Boys castrated by Catholic church

It's an old problem for the Church--is God good because He does good things, or because He defines what good means? The Church seems to hold that the Church is good because it defines what good means, which means that anything they do is moral because they say so.


This is true. I know some posters here lean toward the "god defines what is good" viewpoint.
 
shadron said:
I'd have to argue about that one. The members of the church certainly do feel emotionally attached not only to their local church but also to their diocese and to the Holy See. All the local catholics read the diocesan newspaper
I had the opposite experience. The peopel where I grew up were loyal to the parish community--not the parish itself, and at least one priest left a few hours before the angry mob arived, but to the members of the parish. No one read the diocesan newsletter; in fact, I didn't know there WAS one until a new priest came and mentioned reading something in it. And if the bishop tried to tell us ratings for movies....well, it was a small community, and the parents knew the skeletons in the bishops' clossets (we had two, which was weird considering the population).

I think this is going to vary from one diocese to the next, or even from one parish to the next. The Church isn't exactly as monolithic as people think (and the Protastents are best described as atomized), and local variations make a HUGE difference.

X said:
I know some posters here lean toward the "god defines what is good" viewpoint.
Given the story of Abraham trying to sacrifice his son, it's the only defensible position for a Catholic to take. That said, it's also fundamentally flawed. Even if we assume that God is infallible, Catholicism teaches that humans are not (with the obvious exception); thus, what the men of the Church do can be evil. Wouldn't be the first time a major part of the hierarchy was accused of heressy. Thus, even if Catholics assume that the Church is worshiping the right God, and that that God is infallible, they should still oppose these actions, and in fact should be even more aggressive than us atheists in prosecuting these people. For non-members like me it's disgusting and immoral and evil. To a Catholic it'd be sacrelige.
 
This is true. I know some posters here lean toward the "god defines what is good" viewpoint.

Ah, the old Natural Law vs Divine Command debate. bringing back memories of my comparative religions course in college.
 
An investigation by Dutch newspaper NRC Handelsblad and published this weekend claims that up to eleven boys were castrated while in the care of the Dutch Roman Catholic church in the 1950s, supposedly to rid them of homosexualityAlso reported is that one young man was castrated in 1956 after telling police he was being abused by priests, the newspaper reported.

According to media reports the Dutch Catholic church has said it is willing to co-operate with an investigation to find out whether the reports are true.

More info.
NY Times
BBC
Reuters

Perhaps the church ought to extend this practice to their priests if they're really that concerned about homosexuality.
 
In my experience, U.S. Catholics are decidedly (and ironically) parochial. The bishop is regarded as an administrative adversary from the big city who has little idea of the daily goings on in one's local parish. I can remember several times growing up in which some decree from the bishop was very much at odds with how the local parishoners viewed things. We had no idea what cardinals were for, but we usually liked the pope 'cause he was the one Catholic who the media paid any attention to.

Re: pedophile priests, and why they're tolerated by rank and file Catholics: It's complicated, but I think it stems from stuff like this:

1) First, Catholics who've given any serious thought to the situation at all have already left the church.

2) Those that have chosen to stay in 2012 are already rationalizing transubstantiation, resurrection, and virgin birth - the "overall good of the Church outweighs the harm of a few bad apples" rationalization is a walk in the park, comparatively.

3) Suffering - the more one suffers the more likely one is to get to heaven. This is straight out of the Sermon on the Mount. So while personal tragedy might make Catholics sad, they don't necessarily get outraged the way other folks might expect. (One of my main motivations for finally breaking away was that I wasn't feeling outraged enough by tragedies in this world. Once you realize there's no heaven waiting for these miserable, suffering people, you care more about doing something to help them right now.)

4) Forgiveness - In Catholicism, suffering is a blessing and its corollary is forgiveness. We forgive no matter how heinous the crime. Remember, Jesus asked forgiveness for the guys who were at that moment crucifying him.

5) Gay people - Catholics know darn well that some people are just gay and there's no way around it. They don't "choose the gay lifestyle" or however some idiot mouthpiece like Santorum might characterize it, people are born gay and rank-and-file Catholics have recognized this for centuries. In olden times, there were no opportunities for these people - except in the Church. So it is assumed that some significant proportion of priests are gay and sadly, "gay = pedophile" to Catholics - or at least gay "celibate" priests are likely to be interested in fondling altar boys if the opportunity arises. So we were warned to "not get too chummy" with the priests and that was that.

I realize that some of these thoughts might incense some readers; I'm just trying to paint an honest picture of how Catholics in my experience might react to these ideas. I have no doubt that millions of people in the U.S. right now would agree wholeheartedly with 2–5, and that these attitudes are in large part responsible for the absence of outrage among Catholics re: pedophile priests. Keeping such scandals hush-hush isn't really that far out of step with core Catholic values even though it seems a direct contradiction to what the Church is supposed to be about.
 
In my experience, U.S. Catholics are decidedly (and ironically) parochial. The bishop is regarded as an administrative adversary from the big city who has little idea of the daily goings on in one's local parish. I can remember several times growing up in which some decree from the bishop was very much at odds with how the local parishoners viewed things. We had no idea what cardinals were for, but we usually liked the pope 'cause he was the one Catholic who the media paid any attention to.

Re: pedophile priests, and why they're tolerated by rank and file Catholics: It's complicated, but I think it stems from stuff like this:

1) First, Catholics who've given any serious thought to the situation at all have already left the church.

2) Those that have chosen to stay in 2012 are already rationalizing transubstantiation, resurrection, and virgin birth - the "overall good of the Church outweighs the harm of a few bad apples" rationalization is a walk in the park, comparatively.

3) Suffering - the more one suffers the more likely one is to get to heaven. This is straight out of the Sermon on the Mount. So while personal tragedy might make Catholics sad, they don't necessarily get outraged the way other folks might expect. (One of my main motivations for finally breaking away was that I wasn't feeling outraged enough by tragedies in this world. Once you realize there's no heaven waiting for these miserable, suffering people, you care more about doing something to help them right now.)

4) Forgiveness - In Catholicism, suffering is a blessing and its corollary is forgiveness. We forgive no matter how heinous the crime. Remember, Jesus asked forgiveness for the guys who were at that moment crucifying him.

5) Gay people - Catholics know darn well that some people are just gay and there's no way around it. They don't "choose the gay lifestyle" or however some idiot mouthpiece like Santorum might characterize it, people are born gay and rank-and-file Catholics have recognized this for centuries. In olden times, there were no opportunities for these people - except in the Church. So it is assumed that some significant proportion of priests are gay and sadly, "gay = pedophile" to Catholics - or at least gay "celibate" priests are likely to be interested in fondling altar boys if the opportunity arises. So we were warned to "not get too chummy" with the priests and that was that.

I realize that some of these thoughts might incense some readers; I'm just trying to paint an honest picture of how Catholics in my experience might react to these ideas. I have no doubt that millions of people in the U.S. right now would agree wholeheartedly with 2–5, and that these attitudes are in large part responsible for the absence of outrage among Catholics re: pedophile priests. Keeping such scandals hush-hush isn't really that far out of step with core Catholic values even though it seems a direct contradiction to what the Church is supposed to be about.
This meshes well with my own experiences.
 
5) Gay people - Catholics know darn well that some people are just gay and there's no way around it. They don't "choose the gay lifestyle" or however some idiot mouthpiece like Santorum might characterize it, people are born gay and rank-and-file Catholics have recognized this for centuries. In olden times, there were no opportunities for these people - except in the Church. So it is assumed that some significant proportion of priests are gay and sadly, "gay = pedophile" to Catholics - or at least gay "celibate" priests are likely to be interested in fondling altar boys if the opportunity arises. So we were warned to "not get too chummy" with the priests and that was that.

Note: I am not now nor have I ever been a Catholic

That out of the way, I think there is more to this than you indicate. It is the issue of sexual repression that is not unique to the RCC, but you seemed to have mastered. This is linked to the rhetoric that being gay is OK, but acting on it is not. I agree that this motivates a lot of faithful RCC gays to join the priesthood. However, where I diverge is that I think that the repression of their sexuality is what causes them to 'break' and to seek to satisfy themselves with inappropriate, vulnerable targets. The ones they have the easiest access to are the boys.

I find it interesting your point that this has been almost folk wisdom among lay Catholics implying that this is rather institutional. That is why they are not so outraged, because they have already been accustomed to it as 'typical'. It is a good point that I had not considered before.
 
Not that it makes this less horrific but the British govt was also chemically castrating homosexuals in the 1950s as an official alternative to prison. Turing.
 
I think that is sort of like saying how can anyone want to be a US citizen because of US torture in Iraqi prisons, waterboarding, and things like the Tuskegee syphilis experiment.

Find me a country whose government has never committed a crime and I'll move there.
 
I find it interesting your point that this has been almost folk wisdom among lay Catholics implying that this is rather institutional. That is why they are not so outraged, because they have already been accustomed to it as 'typical'.
I have no doubt that children have endured similar abuses from institutions with celibate caste structures all over the world and from the very dawn of such institutions. Personally, I think it's the shroud of enforced celibacy - more than the sexual orientation - that leads to such abuses of boys. Even an otherwise heterosexual priest could end up preying on boys for two reasons: 1) he's got no access to girls and 2) little boys don't get pregnant so there's no evidence of the crime unless the kid talks - and that's not gonna happen.

I spent 8 years as an altar boy and lots of time hanging around various priests. Some were "regular guys" who drank a bit and told dirty jokes; some were professor types who just liked to hear themselves talk; some were just weirdos; at least one was flamboyantly gay - like Charles Nelson Reilly in a white collar. Never had a problem with any of those guys, and never heard of anything involving the 50 or so other altar boys with whom I served. Oddly enough, two of the priests I knew in my youth (not the guys referenced above) were ultimately taken to task for affairs with teenage girls.
 
Much rather read a thread like Catholic Church Castrated by Boy.
 
I had the opposite experience. The peopel where I grew up were loyal to the parish community--not the parish itself, and at least one priest left a few hours before the angry mob arived, but to the members of the parish. No one read the diocesan newsletter; in fact, I didn't know there WAS one until a new priest came and mentioned reading something in it. And if the bishop tried to tell us ratings for movies....well, it was a small community, and the parents knew the skeletons in the bishops' clossets (we had two, which was weird considering the population).

I get the feeling we're all like blind people trying to feel up the elephant. I don't know your area, of course; in ours there was a catholic elementary school associated with every parish, and a high school with every third one. We had our own sports leagues, scout troops - everything was well integrated with communities in Denver. It is much less so today; most of the parochial high schools are gone.

Ah, well. This news leaves me saddened, and angry. Quite angry, building for a long time.
 
I have no doubt that children have endured similar abuses from institutions with celibate caste structures all over the world and from the very dawn of such institutions.
You're right not to have any doubts about this! From Marchena's notes on the Satyricon of Petronius
http://www.fullbooks.com/The-Satyricon-v7-Marchena-Notes-.html
The Christian religion strongly prohibits this love; the theologians put it among the sins which directly offend against the Holy Ghost ... We have even noticed that they are the priests of the Lord and especially the monks who practice this profession most generally amongst us. The children of Loyola have acquired well-merited renown in this matter: when they painted "Pleasure" they never failed to represent him wearing trousers. Those disciples of Joseph Calasanz who took their places in the education of children, followed their footsteps with zeal and fervor.

St Joseph Calasanz, died 1648, established the Piarist order, which specialised in educating boys, often from poorer families. Needless to say, the usual problems arose, and the Saint dealt with them in time-honoured fashion:
Problems were exarcebated, however, by Father Stefano Cherubini, originally headmaster of the Piarist school in Naples who systematically sexually abused the pupils in his care. Father Stefano made no secret about at least some of his transgressions, and Calasanz came to know of them. Unfortunately for Calasanz as administrator of the order, Father Stefano was the son and the brother of powerful papal lawyers; no one wanted to offend the Cherubini family. Father Stefano pointed out that if allegations of his abuse of his boys became public, actions would be taken to destroy the Piarists. Calasanz therefore promoted Father Stefano, to get him away from the scene of the crime, citing only his luxurious diet and failure to attend prayers. However, he knew what Cherubini had really been up to, and he wrote that the sole aim of the plan “… is to cover up this great shame in order that it does not come to the notice of our superiors”.
See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Calasanctius
 
You're right not to have any doubts about this! From Marchena's notes on the Satyricon of Petronius
http://www.fullbooks.com/The-Satyricon-v7-Marchena-Notes-.html

St Joseph Calasanz, died 1648, established the Piarist order, which specialised in educating boys, often from poorer families. Needless to say, the usual problems arose, and the Saint dealt with them in time-honoured fashion: See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Calasanctius

They're just following Jesus's command to "Let the little children come unto me".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom