Browne wrong again and the police pay: Hunter Horgan

<snip>

ETA: Found some good news on the Haunting Evidence site. Seems they have a poll asking "After watching 'Haunting Evidence,' what are your feelings on the paranormal? ". Two thirds answered, "I’m a total skeptic." :)

I would not take that too seriously. I am sure it would be biased against skeptics. And the figure is 66.78% for "I’m a total skeptic." Must have gone up 0.1% because I voted.
 
I would not take that too seriously. I am sure it would be biased against skeptics. And the figure is 66.78% for "I’m a total skeptic." Must have gone up 0.1% because I voted.

I just voted, too. It's nice to see that the skeptics are ahead. Especially since I watched that show once and...big surprise...the "psychics" did not solve the case.
When will people realize that they can't and don't offer anything useful? Any case profiled that has to end with the words "if you know anything about this case please call your local police department or 1-800....etc." should clue people in that these "psychics" are completely useless.

By the way, is there a way to find out how Sylvia on Montel fares with the non-high-profile cases of the guests' missing or murdered loved ones? These people are on all the time asking for her help and Sylvia spouts her usual "help," and I wonder what happens later with her so-called information. For every high-profile case there must be 20 or so cases that are not that can either help to prove or disprove Sylvia's professed abilities.
 
Last edited:
I voted, too, actually.

M, I think you might be interested to know that some months back I scoured Lexis Nexis for "Sylvia Browne" and found several local paper articles from years back about missing people's families and their appearances on "Montel".

It would be like the Buffalo papers would report that so and so's family was gonna be on "Montel" or so and so's family had been on "Montel" or in articles about police investigations into these cases they'd mention the family had been on the show.

I was intrigued and I tried to follow-up on these missing persons' cases. Surprise, surprise none of them were ever found. The same Missing Person websites that were up then are still up now.
 
I voted, too, actually.

M, I think you might be interested to know that some months back I scoured Lexis Nexis for "Sylvia Browne" and found several local paper articles from years back about missing people's families and their appearances on "Montel".

It would be like the Buffalo papers would report that so and so's family was gonna be on "Montel" or so and so's family had been on "Montel" or in articles about police investigations into these cases they'd mention the family had been on the show.

I was intrigued and I tried to follow-up on these missing persons' cases. Surprise, surprise none of them were ever found. The same Missing Person websites that were up then are still up now.

Thanks for that. I had wondered. Well, tho I'm glad Sylvia can't claim any credit for helping, I'm sorry that those same people are still missing.
With the increased publicity against Sylvia, maybe some of these people who she was supposed to help on Montel will come forward and say something.
 
I just received a reply from the Thibodaux Police Department's Public Info Officer. She said she looked into it, and can find no record (or anyone who remembers) having paid a fee to Sylvia for consultation services. She said what I took to mean that as a rule they wouldn't.

QG, do you (or anyone else for that matter) have any contact info for the newspaper that printed the story, The Advocate in Baton Rouge? Would be interesting to see what the reporter says about his or her source.
 
Guess I should've done a bit of googling before askign for help. I did find a contact for John McMillan of The Advocate, and I have sent an inquiry to him.

Also, Ms. Guise said that maybe Sylvia was contracted by a private investigator hired by the family.
 
BTW, is it really a psychic feat to suspect the young mulatto" homosexual? I would have thought that went without saying, and would have figured the local police would have figured that out anyway.
 
Guess I should've done a bit of googling before askign for help. I did find a contact for John McMillan of The Advocate, and I have sent an inquiry to him.

Also, Ms. Guise said that maybe Sylvia was contracted by a private investigator hired by the family.

E-mail to the reporter bounced.

I sent a follow up query to the Public Info Officer asking in particular about the fact that the newspaper story alleges that it was the police captain who sought Sylvia's help. I understand it might be a touchy subject for this officer (and not really part of her regular duties), so I'm trying not to be very pushy.
 
E-mail to the reporter bounced.

I sent a follow up query to the Public Info Officer asking in particular about the fact that the newspaper story alleges that it was the police captain who sought Sylvia's help. I understand it might be a touchy subject for this officer (and not really part of her regular duties), so I'm trying not to be very pushy.

I think with calling you'd get better answers. I doubt the police would want this stuff in writing as it would be forwarded to anyone and likely to be embarrassing. In another case, the officer wanted to talk over the phone, and not via email.

I followed up on another case, and talked to an officer over the phone. When I directly asked if they paid Browne he said he wasn't sure, but wouldn't rule it out.

Also maybe try emailing the editor of the newspaper to follow up.
 
Yes, good point QG. I'll give it a few days to see if she answers and then try a phone call. I may also call the newspaper to see if they know how I can contact the reporter.
 
She replied. Unfortunately, we're kinda at a dead end. Capt. Martin (the one who, according to the newspaper story, sought out Sylvia's services) is no longer with the Thibodaux P.D.
 
She replied. Unfortunately, we're kinda at a dead end. Capt. Martin (the one who, according to the newspaper story, sought out Sylvia's services) is no longer with the Thibodaux P.D.

Was that by email or phone?

That's too bad a government agency gave money to someone and can't even confirm it years later.

They would certainly have a file on this murder including tips received. Of those tips would be Browne and information related to. I fail to see how a change in police captains would cause information to disappear.

Maybe if some JREFer lives near Thibodaux they can request those records in person.
 
Was that by email or phone?

That's too bad a government agency gave money to someone and can't even confirm it years later.

They would certainly have a file on this murder including tips received. Of those tips would be Browne and information related to. I fail to see how a change in police captains would cause information to disappear.

Maybe if some JREFer lives near Thibodaux they can request those records in person.

Just by e-mail. You care to give her (the public affairs officer) a call and start fresh? (I don't think I have the personality to do gentle pushing.)
 
Just by e-mail. You care to give her (the public affairs officer) a call and start fresh? (I don't think I have the personality to do gentle pushing.)

I'll do it when I know Robert can follow it up as well. In other words, yes, soon.

Of course if the police officer used his own money then we will never know anything for sure.

Maybe, but the article I quoted said:

...
The Thibodaux Police Department paid $ 400 for a half-hour consultation with Browne because, her secretary Larry Beck, said, "They wanted it right away."
...
 
How did we all miss this?

The most likely killer was found and arrested in 2007:

http://www.wwltv.com/local/stories/wwl091907jbpriest.ed5f57f4.html

http://www.wdsu.com/news/14141588/detail.html

http://www.meridianstar.com/local/local_story_265022348.html

http://www.wwltv.com/local/stories/wwl011808tpjuvenile.341e73ec.html


I can instantly hear Sylvia's fans' rebuttal to this: "Well, she said he'd be a mulatto!".

And maybe "Well, how do you know he wasn't gay?"

Wow, I didn't see this.


Original article from 1997 citing Sylvia Browne:

The Advocate (Baton Rouge, Louisiana)
September 14, 1997 Sunday METRO EDITION
SECTION: NEWS; Pg. 1B
HEADLINE: Psychic gives police clues into priest's 1992 slaying
BYLINE: JOHN MCMILLAN, RIVER PARISHES BUREAU
DATELINE: THIBODAUX

THIBODAUX - A little more than five years ago, the body of the Rev. Hunter Horgan III was found lying face-down in a pool of blood in the business office of St. John's Episcopal Church.

A California psychic hired by the Thibodaux Police Department now says the priest was killed by a "young mulatto" homosexual who was enraged by Hunter's rejection of his advances.
...

Source

Ten years later:

TITLE: Arrest in priest’s murder begins closure
DATE: 03:27 PM CDT on Wednesday, September 19, 2007
PUBLISHED: Houma Courier/WWL-TV

THIBODAUX -- In this town where murders are as rare as snow, the hallowed grounds of an Episcopal church are haunted by questions from a 15-year-old mystery.

Rev. Hunter Horgan III was found murdered in the rectory of his church in 1992.

Who bludgeoned a popular priest to death on a summer night in 1992, and for what reason?

Gathered Tuesday in front of the church hall where the priest was slain, a number of the faithful, family and clerics were told by police officials that answers had finally emerged.

Derrick Raynard Odomes, a 28-year-old habitual criminal, is accused of robbing and killing the Rev. Hunter Horgan III at St. John’s Episcopal Church on Aug. 13, 1992. The arrest, some said, begins a sense of closure for a crime that has remained an open wound.
...
Detectives re-interviewed the two men questioned in 1998, to see if they had a change of heart and would give further details about Odomes’ potential involvement with the crime, and they did.

With information gathered from those witnesses, detectives obtained court orders that allowed them to retrieve evidence from Odomes, including DNA and handprints.

A State Police specialist matched a handprint taken from the scene in 1992 with Odomes’ handprint.
...

Source

So do the police get a refund from Browne?

It seems Odomes was a long-time suspect prior to Browne's reading. It also appears that she was wrong on the motivation for the murder: it was robbery, not "homosexual advances."

I don't know what Browne meant by the offensive term "mulatto" and what that does or would have to do with anything, but I attached Odomes's mugshot below. Maybe one of Browne's defenders can explain it to us.
 

Attachments

  • Odomes.jpg
    Odomes.jpg
    5.8 KB · Views: 156
I don't know what Browne meant by the offensive term "mulatto" and what that does or would have to do with anything, but I attached Odomes's mugshot below. Maybe one of Browne's defenders can explain it to us.

Mulatto: Of mixed Caucasian and African American heritage. In this case, Browne threw that in to indicate someone who might have lighter skin, as a result of his Caucasian heritage, than some African Americans. While I would never speak well of Browne, I don't think she meant it as offensive. For police conducting a search, it would be an important factor.
 
Either you or I should have caught this earlier, QG. :( What a good coincidence I just happened to think of this in relation to another thread and Googled it.

Mr. Odomes is actually what I would described as a dark-skinned African-American. Maybe mid-toned but not light-skinned.

I doubt he's biracial but it's entirely possible he is of mixed ancestry.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom