Here's another mention of the court case:
http://www.dailycomet.com/article/20081220/ARTICLES/812209971/0/SPORTS12
Here's a little something you all might enjoy:
http://www.lexisnexis.com.proxy.wex...&treeMax=true&treeWidth=0&csi=144563&docNo=13
The Advocate (Baton Rouge, Louisiana)
October 13, 1997 Monday METRO EDITION
Story, use of psychic criticized
SECTION: NEWS; Pg. 8B; READERS' VIEWS
LENGTH: 438 words
I read with shock and dismay the article describing the Thibodaux
Police Department's use of a "psychic" investigator in the Rev.
Hunter Horgan III murder case ("Psychic gives police clues into
priest's 1992 slaying", Sept. 14, 1997, Pages 1B and 2B).
In an age when the forensic sciences have improved our
understanding of the best methods for the collection and evaluation
of evidence of crimes, it is disheartening to see officials waste
taxpayers' money on an investigative method that has no validity
whatsoever.
The use of these kinds of "clues" has a long and terrible record
in human history, ranging from the medieval European Inquisition to
the Salem witch trials, where in both cases the accusers believed
that they did it "all for God," as Ms. Sylvia Browne does.
But even more troubling is the manner in which the article was
written.
In it, John McMillan of the River Parishes Bureau reports that the
purported "psychic," Sylvia Browne of Campbell, Calif., "found the
body of a murder victim for an agency in Pennsylvania and gave the
FBI a description and the names of the perpetrators of the World
Trade Center bombing. "
This information is stated as fact in the article and does not
attribute its source.
Did Mr. McMillan contact the investigative agencies or any other
sources in an effort to verify this information as any responsible
journalist would do?
Or did he report as fact statements supplied by Ms. Browne and/or
the officers who hired her.
If she did singlehandedly solve both these crimes, she should be
hailed as a true wonder of our age and should be enlisted to assist
the authorities in solving all major crimes.
But if, as I suspect, Mr. McMillan failed to use objective
journalistic techniques, then he, the editors of the Metro/State
section and the Sunday Advocate editor should apologize to their
readers and also to the family of Rev. Horgan for misleading them
about the qualifications of this "investigator. "
While I can understand that the police in Thibodaux would want to
use all available resources in the investigation of this terrible
crime, I also believe that our police forces should use rational,
reasonable methods of systematic inquiry.
Would you like to be arrested for murder on the strength of a $ 400
tip from a "California psychic" like Ms. Browne?
Unfortunately, I have come to expect this state's elected
officials to act irrationally.
Should I now expect the newspaper of record for the state of
Louisiana to be unskeptical, anti-scientific and unobjective?
Joe Olivier
1520 W. Congress St.
Lafayette