• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Cont: Brexit: Now What? 9 Below Zero

Status
Not open for further replies.
Johnson is trying to use this to force a general election, and he may succeed.

Why would Johnson want another general election? Didn't May try that, to her dismay. Also, didn't this whole fracas start with Blair calling for a referendum that he thought would strengthen his position only to get defeated? History seems to suggest it's a risky strategy. <-- assuming my memory is correct.
 
Last edited:
Why would Johnson want another general election? Did May try that, to her dismay.
Yes, right.
Also, didn't this whole fracas start with Blair calling for a referendum that he thought would strengthen his position only to get defeated? History seems to suggest it's a risky strategy. <-- assuming my memory is correct.
The 2016 referendum was called by Cameron, not by Blair.
 
Why would Johnson want another general election?
Because he has no majority and is unable to get legislation passed. The only way to get anything through the House of Commons right now is for the Labour and Conservative parties to agree on it. Unfortunately Brexit is one topic where they can never agree, and that's why we have the ongoing stalemate that's harming everyone.
 
Except that parliamentary rules prevent them from proposing the same thing over and over?

Weirder and weirder.

Johnson will just answer ever question & criticism with "Give me an election". It will be politics by the nagging of a five year old, in a sane country this behaviour would rapidly render him unelectable. Of course in a sane country his history of compulsive lying covering his entire working life would have done that.

"Dad, can we go to Duff Gardens"
"Dad, can we go to Duff Gardens"
"Dad, can we go to Duff Gardens"
"Dad, can we go to Duff Gardens"
"Dad, can we go to Duff Gardens"
"Dad, can we go to Duff Gardens"
 
Why would Johnson want another general election? Didn't May try that, to her dismay. Also, didn't this whole fracas start with Blair calling for a referendum that he thought would strengthen his position only to get defeated? History seems to suggest it's a risky strategy. <-- assuming my memory is correct.

Because he thinks, possibly quite rightly, he can win a majority and once he has that he can drive the country into the gutter to benefit himself and his rich cronies. He has ideologically cleansed the party and cabinet so he can drive through whatever he wants if he gets the numbers.

At the minute the only thing holding off the disaster is the fact that the opposition aren't giving him the election he wants. I guess the thinking is that the longer he is rendered impotent the more the Brexit party might gain but it could well have the opposite effect if he is seen as being the guy who is standing up for Brexit against the tide of Parliament trying to stop it.
 
Why would Johnson want another general election? Didn't May try that, to her dismay. Also, didn't this whole fracas start with Blair calling for a referendum that he thought would strengthen his position only to get defeated? History seems to suggest it's a risky strategy. <-- assuming my memory is correct.

I think you're assuming a level of wise decision-making that has not thus far been evident.
 
At the minute the only thing holding off the disaster is the fact that the opposition aren't giving him the election he wants. I guess the thinking is that the longer he is rendered impotent the more the Brexit party might gain but it could well have the opposite effect if he is seen as being the guy who is standing up for Brexit against the tide of Parliament trying to stop it.

I'm not sure "thinking" is the word I'd use for British opposition right now. Not for Labour at least.

McHrozni
 
If Labour refuses a Dec 12 election on Monday. PM’s spokesman says “Nothing will come before Parliament but the bare minimum. We will pursue a general election every day from then onwards, and do everything we can to get it”.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1187677857608294400

That No10 threat to go on strike by putting nothing more before Parliament if an election isn’t agreed? It’s off. Only Brexit legislation will be held back. PM spokesman: “He has a domestic agenda. We want to deliver for the British public”.
 
Why would Johnson want another general election? Didn't May try that, to her dismay. Also, didn't this whole fracas start with Blair calling for a referendum that he thought would strengthen his position only to get defeated? History seems to suggest it's a risky strategy. <-- assuming my memory is correct.
Cameron.
 
That has changed since Sajid Javid's car crash interview on R4 this morning.

This seems to be standard practice now. Say something, immediately contradict it, say something else, contradict that, say another different thing and then do something else entirely.

I guess its just so people can pick and choose what answer they like and it can be cut down into clips for Facebook later.
 
Also, this morning on 5Live, an MP (assume labour) was lamenting how BJohnson has been pulling the debate from Parliament repeatedly. I'm probably misremembering the exact wording, but basically he was saying that they want to debate this, but Boris keeps stopping them. If we want to get it done, we should be blaming him for time wasting not, the opposition parties.

How much does he want a no deal?

Sure there's plenty of analogies for this.
 
Also, this morning on 5Live, an MP (assume labour) was lamenting how BJohnson has been pulling the debate from Parliament repeatedly. I'm probably misremembering the exact wording, but basically he was saying that they want to debate this, but Boris keeps stopping them. If we want to get it done, we should be blaming him for time wasting not, the opposition parties.
Exactly.
How much does he want a no deal?
Very scary.
Why would Johnson want another general election?
Because he has no majority and is unable to get legislation passed. The only way to get anything through the House of Commons right now is for the Labour and Conservative parties to agree on it.
Yes, Johnson has no majority, but it is the Conservative party which still has the most MPs in the House of Commons, so Boris is still the logical Prime Minister. He is not the only one leading a minority government (other examples in Europe: Sanchez government in Spain, Michel government in Belgium ...).
It seems to me Johnson's logical priorities should be an in-depth debate in Parliament of the new Brexit deal, which has already been approved once, and avoiding no-deal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom