a variety of genetic factors. Furthermore, she did not mention skin-color.

While I would never speak well of Browne, I don't think she meant it as offensive. For police conducting a search, it would be an important factor.

Intent or not, its an arcane term given what we know about skin-pigment and genetics. It's in the same out-dated vocabulary, such as calling someone "colored."
 
Which means absolutely nothing. The average African American has 80% African and 20% European ancestry. It a hollow term for someone who thinks of skin pigment as some defining feature of ancestory.

Well, I didn't invent the word, simply offered the definition of it.

The article reported Browne claimed the man was "killed by a young mulatto." It's unclear what she meant by it because someone whose mother is white and father is black can still be "dark-skinned" based on a variety of genetic factors. Furthermore, she did not mention skin-color.

I disagree. Look, my mother consistently used the term "mulatto" to describe a varying light brown skin tone, in precisely the same way that she used "peaches and cream" or "English Rose" to describe those skin tones. She was not a racist - it was simply the term and the context she had grown up with. She was from Turner, Kansas-the same area of the country where Browne grew up-and they were the same age. So, given those similarities, it's not impossible that Browne grew up hearing that term in the same context and, in her mind, she was mentioning a skin color. Skin tone. Skin shade. Whatever.

It's in the same out-dated vocabulary, such as calling someone "colored."

Why are you pointing that out to me? I'm aware it's outdated. I don't use the term. Point it out to her.
 
Last edited:
... She charged police for the identity of the man responsible for a murder?
Disgusting.
 
Well, I didn't invent the word, simply offered the definition of it.

I know.


I disagree. Look, my mother consistently used the term "mulatto" to describe a varying light brown skin tone, in precisely the same way that she used "peaches and cream" or "English Rose" to describe those skin tones. She was not a racist - it was simply the term and the context she had grown up with. She was from Turner, Kansas-the same area of the country where Browne grew up-and they were the same age. So, given those similarities, it's not impossible that Browne grew up hearing that term in the same context and, in her mind, she was mentioning a skin color. Skin tone. Skin shade. Whatever.

The meaning of words change, as do appropriateness. Older people tend to use words that were common when they were younger. No different than old men still dressing in a fashion decades old.

That is why some people who are not racist still call African-Americans "colored," despite that not being appropriate. Browne being a public figure making public statements should be careful when making public statements. And she could also use terms that are less vague (we still don't know what she meant by it).

It's 'biracial,' not 'mulatto'
December 06, 2008
modbee.com

Regarding "Obama is as much white as black," (Nov. 18, Letters): It would behoove you to utilize a new word rather than the antiquated Latin term "mulatto."

It was often used during the days of slavery and is offensive to some who, like me, have children of mixed ethnicity. Biracial, meaning two races, is much more relevant today. During slavery, it did not matter if one was partially white. He or she was considered black. Yet we owe it to those who have fought valiantly for civil rights to call Barack Obama our first black or African-American president.
...

http://www.modbee.com/opinion/letters/story/524024.html

Why are you pointing that out to me? I'm aware it's outdated. I don't use the term. Point it out to her.

I pointed out the problem with its usage (vagueness, offensiveness, and scientifically incorrect) to anyone reading this post.
 
Last edited:
The meaning of words change, as do appropriateness. Older people tend to use words that were common when they were younger. No different than old men still dressing in a fashion decades old.

That is why some people who are not racist still call African-Americans "colored," despite that not being appropriate. Browne being a public figure making public statements should be careful when making public statements. And she could also use terms that are less vague (we still don't know what she meant by it).

I agree, absolutely. I was only looking at her statement from the viewpoint of whether she was being deliberately offensive, as she so often is. In this case, in the context in which she used the word, I don't think she was. Inappropriate, yes, but not intentionally derogatory. That's all. And that's about as much credit as I'll ever give her.

I pointed out the problem with its usage (vagueness, offensiveness, and scientifically incorrect) to anyone reading this post.

Yeah, sorry, I realized that after I posted. :)
 
I disagree. Look, my mother consistently used the term "mulatto" to describe a varying light brown skin tone, in precisely the same way that she used "peaches and cream" or "English Rose" to describe those skin tones. She was not a racist - it was simply the term and the context she had grown up with. She was from Turner, Kansas-the same area of the country where Browne grew up-and they were the same age. So, given those similarities, it's not impossible that Browne grew up hearing that term in the same context and, in her mind, she was mentioning a skin color. Skin tone. Skin shade. Whatever.

I agree. An African-American with lighter skin is very often referred to as a "mulatto" by older people, even if they are not biracial.

However, whether he has a white parent or not, this young man is actually dark-skinned. By me, anyway.

So I chalk it up to a "wrong", even if she was describing skin tone.
 
Here's another mention of the court case:

http://www.dailycomet.com/article/20081220/ARTICLES/812209971/0/SPORTS12



Here's a little something you all might enjoy:


http://www.lexisnexis.com.proxy.wex...&treeMax=true&treeWidth=0&csi=144563&docNo=13


The Advocate (Baton Rouge, Louisiana)
October 13, 1997 Monday METRO EDITION
Story, use of psychic criticized

SECTION: NEWS; Pg. 8B; READERS' VIEWS

LENGTH: 438 words



I read with shock and dismay the article describing the Thibodaux
Police Department's use of a "psychic" investigator in the Rev.
Hunter Horgan III murder case ("Psychic gives police clues into
priest's 1992 slaying", Sept. 14, 1997, Pages 1B and 2B).
In an age when the forensic sciences have improved our
understanding of the best methods for the collection and evaluation
of evidence of crimes, it is disheartening to see officials waste
taxpayers' money on an investigative method that has no validity
whatsoever.


The use of these kinds of "clues" has a long and terrible record
in human history, ranging from the medieval European Inquisition to
the Salem witch trials, where in both cases the accusers believed
that they did it "all for God," as Ms. Sylvia Browne does.
But even more troubling is the manner in which the article was
written.
In it, John McMillan of the River Parishes Bureau reports that the
purported "psychic," Sylvia Browne of Campbell, Calif., "found the
body of a murder victim for an agency in Pennsylvania and gave the
FBI a description and the names of the perpetrators of the World
Trade Center bombing. "
This information is stated as fact in the article and does not
attribute its source.
Did Mr. McMillan contact the investigative agencies or any other
sources in an effort to verify this information as any responsible
journalist would do?
Or did he report as fact statements supplied by Ms. Browne and/or
the officers who hired her.
If she did singlehandedly solve both these crimes, she should be
hailed as a true wonder of our age and should be enlisted to assist
the authorities in solving all major crimes.
But if, as I suspect, Mr. McMillan failed to use objective
journalistic techniques, then he, the editors of the Metro/State
section and the Sunday Advocate editor should apologize to their
readers and also to the family of Rev. Horgan for misleading them
about the qualifications of this "investigator. "

While I can understand that the police in Thibodaux would want to
use all available resources in the investigation of this terrible
crime, I also believe that our police forces should use rational,
reasonable methods of systematic inquiry.
Would you like to be arrested for murder on the strength of a $ 400
tip from a "California psychic" like Ms. Browne?
Unfortunately, I have come to expect this state's elected
officials to act irrationally.
Should I now expect the newspaper of record for the state of
Louisiana to be unskeptical, anti-scientific and unobjective?
Joe Olivier
1520 W. Congress St.
Lafayette
 
Yeah, I saw that too, but I didn't think a letter to the editor was worth posting. It's just one man's opinion, which didn't get a reply.

Also you might avoid posting personal information, like addresses. I'm sure the author doesn't want Browne's supporters sending nasty letters then or ten years later.
 
Accused priest killer's case remains in adult court

Here's an update on the murder trial:

Accused priest killer's case remains in adult court
‎May 29, 2009‎
Houma Courier

The Louisiana Supreme Court has denied an accused priest killer’s request to have his first-degree murder trial held in juvenile court.

Defense attorney Lynden Burton argued Derrick Odomes should be tried as a juvenile because he was 14 in August 1992 when he allegedly killed Episcopal priest Hunter Horgan. At the time, state law considered 14-year-olds as juveniles.

But the state’s highest court voted 4-2 last month not to hear Odomes’ case, thus upholding previous rulings made at the district and appeals court levels that the now 31-year-old defendant should be tried as an adult.

Authorities arrested Odomes on Sept. 17, 2007, more than 15 years after Horgan was slain inside the rectory of St. John Episcopal Church. The elapsed time between the incident and the arrest has made the issue of court jurisdiction a hotly contested one.
...
No new trial date has been set.

Full article: Houma Courier
 
"As a magician he doesn't have the credentials to judge anyone, especially on psychic abilities". Now that is funny. Thank you for the video. I have to say that is the first time I've seen Randi get mad like that but he held his composure pretty well don'cha (yes this is a Southern word) think.
 
Intent or not, its an arcane term given what we know about skin-pigment and genetics. It's in the same out-dated vocabulary, such as calling someone "colored."

"Mulatto" may actually be worse than "colored" as it seems to derive, at least in part, from a Spanish/Portuguese word that means "young mule" (according to the Oxford English Dictionary, anyway).
 
Here's an update:

Alleged teen killer, now 32, to be tried as adult
THIBODAUX DAILY COMET
‎Nov 24, 2009‎

THIBODAUX, La. (AP) - A 32-year-old man accused of killing a priest when he was 14 years old will be tried as an adult.

The U.S. Supreme Court has refused to hear Derrick Odomes' arguments for a trial in juvenile court, leaving intact rulings by three Louisiana courts.

He is charged with first-degree murder of the Rev. Hunter Horgan, who was bludgeoned, stabbed and robbed in the rectory of St. John Episcopal Church in August 1992.

Odomes was arrested 15 years later, on Sept. 17, 2007.
...

Full: THIBODAUX DAILY COMET
 
Update:

Suspect in priest slaying wants charges dropped
Daily Comet
By Abby Tabor
‎Jan 21, 2010‎

A Lafourche district judge postponed setting a trial date for a man accused of killing a Thibodaux priest after the defendant's attorney filed court papers Wednesday afternoon seeking to have the case thrown out.

Lynden Burton, the New Iberia-based attorney for Derrick Odomes, argued in his motion that his client is not eligible to receive prison time if convicted of the Rev. Hunter Horgan's August 1992 killing because state law at the time prevented 14-year-olds from being tried as adults.
...
Odomes' next scheduled court appearance on March 11 could provide an answer to the crucial issue of sentencing, as well as a new trial date, or it could lead to delays while the side that loses the ruling appeals to higher courts.

Odomes' case was delayed much of last year while his attorney appealed Judge John LeBlanc's decision to keep the case in adult court. The U.S. Supreme Court decided not to hear his case in October.
...
Burton's motion surprised prosecutors and the victim's family.
...
So does Horgan's family, who have waited more than 17 years for someone to be brought to trial for their relative's death.

“The family is very patient but very strong,” said family spokesman Jon Perry, Horgan's cousin. “We will be there when there is a trial.”
Full: Daily Comet
 
Some more info on Browne's involvement (if this hasn't been posted before):

http://thewoundedbird.blogspot.com/2007/08/in-memoriam-hunter-horgan.html

...


Porter Horgan [the victim's brother] argues that Thibodaux Police missed their opportunity to make an arrest long ago by failing to interview the proper individuals and evaluate the right evidence. One year after the crime occurred, the family hired a private investigator from Baton Rouge.

"We were amazed they didn’t interview certain people of interest," the minister’s brother said, declining to elaborate.
....

The Thibodaux Police Department’s use of psychic Sylvia Browne, best known for her appearances on TV’s "The Montel Williams Show," also drew Porter Horgan’s ire. The California-based psychic was paid $400 for one half-hour reading in 1997, Martin said, noting that most of the department supported the idea, as did then-Mayor Warren Harang.

"The Thibodaux Police Department is lost," the minister’s brother said. "I don’t think they could track an elephant in fresh snow."

...


Given that they neglected to look into a pretty obvious lead for 15 years, spent years on the wrong suspect and called a psychic they saw on TV to solve a murder, it sure as hell sounds like it...
 
Last edited:
Update:

Suspect in priest slaying won't do time
Houma Courier
By Raymond Legendre
‎March 12, 2010‎


A Houma man charged with the August 1992 slaying of a Thibodaux priest won't receive prison time if convicted of the crime, a district judge ruled Thursday.

Accused priest killer’s case remains in adult court Derrick Odomes, who was 14 when the Rev. Hunter Horgan III was killed, cannot be sentenced if convicted of first-degree murder in the priest's death, Judge John LeBlanc ruled. State law in 1992, the year of Horgan's murder, forbid juveniles convicted of a crime from serving time past their 21st birthday.
...
Full: Houma Courier

And yesterday:
Suspect in priest's slaying accused of crimes in jail
Houma Courier
By Raymond Legendre
March 19, 2010


An alleged priest-killer is accused of threatening to harm a jail guard who months earlier reported seeing the inmate performing a sexual act in her direction from inside his cell.

Alleged priest-killer scheduled to appear in court today The murder charge “won’t stick. I’m going to get out. I’m going to get you girl,” Derrick Odomes allegedly told deputy Haley Burkett Monday evening, according to Lafourche jail warden Alan Abadie.
...
Excluding his murder charge, Odomes has five pending felony charges — two counts of issuing worthless checks, theft, obscenity and intimidation of a witness.
...
Full: Houma Courier
 
Dont know the rules in the states,but,in Canada,if anyone withholds information about a murder,they can be charged. Why wasnt she forced to give a name? Then again,what kind of cops would use her services to begin with.

Good golly,someone needs to protect the characters of the dead around that woman. She is hurtful. She came here to Edmonton. A woman and her daughter was talking to her. The womans son had committed suicide and she was finally able to cope with this with the help of councelling. Sylvia informed her that her son was actually murdered. What a heartless animal she is. She had the poor lady crying and very confused.
 
An article by someone who knew Horgan:

Priest Murder Case Shows Leniency Of Louisiana Crime Laws ‎
Bayou Buzz
By Jim Brown
April 1, 2010

Father Hunter Horgan was a popular Episcopal priest in the small South Louisiana town of Thibodaux, Louisiana. He was severely beaten and then stabbed to death in the office of St. John’s Episcopal Church where he was rector. After 18 years of searching, the alleged killer, one Derrick Odomes, was caught, and bound over for trial. But last week, a district judge in the case ruled that Odomes committed the heinous crime as a juvenile, and under Louisiana’s convoluted law, he does not have to serve any time. What kind of justice is that?
...
Let me converse a bit about this special Episcopal priest whose life was taken so tragically. I knew Fr. Horgan. He presided over the marriage ceremony of my wife and me back in 1982 at Trinity Episcopal Church on Jackson Avenue in New Orleans. He was friendly, quite funny, and definitely my kind of priest.

As in many marriage ceremonies, the pastor visits and counsels with the couple before the ceremony. Fr. Horgan wanted to visit with us, but I keep finding an excuse to put off the session. He was younger than me, and I did not anticipate any words of wisdom from who I considered to be this “a bit wet behind the ears” preacher. Boy was I wrong.

When our counseling session finally took place, Fr. Horgan, bless his soul, did not hold back. He told my bride to be, in no uncertain terms, that she should work hard to please her husband (me), have a tasty dinner waiting each night, and be sure to “look good for him” when I came in the door from work. My fiancée was livid. I was ready to give Fr. Horgan a high five.
...

Full: Bayou Buzz
 
Both Fr Horgan and Mr Brown sound like people who would still use "mulatto." :rolleyes:
 
Trial date set

Here's the update:

Alleged priest killer's trial still set for August
‎Houma Courier
By Raymond Legendre
May 20, 2010 at 12:44 p.m.


The trial of a man accused of killing a Thibodaux priest nearly 18 years ago will go likely go forward in August, lawyers said, though a local judge ruled two months ago he cannot be sentenced for the crime because he was a juvenile at the time of the alleged murder.

District Attorney Cam Morvant II and defense attorney Lynden Burton each said they believe Derrick Odomes' Aug. 23 trial date will proceed as planned, even though an appeals court has not ruled whether he can be sentenced if convicted because he was a juvenile at the time.

Odomes, a 32-year-old Houma resident, is accused of killing the Rev. Hunter Horgan in August 1992 inside the rectory of St. John's Episcopal Church in Thibodaux. Odomes was 14 at the time of the priest's death.

District Judge John LeBlanc ruled in March that even if Odomes is convicted of killing Horgan, he can't be sentenced because state law in 1992 prohibited a juvenile from being sentenced as an adult. The Lafourche District Attorney's Office appealed LeBlanc's decision. Though the appeal is before the 1st Circuit Court of Appeal, that should not delay Odomes' trial, Burton and Morvant said.
...
One issue that will likely be discussed at Odomes' next court appearance is the prosecution's request to increase Odomes' bond amount based on a pending witness-intimidation charge.

That charge stems from allegations Odomes threatened a Lafourche Parish jail guard who was the alleged victim of an earlier obscene act committed by Odomes inside the jail.
...
Full: Houma Courier

And:

Alleged priest-killer's trial remains on course, attorneys say
‎Houma Courier (blog)
By Raymond Legendre
Published: Wednesday, May 19, 2010 at 10:08 p.m.

Attorneys in the case of a man accused of killing a Thibodaux priest nearly 18 years ago said Wednesday that they have begun preparing for his August trial.

District Attorney Cam Morvant II and defense attorney Lynden Burton each said they believe Derrick Odomes’ Aug. 23 trial date will go ahead as planned, even though an appeals court has not ruled whether he can be sentenced, if convicted.
...
Full: Houma Courier (blog)
 

Attachments

  • DerrickOdomesJail.jpg
    DerrickOdomesJail.jpg
    39.1 KB · Views: 1

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom